Gerry Dulac: OK kids, let's get the fun started....fire away

Andrew in ATL: Hi Gerry, does camp darling Lee Nichols make the team this year?

Gerry Dulac: Not sure who thinks he is the camp darling but it's going to be very difficult. If it's not Kaleb Johnson, its likely going to Travis Homer because of special teams. But Nichols always looks good to me

BeaverFallsKid: Hi Gerry. The “flip” of the offensive line assignments is probably the right thing to do. However, in the short term, 4 of your guys are playing positions they have not played before for the Steelers. What are your observations of how the OL line guys are adjusting to their new assignments in camp?

Advertise with us

Gerry Dulac: They are not flip-flopping positions to see what's the best combination, they are doing it to see what position flexibility they have with their players. Their line will remain the same, pending Iheanachor's return/development.

Andrew in ATL: How many WRs make the roster out of camp?

Gerry Dulac: Six -- DK, Pittman, Wilson, Bernard, Skowronek and Wetjan, who is the returner

Andrew in ATL: Who starts at RT Opening Day?

Gerry Dulac: Right now it's Dylan Cook. I think the injury has slowed Iheanachor's progress. But it's only a matter of time

Advertise with us

Zamo: This must be the most exciting preseason for me personally in over a decade. I feel so much better about our new coaching staff, our leadership (Khan/Weidl), our depth, QB room and future. The national media are sleeping on us and really believe we will turn heads this season. Do you share my opinion? Hope you and the rest of the media enjoyed another few weeks in Latrobe!!

Gerry Dulac: I might share most of your opinion, but I'm not sure I can come close to matching that unbridled enthusiasm

Josh: Good morning Gerry. There’s a narrative floating around that the Steelers may not value the CB position as much as others (OLB, DT, etc) because they haven’t gotten the JPJ extension done. But are we so sure that they haven’t made a more than fair offer to Porter and he won’t budge off his asking price? Excuse me for speculating, just seems odd to me that the Steelers wouldn’t offer him a fair deal given their issues at drafting that position all of these years. What do you think?

Gerry Dulac: I think most of this is about Porter and what he wants to do -- or what he thinks he's worth. Unless something has changed in the past few days, there has not been any significant discussion/movement toward getting a deal done.

BeaverFallsKid: News reports say John Rahm is coming back to the PGA tour in 2027. Do you think the penalties for returning LIV guys is too much, too little or just about right?

Advertise with us

Gerry Dulac: Too much but I get it

Josh: When the regular season begins, will you miss Tomlin Tuesdays? Or will it be better to have McCarthy Monday’s? Away games may be the worst for that if you need to attend the oress

Gerry Dulac: After 19 years, no.

Sal: Happy Tuesday Gerry! If Allar and Howard keep having solid preseason games, do you see an scenario where Rudolph can be traed

Gerry Dulac: I learned a long time not to discount the possibility of anything, especially if someone comes knocking with a deal that is too hard to pass up. But, as of right now, that is not in their crosshairs at all

Advertise with us

Lou: Hey Gerry. Will the new turf hold up all season or come December people will be complaining as usual?

Gerry Dulac: I think the point of having this new turf is 1) make it uniform as much as possible for all outdoor stadiums, 2) not having problems in December. But, don

Gerry Dulac: Oops...But don't forget (which you might), they re-sod the field at least two times a year after the start of the season

Tampa Too: Gerry. Thanks for all your hard work with these chats. My question is at this point in camp who is your surprise player to make the team and a surprise player to be possibly cut?

Gerry Dulac: Travis Homer could be the surprise player to make the team. Therefore, Kaleb Johnson would be the surprise player to be cut. Remember, I said COULD. We'll see

Advertise with us

Todd: Hi Gerry, which player(s) do you think is a A) benefiting, and B) struggling the most from the coaching overhaul (schemes, philosophies, instructional techniques, etc.) Thanks!

Gerry Dulac: I'm not sure any are struggling with the change, and if they are it's not detectable. There's no questions the QBs have benefitted the most from having McCarthy around. Probably the receivers, too.

Zac from Thailand: Biggest change noticed from your perspective inside the building compared to the Tomlin years?

Gerry Dulac: I'm not qualified to evaluate what happens inside the building because, unlike the old days, we're not inside the building anymore during the week. But the changes from Tomlin have been terribly evident on the field if you were able to attend practice at SVC. His approach, scheduling, philosophy is entirely different

Fletch: Gerry, thank you for the insight and info you provide to us fans. Haven't seen anything yet on playing time for QB's for game 2. Do you think they would be better off having Howard play 1st and 2nd quarters and Allar 3rd and 4th and then switch order for final game? Seems like that would be more productive than giving some of their plays to Rudolph (or Rodgers - hope not). Thanks.

