Gerry Dulac: OK kids, we're going to get started soon as I get a coffee so get ready.....
Gerry Dulac: OK, here we go....
Bill In LA: Gerry, I've seen enough of Aaron Rodgers (and "Hands of Stone” Metcalf). This is not a Superbowl team nor even a playoff team. So let's start a combination of Drew Allar and Will Howard at QB going forward, and see if a franchise quarterback emerges. If so, the Steelers are set up for the future, and if not, the Steelers get a high draft pick to draft a QB. What's wrong with my plan?
Gerry Dulac: Well, you forgot about this season already Bill. And I'll let them know this is not a playoff team and should forego the next 15 games. But, hey, aren't up you up a little early??
Josh: McCarthy spoke about offensive line continuity being the main issue with their rough start. How does continuity fix Spencer Anderson spending more time in the backfield than Jaylen Warren and Rico Dowdle?
Gerry Dulac: Now that's funny. Cruel. Maybe misguided, misinformed. But funny
Read More
Bill In LA: How does having two bald kickers affect the Steelers kicking game?
Gerry Dulac: It's smoooth
Josh: if JPJ sits out this week, do the Steelers take the we want volunteers and not hostages approach and try to facilitate a trade (if anyone is interested). Or do we see them actually start to fine and suspend him and keep him away from the team?
Gerry Dulac: Call this what you want -- a situation, a dilemma, a charade -- it's not going to continue much longer. If Joey decides to play, then all that nonsense in OTAs and minicamp, and then the sudden injury in training camp, was for naught? What was the purpose? If he decides to play, after walking away from something just north of $27 million, and risking injury, how much sense does that make? I like Joey. More importantly, the Steelers like Joey, too. But this won't drag on
John C: Hi Gerry, in your opinion, is Harmon seeing the field enough?
Gerry Dulac: I don't have a problem with his amount of snaps. They want to rotate different guys in there to keep them as fresh as possible. No issue
Bill In LA: Gerry, if I put together a team by drafting players from the 32 NFL team practice squads, and my team plays the 2026 Steelers, what's the score? I say its: Bill In LAers 24 - Steelers 6.
Gerry Dulac: I'm curious Bill -- what color is the sky in your world?
Soggy: Good Morning. Is there a fix for DK? Seems like his confidence has taken a hit as well based on his body language during the game
Gerry Dulac: I'm sure it is terribly frustrating for him. It's like Scottie Scheffler missing all those 2- and 3-foot putts this year. Eventually, it starts to wear on you and makes even the simplest tap-in cause for a basket of nerves. With DK, it's the same. The easy passes are the ones he's dropping.
Marty: Is it true that the L.A. in Bill from L.A. is really Lower Alabama! Roll Tide !
Gerry Dulac: Could be Lower Aliquippa
bill: Gerry, should the Steelers change their approach to preseason and actually play those who will open the regular season?
Gerry Dulac: No. Sean McVay never plays ANY of the Rams starters in the preseason and they seem to do just fine.
Marty: Andy Weidl was a genius evaluating talent while with the Eagles. What changed when he went to the Steelers?
Gerry Dulac: It's the same guy
KinVA: I know it's very early in the new season, but if the Steelers offense sputters once again this Sunday against the Bengals, do you think there is reason for major concern (or panic)?
Gerry Dulac: Panic, no. Too early for that. Concern? Uh, maybe a pinch. But what there will be will be a lot of annoyed fans in Acrisure Stadium who were expecting more who will start voicing their displeasure. And loudly
Charlie from Sugartown: Good Morning Gerry, seems that a new coaching staff, took for granted how young the O Line is, and just expected every single player other than center playing a completely different position would magically gel together. MM comment that they didn't have them work together as a unit during training camp was HC malfeasance! Not bringing in a new young head ca
Gerry Dulac: That young stuff is ridiculous. These guys have played plenty of NFL football, most of them together. Now, I'm willing to allow for the flip-flop of right side-left side. But, unlike Aaron Rodgers, Metcalf, Watt, Heyward, et al., the offensive line played several series together in every preseason game. I'm not suggesting they're not very good because I believe they are. It's been a tough start to the season, but it's a long way to go. As Dick LeBeau once said, "I've seen sicker dogs than this get well in a hurry."
Shar Pourdanish: Most of the blame for the ineptitude of the offense belongs to the players but what about McCarthy’s play calling? Where are the check downs to the backs, hot receivers on a blitz, screen passes?
Gerry Dulac: It's a lot of everything. I've seen plenty of checkdowns to the backs and teams are reluctant to blitz Rodgers a lot because he's so good at picking them up. As for screens, I think those are right up there with the tackle-eligible in McCarthy's offese.
Soggy: what adjustments on offense do you expect to see this week against the Bengals
Gerry Dulac: Hopefully score more than one TD
Tom M.: It seems Porter is either faking the back injury or didn't keep himself in playing condition which could be related. What’s the worse look for Porter and does it reflect poorly on his character regardless?
