Ray Fittipaldo: Good afternoon. Let's get the chat started.

Stairway to seventh seed: Ray: I have seen Georgia Tech Guard Keylan Rutledge mocked to the Steelers in the 3rd round and they did bring him in for a visit, but I have also seen him mocked in the early 2nd round and ranked #44. With the signing of Hoffman, do you think Rutledge is still a target and what round do you think it would take to get him?

Ray Fittipaldo: This is the type of draft where there won't be a lot of difference in how teams rank guys in the second or third round. So some guys you see in the second will fall to the third and vice versa. It's just going to depend on how the individual teams rank these guys on their board. This is a depth draft. Good prospects, but it's not projected as the type of draft that's going to produce superstars. Of course, much of that has to do with the lack of top QB prospects, but it also applies to other positions.

Bob: Now that we signed Brock Hoffman to replace Semealu along with the Pittman, Brisker, Dowdle etc can the Steelers now draft best player available?

Advertise with us

Ray Fittipaldo: I wouldn't say Hoffman was signed to replace Seumalo. I think the leader in the clubhouse (before the draft) is Spencer Anderson. Honestly, Hoffman might be competing with Ryan McCollum for a roster spot as the top interior backup at center and guard. But we'll see how camp unfolds. To answer your question, yes with those other moves they are set up to draft the best player available at certain positions (in my opinion, guard, safety and receiver).

Lab in Whitney: Thanks for all of the great work Ray. A personal question if you don't mind - all of your fans really enjoy your work here and on the radio. Where are we going to be able to find you after May? We NEED our "Ray F Steelers fix" !! ... and a Steelers' question - does Roman Wilson make the team this year?

Ray Fittipaldo: Yes Roman Wilson will make the team this year. The coaches want to develop him... As for your other query, hopefully I can answer that soon. Like everyone else, I'd like to know ha ha.

Stairway to seventh seed: Ray: are you souring on this WR class at all? Tate ran a slow time. Lemon is reported to have had strange interviews. Tyson has injury concerns. Concepcion had 7 drops last year. Cooper padded his stats with 207 yards and 4 TDs vs Indiana State.

Ray Fittipaldo: My favorite has always been Tyson and I haven't soured on him. I don't have the medical information the teams have, but I like him best. It does seem like the receivers are falling a bit in some of these mock drafts. We'll see how it plays out. Maybe one goes in the top 10 and then there is a run on the others shortly thereafter. Or maybe the first one is drafted at 12 or 15 and the Steelers have their pick of two or three guys in that spot at 21.

Advertise with us

chuck Mac: What is your % call on ARod returning to Steelers. If he doesn't return - please tell us you don't see something other than Will Howard/Mason as the 2 main QB's. Hate to see us go to the dumpster pile!

Ray Fittipaldo: This is an educated guess, but I'm at 80% he'll come back. And if he does retire then I think Will Howard would be competing for the starting job with Rudolph and maybe another veteran, but honestly who's left out there who would seriously challenge either?

Stairway to seventh seed: Ray: do you think the recent more positive reports on Brod Jones's health are a smokescreen and they are looking at tackle in round 1? Jones wasn't that good anyway and with Hoffman in the fold, Guard seems like less of a need.

Ray Fittipaldo: As I wrote above, I don't view Hoffman as a slam dunk starter over Anderson. They might draft a guard in the first three rounds too. That rookie would be part of the competition if he's taken that high. Obviously, the two veterans would have an advantage, but anyone they take on the first two days of the draft would be competing for time.

Jim Bow Dean: I’ve read in several places that they should not draft a QB because you can’t develop two at the same time. Normally they may be true, but if Aaron comes back how many snaps in McCarthy’s office does he need? There should be plenty to go around.

Advertise with us

Ray Fittipaldo: I disagree with that. As long as you don't have your future starting QB you might as well take as many bites at the apple as you can.

Jim Bow Dean: In Tomlin’s 19 seasons only 3 times did an insider linebacker make a pro bowl. Timmons once and Shazier twice. Shazier probably would have made more, but still isn’t that ridiculously low? Maybe what Tomlin was asking the linebackers to do was the problem and not the players.

