Each week, Christopher Carter gives his grades after watching the All-22 film of the Steelers’ most recent game. While all players are considered, players not named had neutral grades because they didn’t impact the result or their combination of successes and mistakes evened each other out.
Sunday’s 20-3 loss to the New England Patriots was the first time the Steelers scored only three points since Kenny Pickett’s first career start in 2022.
While the defense forced turnovers and kept the team in the game, the offense had plenty of abysmal performances that are reflected in the grades.
Here are this week’s Stars and Skulls:
⭐⭐⭐ (Elite performance)
None
⭐⭐ (Exceptionally good game — or multiple vital plays)
LBs Nick Herbig, T.J. Watt
Read More
The outside linebackers were the best unit on the field for a second consecutive game.
Watt’s 1 1/2 sacks gave him multiple sacks in both games so far, and he added three pressures and a run stuff. Herbig didn’t get any pressures, but he forced and recovered a fumble, had two run stuffs and blew up a screen pass on third down to kill a drive.
The two of them together were a big reason why the Steelers stayed within a touchdown of the Patriots until the final minute of the third quarter.
⭐ (Solid — or made a big play without a costly one)
DL Keeanu Benton, Derrick Harmon, Cam Heyward
Harmon led the Steelers with four pressures and eight tackles, and he had half a sack with two run stuffs on the day. After registering zero pressures in the season opener, Harmon looked more ready to help collapse the pocket.
Benton had three pressures with his three tackles. Heyward added three more tackles, a run stuff, a pressure and another batted pass.
They weren’t stellar, but those defensive linemen were disruptive enough to keep Patriots QB Drake Maye uncomfortable throughout the game.
LBs Alex Highsmith, Patrick Queen
Highsmith would have had a two-star grade with his sack, three tackles, two tackles for loss, three pressures and the pass he swatted at the line of scrimmage. But his offsides penalty negated a Jalen Ramsey sack that would have ended a drive. The Patriots scored their lone offensive touchdown plays later.
Queen also could have received a higher grade, as his interception was a big play that kept the Steelers in it. But he needed to be stronger against the run and he missed some opportunities to slow down the Patriots’ rushing attack.
S Robert Spears-Jennings
Though he played only one snap on defense, the rookie safety did have four tackles on special teams.
P Cameron Johnston
Eight punts on the day, averaging 48.1 yards. Three of them landed inside the Patriots’ 20-yard line.
🤷🏽♂️ Notable neutrals (Player had a mix of good and bad)
WR Germie Bernard
The rookie receiver stepped up with four catches for 35 yards to lead the Steelers in receiver and he delivered multiple solid blocks to help spring teammates. But he also dropped a pass that led to the game-clinching interception.
RB Jaylen Warren
Warren totaled 77 yards from scrimmage on his 13 touches, but there was not much else he could do as he was constantly swarmed behind the line.
K Chris Boswell
For a second consecutive game, Boswell made an impressive kick with a 56-yard field goal. But he also missed another field goal from 57 yards.
💀 (Mildly poor game — or made a critical mistake)
RB Rico Dowdle
Didn’t have much space to run, but also missed some of the opportunities that Warren didn’t.
OL Mason McCormick
Was beaten for a sack, but that was the only pressure he allowed on the day and he was the least of the Steelers’ problems when it came to run blocking.
S Rayshawn Jenkins
Struggled in run defense from the safety position and looked lost at times in coverage. At least he wasn’t charged with getting beat for any big pass plays.
💀💀 (Bad overall game — or multiple critical mistakes)
QB Aaron Rodgers
Though Rodgers was under siege all game, he also held onto the ball too long on some key plays and ran into danger instead of throwing the ball away. It did not look like he was aware of what the Patriots were trying to do most of the game and he did not have many hot reads to counter their blitzes.
OL Dylan Cook, Troy Fautanu
Both the Steelers’ tackles had rough days. Each gave up two pressures and were not consistent assets in the running game. There were some positive reps, but neither did nearly enough to balance out their biggest mistakes in the game.
CB Asante Samuel Jr.
Samuel’s missed tackle Sunday gives him three on the season, showing some consistent tackling issues when he wants to help limit quick passes and the run. He also allowed four catches for 86 yards on five targets in coverage. Samuel lost inside leverage several times when in man coverage.
S Jaquan Brisker
Two missed tackles, wasn’t an asset against the run and allowed four receptions on four targets for 68 yards. He didn’t look strong in man coverage and was beaten for an explosive play.
💀💀💀 (Terrible performance, major hindrance to the team)
OL Zach Frazier, Spencer Anderson
This might have been Frazier’s worst NFL game. He allowed four pressures and was consistently pushed backwards in the run game, blowing up runs for Warren and Dowdle. Even when he technically didn’t give up a pressure, he got pushed back enough that it disrupted teammates in their assignments.
Anderson allowed four pressures and a sack, and he was a major problem for the Steelers’ rushing attack.
The interior of the Steelers offensive line never looked stable during the game. It made the pocket less reliable for Rodgers. And the running backs had to continuously dodge defenders at the line of scrimmage or in the backfield.
WR DK Metcalf
Two more drops for the team’s top receiver. And looked like Metcalf never got open against star Patriots cornerback Christian Gonzalez. Through two games, he has arguably been the biggest liability on the team. That has to change for the Steelers offense to turn things around before it’s too late.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.