Ray Fittipaldo: OK just got back from Mike McCarthy interview. It will be Will Howard and Drew Allar only against the Jets on Friday night.
Ray Fittipaldo: Please post your questions.
Turk in MD: What exactly is going on with Troy F? It's been stated in previous chats that he may be our best OL. (Maybe that's Frazier now). Is this just getting familiar again with playing from the left side or something else?
Ray Fittipaldo: I think he's still getting used to playing on the left side. He's done interviews in camp saying as much. There is still 3 weeks until the regular season for him to get that ironed out.
NYSteel: Is it possible that Samuel starts ahead of Porter if Porter does not get back to practice and learn the defense and contract negotiations have broken down/reached a stalemate?
Ray Fittipaldo: I would say as long as Porter is signed by game week he would start. If he doesn't sign until Friday or Saturday then I could see Samuel starting. And yes I know Watt signed on Friday and played, but he's a different animal.
Read More
Buddy Dial: For years I've been hoping for a full back if the steelers genuinely want to run the football. How much do you think MM will employ a fullback ?
Ray Fittipaldo: It certainly seems like Riley Nowakowski is in their plans. Likely will depend on the opponent. Might be 5 snaps one week and 20 the next.
Turk in MD: Looks like the start DL of the future is Benton, Black, and Harmon. Harmon looks legit. Black (it's been reported by the PPG) needs to improve his technique but is a natural NT. My question is whether Benton is just a good rotational player or is he the next Tuitt? His contract suggests that he is? I'm not sure...
Ray Fittipaldo: He's a much different player than Tuitt, who could rush the passer and play the run well. We've seen flashes of pass rush from Benton, especially last season. As far as run defense goes I don't think he's in Tuiitt's league. If Tuitt played now he'd get much more than Benton got.
Ray Fittipaldo: In my first 53-man roster projection I had the Steelers moving on from Johnson. Here is the full story https://www.post-gazette.com/sports/steelers/2026/08/19/53man-roster-p...
NYSteel: Does Kaleb Johnson get cut or traded or make the team?
Ray Fittipaldo: Question to previous answer.
NYSteel: Are you worried about the o-line? They looked awful against the Packers starters.
Ray Fittipaldo: The were some issues in pass pro, but the one sack was on Homer and not the OL. I'd even say it's on the scheme more than Homer. You can't expect a RB to block Lukas van Ness 1-on-1. I didn't think the run blocking was very good, but I don't think they were emphasizing that either. It seemed like they focused on the passing game in the opener.
Buddy Dial: What percentage of defensive plays do you think we will see Watt moving around on the defense ?
Ray Fittipaldo: They won't show anything like that until the regular season. So TBD.
Paddy: Is Max Iheanachor's injury neck-related, and is there any elevated level of concern there? He was supposed to be back in a few days initially and now it's set to be at least 2 full weeks with McCarthy saying he's unlikely to play Friday.
Neck issues can be trickey, and it's a little concerning to me.
Ray Fittipaldo: We have not been told the nature of the injury, but speculation has been it's a stinger. And yes those can be bothersome. According to McCarthy's initial discussion with us it was not considered a serious injury so I doubt it's escalated into something that will keep him out long term, but we'll see. McCarthy said the other day it's unlikely Iheanachor would play against the Jets.
MikeM65 in Florida: The Steelers seem to be dishing out quite a bit of money to players who have never made a pro bowl and even aren't full time starters. Is this the new norm in the NFL?
Ray Fittipaldo: I definitely think they are projecting with Herbig and Benton. I think they'll be starters by next season. In these types of situations, where players are behind established veterans, yes there is some betting on the future. And no, I don't think it's the norm across the NFL. Unique situations with Watt and Highsmith blocking Herbig and Cam Heyward playing well deep into his 30s.
The Robber: Hello Ray,NFL cutdown day can be a roller coaster ride for players. Initially you may make the 53-man roster, but then you’re waived the following day when your team grabs a recent cut from the waiver wire. If the Steelers go shopping the day after cutdown day, what position would they look to upgrade? And who might be cut to make room for the new acquisition?
Ray Fittipaldo: Safety most likely. Not sure their depth is good enough there.
George C. from Scott: Do NFL teams still have a Turk? I remember that from the Noll era, but you don’t hear about someone specifically designated much anymore.
Ray Fittipaldo: There might not be one specific person do it, but yes there is a guy or guys who are assigned with contacting players and then having them meet with the GM. We get to see those uncomfortable moments once in a while during the season too when you see someone gat tapped on the shoulder in the locker room when there is a move.