Ray Fittipaldo: I guess we'll find out, but inside linebacker in today's NFL is one of the most difficult positions to play. You have to be athletic enough to cover TEs and RBs an even WRs on occasion. On top of that, you have to be big and strong enough to be effective against the run, which means taking on blocks and getting a little dirty.

artie bridge: Hi Ray. How do you assess Patrick Queen's play in his two years with the Steelers? Seems to me he hasn't lived up to his hype or salary. What do you think he could command in a trade?

Ray Fittipaldo: First off, I don't get the sense the Steelers want to trade Patrick Queen. Whenever you sign someone to a big money deal there are expectations. I don't believe he's lived up to the contract, but he's been OK. He improved from year 1 to year 2. Unfortunately for him,, now he's learning a new system and new coaches. Everyone is, but I think it's especially challenging when you're the quarterback of the defense and the hub of communication.

Advertise with us

Paolo: Where would Will Howard rank in this years QB class?

Ray Fittipaldo: I get this question every week and I never published it because it's so hard to say. Maybe he'd be a Day 2 pick this year rather than a Day 3 pick. But does it really matter? He's here, the Steelers like him, and he's going to be developed.

Bob: Any chance Steelers plug Proctor in at LG in 26 and LT in 27?

Ray Fittipaldo: I'm not sure how the dominoes would fall, but rest assured if they draft an offensive lineman in the first round that player will have a real opportunity to start early.

Rick Woods: Ray, I don’t understand all the Drew Allar hate from fans. I think he’s exactly the type of QB pick the Steelers are looking for in this draft. Excellent physical traits, played at a big school against top tier talent, projected first round pick that fell down the draft boards because of an injury and poor senior year performance, available in the 3rd or 4th round where they have multiple extra picks. What’s not to like with that scenario? Low risk, high reward pick. Am I wrong?

Advertise with us

Ray Fittipaldo: You're not wrong. QB might be the play with one of those three third-round picks. Allar is an interesting prospect. He never performed well in big games. That's really concerning for me because an NFL starter should be able to elevate the play of those around him. Allar wasn't able to do that. But there are questions about how well he was coached, the style of offense, the play-calling, the receivers he worked with. I get the big picture. In the end, I think some team will roll the dice on him on Day 2. He has too many traits you cannot teach.

Bob: Greg Lloyd or James Harrison

Ray Fittipaldo: James Harrison. I'm not even sure it's a debate.

Tampa Too: Ray. How many more mock drafts are you going to do for the Steelers prior to the actual draft next month?

Ray Fittipaldo: Just one more. Will wait until the pro days are over and then I'll do my final one.

Advertise with us

Pistol33: Thanks for the chats Ray!! If they pick a QB who's your prediction they select and what round ?

Ray Fittipaldo: My educated guess is third round based on the players they've had in for visits and the guys they had formal interviews with at the combine. I'd just be guessing on who.

Jerry: Do you think Chris Boswell and the Steelers will soon get an extension done? Thanks Ray

Ray Fittipaldo: I'm not sure about the soon part, but they'll sign him before the season starts.

Darnell: Hello Ray. I’ve heard Denver may be willing to trade Mims after acquiring Waddle. Do you think there is any truth to this and if so, what might the Steelers need to give up to get him? Thank you.

Advertise with us

Ray Fittipaldo: They should see what happens in the draft before they make any more trades. This is a good draft for receivers.

Chill Dave: Hi Ray, if the top two safeties, top three WRs, and the PSU guard were all off the board, who would you take of these four: Cooper Jr., Boston, Concepcion, McNeill-Warren?

Ray Fittipaldo: Boston or McNeil-Warren. I think Boston would be the best receiver on the board at that point. They can figure out how to use those guys. Just get the best player. McNeil-Warren is a playmaking safety with versatility who would fit nicely into the defense as well.

Chill Dave: Hi Ray, assuming what we assume about the 2027 draft, would you trade this year's 1st round pick straight up for a 1st rounder in next year's draft (assuming a willing trade partner, of course)?

Ray Fittipaldo: No. Too much unknown there. That pick could be No. 32 or 27. They're picking at 21 this year. It's interesting. There is a belief in the analytics community that future draft picks are overrated, but there are a lot of teams like the Steelers who are QB-needy who will be looking to amass draft capital next year. Going to be fun to see what happens.

Advertise with us

MikeM65 in Florida: It's been a few years since Johnston has been a good punter and to me Waitman seemed to be at least average. Why risk Johnston when Waitman was a restricted free agent?

