It is one of the cruelest of ironies, a statistical conundrum that has the makings of a Shakespearean tragicomedy.

In the past six seasons, the Steelers have been so good at winning regular-season games when first place or a playoff spot is on the line. They’ve already done it once this season and get a chance to do it again Sunday night in Cincinnati.

But when it comes to winning a postseason game, the Steelers have been so, well, bad.

How can the essential ingredients — Aaron Rodgers calls it the “secret sauce” — that allow a team to survive showdown games in the regular season disappear so quickly in the playoffs?

Advertise with us

Not to mention repeatedly?

It’s not easy to explain.

Let’s start with what is known.

Since last November, the Steelers have won three straight games against AFC North opponents when first place has been at stake. The most recent example came two weeks ago when the Steelers beat the Cleveland Browns.

Last season, the Steelers beat the Baltimore Ravens twice to take over first place, including their Jan. 4 win that secured them the AFC North title.

Advertise with us

But it goes further than that.

Since 2021, the Steelers have won eight of the past 10 games after Nov. 1 when either the division lead or wild-card playoff positioning hung in the balance.

The Steelers (6-2) will have another one Sunday night when they face the Cincinnati Bengals (6-2), with whom they share the AFC North lead, at Paycor Stadium.

So why hasn’t that translated to the postseason?

The Steelers’ recent failures in the postseason are not only well-documented, they are the reason their fan base has tempered its enthusiasm this season after the team’s good start. They have seen this before.

Advertise with us

It’s been 10 years since the Steelers last won a playoff game. They’ve lost seven in a row — three of them at home — while allowing a staggering average of 37.1 points in those defeats.

Whatever they have done in the regular season disappears like socks in the laundry when they get to the postseason.

So will this year, should the Steelers take control of the division against the Bengals and never let go, be any different?

Rodgers thinks it could. He said the Steelers possess the one essential element he looks for in teams who have success. And he’s been observing for 22 years.

“The secret sauce is in the way guys communicate with each other, the way they hang out in the locker room, how much chatter there is,” Rodgers said Thursday. “And, then, how much guys hang out outside the facility. I think when you have a good team, they do that. Winning can help.”

Advertise with us

But does winning foster camaraderie or does camaraderie begat winning?

“I think the hang-out precedes the winning,” Rodgers said. “I think that’s an important part of the offseason stuff, the Latrobe stuff, that teams that are not the most talented can win when they’re super-connected.”

Rodgers said he would actually prefer that his teams be “a little less talented but way more connected.”

“Some of the most talented teams I was on weren’t the most connected,” he said. “I always say the team that won the Super Bowl in Green Bay was not the most talented that we had in all my time there. But it was the most connected.”

Rodgers thinks the Steelers have that connection this season, even more so than last year. Part of the reason is because several players — including himself, DK Metcalf and Jalen Ramsey — are in their second season with the team.

Advertise with us

“And I felt like last year we had a really good, connected team,” Rodgers said.

Unlike Rodgers, who has 11 playoff victories and that Super Bowl championship in 2010, defensive end Cam Heyward has been involved in just one postseason victory in 16 years — an 18-16 win on Jan. 9, 2016 in Cincinnati.

Heyward said the one element he looks for in a team is cohesion. He said those teams find different ways to win.

“I think that is very critical,” Heyward said. “Obviously, it requires luck, but it also requires being prepared for those moments, whether it’s an end of a drive and finishing with a touchdown or getting off [the field] quick, little things like that. It’s geared toward situational moments and winning those moments.”

Those moments have been plentiful in the regular season.

Advertise with us

Doesn’t matter if it was Rodgers throwing a 31-yard touchdown to Calvin Austin III with 55 seconds left, like he did this past January to clinch their first division title in five years — but not until after Ravens kicker Tyler Loop missed a field goal as time expired.

Doesn’t matter if it’s Mason Rudolph throwing two touchdowns to George Pickens to beat the Bengals and secure a wild-card spot in 2023 or the defense registering nine sacks against the Cleveland Browns and snatching a wild-card spot from their division rivals in 2021.

But, oh, those playoff embarrassments.

“I’ve been very lucky to be a part of a lot of teams that have just been together,” Heyward said. “It’s just different stages.”

The regular-season stage has been rife with game-winning moments. The postseason stage? Not so good.

It remains to be seen if the Steelers can continue one and change the other.