Advertise with us

Gerry Dulac: Rodgers is not going to play, nor should he. McCarthy would only use him if DK and Pittman are healthy and they are not. My guess is you will see much the same rotation as last week, though MM hasn't said what he will do.

Rocky Mtn Steeler: Good morning Gerry. My question is about DK and Pittman. Are they doing anything during practices? Drills? Any activities? Do they work with the QB's on passing drills? Obviously they're not playing in games but I'm trying to understand how injured they are and whether this is something which could affect the beginning of the season.

Gerry Dulac: Not to worry, Rocky Mountain. They will be fine. They really don't need all that training camp work and preseason games anyway.

Fletch: Hi Gerry. Where does B. Jones stand after camp and 1 preseason game with the coaches? Is he currently leading the pack to start at RT? Will he likely end up as swing tackle? Do you see him getting traded if someone has a need? Thanks.

Gerry Dulac: Right now he is the swing tackle because he can play both sides. He might be third in line at RT because of Cook and Iheanachor, once the No. 1 pick returns. For now, a trade is not in their plans, but, again, anything is possible these days in the NFL

Advertise with us

Lebowski: Let’s talk quarterbacks. Is it likely the Steelers keep all four on the roster when the cut is 53? If not, who is the odd man out? I assume the Steelers would at least consider taking a draft pick for one of them. Which is most likely to be traded if an offer is made? How high a pick could reasonably be offered?

Gerry Dulac: To your point, the only QB who would fetch anything in a trade is Rudolph. Howard wouldn't, and Allar isn't getting cut or traded. They probably wouldn't get anything more than a sixth for Rudolph

Fred: Good morning from Prescott AZ Gerry! Do you think the injuries to Ramsey, Pittman & DJ are more severe than being communicated? I know MM is holding them close to the vest, but valuable practice and timing opportunities with Aaron are being missed.

Gerry Dulac: Ramsey possibly, only because he remains on the PUP list. But Pittman and DK will be fine. MM is not being secretive; it's just that coaches aren't required to list the nature of injuries in the preseason, so why should they.

Delaplane: Given the college production, what exactly does it look like to you that Johnson isn't doing? And do you think they'll cut bait?

Advertise with us

Gerry Dulac: What he's not doing is showing whatever he has in a game. He has not taken advantage of any chance he has been given in a game

Fletch: Hi Gerry. Hoping they will keep the 4 QBs. If they keep 4 on the 53, do you think the rest of the O will consist of 3 RB, 6 WR, 4 TE's (including Nowakowski), and 9 OL or are they more likely to lose a player on defense to carry the extra QB? Thanks.

Gerry Dulac: That's a pretty good summation. Nowakowski will either be the 4th RB or the 4th TE, however you want to count him

Corey: Mr. Dulac- much respect for the awesome job you do everyday, thank you! I’m looking forward to watching this defense with the players we’ve added and PG’s gamplanning. What are your thoughts, could this D be top 10 this year?

Gerry Dulac: I'm waiting to see. I don't think it's been stressed enough how much pressure/scrutiny Patrick Graham will be under with this defense. He has a lot of good pieces and depth. Can he show they are better than recent years?

Advertise with us

Penn Hills Stush: Is Kaleb Johnson going to get cut?

Gerry Dulac: Anything is possible

Steeler Joe: Hey, Gerry -- thanks for the chat. I know it's been asked a hundred times, but: Is there a legitimate scenario where the Steelers keep four QBs? It seems like this is the rare situation where it would make a lot of sense.

Gerry Dulac: It does make a lot of sense and it's not as rare as you think. Part of the logic is this: Your starter is retiring after the season, you don't want to bring in another veteran to be the starter, and you have two young guys who you think are pretty good. Plus, every move you have made the past 2-3 years, including with the head coach, is to bring in veteran guys to get you over the top, which is why keeping Rudolph is in line with that thinking. I'll hang up and listen

Steeler Joe: If you were trading one of them, which QB would demand more in return, Rudolph or Howard? I get that Rudolph is a proven vet, but Howard seems to be a young guy with more upside and thus might actually bring more of a return.

Advertise with us

Gerry Dulac: With all due respect, Howard wouldn't fetch anything. He's never played in a real NFL game and last week was the first time he even took a snap in an NFL preseason

Steeler Joe: Will Drew Allar get to see any disguised coverages in preseason? I wonder how he'll do when the defenses stop being so vanilla ... that's when we're going to find out if he's really able to process and make good decisions.