Ray Fittipaldo: Johnston was their guy before the injury. Maybe he's fully recovered and they believe in his ability a little more than Waitman.

Linus: What is your opinion of the new Steelers’ coaching staff and how would you rate it on a scale of 1 to 10?

Ray Fittipaldo: Generally I like the staff, but let's wait to see what they do in actual games!

Chris O., Glassport: Thanks for your chats Ray. I saw one mock draft in which the Steelers take Kenyon Sadiq. How far up would the Steelers need to move up if they had the chance to get him? I’d be surprised if he was available at pick #21.

Advertise with us

Ray Fittipaldo: I can't see them taking a TE in Round 1.

CG: Hi Ray, what helps Rodgers the most for the coming season as the Steelers first pick. a left guard, a slot wide receiver, or a defensive stud that helps the defense get off the field on 3rd downs?

Ray Fittipaldo: Probably a receiver given the current stare of the room.

Michael: Ray, is a middle linebacker a black horse pick in the 2nd / 3 rd round? Assuming Queen is not extended and Wilson remains one dimensional, 2026 looks bleak at that position.

Ray Fittipaldo: Yes it is. They had Jacob Rodriguez in last week. They've been focused on some other ILBs too.

Advertise with us

Greg: Could Ioane be our next David DeCastro? He's a total brick wall and fills our biggest hole on the line. I'd much rather spend the 1st rounder on a sure thing in the trenches that gamble on another project. What are the odds he actually falls to us at 21?

Ray Fittipaldo: I don't know if he'll be there at 21, but the Steelers will definitely consider him if he is. He's the best pure guard prospect in this draft.

ralph: Since all options are open on what position we should draft, i think, out of left field, pick Sonny Styles, if available. He is a difference maker on every defensive play . Just saying .

Ray Fittipaldo: I'd be OK with that, but I doubt he falls all the way to 21. I saw one recent mock had him going to the Bengals at No. 10. I've seen some others with him going earlier.

Swannie88: Hi Ray - WR high in the draft is a must, right? If Pittman or DK goes down, it is deja vu all over again. What do you think? Thanks.

Advertise with us

Ray Fittipaldo: Yes, almost certainly in the first two rounds.

Wiscoken: Hi Ray - What is it that makes scouting college QB's so much more difficult than other positions? No other position carries as much risk (and high failure rate) as QB. First round draft pick failures rates remain very high, and even with all the modern advanced analytics, the scouting and draft failure rates remain staggeringly high.

Ray Fittipaldo: I think the main issue is the colleges do their own thing with their offenses. There are not many college teams running pro-style offenses. You can project, but you don't know how they'll operate in an NFL-style offense.

Arthur not Art: Have you had enough exposure to McCarthy to get a feel for the differences between him and Tomlin and if they will change how veterans and younger players are managed and developed?

Ray Fittipaldo: I have not. Without the rhythm of practices and seeing him in his element I don't have an opinion just yet.

Advertise with us

Dj: Jalen Ramsey is set to make $19.5 million this year, next year that rises to $21.7 million. At this stage of his career and based off his play last year I was surprised they brought him back. He did not play like a top CB and at safety there seemed to be a lot of broken plays. Was the blown coverage due to communication issues and do you think his play will elevate under Graham?

Ray Fittipaldo: I know the new staff is excited to work with him. They believe he'll be a big part of what they do on defense. Just how he's deployed we'll have to wait and see.

Rob in CT: Regarding Allar, I Googled greatest QB's from Penn State. #1 was Kerry Collins. PSU is known for LB's but not QB's. Allar didn't have much with WR's I've heard. I'd roll the dice in Round 3. What do you think? Thx

Ray Fittipaldo: I would not be opposed to that.

Arthur not Art: When do you think they take a TE? If it's in the 3rd or 4th, who do you think they target? Thanks.

Advertise with us

Ray Fittipaldo: I think third or fourth round is a solid spot to address TE. They have their pas-catching TE in Freiermuth and their run blocker in Washington. Whomever they get should be able to do both.

Greg: What's your guess on how much Washington plays this year vs last year?

Ray Fittipaldo: Interesting question. I do think Arthur Smith really valued Washington and what he brought to his offense. Brian Angelichio is a former TEs coach wo maybe that bodes well for Washington, but we really won't know until we get to camp and see what their plans are. I do know this: They signed Freiermuth to a big contract. I think there is a desire within that building to get more production from him, and that might mean a slightly reduced role for Washington.

