CLEVELAND — Post-Gazette reporter Ray Fittipaldo grades each position group and the coaching staff after the Steelers’ Week 4 game against the Cleveland Browns.
Quarterback
Aaron Rodgers got off to a great start and he had a great finish. But what transpired in between likely cost the Steelers the game. Rodgers was intercepted by Denzel Ward early in the second quarter, when the Steelers led 7-0. It was a poor decision by Rodgers, who should have thrown the ball away when he didn’t have any open receivers.
Instead he threw it in the direction of Cleveland’s best corner. The Browns seized the momentum and scored 21 unanswered points to end the half. Rodgers was terrific in the fourth quarter, leading the Steelers to 15 points to tie the score. He finished with 299 yards and three touchdowns, but his poor decision on the interception gave the Browns the momentum.
Grade: C+
Running backs
Jaylen Warren was effective early in the game. He had 49 yards from scrimmage in the first quarter, but the Steelers got pass-happy in the second and third quarters, rendering Warren ineffective. Warren is at his best when he gets consistent touches. The coaches finally went back to him in the fourth quarter, and he finished with 123 yards from scrimmage. If they didn’t go away from him in the middle of the game, it might have had a different outcome.
Grade: A
Read More
Receivers
DK Metcalf had his first 100-yard game of the season, catching five passes for 115 yards, with most of his damage coming in the fourth quarter. Roman Wilson was effective early before he was injured. He had 74 yards and caught a 12-yard touchdown pass from Rodgers. Darnell Washington and Pat Freiermuth also caught touchdowns. The numbers look good on the stat sheet, but the receivers didn’t win consistently enough in their 1-on-1 matchups in the first three quarters.
Grade: C+
Offensive line
Rodgers wasn’t doing the line any favors by holding the ball as long as he did on some plays, but the Browns got consistent pressure and sacked Rodgers five times. Rodgers was hit 10 times, far too many on any quarterback, much less the oldest starter in the league. The running game was solid, with the running backs averaging almost 5 yards per carry. They just need the coaches to lean more into the run earlier in games.
Grade: C
Defensive line
Cam Heyward had seven tackles, but the rest of the line was quiet. Derrick Harmon suffered a foot injury in the first half and did not play in the second. He was in a walking boot after the game.
Harmon’s absence was a big hit to the run defense. The Browns finished with 112 yards rushing. If Harmon is out for the next game, the next players up are rookies Gabriel Rubio and Kevin Jobity Jr. Neither has dressed for a game yet this season.
Grade: C
Linebackers
T.J. Watt had two more sacks to give him 5.5 on the season. His strip sack and recovery late in the third quarter was the first time the pass rush got to Deshaun Watson. It signaled the start of a stronger finish for the edge rushers. On the next series, Jack Sawyer tipped a pass that led to a Robert Spears-Jennings interception. Unfortunately for the Steelers, Watson had all day to sit back and pick apart the defense in the first half.
The inside linebackers really struggled on Cleveland’s first touchdown drive. Patrick Queen missed an open-field tackle against Quinshon Judkins that gained 12 yards. On Jaleel McLaughlin’s 28-yard touchdown run, Cole Holcomb missed his tackle near the 20-yard line. Payton Wilson led the Steelers with nine tackles. Maybe the coaches shouldn’t have taken him off the field on the series when McLaughlin scored.
Grade: B-
Secondary
The Steelers spent the short practice week preparing to play the game with Joey Porter Jr., who worked with the first-team defense all week. Then he claimed a back injury again and was gone by Wednesday night.
Those who did play in the game struggled mightily. The only thing that was worse than their coverage was their tackling. The Steelers are high on Daylen Everette, but he gave up a 60-yard pass to Denzel Boston. Safety Rayshawn Jenkins was missing tackles all over the field early and was replaced by Spears-Jennings, a rookie seventh-round pick. DeShon Elliott is eligible to come off of injured reserve next week, and it won’t be a moment too soon.
Grade: F
Special teams
The Steelers made Chris Boswell the NFL’s second-highest-paid kicker, but he’s already missed three field goals this season, including a 48-yard attempt midway through the second quarter. That miss was the difference in the game, when Browns kicker Andre Szmyt booted a 56-yarder with 10 seconds left for the win.
Cameron Johnston’s 62-yard punt to the 1-yard line with 5:31 remaining gave the Steelers defense a chance to flip the field. Johnston averaged 51.8 yards per punt on his five attempts.
Kaden Wetjen averaged 15 yards on his two punt returns, but the return game has yet to break a long play to flip the field for the offense.
Grade: D
Coaching
So much for Mike McCarthy having a better plan to get the Steelers off the schneid on Thursday nights. His team was wildly inconsistent in all phases.
McCarthy’s insistence on subbing players in and out cost him big time in this game. Everette was badly beaten for a 60-yard catch on the first snap he played in the game. What made this an even more curious decision was Asante Samuel Jr. had been playing so well on the first two series of the game. Everette had to play once Jamel Dean was injured, but he didn’t have to go in when Samuel was feeling it.
McCarthy is big into analytics, but he should allow starters to remain when they’re in a good rhythm. On the Browns’ first touchdown, Holcomb was subbed into the game for Wilson and missed the tackle that allowed McLaughlin to score.
There is something to be said for keeping your best players fresh, but McCarthy’s overzealousness with analytics can lead to overexposure for reserves. He should leave more room for playing the hot hand.
Grade: F






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.