Ray Fittipaldo: Good afternoon. Let's get the chat started.

Daniel: Thanks for doing the chats. I know things haven't looked good for the team especially last week but still early in the season. Some long runs allowed but overall I've been impressed with the defense as not a lot of points allowed. Is this week key to see if they can do that against an elite offense?

Ray Fittipaldo: Absolutely. Joe Burrow is one of the top QBs in the league, and he has two elite WRs in Ja'Marr Chase and Tee Higgins. Asante Samuel and Jamel Dean will be tgested. Dean, by the way, did not practice yesterday so we'll see if his status changes later on today; That, obviously, will be a big key.

Greg: Hi Ray...Assuming the Steelers had made an offer to JPJ before the season started, I'm wondering what would happen if he or his agent decided to accept it now. No negotiating, he just signs the sheet. I don't believe it would be any different than any other in-season signing, would it?

Advertise with us

Ray Fittipaldo: That would be interesting. Porter would have to accept soon though. I cannot imagine the Steelers keeping the same offer on the table if Porter misses many more games. I'm not even sure it's there anymore. Their best offer was north of $27 million a year. Gerry reported that over the weekend We don't know the term of the guarantee structure, but we do know the ballpark the Steelers were in with AAV. And in terms of AAV, it's a very competitive offer.

MP: Good morning Ray. The Steelers appear are purposely trying to get younger, which I imagine is why they kept all 10 players drafted this year. But it doesn’t seem like many have gotten much playing time thus far. Why go younger if they’re not playing?

Ray Fittipaldo: Give it some time. Germie Bernard got to play against the Patriots because of the injury to Michael PIttman Jr. He played well for the most part, made some plays. And this might be the week Max Iheanachor cracks the starting lineup.

MP: It’s still very early in the season but if things continue as they are, when might we get a chance to see what Allar can do? I think he possesses the most upside of the backups. He’d be mobile behind an unsteady line and he has a big arm.

Ray Fittipaldo: But is he ready to play? Does he know the offense? Does he know how to read NFL defenses? You cannot force a player like that onto the field if he's not ready. Plus, the Steelers did not bring Rodgers back to bench him. Unless there is an injury or the season is totally lost in December I do not seem them making a change.

Advertise with us

RhinoSteeler: Could the Oline being bad so far this year be blamed on coaching since they flipped the line in training camp instead of keeping continuity??? Cook flipped and so did Troy plus the guards.

Ray Fittipaldo: People are going to come up with all kinds of excuses if this continues. I didn't hear Fautanu complain about it this summer. The only thing he has pushed back against is the potential of moving to guard. He will not do that willingly. He admitted in camp it was taking some time to get comfortable on the left side, but it wasn't something he seemed really worried about. But I guess we'll keep hearing this kind of stuff just like we did with Broderick Jones, who flipped sides through his early years with the team. In the end, he just wasn't good enough.

John from Toronto: Hi Ray. When will the Joey Porter Jr saga end?

Ray Fittipaldo: Your guess is as good as mine. Will be interesting to see what Porter does today after the Steelers removed back injury as the reason for being on the injury report. Seems like this has to end soon, but who the heck knows?

obxandy: What are chances JPJ plays Sunday? Thank you for your insights.

Advertise with us

Ray Fittipaldo: If you were JPJ, would you want to return against Chase and Higgins? I'm not thinking that would be the smartest business decision.

J D: Ray, how can JPJ get so much bad advice and not lock in to the new offered contract for big money? Is he so out of touch and arrogant that he will bypass the $ because he has hurt feelings because he thinks he's worth more?

Ray Fittipaldo: Apparently the issue are the guarantees in the contract though we don't know exactly what the issues are.

Pittfan: Hi Ray. We've seen in the last 19 years the Steelers manage to win more games than they lose. Does it happen this year?

Ray Fittipaldo: We're only two games in, but I'm starting to wonder if this is the year. I've had similar thoughts in the past. In 2013, they were 0-4 and rebounded to finish 8-8. Things looked really bad in 2019 when they lost Ben Roethlisberger and had to play Duck Hodges for long stretches of the season. And yet they still finished 8-8 again. Of course, Mike Tomlin had a knack for getting the most out of his teams. Maybe we'll see if Mike McCarthy can do the same.

Advertise with us

Silent Bob: Hi Ray - When do you think things hit the tipping point where fans really turn on JPJ? This weekend if he doesn't play? We have the top WR duo - and division rival that is playing well - coming into town - with the Steelers already feeling on the ropes. I wonder how his teammates would respond to him not being on the field?

Ray Fittipaldo: That's a good projection, but I've been thinking this week about the fans turning on McCarthy if the offense has anther slow start. To me, the issues are all on offense right now. The defense has played well for the most part minus giving up a few big plays against the Pats.