Turk in MD: I appreciate the need to keep a veteran back up QB on the team should/when the 43-year old QB gets injured. Do they think Howard or Allar could be the backup in 2027?
Ray Fittipaldo: I think they're trying to find out if they can be the backup this season. Howard will start against the Jets and the coaches will get to evaluate him against their starters for at last a few series.
Jana: Being an x offensive lineman what is your opinion on if this O line will mesh this year all things considered???
Ray Fittipaldo: It's an interesting group. Frazier is a really good center. I think eventually the left side will be good. Fautanu has not looked real comfortable at left tackle yet, but I think he will. The starters on the right side are placeholders. Eventually it will be Max Iheanachor and Gennings Dunker. How quickly do they become starters is the question. That's the O-line of the future, but Iheanacr's injury and Dunker coming along slowly means it won't happen early in the season.
Turk in MD: Any update on how long before Max is back?
Ray Fittipaldo: I don't think it will be this week.
TVC15: Hi Ray, Is there any trade value for Kaleb Johnson instead of just cutting him? Seems like some team would give a late round pick to take a chance on his potential.
Ray Fittipaldo: I doubt it.
BPOS: One has to wonder if JPJ is wanting to be paid like a top 3-5 CB when its likely the Steelers and the rest of the league put him just outside the top 10. What do you think the risk is he and his agent have LeVeon Bell like delusions and simply refuses to play. It feels like we'd be ok regardless so I think the Steelers have more leverage there no?
Ray Fittipaldo: Bell's own agent did not want him to hold out. That was all Bell. So no, that won't happen. It might come down to the wire, but I still thinks this deal gets done before the start of the regular season.
brian: Hi ray, Do you think the CB play we've seen in preseason from our two corners has given the Steelers some leverage with Porters negotiations knowing they have good back ups?
Ray Fittipaldo: It's nice to know the depth is good, but Porter is an upper echelon player at the position. He makes the defense better if he's on the field.
Stairway to seventh seed: Ray: is part of the 3 vs 4 QB issue dependent on whether Allar can clearly separate from Howard in demonstrating long term potential? If they leave the preseason thinking Allar is definitely a high potential future starter, is there really a need to also keep Howard? If they do keep 4, will that mean that Allar is probably not the answer?
Ray Fittipaldo: Yes there is because Rudolph is not signed beyond this season. I think you want both on the roster next offseason even if the plan is to draft another QB.
Peter: If MM has seen everything he needs to from Rudolph, is he locked in as the #2, or do the Steelers want to avoid him getting injured so a trade can occur?
Ray Fittipaldo: People will certainly read into his comments and the fact that he's not playing. And they might not be wrong.
Ryan: Ray what do you think about the play of Gabe Rubio and Kaden wetjen i think both looked good on Thursday and i think both will get playing time during the regular season with Logan Lee being injured
Ray Fittipaldo: Rubio has been better than I anticipated. He is a good run defender. Wetjen was impressive in his first outing as a WR, but I still go back to what McCarty said a day or two after that. He really challenged Wetjen to produce more as a receiver and said he expected him to score.
Mr Rooney: Lots of excitement after Allar's strong showing against GB. Can a simple change to footwork and rhythm truly make that big of a difference? Granted it was against 3rd string camp bodies. But when up against first-rate competition, can what appears to be very basic modifications truly take a QB from under performer to NFL starter...or even NFL champion? It seems too rudimentary to be so IMO. Your thoughts?
Ray Fittipaldo: I think what we're seeing is Allar has been coached by professional coaches for fourth months, and it's showing up in his game. The coaching he received at Penn State wasn't close to what he's getting with the Steelers.
The Robber: Hi Ray, after witnessing a glimpse of McCarthy’s coaching prowess with QB’s in the preseason game against Green Bay, doesn’t this illustrate a HUGE gap in Tomlin’s resume? The QB is universally regarded as the most important position across all team sports. Yet Tomlin completely failed to develop anything after Big Ben. His talent evaluation was terrible (e.g. Trubisky and Pickett). His development of QB’s was equally poor (Fields & Wilson). And he undercut Rogers’ ability to take reasonable risks. (DON’T turn the ball over!). Tomlin didn’t even see the need to have a QB coach on his staff some years. It’s a QB-driven league and McCarthy elevates that position and develops it. Why didn’t Tomlin ever understand that?
