Gerry Dulac: OK kids, I'm ready to go if you are...fire away!!
Stairway to seventh seed: Gerry: huge win, but after the excitement died down the reality of a very poor defensive performance became clear. I was hoping that soft zones and easy pitch and catch completions were thrown on the ash heap of Tomlin/Austin history. I suppose you can argue that it eventually worked, but not really. What were your thoughts on Graham's ultra conservative defensive approach?
Gerry Dulac: My thoughts are Joe Burrow, Ja'Marr Chase and Tee Higgins are very good, which I thought before the game, too
Ryan: Hey Jerry. Looks like DK showed the critics on Sunday with the TD. Now, what can they complain about him?
Gerry Dulac: A holding penalty that negated an 87-yard run??
Bill In LA: DK Metcalf is averaging about 2 penalties and 2 drops per game, with only 3.6 catches per game. Couldn't the Steelers get 3.6 catches per game from a veteran minimum contract (without the drops and penalties)? How does Omar Khan justify paying $ 33 million per year for Metcalf's below average performance?
Gerry Dulac: It's $30 million a year, but who's to quibble, Bill. I was surprised at the contract at the time of the trade and I'm still surprised.
Bill In LA: Gerry, to answer your questions from last week, yes I am up early, and the sky is always blue in Southern California. My question for you: Looking back now, why do you think Art Roony II was satisfied for so many years with 'non-losing' seasons and never would replace Mike Tomlin until he quit?
Gerry Dulac: Well, Mr. Sky is Blue, I think it's because Mike Tomlin has proven to be a very good coach, one who might get into the Hall of Fame one day, just like the other two coaches they neve fired when they, unlike Tomlin, had losing seasons.
Stairway to seventh seed: Gerry: since the 2021 Thursday night game where the defensive line was absolutely destroyed in Minnesota, Cam Heyward has only total 0.5 sacks in four straight Thursday night road losses. Does Cam's body just simply not recover enough for him to be ready on Thursday and should the Steelers consider dressing a 6th DL for more rotation options tomorrow?
Gerry Dulac: Well, my friend, that's some pretty darn-good research there and, if true, I did not know that. But, he was a younger man when that streak, according to your research, started, so maybe it's not about age. Nonetheless, you raise a very intriguing thought. And maybe they will.
Stairway to seventh seed: Gerry: I was shocked at how many media members, even local ones, just cavalierly opined that Porter probably wouldn't want to play against Chase and Higgins and sort of dismissed that as a logical decision without challenging the cowardice. Are we going to enter a new phase of this "hold-in" where Porter plays, but then his back flares up the week before he would face any WRs that will expose him for the $18m per year corner that he really is?
Gerry Dulac: You are reading or listening to the wrong people if someone ridiculously said that!
Stairway to seventh seed: Gerry: I was not in the camp of those worried about special teams because they kept a 4th QB, but with Porter also "redshirting" right now and the kickoff coverage being so abysmal I am starting to wonder. Do they need at least one roster spot for a special teams coverage ace?
Gerry Dulac: They have two -- Skowronek and Bruener
Tom in Tn: Good morning Gerry, I watching the forest 3 games this defense still concerns me. There is plenty of money invested there and they just can’t seem to take the next step consistently week to week. What are your thoughts on this defense overall?
Gerry Dulac: Overall, it's been pretty good, the first two games in particular. And I've seen worse performances against Burrow and his WR friends. They are pretty good, after all.
Dan: Hey Gerry, thanks for the chat. Have you ever thought about writing a book on the Steelers? I read everything I can about them and would imagine that with your insight you’d have some great stories. Thanks!
Gerry Dulac: Well I have thought about it.
Matt in Kersey: Gerry, I am so confused on the Porter situation... Is Porter sitting out refusing to play or are the Steeler sitting him? So many rumors and the enter situation doesn't make sense to me! MM say he wants him to play??
Gerry Dulac: The whole situation can be confusing because it looks as though the Steelers are complicit in JPJ's plan, which they aren't. The Steelers have always wanted him to play and even upped their contract offer to slightly north of $27 annually. He, apparently, didn't think that was enough, or needed more guaranteed money, or something. Up to now, even beyond all that, he hasn't been in shape to play. Apparently, he is now. So the now the real fun begins. Will he play, as he says he will? Or will the Steelers decide it's time to take action? Keep watching
Tampa Too: Gerry. The Steelers wasted At least three timeouts in this game due to communication problems possibly? Was any explanation ever given for these timeouts. I don’t understand when you have such a veteran quarterback and veteran head coach why this happened
Gerry Dulac: I had it at five actually. Inexcusable.