BAB: Same question I asked Gerry last week. His answer was interesting. I asked what was Mike McCarthy’s experience developing a raw quarterback. Gerry replied, not verbatim: he has never really developed a raw quarterback. What are your thoughts?

Ray Fittipaldo: I mean, he's right. He went from Favre to Rodgers to Prescott. Other than when Rodgers was injured and a backup had to play we really didn't get to see McCarthy working with a developmental QB for a long stretch.

Advertise with us

Realist: I would like to see the Steelers draft a playmaking safety. I believe that position is undervalued. A true playmaking safety can make a huge difference. I saw you had the S from Oregon in your mock. Will they need to trade up to get him?

Ray Fittipaldo: I agree with you. He might be there at 21. You never know, but I almost always see him gone before 21 in the mocks I see online.

Steeler Joe: Regarding trading picks for next year: Everyone assume THIS year was going to be a hot one for QBs, too. I'd never assume such a thing. It's dangerous.

Ray Fittipaldo: True, but you also have to trust your scouts who are out there watching these guys from August until January. If they tell you 2027 is going to be a really good class you have to listen to them. I understand what happened this past season, but I think that was a bit unusual.

Gretta: What are we to make of all the photos released of Roger’s and Howard seemingly inseparable (or so we have been lead to believe) at a charity event they both participated in last weekend?

Ray Fittipaldo: I know Rodgers thinks very highly of Howard and that he'll do whatever he can to help him. Beyond that, I would not read too much into any photos of the two.

Al Tuna: With 12 draft picks, the Steelers were positioning themselves to draft a QB from a deep class that proved to be underwhelming. I hope the fact the draft is being held in Pittsburgh doesn't factor into their picks. They have an opportunity to strengthen there roster by picking the best available atheletes and should do so.

Ray Fittipaldo: I think they will do that, Tuna. I don't think they will reach for a QB. They just did that with Kenny Pickett.

Steel Russel: Does the uncertainty, that Mike provided in his interview yesterday. make it time to investigate a cheap option like anthony richardson?

Ray Fittipaldo: I don't think so.

Ryan: Good afternoon Ray what do you think about the signing of Jaquan brisker i think it was a good signing because he’s from Gateway high school

Ray Fittipaldo: I think he's a good player, but he only signed for one year. I think they want to draft a safety from a strong safety group in this draft.

Wiscoken: How close is Peyton Wilson to truly being a "green dot" every down player? He has shown glimpses of having what it takes, but he has also shown to really struggle shedding off blockers. Not sure if this is a technique challenge... a strength/size challenge... or something else. It seems as if he is close, but I'm also sure this can be said of a lot of players who are viewed as every down players (that fine line that separates the good from the great).

Ray Fittipaldo: Yes it will be interesting to see how this staff wants to use him. I do know any ILB has to be able to step up and take on linemen. Wilson is athletic enough to run under some offensive linemen or ran by them to make a play, but every good ILB has strong take-on and shedding skills. Wilson has to get better in that regard. But everything else? He's really good for a defense. He's fast. He can cover. He has a knack for bring around the ball. He hustles (see the Vikings game). There is a lot to like there.

Leonard: Najee Harris still on the market, probably smart to bring him home and let him make things right, thoughts?

Ray Fittipaldo: Nah

Ray Fittipaldo: Ioane or Thieneman. I'd probably lean Thieneman but Ioane would be a great pick too. If that scenario unfolded for the Steelers it would be a great thing either way.

Steelers Nation Jersey Chapter: Good afternoon, Ray Olaivavega Ioane, Dillon Thieneman, Ty Simpson, Makai Lemon are all available at 21 who are you taking?

Ray Fittipaldo: Oops question to previous answer.

Leonard: Hi Ray, what is your personal opinon on Tomlin moving on? Positive move for the team, going to be a disaster, way past time?

Ray Fittipaldo: Every coach has an expiration date. McCarthy had one in Green Bay. Tomlin had one in Pittsburgh, and I can make an argument it was well past time. In the end, I think it will be a positive, but maybe they take some lumps before the sun shines again.

Ray Fittipaldo: Ok thanks for all the great questions this week. We'll do another chat next Tuesday.