Blame it on the rain. Or the snow. Or on Myles Garrett treating Mason Rudolph’s head like a piñata.
The past seven trips to Cleveland haven’t been kind to the Steelers. They’re 1-6 there since 2019, with many of the losses of the inexplicable variety.
There was 2023, when Dorian Thompson-Robinson beat them. It was the first and only time in his brief NFL career he won a game as a starting quarterback.
Then there was the snow-globe game in 2024, when Jameis Winston led a late touchdown drive to earn one of the Browns’ three victories that season.
And who could forget last season’s debacle? The Steelers, with a chance to clinch the division title, lost to a Browns team that had lost seven of eight.
Oh, and Cleveland’s quarterback was Shedeur Sanders.
Read More
Thompson-Robinson, Winston, Sanders — that’s quite the trifecta for the Steelers.
“There is something about Cleveland,” linebacker Patrick Queen said this week. “When we play Cleveland, it’s always a weird game. It’s a weird feel, especially night games. They’re rowdy. Fans throw dog food and whatever else.”
Including beer. You can ask Dianne Freiermuth about that.
The Steelers last won in Cleveland in 2021, when her son, Pat, caught a touchdown pass from Ben Roethlisberger in the back of the end zone in the fourth quarter to give the Steelers a 15-10 win. Browns fans doused Freiermuth’s mother with beer after he scored. She hasn’t attended a game in Cleveland since.
“Going into the Dawg Pound on Thursday night, it’s going to be rowdy,” Freiermuth said. “They don’t like us very much. Every single year I go to the Dawg Pound, I hear a whole other elevated level of [trash] talking. It’s fun. It’s always fun to play in Cleveland. I’m looking forward to a rambunctious crowd.”
Not only do the Steelers have to reverse their recent curse in Cleveland, but they must also solve a longstanding problem of winning on the road on Thursday nights.
The Steelers are 3-16 in Thursday road games since the 1970 merger. They are 0-9 in Thursday night division road games and 0-4 in Cleveland.
Three of those losses have come since 2019, when Garrett incited a brawl after he clubbed Rudolph in the head with his own helmet late in a 21-7 Browns victory.
In the Thursday night game in 2024, the Steelers allowed Winston to drive the Browns for the winning touchdown with 57 seconds remaining in regulation.
So why do strange things keep happening to the Steelers whenever they travel to Cleveland?
“If I knew, I would try to prevent it, but I absolutely have no idea,” Queen said. “They have a great fan base. They’re loud. They’re obnoxious. They throw all kinds of stuff. They say all kinds of things. It’s just one of those places. It’s never sunny. It’s always gloomy. I haven’t ever had a sunny game there — ever.”
Former Steelers coach Mike Tomlin, despite great successes over his 19-year tenure, could never quite figure out how to prepare his team to win road games on short rest.
Mike McCarthy, on the other hand, has a long history of success in Thursday games, with a 17-8 record.
“I just think we have a sound plan,” he said. “I think we pay attention to the things that are the most important and in tune with the environment we need to play in, too. Playing on the road on Thursday is a lot different obviously than playing at home, but I think the fact we’re close, I think that helps. It’s just a bus ride up there.”
It’s a new era that, with McCarthy in charge, surely will produce more memorable moments in the Steelers-Browns rivalry.
When the Steelers were dominating the series in the first two decades of the century, it was difficult to refer to it as a rivalry. But the Browns’ recent success and some controversial moments have made it feel more like one lately.
Garrett is gone, traded to the Los Angeles Rams in the spring, but bad blood remains.
Tomlin went to unusual lengths last October to chastise Browns general manager Andrew Berry for trading Joe Flacco to the Cincinnati Bengals early in the year, a rare in-season trade involving divisional foes.
Tomlin traded in his headset for a microphone and he hasn’t stopped stoking the flames.
In his new role as an analyst for NBC, Tomlin leapt at the opportunity to take a shot at the Browns following their 34-10 loss at Jacksonville in Week 1. Tomlin evoked JuJu Smith-Schuster’s famous quote: “The Browns is the Browns.”
Or is it infamous?
Smith-Schuster uttered the quote in the days before the Browns upset the Steelers in a 2020 playoff game.
Under first-year coach Todd Monken, the Browns upset the Tampa Bay Buccaneers a week after Tomlin’s barb. He wasn’t shy about using Tomlin’s words as motivation.
“The Browns are gonna Browns. [Expletive] that,” Monken shot back at his postgame news conference. “The guys took that to heart.”
Need another reason for the hatred to resume Thursday night?
The winner will be alone atop the AFC North with a 3-1 record.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.