There will be one more preseason game to determine how many quarterbacks Steelers coach Mike McCarthy will keep on his 53-man roster.
But he doesn’t need another game to know this: Will Howard and Drew Allar will be on the team.
That decision was reached even before Friday night’s 17-0 preseason loss against the New York Jets, team sources told the Post-Gazette. It didn’t even matter that both Howard and Allar failed to perform like they did a week earlier when they had the town buzzing.
They will be kept when the Steelers reduce their roster to 53 players after Thursday night’s preseason finale in Buffalo.
Howard threw two interceptions in the second quarter, both inside Jets territory, and failed to produce a point at Acrisure Stadium. Allar completed just 11 of 23 passes for 110 yards – 38 came on a deep sideline completion to tight end Lake McRee – and was sacked three times.
“Last week we were able to make big plays and had a lot of production that overcame a lot of our mistakes, particularly penalties,” McCarthy said. “We had mistakes, particularly on those two plays, that we didn’t overcome.”
Read More
After putting up 28 points in the preseason opener against the Packers, the Steelers were shutout in the preseason since a 17-0 loss to the Philadelphia Eagles in 2016. And that despite being inside the Jets’ 37 on four occasions.
“Those two turnovers will really make it sour,” said Howard, who started the game and played the entire first half. “There were some good things out there, but if you don’t win the game and turn the ball over, that’s unacceptable.”
Now the question remains: Do the Steelers retain Mason Rudolph, a decision that would appear to be a given because he is the only experienced backup to Aaron Rodgers?
Rudolph didn’t play against the Jets because McCarthy said he saw all he needed to see from his ninth-year quarterback in the preseason opener against Green Bay.
Howard had his moments in the first half, including a 14-yard completion to Roman Wilson on his second attempt of the night and a 16-yarder to Ben Skowronek on third-and-8 to the Jets’ 31. He finished with 10 completions in 15 attempts for 74 yards.
But, oh, those interceptions.
“One mistake leads to two and it happened on both plays,” McCarthy said, referring to the interceptions. “There was something that wasn’t right and he’s got to play through it. He played through it last week.”
The first came on third-and-4 at the Jets’ 14 when safety Andre Cisco stepped in front of a pass in the right flat for Wilson, who was running a shallow cross.
The second also came on third-and-5 at the Jets’ 37 when he underthrew Wilson on a drag route and was picked off by cornerback Samuel Womack III. McCarthy doesn’t like interceptions in practice, let alone a game.
“There are always plays that are cleaner than others,” McCarthy said. “And those two plays were not cleaner.”
Added Howard: “It’s a shame because both of those were good drives. “I felt like we were moving the ball really well. One of the first things we talk about is protecting the football. I just got to be better.”
Allar did not match his sterling debut from last week when he threw for 153 yards, accounted for three touchdowns (two passing, one rushing) and had a near-perfect passer rating. After replacing Howard in the second half, he completed just six of his first 14 passes for 68 yards until the final drive of the game.
That’s when he completed five of nine passes for 42 yards and moved to the Jets’ 27 when time expired. It was the fourth time the Steelers were in Jets territory and failed to score.
“I need to do a better job, especially early in drives, taking what’s given,” Allar said. “I felt like I passed up a couple opportunities early in drives that either set us back with an incompletion or sack. If I just take what’s there, we’re not backed up. That’s where I felt I could help the offense more.”
Allar’s only highlight was a lofting 38-yard completion down the left sideline to McRee to the Jets’ 17. But that failed to produce points, too, because backup kicker Laith Marjan tugged a 44-yard field-goal attempt.
In his defense, Allar was playing mostly with players who won’t be with the team in another week or so.
“No matter how good a game I played, how bad a game I played, win or lose, it’s about the process and going through the same thing every week,” Allar said. “If you’re changing your routine every week based on how you played, I feel like that just overall it’s not going to help you get better through a season.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.