Ray Fittipaldo: I'm sure he understood the importance of the position, but I'm not sure if he was always able to attract top quality assistants.
Jim Bow Dean: Aren’t there only three roster decisions to be made? Four QBs vs. three, Homer vs. Heidenreich, and Kaleb Johnson vs. a seventh DL? Seems to me everything else is obvious.
Ray Fittipaldo: How about the secondary? That position was not easy for me to go through and decide who was on and who was off especially at safety.
Turk in MD: Everybody needs a Turk. :-)
RJ: I tend to be overtly optimistic, I see the O being more pass oriented utilizing the ENTIRE field, I see many O sets utilizing two TE's and I see more passes to the flat area utilizing the running backs. What do you see for the Steelers O ?
Ray Fittipaldo: I definitely think the offense has a chance to be better. It's not just the scheme and design of the offense. They went out and got Michael Pittman Jr. They signed Rico Dowdle. They invested again in the offensive line.
Jewelsongs: Good morning Ray, do you think it makes sense to spend a roster spot on Homer? I know special teams are important, but is he that much better than others? He doesn't add anything as a running back. Thanks
Ray Fittipaldo: He doesn't add anything as a RB, but neither did Miles Killebrew as a safety. Same with Skowronek at WR. There are some guys who are on the team strictly for the abilities on special teams.
Hometown: Any chance the hometown guy (MM) gives another hometown guy (EH) a chance to live the dream? I saw your roster projection and noticed he didn't make the cut.
Ray Fittipaldo: Practice squad I think.
Dormont_Legacy: Nice article on the 53 man projection. But it makes we wonder - why would a skill player not be able to learn or play special teams? Isn’t that just about being an athlete and staying in your lane? I don’t get why someone on the bubble for a roster spot couldn’t learn special teams.
Ray Fittipaldo: Special teams have to get their nose dirty. They have to be tough and instinctive football players. Not every skill position player has those traits.
Steeler Joe: So, Rudolph sits. That means one of a couple of things: they want to keep him healthy as trade bait; they are looking to see if they can survive with just the two young kids behind Rodgers; or Howard and Allar are battling for one spot. Which do you think is the most likely scenario?
Ray Fittipaldo: I think they want to find out if Howard can be the backup. If they come to that conclusion there is no reason to keep Rudolph.
Turk in MD: Can MM really determine whether Howard or Allar can be a starter by the end of this season or is the team locked into drafting a QB in round 1...possibly with a ton of draft capital?
Ray Fittipaldo: I think McCarthy can have a pretty good idea. Listen, you never know until a guy is in that situation, but I think he can learn enough in practices and the preseason games about where he is in his development.
RJ: Just saw the plan is Howard 1st half and Allar 2nd half Friday. I like this, because, in my view if the kids do well, Mason is trade bait. What is your take on this, Ray.
Ray Fittipaldo: I think you might be on the right track.
Tin Cup: Ray, which position group will Patrick Graham's scheme benefit the most?
Ray Fittipaldo: Hard to say without seeing his defense in a real game yet, but he is a creative play caller so I think you could see Jalen Ramsey flourish in his scheme and others who will have freedom to move around and use their instincts to make plays.
Stairway to seventh seed: Ray: after all of that draft capital investment, is offensive line still your biggest concern going into the season?
Ray Fittipaldo: I would not say it's my biggest concern, but they definitely need to take a step forward as a group.
JR in SC: Thanks for the chats Ray. Can you expand a little bit on what footwork issues Allar has? Just saying he has issues is a little too generic for me.
Ray Fittipaldo: He had footwork issues in college. When he got to the Steelers McCarthy put him through his QB school. McCarthy has a very specific and detailed way of developing his QBs. I think you saw the improved footwork in the Packers game when he was asked or had to roll out of the pocket. It was night and day difference between his PSU days.
SoCalFan: Hi Ray…we’re almost there! My question relates to Rodgers. By all accounts, he can still sling it as accurately as anyone can put great zip on it. Is the reason he is no longer a “top” quarterback less about mobility (MVP Stafford can’t run) and more about not being willing to take a hit in the pocket? His IQ and ability to manage a game is a real treat to watch!
Ray Fittipaldo: Right. I think Stafford is a good comp. They both are really good at diagnosing defenses and know where to go with the ball at this stage of their careers. Athleticism was a big part of their games when they were young, but they've adapted as their athleticism has diminished.
Ray Fittipaldo: OK that's all the time I have for today. We'll chat again next week.







Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.