Ray Fittipaldo: Welcome and let's get started.
Noah Kravitz: It's still very early on but do you think they would be comfortable with rolling with Cook and Anderson on the left side to start week 1
Ray Fittipaldo: They like Anderson and Cook. Does that mean they won't draft a guard at pick No. 21 in the draft? No. If there is a guard who is the BPA on their board at that point I think they might take him. Tackle is a bit of a different story because of the uncertainty surrounding Broderick Jones. There is a bit more optimism that he'll be able to return. Because of that I do not think tackle will be in consideration in the first round. However, they do need to develop some young depth at the position especially with Jones' status up in the air.
Wasabi peas: When do you think they will lock up JPJ? Or Boz?
Ray Fittipaldo: They typically like to get through free agency and the draft before they negotiate deals for players with one year left on their contracts. I don't think Boswell's deal will be hard to negotiate. He'll get top money for kickers because he's proven to be one of the best in the NFL. Plus, it won't be expensive. I think he'll come in around $7 million a season. Porter's deal could be trickier because the deal will be much bigger. That negotiation might stretch into the summer.
Noah Kravitz: What is the deal with Broderick Jones and do you think there's a high probability that they either draft a guy in the early rounds and decline his option.
Read More
Ray Fittipaldo: Given the uncertainty with his injury I don't think they can pick up the option. I don't think they'll know for sure by May 1 if he'll be cleared by doctors. For that reason, he'll be in position to play out the final year of his rookie deal. That does not close the door on a second contract. They could still do a deal with him this summer before the season starts or after the season is over.
Tim from Canada: Hi Ray - thanks for the great chats. When speaking of the draft, and considering the free agents we landed, what would be your higher priority - CB or S? Thanks.
Ray Fittipaldo: Safety. Look at what they did there. They signed Brisker and Savage to one-year deals. If they find a safety in the draft who projects as a long-term starter there is no commitment beyond the 2026 season to those guys. Corner is a much different story. Dean signed a three-year deal worth $36.75 million. If they wanted to walk away from that deal after the season is over they'd be on the hook for $8 million in a dead cap hit. The Steelers do not typically take on big dead cap hits like that. On the surface, it looks like they are committed to Dean for more than one season. For that reason I don't think corner is a consideration in Round 1. And an corner they take likely will project to the slot and not outside.
Bud: Hello Ray. Any chance the Steelers would consider signing Derek Carr if Rodgers doesn’t return?
Ray Fittipaldo: I don't think so. They would like Rodgers to return. If he decides to retire they are very excited about the potential of Will Howard.
Noah Kravitz: What's your dream day 1 and day 2 of the draft for the steelers? or what position do you think is a must to have solved by the end of the draft
Ray Fittipaldo: My second mock draft publishes tomorrow so stay tuned.
Noah Kravitz: Two positions that aren't necessarily needs: running back and tight end. in the event that either Sadiq or Love falls to them would you think they'd take a shot at one of them, and if so which one?
Ray Fittipaldo: Running back is not a need, but tight end most certainly is after the release of Jonnu Smith and the departure of Connor Heyward in free agency. Now I don't think it's a first-round need, but I could see them taking one on Day 2 or Day 3. It's a good TE class.
Bud: Hello Ray. Do you think the Steelers might move up to get the safety from Oregon? And do you rate him below the safety Downs from Ohio State?
Ray Fittipaldo: Downs is a good player, but I see a higher ceiling in Thieneman. Maybe Downs has a higher floor, I don't know. But it's hard to watch Thieneman on film and not at least put him in the same general area as Downs. There is not a lot of difference in my opinion. Maybe people in NFL circles feel different. We'll find out soon enough.
Wasabi peas: I think we go OL in the first round unless a can’t miss wr prospect falls to them. What are your thoughts?
Ray Fittipaldo: Guard, receiver or safety in no particular order. Might be BPA at those three positions.
Bud: Hello Ray. Will you and the other PG writers be in different places throughout Pittsburgh during the draft?
Ray Fittipaldo: I don't think plans are completely set, but I do believe Chris Carter will be doing a live show on our YouTube channel. The rest of the beat writers will be at the South Side complex with the team. That's where they always do the draft and that won't change just because it's in Pittsburgh this year. I'm sure the Steelers will have former and current players out meeting and greeting people at Point State Park and over at the stadium, but Omar Khan and his scouting department will be operating as per usual from the South Side.
Tom M.: The Steelers have signed some free agents and lost some. Do you know how the various moves will affect compensatory picks for next year? I do know that those who were released (e.g. Jonnu Smith) do not figure into this.