Tim: Does Dunker have a realistic chance of contributing this year? Mauler in the run game but lacking in pass pro. Did the organization not realize this pre draft and is this something he can be greatly coached up?

Ray Fittipaldo: Not right now. It appears Brock Hoffman is the top choice at right guard if there is a change on Sunday. And there were signs pointing to that yesterday in practice.

Offensive: Ray, good morning, this is now 2 straight regimes that have forced “position flexibility” with the OL. And in nearly every case it’s been with young/inexperienced linemen. It all started with Tomlin's indifference towards Dotson, insisting on going back to Feiler, while ultimately trying to get Ben killed with Green playing center, to the last 3 high picks all playing different positions from College. Everyone seems to try and outsmart themselves. How has all this position flexibility turned out so far?

Advertise with us

Ray Fittipaldo: I see your point. Your backups need position flexibility. Your starters do not. Perhaps the Steelers should have honed in on that rather than experimenting with their starters as much as they did in camp.

bill: Ray, should the o line have played together more in the preseason than they did?

Ray Fittipaldo: Yes and maybe the coaches should have sold out and had Iheanachor be the starter from the jump.

Ted Lasso: Ray, why did the Steelers draft a FB and then only use him for 2 offensive snaps against NE. Nothing else was working. Maybe they should have tried to kick start the running game with a lead blocker.

Ray Fittipaldo: The running game was gold awful. The fullback might be part of the answer but so is Darnell Washington.

Advertise with us

Jim: Good morning Ray, Was the injury designation removed from #24 so that the team could start to fine him if the holdout continues?

Ray Fittipaldo: It was removed last week too, and they didn't fine him. Porter claimed a back injury. I'm not saying he does that again today, but you see how this is an issue for the Steelers, don't you?

MrSamsonite: Good morning Ray. It’s only been 2 games but there is a clear difference between Warren and Dowdle. Do you think Coach M will acknowledge this and use Warren more? He is much better in pass protection and a more effective runner. Maybe more like a 60/40 split in favor of Warren?

Ray Fittipaldo: You and I see it, but I'm not sure they do.

Linus: I hate to say this but the Steelers’ offense looks absolutely horrendous. It has to get better or else this season will be a complete disaster. Do you think there is one particular reason why the offense looks so bad?

Advertise with us

Ray Fittipaldo: DK Metcalf and the offensive line playing really bad.

Dan: Hey Ray, thank you for the chat. Do you think Ben gets in the HOF this year? I saw an article on nfl.com where the writer didn’t even list him in his projected inductees. I’m not sure if Ben is appreciated as much as he should be outside of Steelers fans. Playing in the same era and conference as Manning and Brady probably hurt him as well. Thoughts?

Ray Fittipaldo: Roethlisberger should be a first-ballot Hall of Famer, but I'm not sure the voters will vote for him. Especially with the new system. There are no writers from the AFC North represented in the voting. The Hall revamped the entire process and eliminated many beat writers from the process.

PK: Why are the Steelers not giving JPJ fines for not playing in games if the only reason now is conditioning? Seems like the Steelers are losing all their leverage by paying him to do nothing.

Ray Fittipaldo: Proving someone does not have a back injury is hard. It's not like an X-ray or MRI can prove it one way or the other.

Advertise with us

RL Madison: As 'low' as things seem, they can redeem themselves and take early control of the North over this coming 5 day period - then have a 10 day break before hosting Indy. Would the bandwagon then fill up?

Ray Fittipaldo: They'd be climbing to get back on. What do you think the chances are of the Steelers winning twice in five days with an offense that is averaging 8 points per game?

DaquidoBazzini: Hi Ray…Still early, but in retrospect, do you think McCarthy made a mistake switching McCormick and Fautanu from the right to the left side?

Ray Fittipaldo: Let's let them play a few more games before coming to a conclusion on that.

Ray Fittipaldo: I do think some of it has to do with Iheanachor and not wanting to expose him to two positions as a rookie.

Advertise with us

G Man: Hi Ray, if my understanding is correct, the Steelers don’t like to guarantee a lot of money in a contract after the 2nd year. It seems like a lot of other teams are starting to guarantee more money in their player contracts the past couple of years. Are the Steelers going to need to adjust how they structure player contracts in their future?

Ray Fittipaldo: Maybe. They adjusted for T.J. Watt, a future Hall of Famer. If Joey Porter Jr was thinking he'd take a page out of Watt's playbook then I think he overvalued himself. Porter doesn't even have a Pro Bowl to his name. Watt is a multi-time first-team All-Pro and won the NFL defensive player of the year award.

Takoma Tom: Any chance the game this Sunday will be competitive or will Cincinnati boat race the Steelers?

Ray Fittipaldo: What's the bigger key to the game? Making sure Joe Burrow doesn't beat them, or making sure Dexter Lawrence doesn't beat them?