RAM: Hey Gerry! In the Cinci game our D seemed to play zone for most of the game allowing Burrow to play pitch and catch in between coverage most of the game. Were we willing to give them short yardage to avoid a big splash play down field or what?
Gerry Dulac: Good observation and that is correct
Tampa Too: Gerry. What’s your take on the president’s cup? At 14– 1–1 it seems like this is such a one-sided affair that perhaps it should go away?
Or maybe they can make it a net event and give strokes.. Your thoughts?
Gerry Dulac: It almost wasn't one-sided this weekend. Kinda why I wanted to see the international team win. Maybe that would lend more drama/interest in the event
itsallmoot: Is it fair to say one of the most important, if not the most important things needed for success this year and in the future, is the devlopment of the O-Line? If it can run and pass protect, AR can pick defenses apart and the D can stay off the field against the big time Qb's in the AFC. also, whoever is QB next year will need a strong running game to help them out (like Big Ben had in the early years). Game against the Bengals seemed encouraging. If they regress, we are in trouble. thoughts?
Gerry Dulac: It's not only fair to suggest, it's one of the basic fundamentals of winning football -- gotta win up front. Yes sir.
Theo Bell: What was the problem getting the plays in and wasting multiple timeouts? It’s not as if they have a rookie QB and rookie coach.
Gerry Dulac: Exactly. As I said, inexcusable. And it wasn't just one or two times
itsallmoot: On JPJ, seems like it's best if we can work this out. Even if we got a late 1st round/early 2nd so we could go after a top tier qb next year, I think it's better to have a known commodity (top 10ish CB) than hoping we hit it with a young QB. Thoughts?
Gerry Dulac: If someone would offer a late first-round pick -- and you don't always know if it might turn out to be higher -- I think you would see a trade get done. And for the reason you suggest
Uncle Leo: Hello Gerry! That was a great game for Omar. His draft picks on the oline and his contract/free agent decisions - Warren, Hoffman, and Washington - were great. Terrible game for Joey Porter. He basically abandoned his teammates by either being unwilling or unready against the division opponent he is most positioned to help beat. He only makes it worse by betting against the team again this week with Ramsey hurt if he doesn’t play. I’m ready to send him anywhere for a first… your thoughts?
Gerry Dulac: You are not alone in your observation. And he is not making anything better, unless he decides to play. And then what sense does that make after everything he decided to do since the spring??
Tom88: Isn't is absurd the Steelers finally draft a very good CB; a position they have been terrible at drafting for and can't work out a deal? A year after they traded away one of the NFL's best WR's (at a loss) while their remaining WR's leave a lot to be desired. Maybe the problem is upstairs? Not just Tomlin.
Gerry Dulac: Maybe there is a lot more to it than you seem to think.
Steelguy70: Is Porter going to play?
Gerry Dulac: We'll see. The Steelers are suggesting he's ready. It's up to him. If and when he does, it might be a good idea if the first game was on the road.
Dave: Gerry, How much longer is this Porter, Jr. stuff going to go on?
Gerry Dulac: Let's hope not much longer. If he decides now not to play, there will be a resolution to all this -- and it might not be a favorable one for 24. Remember, they made him an offer that would have made 24 the seventh highest-paid CB in the league. He and his rep decided that wasn't enough. So do you think he is more than the seventh-best CB in the league? Do you think he's the seventh-best CB in the league??
Josh: Good morning Gerry. You had mentioned how Everette was hailed as one of the best rookies in camp by the Steelers coaching staff. Did his play possibly change their direction in negotiations with Porter jr? In a sense did they feel like he could eventually take over JPJ’s spot for much cheaper which led them to not engage as quickly with Porter as we initially thought they would?
Gerry Dulac: Not at all. Had no effect.
Joe: Is Porter going to be traded in the next few days? Lots of rumors circulating. If so, will they get a first round pick for him?
Gerry Dulac: If they could get a first-round pick for him, the deal might already have been done. Let's be clear about one thing here -- the Steelers like JPJ, both as a person and a player. They wanted to sign him, and at a price above what he's worth. But that wasn't good enough apparently. And so here we are
Rahn: It's early, but how would you rate this club as far as leadership and unity? A lot of cliques?
