To help count down the days until the 2026 NFL Draft here in Pittsburgh, the Post-Gazette’s beat reporters will rank the top 10 draft picks in Steelers history. The series will conclude April 23, the day of the first round of the draft at Acrisure Stadium. Let the debates begin.
9. Mike Wagner
Round 11, pick 268 in 1971
10 seasons with Pittsburgh
The Steelers built a portion of their vaunted Steel Curtain defense in the 1971 draft, getting linebacker Jack Ham in the second round, end Dwight White in the fourth and tackle Ernie Holmes in the eighth.
But maybe their greatest move was getting a four-time Super Bowl starter all the way down in the 11th round.
Mike Wagner was a hard-hitting safety who started 116 of 119 regular-season games since he was a rookie and saved some of his biggest moments for the biggest games.
Read More
Former linebacker Andy Russell called Wagner “the best safety the Steelers ever had,” a rousing tribute to a player who had 36 interceptions, 12 forced fumbles and five fumble recoveries in 10 seasons.
Wagner also had five interceptions in the postseason — two coming in the Super Bowl when he picked off Hall of Fame quarterbacks Fran Tarkenton and Roger Staubach in back-to-back years.
His ability to anticipate plays was one of the reasons he was named first-team All-Pro in 1973 after tying for the league lead with eight interceptions. He was also a Pro Bowl selection in 1974 and 1975.
“Our defense got to be pretty complicated, and Mike knew what everyone was doing,” said Hall of Fame linebacker and longtime friend Jack Ham.
Wagner played on a defense that eventually had five players voted into the Pro Football Hall of Fame — Ham, Joe Greene, Jack Lambert, Mel Blount and Donnie Shell. But his tenacity and intelligence were a valuable asset to a unit that terrorized the NFL.
And they found him on the 11th round.
The PG’s top 10:
9. Mike Wagner, S, 1971






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.