Gerry Dulac: I was told by medical people who know that there is no blood test that determines a person's level of pain. If JPJ says he has pain in his back, even though he has been deemed healthy enough to play, then he must have pain in his back, right?? I'll say this, the whole thing does not reflect positively on Porter, which is too bad
Dan: Hey Gerry, thanks for the chat. Something I’ve noticed about DK is that he just doesn’t look natural catching passes, especially contested ones. Whereas Hines or Swann looked like it came natural to them. DK can run fast, jump high and is strong but he just doesn’t look like a natural at wide receiver if that makes sense. Swann and Ward weren’t particularly fast but they were players. DK looks more like an athlete than a football player to me. Thoughts?
Gerry Dulac: It does make sense and I get your point. And it's a good one.
Silent Bob: Hi Gerry - do you think JPJ was saying Sunday 'man, I am nowhere near as good as Christiain Gonzalaz!' I doubt it. But he should have. JPJ is good but Gonzalaz just showed how a $30m+ cb plays.
Gerry Dulac: Don't think he did, but you're right about one thing -- Christian Gonzalez is pretty darn good and deserves to be the highest paid CB
TVC15: Hi Gerry, Was Metcalf this butter fingered with the Seahawks? These are bot acrobatic or contested catches he is dropping but simple sure things that would get a high schooler benched. Is there evidence that he will get better?
Gerry Dulac: Yes he was. And, you're right, it's the easy ones he's dropping. Do I think it will get better? Yes I do
Tom M.: If Porter continues to not be available, do the Steelers have any recourse via the collective bargaining agreement to stop paying him and prevent him from accruing service time towards free agency?
Gerry Dulac: Sure. They could start fining him. They could suspend him. But if he keeps saying he has pain in his back and is unable to play, what then? One thing for certain: This whole mess is headed for a battle with the players association.
Soggy: With several QB's going down this past week, does this create a market for Mason??
Gerry Dulac: No. But, as I always say, anything is possible when it comes to desperate NFL GMs
Uncle Leo: Hello Gerry! I feel like Porter has made his point but that if he missed the bengals game — a game he was drafted to impact — then he is now screwing his teammates and the organization and he’s showing you who he actually is. I hope he gets better advice this week than what’s been on offer the last few months. He’s never going to recoup the +$20M he’ll have passed on this season and he might be about to burn bridges with his hometown and employer. Your thoughts?
Gerry Dulac: My thoughts are, your thoughts are pretty much spot on, especially the advice thing
BeaverFallsKid: In the post-Ben Mike Tomlin era, regardless of the offensive coordinator, the strategy was to get the ball out quickly due to shaky offensive line. In watching the Patriots game and reading the comments of AR and HCMM it seems both are looking for more down field passing opportunities with more 5 and 7 step drop backs. In theory that opens up the offense and delights fans. But how can HCMM and AR actually execute that concept with the personnel they have? One reason HCMT won more games than he should have is because he lived in the real world and was able to minimize the weaknesses of his teams. Can McCarthy adjust similarly given what he has learned in two weeks of watching his team and the limits created by his personnel?
Gerry Dulac: Whoa, who let this introspective, bright chap into the chat? I'd pay you but I'm out of money. We donated too much to the JPJ fund
Scott via Louisville: How does Joey Porter’s dad let his son get into this position. Of all the people in his sons life, he has to know the business of the NFL and the resolve of the Steelers. He is under contract for 3-4 million and the Steelers offer him $27 million a year and he tries to play games?
Gerry Dulac: Yes, he should know better. Didn't the Steelers even bring him back as an assistant coach???
TVC15: It is only one loss but .... didn't anybody have a problem hiring a coach who was fired from two different teams that had elite quarterbacks in their prime?
Gerry Dulac: Apparently you did. It's like you said, only one loss.
Scott via Louisville: Do you keep the offensive line intact and give them more time to congeal or do you replace Spencer and or Cook this week.
Gerry Dulac: It's only a matter of time before Max Iheanachor gets in there
Bones: Good morning Gerry. The defense is "good enough" even without jpj. I believe the #1 problem is our offensive line. If our opponents only score in the teens, we'll lose most games. Now, how do we fix it? Or are we on our way to a high 2027 draft pick? Thank you sir.
Gerry Dulac: The defense has not missed JPJ in either of the first two games. I'm willing to give it time. It's only been two games. And they are 1-1. Ask the Chargers and Texans how they feel after 2 games.
Stairway to seventh seed: Gerry: the Steelers are $9m over next year's projected cap with only 40 players under contract. They don't have a veteran QB, Queen, or Porter on the 2027 books yet. Now they will try to "restructure" their way out of this problem, but they may have to make cuts. An aging, over-rated $21m per year slot corner would be an obvious cut. Is this why Ramsey is "mentoring" Porter out of town?