Gerry Dulac: I don't rate or evaluate cliques, unity or leadership, at least not in September. I'll wait until I hear players gripe about it, good or bad.
Pittfan: Hi Gerry. Is there reason to be concerned about signing Benton to an extension? I don't care about the amount as much as locking up a player who isn't producing. I am missing something in his performance?
Gerry Dulac: So it is about the extension and "locking" him up. Benton is not the type of player who is going to jump out at you, not like the size of his contract did. He is a good, solid player
jim: Gerry, if you're the GM, do you trade Porter for anything less than a #2 pick or do you keep him on the team this year and tag him next year? He is the best CB on the team, and I'd just as soon keep him and tag him and get 2 more seasons out of him.
Gerry Dulac: No, nothing less for sure. But, even if they tag him, what makes you think he won't pull the same act again? He is their best CB, which is why they wanted to sign him and came up on their offer. This isn't about them. It's about 24.
Josh: We keep hearing it would take a premium package to trade JPJ. What is a premium package in the Steelers point of view? Loose reports say a 2nd could get it done. That doesn’t seem premium to me. But I think if they settle for less than that then Khan and the Steelers look incredibly soft in this situation.
Gerry Dulac: I don't know anything about a premium package. You used the right word, though -- loose
BP: GM Gerry, over the past few seasons we've attempted to use a RB during the game that is not one of the top 2 RBs. I cant remember them ever getting more then a yard or two. Why do we continue to try it? Just run our top RBs or throw the damn ball.
Gerry Dulac: What, it happens for maybe 1 or 2 plays? I think it's going to be OK.
Daniel: Obviously Week 2 was not good. Week 3 was quite a change. Which do you think is more indicative of this team or are they still a work in progress that can end up either way?
Gerry Dulac: Hey, that's the NFL. Go ask the Falcons or Commanders or Case Keenum. Happens every week with every team. Who knows? That's why they played 17 of 'em
Ryan: Jerry, MM has a long way to go before the fans accept him. One good game isn't enough. He will never fill Tomlin's shoes.
Gerry Dulac: I'll tell him you think so Rian
Greg: Any thoughts on why we've never won a Thursday evening game in Cleveland?
Gerry Dulac: Or why they're 1-6-1 in their last eight games there? An annual division winner/challenger against a division bottom-feeder, too
Steeler Ken: Gerry: What do you think the chances are that the Steelers pick-up another WR, possibly Brian Thomas Jr from the Jags?
Gerry Dulac: They won't, unless there is some type of major injury
Colorado Joe: Hi Gerry, nice call on your Steeler prediction ! What is the % likelihood that JPJ plays vs, Cleveland ? Do you believe he will finish this season as a Steeler ? Thanks
Gerry Dulac: I'd say the odds are less than 50-50 he'll play, maybe the same for the season, but we'll see.
BP: GM Gerry, how is the pole position in the QB room now and how do you see it changing by next year with the assumption that we dont pick up another QB after AR sails off into the sunset?
Gerry Dulac: The pole position now will be different next season. And you're assumption they will not pick up another veteran QB is pretty much spot on. That's the last thing they want to do.
James Ryan: Hey Gerry. Thanks for the chats. Let's hope this is the final week of you having to answer JPJ questions. Do you think there is a better chance that he suits up for the Steelers this season? Or that he is traded?
Gerry Dulac: Again, 50-50. But I'm going to take Joey at his word that he will "definitely" play at some point this season. Then again, he really never said for whom.
Retire21: People remark about the disparity of what the two different units are paid on the Steelers roster. Isn’t this partly the result of success of their drafts? They wanted to extend Benton and Herbig and likely now Harmon.
Gerry Dulac: Absolutely. Granted, they spent a decent buck on Ramsey and Queen, but not like they did on Metcalf.
Charlie from Sugartown: GOOD MORNING Gerry, what happens first Joey Porter plays in a game for the Steelers, or the straight of Hormuz opens up to regular shipping ?
Gerry Dulac: Hahaha. Nothing against Joey, but I'd really like to see the gas prices go way down
Pittfan: Hi Gerry. When DeShon Elliott comes off of IR, who do you think gets released? It seems Eli Heidenreich would be the most obvious but the homer in me would really hate to see that happen. Not to mention, I really believe he has some upside.
Gerry Dulac: Not sure it would be Eli unless McCarthy wants just two RBs and a FB on the roster. But the decision is not always that difficult because of the way teams can now elevate players from the practice squad on a weekly basis
Bill In LA: DK Metcalf's new name is "D Claypool Metcalf" from now on.
