The NFL Draft will be held April 23-25 on the North Shore near Acrisure Stadium. Here’s a weekly look at the players national experts are projecting the Steelers to take with their first-round pick at No. 21 overall.

Josh Edwards, CBS

The picks: CJ Allen, Georgia ILB (first round); Zachariah Branch, Georgia WR (second round); Logan Jones, Iowa C (third round); Davison Igbinosun, Ohio State CB (third round); Keith Abney II, Arizona State CB (third round)

What they’re saying: “By trading for Michael Pittman Jr., Pittsburgh alleviated some of the pressure to acquire another receiver. The Steelers don’t have many pressing needs in the present, but they’re an older team that should be looking to get younger. The hope is that CJ Allen and Payton Wilson can be the battery of the future.”

Advertise with us

PG reaction: It’s an inconvenient narrative that inside linebacker remains a point of organizational need beyond 2026.

Yes, Patrick Queen remains under contract for another year. Yes, it appears the trade rumors swirling around him have died down since the start of free agency. So no, this is likely not a pick that would make the team noticeably better this fall. Few people, therefore, are going to want to eat their proverbial vegetables and search for a future defensive QB in this draft.

It’s also true that the Steelers could opt to extend Queen either this summer or in free agency a year from now. He’s still just 26 and could still be in or close to his prime for another full contract. Until he puts pen to paper, though, you have to look at this spot more than you’d likely prefer to.

Individually, Allen might be a bit of a reach for the Steelers in the first round. Multiple mocks tracked this week dropped him out of it, and NFL.com scout Lance Zierlein writes that he’s a “green dot” linebacker and team captain more capable of “rowing the boat than making big splashes.”

Translation: He’s not the kind of athletic freak that, say, Ryan Shazier was in his prime.

Advertise with us

He’ll run the defense responsibly and make the plays he’s supposed to, so there may not be a ton of upside here. That might make him more attractive to the Steelers on Day 2 should he fall, but he should be on your radar nonetheless.

Beyond him, Branch could be a decent slot receiver between DK Metcalf and Michael Pittman. Jones is a pure center who’s not worth a third-round pick with Zach Frazier on the roster. And both Igbinosun and Abney profile as outside corners. It’s possible they could be useful depth behind Joey Porter Jr. and Jamel Dean, but it’s unlikely they’d help much in the slot, a greater area of need.

Mel Kiper Jr., ESPN

The pick: Vega Ioane, Penn State G

What they’re saying: “The Steelers’ quarterback situation is still a big question. Will Aaron Rodgers return? Will another veteran step in — such as Kirk Cousins? Or will Pittsburgh target a signal-caller in the draft? No matter what the Steelers plan to do, the top two quarterbacks are off the board here, and there isn’t a third one worthy of a Day 1 selection.

Advertise with us

“Instead, Pittsburgh can try to replace Isaac Seumalo, who signed with the Cardinals. Ioane is the top pure guard in the class, with the power to physically move pass rushers out of the way and the light feet to erase second-level defenders. He didn’t give up any sacks last season.”

PG reaction: The original draft guru is on theme with another pick that’s unlikely to inspire the fan base, especially with the draft in Pittsburgh this year.

Ioane’s solidified stock lines up pretty perfectly with where the Steelers are selecting, though. He’s consistently going between No. 15 and 21 in most mocks. With Seumalo departing and no replacement signed, we know that the Steelers will likely be selecting someone to play on the inside. Why not a guy who could hold down the spot for most of a decade like David DeCastro did?

If he’s there when the Steelers are on the clock and most of the top playmakers are off the board, there may not be a ton of arguments against this pick, even if it will likely be met with a muted North Shore cheer.

Daniel Jeremiah, NFL.com

Advertise with us

The pick: Blake Miller, Clemson OT

What they’re saying: “Broderick Jones has underwhelmed at left tackle. With Miller in the fold, Troy Fautanu could move to the blind side in Jones’ place, thus clearing a spot for the rookie at RT.”

PG reaction: Edwards of CBS also did a separate mock from his three-rounder shown above in which the Steelers made this selection, as well. Colleague Tom Fornelli had them go with Alabama’s Kadyn Proctor at this position. And Sporting News’ Vinnie Iyer highlighted Georgia’s Monroe Freeling in his mock this week. So national observers remained focused on left tackle as a weak link.

As we’ve noted throughout the offseason, Jones was not as bad statistically as many make him out to be. His terrible Week 1 against New York, in which he gave up three sacks, skews his numbers. On the merits, a third first-round tackle selection in four years is likely an overreaction to his play through three NFL seasons.

His health remains a wild card after a late-season neck injury, though. Only the Steelers really know his true condition, so it would be hard not to trust their judgment of the situation if they make a pick like this.

Advertise with us

That said, even if we remove Jones from the equation for this mental exercise, Miller could be a questionable pick. He’s played exclusively on the right side through 54 college starts. Fautanu made major strides in his first full season in that spot, so there’s a risk of messing with success by moving him to the left side simply to accommodate a rookie.

If the Steelers go with a tackle, there’s a good argument to be made that they should be hunting for more versatility than Miller’s profile implies. Through that lens, Freeling looks like the better potential fit.