Welcome to Brian Batko's Steelers mailbag. You can submit your questions to Brian directly @BrianBatko on X and bbatko@post-gazette.com.
Ron K: I’m still curious about the long-term plan for a franchise passer. Since they didn't use their draft capital to move up this year—likely because Mendoza was the only top-tier prospect—where does that leave them? Having drafted Howard and Allar in back-to-back years, do they believe one of them can overcome their deficiencies under MM? Or will they look to the draft again next year? If so, do they have the assets to move up for one of the top prospects, or would they consider trading future picks to get in position? I suppose a lot hinges on how Howard and Allar look in camp. Thanks!
Brian: Yes, a lot hinges on the progress of Will Howard and Drew Allar or lack thereof. Really, it will be up to the coaching staff and how they gauge that progress.
As an avid “Hard Knocks” viewer, I watched the season Mike McCarthy was on with the Dallas Cowboys. And I remember an episode when they were discussing keeping Pittsburgh’s own Ben DiNucci on the roster at cut-down time, and McCarthy issued a mission statement of sorts.
“This is my issue — to me, this is a philosophical issue — I just don't believe in giving up on a guy in his second year,” McCarthy tells Jerry and Stephen Jones as they sift through the quarterback depth chart. “Ben DiNucci has things we’re not gonna find in free agency. If Ben DiNucci’s gonna make it, he’s gotta get it going between his ears. But the physical tools are there. I’m disappointed he didn’t show us more in the games. ... But he’s a young guy. We may have something there.”
In the end, DiNucci didn’t make the team that year and never played in another NFL regular season game. But that’s not the point. It’s a glimpse into McCarthy’s quarterback mindset.
Read More
And with all due respect to DiNucci, he was a seventh-round pick, not a third-rounder or even a sixth-rounder. So imagine how patient McCarthy can be with Drew Allar and Will Howard — or Drill Hallard, as I’m referring to them — and how that could affect the draft strategy in 2027.
But I wouldn’t recommend going down the rabbit hole of first-time draft-eligible 2028 quarterbacks. Then you might run across Akili Smith Jr. and your mind will really have a tough go of it with Father Time.
Sean M: Hey Brian. While the Steelers draft seems competent if uninspired, do you have any insight to the possibility that the team sought to draft solid/good players with work ethic and character over “flashy” and selfish guys that disrupt team chemistry? Not saying these guys are not talented, but a roster with more hard hat guys and fewer drama queens might be just what the Steelers need in the post-Tomlin era. Thoughts?
Brian: Hey Sean. Omar Khan has talked a lot about bringing in “good people” since replacing Kevin Colbert as general manager. He tends to put that even before “good players,” which probably speaks to your point.
To me, it’s certainly productive for establishing and maintaining the culture you want. If nothing else, it raises the floor. The Steelers had a pretty high ceiling when they had, shall we say, some malcontents in the mix. But then again, they never broke all the way through. Anecdotally, as someone who’s in the locker room just about every time it’s open to media, I can feel a difference over the past few years.
Lee Y: Which of our 3rd round draftees were drafted with the third rounder we got from Dallas in the George Pickens trade? Thank you very much. Love your stuff.
Brian: Why, thank you, Lee. That would be No. 76 overall, Drew Allar. We’ll see how he compares to the players the Steelers drafted with the picks they acquired for Chase Claypool (Joey Porter Jr.), Antonio Brown (Diontae Johnson) and Martavis Bryant (Mason Rudolph, by way of a seventh-rounder, too).
Wait, I also just realized both Allar and Rudolph were drafted 76th. Speaking of quarterbacks and player-for-pick deals, Kenny Pickett turned into Payton Wilson and Donte Kent, more or less.
Chris B: What’s with this big idea that the Steelers need to have a veteran backup? I know Howard is inexperienced, but would it not make more sense for the Steelers to give him QB2 reps and let him grow as opposed to being on the scout team?
Brian: I don’t necessarily agree with that notion, Chris. It sounds like you and I are generally on the same page that unless Will Howard looks borderline non-functional as an NFL quarterback, you’re better off banking on his upside and development than having Rudolph on retainer again.
You make a valid point about the practice aspect of it, as well. We’ve had this conversation so often through the game-day lens, but reading plays off a card and doing what the script dictates as the scout-team quarterback wouldn’t be nearly as beneficial as running your own offense. It would be a lot riskier than keeping Rudolph around for any sort of rescue, of course. At some point, you just have to take that calculated gamble as a nod to the future.
Ed H: Of the AFC North teams, which club has had the best overall offseason so far? And why?
Feel free to list best to worst in your opinion.
Brian: Well, Cincinnati is the only team that kept its coach from last season. But that could be a classic case of: “Is that the good news or the bad news?” If you think Zac Taylor is no good, then the Bengals’ coaching stability is less of a feature and more of a bug.
But even on top of that continuity, the Bengals made the biggest splash — literally — by trading for 6-foot-4, 340-pound defensive tackle Dexter Lawrence II, a two-time All-Pro. Finding players to help score points has never been much of an issue with Joe Burrow throwing to Ja’Marr Chase and Tee Higgins. It’s keeping opponents off the scoreboard that has been a challenge, and Lawrence should make a difference.
Baltimore made an impact addition, too, in Trey Hendrickson. Sure, it came at the expense of Maxx Crosby, but the Ravens wound up with Hendrickson and Penn State guard Vega Ioane as their first-round pick instead. It looks as if they have a massive weakness at center, though. The downgrade from Tyler Linderbaum to whoever starts there for the Ravens might be the single largest drop-off from any team in this division’s 2025 roster to 2026.
Meanwhile, Cleveland is saving up for the kids’ college funds while the rest of the division lives its life. Some sensible signings in free agency — mainly to replenish the offensive line — plus another deep draft class but still not much to get overly excited about under new coach Todd Monken until the quarterback situation has any clarity. The Browns effectively elected to punt on that position this offseason, so they’ll likely be punting a lot come the fall.
Which brings us to the Steelers, whose offseason ultimately will be determined by the success they have in the short term and long term with McCarthy, their first head-coaching hire in 19 years. But on the player personnel front, they’ve essentially gone from Calvin Austin III, Adam Thielen, Kenneth Gainwell and Isaac Seumalo to Michael Pittman Jr., Germie Bernard, Rico Dowdle and Gennings Dunker on offense, plus Max Iheanachor. The defense has gone from Daniel Ekuale, James Pierre and Chuck Clark/Kyle Dugger to Sebastian Joseph-Day, Jamel Dean and Jaquan Brisker, by and large.
It’s hard not to think the Steelers have built a better supporting cast for Aaron Rodgers. But how much is the question. Just about every team thinks it’s gotten better between February and May.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.