Williamrobert: What's the jpj and Michael Pittman status for this week?

Advertise with us

Ray Fittipaldo: Both limited yesterday. We might know by Friday afternoon when the final injury report out of the week comes out.

Brad in Seattle: At this point, it feels like the Broderick Jones first round bust debacle (I know his injury complicates the discussion) has had far more catastrophic effects and setbacks on the offense than the Kenny Pickett first round bust debacle. Imagine the O-line if Broderick had developed into just a solid starter, not an all pro or pro bowl, just a solid dude - the whole right side, center and left tackle would be set. Would’ve just needed to find the new LG this year. Now, the line feels like it’s in a state of spectacular disarray. Or, in hindsight, do you think the disarray was unnecessarily self inflicted by the new staff? Praying that iMax gets up to speed quickly either way.

Ray Fittipaldo: At this point, I'd blame Jones busting out more than the tinkering by the new staff. But that's right now Fautanu has to start playing better, or people are going to continue to bring this up.

Takoma Tom: After this season is it time to eventuate Omar? I don’t think he’s doing a good enough job. Give the job to Andy and reassign Omar. Rodgers should have never been brought back. He never should have traded for DK. Those are easy one plus Broderick Jones. Yikes were set sack years.

Ray Fittipaldo: Khan is already into his second contract. He's not going anywhere anytime soon.

Advertise with us

Takoma Tom: Can someone ask AR2 when he’s stepping down at the next press conference?

Ray Fittipaldo: Rooney will not do an interview again until after the season is over.

Greenwood: Hi Ray. DK makes more, so I suppose there is pressure to play him, but Bernard (that one big mistake at the end of the game aside) has shown he can catch the ball. And he's known for YAC. At what point do they work the WR with better hands into a more prominent role than the one with consistent drops?

Also, do you think they miss E. Roberts in the run defense game yet?

Ray Fittipaldo: I'm with you on Bernard, as long as he has command of the offense. As for Roberts, he was a street free agent when they signed him in August. If he was still a really good player, don't you think someone else would have signed him before August? Or signed him by now? To my knowledge, he's still out there.

Advertise with us

Tampa Too: Ray. If DK continues his poor play with multiple drops per game when does he get benched? Does it really matter how much money you’re getting paid per year if you’re not producing should you be playing?

Ray Fittipaldo: It does matter. You're not benching a $30 million dollar a year player. Not after two games. Probably not after even 8 or 10 games.

Wreck: It was reported that Spencer Anderson has a broken leg with a chipped bone. How is he still practicing and not on IR? Thanks

Ray Fittipaldo: He's not even on the injury report. I'm not familiar with the specifics, but he was able to finish the game and went through a full practice yesterday.

Mike: Has anyone taken credit/blame for the missed pick-up on that huge bone-crushing sack? Was it Fautanu's miss or did the RB make a bad read?

Advertise with us

Ray Fittipaldo: Frazier took the blame. Said the call wasn't communicated down the line.

Dave Moody: Good morning, Ray, and thank you for the chats. We have receivers that can't catch, an offensive line that can't block, and a 42 year old QB that can't run. What could possibly go wrong the rest of the season? I know that it'll get better, but I can't imagine it getting worse. That was horrible. How would you fix it?

Ray Fittipaldo: Prayer?

Bryan: I know it's early, but have you noticed any pop in the return game that warrants a 4th round pick being used on Wetjen?

Ray Fittipaldo: Wetjen hasn't been bad. I'd say solid. McCarthy did say they were close in the return game so maybe we'll see some "pop" against the Bengals.

Advertise with us

James Ryan: Hey Ray. Would you consider the DK trade the worst in Steelers history thus far? It feels like it was a bit of a panic move after the Aiyuk miss

Ray Fittipaldo: p there right now.

Greg: Can I get my money back for Rico Dowdle? I’m getting Jonnu Smith vibes: a new acquisition getting snaps because we brought him in, rather than because he’s outplaying the guy he replaced. Did we make a mistake moving on from Gainwell, or is the whole running game so stuck that Dowdle hasn’t had a fair shot?

Ray Fittipaldo: Still early, but he hasn't done much. And now he's banged up.

KMan: Hi Ray,

Just a comment re: JPJ negotiations vs Watt. I can't help but think of the scene in True Lies where Charlton Heston's character says to the newbie: "So what makes you think the slack I cut him in any way translates to you?"

Negative Nancy: Hi Ray, I thought when you predicted the Steelers would only win 8 games this season, you were being overly pessimistic, now it looks like you were being overly optimistic.

Ray Fittipaldo: Nah just my gut feeling about the team.

Ray Fittipaldo: OK that's all the time I have for today. The Steelers play on Thursday night next week so Ill be bck the following week.