Gerry Dulac: And you may never find that answer because, once the regular season begins, he may never see the field

Fletch: With the Witherspoon deal done, will they be signing JPJ? Based on top salaries and where he lands in that group, it looks like his deal should be something like 4 yrs, $104M with about $72M guaranteed. If they think that's too much for him, will they work on extending ASJ or roll the dice and try to sign one of them prior to free agency next year. Letting both get to free agency seems like a mistake that will likely cost more than working out something now. Thanks.

Gerry Dulac: Witherspoon's deal, or Gonzalez' pending deal, has nothing to do with the Steelers signing Porter -- if they sign him

Advertise with us

Brian in VA: Good morning Gerry! do you remember that time when some silly Steelers fans were disappointed in the Mike McCarthy hire?

Gerry Dulac: I sure do

Fletch: What's your favorite long shot story of this camp? For me it's Rubio, because I think he has a better chance than the Navy kid.

Gerry Dulac: The odds are against the "Navy kid" from making the team because of who's in front of him. Rubio has a better chance because there is probably room for one more DL and he will be in that mix

Ryan: Gerry what do you think about the play of Gabe Rubio i think he looked good On Thursday and he did good in training camp i think he makes the team because of Logan Lee being injured

Advertise with us

Gerry Dulac: You might be right

Happy Gilmore: Gerry, Mitch Trubisky's last pass as a Steeler was an interception over the middle of the field against the Colts. Had he been picked off down the sideline would he have been punished so harshly? It seems like he broke one of MTs commandments and never saw the field again in a black and gold uniform.

Gerry Dulac: As Bill Cowher liked to say, I don't play the what-if game

Seattle Yinzer: Any "new" updates on injuries to DK, Pittman Ramsey and Iheanachor? Feels like the Steelers have a history of underplaying injury reports in camp. It's a shame to see Iheanachor miss two pre-season games - so important for rookies.

Gerry Dulac: That's because the league does not require teams to list injuries in training camp. Nobody is being sneaky here

Advertise with us

Greenwood: Any word on what Iheanachor's injury is and his ETA to return to the lineup?

Gerry Dulac: No. It looked as though he might return last week, according to MM, and that didn't happen. And he wasn't even on the field Monday for practice. He at least was showing up in uniform even when he wasn't practicing

The Dude: Do you think Joey Junior is worth a first round pick? If not, wouldn’t it be silly to give him elite CB money?

Gerry Dulac: Pay the man!

Lenny from NY: Good morning Gerry. While I’m happy Allar played well, what’s with some reporters anointing him QB for the future. He looked good against third string players trying to make the practice squad. I understand the hope and I hope also but it’s a little premature IMO. Thoughts?

Advertise with us

Gerry Dulac: A little premature??

jonnybgoode: Hi Gerry, what do you see as the main differences between Howard and Allar from a capabilities perspective. Do one or two things stand out from what you’ve seen so far?

Gerry Dulac: Yeah, the throwing arm. Allar can really sling it, though everybody knew that. But if a throwing arm was all that mattered, Jeff George would be in the Hall of Fame

Abella Danger: Hey Gerry, do you think if JPJ gets upset enough he could be traded?

Gerry Dulac: I don't think he's going to be traded.

Seattle Yinzer: I love "Zamo's" question and enthusiasm. And agree with your response, but you did not say why your not matching his enthusiasm? For me - it is lack of trust with the OL. Could you elaborate?

Gerry Dulac: No, it's because I don't get enthusiastic about anything in August

Kevin in Charlotte: Thanks for the chats Gerry. Supposedly our coaching, OL, receivers, DL, LB’s, and secondary are all better than previous years. QB and RB- so,so. Why do the national media jackwagons act as though we can’t make some noise come January?

Gerry Dulac: Why do you (or they) say QB is so-so? And especially RB? That's because those national people typically know not of what they speak

BH: Hi Gerry. The Steelers seemed to show quite a bit of talent, well beyond 53 they can keep. Do you think there are any players in the category of 'we let them go and now they come back to haunt us'?

Gerry Dulac: I'll hold off on that one. That, though, can be the case every year with every team. Sometimes, good players have to be let go.

Delaplane: Going back to KJ... you can't show it in a game if you aren't in the game. There must be something in the practices that is causing him to not be used?

Gerry Dulac: Maybe they use him more this week. Preseason games are to take a look at a lot of people and answer questions. Maybe they wanted to see if Homer, a special teams guy, can be a dependable RB?

Jim Bow Dean: Aren’t there only three roster decisions to be made? Four QBs vs. three, Homer vs. Heidenreich, and Kaleb Johnson vs. a seventh DL? Seems to me everything else is obvious.