Gerry Dulac: I'm not worried about next year's cap, and rest assured, they're not either. They will deal with that then. Yes, Ramsey might be on his final year. And, because they didn't even consider extending him, Queen could be too. And that would be too bad.
MD Stiller: Gerry, we have seen Steeler O lines take time to gel in the past, and while there are obvious issues, do you think that gelling will eventually happen this season. I think we should bite the bullet and put Imax in there now. Hopefully it won't get our 42 year old QB killed before we gel.
Gerry Dulac: I agree with much of what you just said. It's only a matter of time with Max
Stairway to seventh seed: Gerry: the offensive line has had three #1s and a #2 in the Khan era and is probably the worst in the league. The WR group has used two #2s (one in the DKM trade) and a #3 and spent about $53m of AAV on outside additions and is probably the worst in the league. Which position group is the bigger indictment of the Khan man? Or can the OL flops be blamed on Weidl and the WR on Tomlin?
Gerry Dulac: Oh my, such negative vitriol after two games my friend. I think it's far from the truth that the OL and WRs are the worst in the league. But blame is like Christmas vacation homework -- it gets assigned all the time.
bill cowher: Gerry, thanks for the chats. What changes to the offense do you see coming to improve over last Sunday's performance?
Gerry Dulac: It better start up front, which, by the way, is where the Bengals tried to improve most
Bill: GD--move Cook and Anderson to the bench; sit Dowdle, bring up Lew Nichols and sit the Navy kid,
Gerry Dulac: I'll tell them
Lil Wolf: Morning Gerry. Keep up the good work. Really enjoy your Steelers coverage! It doesn’t appear our receivers are being schemed open. Looks like a lot of 1 on 1 routes where being able to create separation is critical. I know it’s early in the season but there doesn’t seem to be much offensive creativity going on. What’s your take? Thanks
Gerry Dulac: LW, I haven't paid enough attention to confirm the WRs aren't "being schemed open." I had absolutely no problem with the game plan and "creativity" in the first game when they repeatedly attacked deep (and didn't get much help from the WRs and officials). I'll wait before I start to share the same concern/negativity/panic that lots of people in te chat seem to have. But, then, that's why I love ya.
SoCalFan: Hi Gerry - is it the switching of positions? The loss of the O-line coach? The arrow was pointing up last year with our young O-line…now it looks JV. Are we in big trouble with this group or am I living in my fears?
Gerry Dulac: I kinda think it's that last part. But I will say losing Isaac Seumalo in free agency didn't help.
MP: Morning Gerry. You’ve continually stated you felt good about the offensive line. Given the significant investment in draft capital and their poor performances the first two games, when should the Steelers expect a decent return on their investments?
Gerry Dulac: Maybe when Iheanachor gets in there. The injury to Broderick Jones and the loss of Seumalo in free agency did not help this line. Fautanu is probably better suited at right tackle than left. There are issues that need some adjusting.
Stairway to seventh seed: Gerry: Here is what I don't understand about the Steelers unwillingness to declare Porter healthy and then suspend him if he won't play. It is alleged that they are afraid he will file a grievance and be able to claim that he is hurt. Ok, so if he wins that grievance they will owe him his full salary. So what, they are paying that to him now anyway, what's the harm in this hard line approach? The benefit seems obvious of sending a message to existing and future players that they won't tolerate such behavior. What would they be doing if they were currently paying him big $$ to stage this farcical injury "hold out"?
Gerry Dulac: Whoever "alleged" they are afraid he will file a grievance has no idea what they are saying. That is not true at all. But he was declared healthy enough to play but Joey says his back is hurting. What are they supposed to do. I'm sure there are enough people in this chat who have had an MRI or X-ray that revealed nothing wrong but still had pain for some unexplained reason. I'm not defending JPJ, I'm just saying it does happen. As for a message, they sent one, which was more a reminder: You're not going to win that battle with them. And that's why they take the stance they do. And one more thing: Did it dawn on anyone that maybe the team thinks he's hasn't earned the right to position himself like this? I mean, he's not TJ Watt or Cam Heyward after all.
Retire21: Will miss your discussions on the HOF. Do you think the exclusion of Bellichek as first year inductee flames this reorg?
Gerry Dulac: I don't think there's any doubt about that
Tim: Do you feel the Steelers are all in next draft to finally find their next franchise qb or are coach MMc and organization still uncertain of the qb room going forward and it’s possibility of already having one?
Gerry Dulac: That is ALWAYS on their mind
Gerry Dulac: OK, I'm searching for one more good one before I have to run.....
Footballtahn: If you like joey and the steelers like joey - is it that joey doesnt like the steelers? Seems like he wants out of here in a very big way.
Gerry Dulac: You've actually had several good ones from which to choose, but I picked this one. The answer: Joey wants to be liked by the team that pays him what he thinks he's worth
Gerry Dulac: And that's all the time we have today kids. See you next week







Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.