Gerry Dulac: I thought you were going to say DeCaf
Peter: Roman Wilson has played decent... but Mr. Rodgers has always disliked WRs that make him look bad. Does that drop/INT from Sunday provide a window for Germie to get more snaps/targets?
Gerry Dulac: I don't think so. Maybe if Wilson would've dropped that easy TD throw, which he bobbled for just the slightest of seconds
Ryan in VT: Hey Gerry. Do you think we see more D. Everette against the Browns? I am wondering if the Steelers have hope, he can be the true JPJ replacement by the end of the season.
Gerry Dulac: I wouldn't go that far. But, I will tell you, they really like Everette. Their depth at CB is/was really good, best it's been in years. But that's contingent on having JPJ there
Rick Woods: Assuming Rodgers and Rudolph stay healthy and the young QBs never see the field this season, what can Allar do from this point forward to show the Steelers they don’t need to draft a Quarterback in round one next year? Is it possible they already know the answer based on what they’ve seen this year? Thanks.
Gerry Dulac: There's not a lot he can do. He gets very few live reps in practice, if any, and will probably never see the field. I don't know if they KNOW the answer right now, but I think they have a pretty decent feel where this might be going.
Steeler Joe: Hey, Gerry. I'm sure you'll get this question a few times, but: Help me understand the Steelers' position on JPJr. They seem to be accommodating him; there doesn't seem to be any animosity. Does the team genuinely see a path back to the field for him in black and gold? Or is the team merely biding its time, getting him back on the field to show he's healthy, then dealing him before November 10?
Gerry Dulac: This is all about Porter finally saying HE feels healthy. He was deemed healthy to play in Week 1. Yes, to a degree they are accommodating him and there's not much animosity, aside from their disappointment on all levels. It is more important for Porter to get back on the field, show he's healthy so another team might be interested in trading for him and paying him what HE thinks he's worth
Peter: True or False: Joey Porter Jr. is a member of the Pittsburgh Steelers on Thursday (10/1/26) as of 8:20p.m. EST?
Gerry Dulac: True, because he's been a member since Week 1
Ryan: The Steelers are only favored by 2.5 points against the Browns. Don't you think it should be a lot more?
Gerry Dulac: Have you seen the way they've played in Cleveland the past 8 years?
NY Steel: At times over the last 5 years, it has felt like the Steelers defense had comparable talent to the 2005-2010 team. Do you agree? If so, why are they so inconsistent from game-to-game relative to the 2005-2010 defenses? Is the difference coaching — was LeBeau just that good?
Gerry Dulac: No I don't. And, yes, LeBeau was that good and the talent was much better!!
Roberto in AZ: A medical and non-football question - which I would understand if you did not answer, but would appreciate a brief comment - is Mike McCarthy’s health OK? He seems to struggle a bit with breathing at press conferences - there is quite a bit of wheezing.
Gerry Dulac: Roberto, I will answer, but only to say I haven't paid attention or noticed, and if I did I'm not medically qualified to evaluate
NY Steel: Who has been the Steelers best defensive coordinator since LeBeau?
Gerry Dulac: Nobody who measures up to LeBeau, which is a steep hill to climb
Ryan in VT: Do we finally see a game where Bernard starts over Roman? I thought R. Wilson had obviously a great start, but it becomes so irrelevant when a drop turns into a 10 point swing. It feels like Bernard is a higher caliber player
Gerry Dulac: Eventually perhaps. But at least we're seeing more plays from Wilson so far. Not many, but some, like the TD
mike: Has Bill changed his mind or does he still want to justify his game plan to start Allar for the rest of the season?
Gerry Dulac: I think he had a coffee, maybe a bagel, and settled down. I little Moe, Larry and cheese perhaps
NY Steel: Do you think Everette will develop into a better CB than JPJ?
Gerry Dulac: That's a big step, but I think he can and will be pretty good
Charlie from Sugartown: Gerry what is the issue with Metcalf and the multiple flags and non-flags with him so far this season? Not defending him but some of his drops could easily have been called defensive pass interference and a couple of the holding calls have been pretty ticky tacky IMO?
Gerry Dulac: I agree with you 110 percent. Good observation. Hey, I forgot to pay you!
Gerry Dulac: OK kids, I'm out of time. Thanx for the question. See ya next week







Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.