Gerry Dulac: I think you got the players mixed up for your camp battles.

Uncle Leo: Gerry…hellooo! Training camp is very conflicting for most of us. On one hand, we want the O to move the ball and score TDs but also want the D to dominate and shut down everything. So if one makes a big play, it’s like a mix of excitement and anxiety because that means we may have a big concern on the other side of the ball. Help us balance this roller coaster of emotions!

Gerry Dulac: Alas, I can't when you think that way. Defenses aren't going to dominate and shut down everything, especially this defense. maybe any defense. This isn't 1976 after all. Actually you and the coaches share a common denominator -- balance. Yours involve emotions. Theirs involve execution

Turk in MD: Hi Gerry, thanks for the chats.

Should we not read too much in to MM's comments about the team having a 1st round grade on Allar? I seem to remember the previous administration saying the same thing about Mason when they took him in the 3rd round.

Gerry Dulac: Correct. I wouldn't read too much into it, other than MM really liked Allar. That was the QB he wanted in the third round, even if Carson Beck were still available

Turk in MD: Good morning Gerry. If Max is not ready to go by the last preseason game, does the team trust him to eventually play this season...or does he miss his window? Being a 1st round pick, I would hope they'd give him every chance to start but under the last head coach...that probably would not have happened.

Gerry Dulac: That was the last head coach. But always keep in mind, a non-Super Bowl team doesn't draft a player on the first round to have him sit around and eat popcorn. Max will eventually play.

Tommy in Florida: Is there any shot Lou Nichols makes the team?

Gerry Dulac: Sure, but it might be slim

Bustin Aechtold: Gerry, is QB the leader in the clubhouse for what position the Steelers draft in round 1 in 2027? And on the flip side, was the future QB for 2027-28 season in Latrobe this season?

Gerry Dulac: That's what we're going to find out. But, as for the leader in the clubhouse, yes

Tommy in Florida: Good Morning Gerry, Thanks for the chats. Going into preseason game 2, who are you eyeing that needs to make an impact to solidify a roster spot? Thanks for your insight.

Gerry Dulac: Kaleb Johnson

Stairway to seventh seed: Gerry: the Steelers have now handed out about $53 million per year worth of contracts to three players who project as backups to three players (Watt, Friermuth, Heyward) who average about $70m per year total and either are in decline or under performed in 2025 or both. Is this prudent cap management by the Khan artist?

Gerry Dulac: I think they are taking full advantage of an expanded salary cap and not having a $100 million QB

Mr Rooney: Gerry. Thank you for the chats kind sir. ESPN dumped on the Steelers pretty hard ranking them 30th out of 32 franchises. Behind even the Jets even?!? I understand the aging argument and that QB remains middling in this upcoming season and very unclear beyond. But 30th?!?!?? IMO there is a good deal of young talent pushing for more playing time after a few successful drafts. And by position groups the Steelers look decidedly stronger and deeper as well. Secondary and D-line in particular are pointing significantly upwards. O-line has the draft picks but remains an open question. RB's WR's...even TE's look stronger too. So I dunno, am I misguided or is this yet another example of national pundits not getting into the details and making a quality assessment of the franchise. Granted not winning SB's sux. But to call the consistent level of winning in PGH "mediocre" just sounds wrong to me. What say you?

Gerry Dulac: That's all you need to know about ESPN and the idiots who put that together.

Seattle Yinzer: With respect, I don't agree - I love your appearances on the Rich Eisen show and your are very enthusiastic.

Gerry Dulac: Haha. I think Rich brings that out in me!

Mr Rooney: Does the kid from Lebo end up on PS? They certainly seem to be trying out his versatility (running, receiving, returning?) The Swiss Army idea of things has an appeal...no?

Gerry Dulac: More than likely

Aces High: Is Omar Kahn signing guys ahead of JP causing the delay in his contract or is it they don't feel he is a 30 million AAV player? This seems to be market rate for a shut down corner.

Gerry Dulac: No, he's signing them because they are amenable to getting a deal done. So what does that tell you....??

TVC15: Is Allar's ankle injury 100% healed and a nonfactor now?

Gerry Dulac: Non-factor

Dan: Why even waste a roster spot on Johnson? There is absolutely nothing he brings to the table.

Gerry Dulac: There must be something.

Bermanski: Hi Gerry, how would Nick Herbig compare to Chad Brown in his prime? He's similar stature and seems to have a simialr style of athleticism. Does he also have similar inside-outside capabilities?

Gerry Dulac: I think Herbig has a way to go before comparing him to Chad Brown

Gerry Dulac: OK kids, that's all the time we have today. Let's try it again next week