Ray Fittipaldo: So right now Gainwell and Dowdle cancel each other out pretty much. Dean does not count against the comp pick formula. The other free agents do. I'm not sure how it will shake out, but I am confident they will not have as many comp picks next year as they do this year.
SMF: Hi Ray: Thanks for the Chats. Do you think the Steelers should try to package their 1 and 2 more draft picks to move into the top 10 for the best Safety or WR in the draft--a Polamalu type of move.
Ray Fittipaldo: Never say never, but I don't think this draft is loaded with generational type players. It's an OK draft at the top, but the strength of this draft is in its depth. So if they can get similar players in subsequent rounds without losing draft picks, why would they trade up? There might be one or two players they'd do that for, but I'm not expecting that to happen as I sit here right now.
Rooney: If they can draft a safety late in the first round the secondary becomes a strength this year with the other pickups? WR in the second round, OG/OT 3rd, DT 4th and extra pick QB ? Agree? Thanks!
Ray Fittipaldo: I like it, Rooney.
Bob: Ray, do you agree that they should sign former cowboys C/G Brock Hoffman to replace Semaeulo at OG? He is only 26 and played for McCarthy in Dallas. I am worried that the ravens will sign him as their center.
Ray Fittipaldo: If they sign him he's not an automatic starter. He'd compete with Anderson, and I'm fairly certain Anderson would have pole position in such a competition. Plus, they'll probably draft a guard with one of their five picks in the top 100. There is going to be competition for that left guard spot no matter what.
Tom M.: The Steelers signed Brisker but for only one year. Is he expected to be a starter or is it for depth? If he’s a starter, wouldn’t you want to sign for more than one year? There’s also been a lot of talk about taking a safety with the #1 pick. How is that impacted by this?
Ray Fittipaldo: We'll have to see how Patrick graham wants to run his defense, but Jalen Ramsey is making a lot of money so he'll be on the field pretty much all the time. The same goes for Porter and Dean and probably Elliott. So then it's about how Ramsey is deployed. Is he a slot CB sometimes? In that case, Brisker would go to safety. If Ramsey is at safety then maybe another DB subs in at slot CB. Training camp and the preseason games should be interesting this summer because we'll get to see how this all plays out.
Sunner in Orlando from Lebo: Should the Steelers go with a wide out or a DB in the first round? I say they draft a WR,DB.OG,DT and an ILB with the first 5 picks. Maybe switch the DB and the WR in the first round. How would you draft?
Ray Fittipaldo: I agree with you for the most part. Not sure where I would rank ILB as a need right now. Patrick Queen, Payton Wilson Malik Harrison and Cole Holcomb are under contract. Only Wilson is beyond this season, but it's hard for me to see them taking one early. Maybe they get a guy in the middle rounds to develop, but they seem committed to keeping Queen so taking an ILB in Round 1 is a long shot.
epiballo: It seemed a lock that the Steelers would trade up in the first round for a top WR. With all the signings, will they still trade up, or try to trade for draft capital for 2027?
Ray Fittipaldo: I think they'd like to trade back and get some capital for 2027. For as much as they like Will Howard there are some really good QB prospects who are expected to be available next year.
Jim: If you were running the Steelers draft, would you still go WR with the 1st pick or would it depend on who is still there? I'm thinking the Oline is still a work in progress and we need another stud there.
Ray Fittipaldo: It would not surprise me at all if they took a guard, a receiver or a safety at 21. Anything else I'd be surprised.
Stairway to seventh seed: Ray: 2027 QB class observation: Manning, Sayin, Dante Moore, and my personal favorite Darian Mensah all will have more college eligibility after this season. In an era where top college QBs can make $6-$9m in NIL money, does it make sense to project them as coming out? And if not, should the Steelers trade picks this year for picks next year as the QB savior might not come in 2027 either?
Ray Fittipaldo: These prospects get pretty good intel on where they'll be taken when they decide to come out. So if they're projected as top 10 picks I don't think there is enough NIL money to coax them to come back. It gets interesting after that. Let's say the '27 class is as advertised. Let's say 5 QB are expected to get drafted in the top 10. In that scenario, what do prospects Nos. 6 and 7 do? That's where it can get tricky.
Stairway to seventh seed: Ray: who do you think the best free agent signing is including the cost and which one has you most scratching your head?
Ray Fittipaldo: I really like the Pittman trade. I know that's not a free agent move, but it's my favorite acquisition so far. He fills a big hole on the roster and the contract is for No. 2 money. It also leaves them room to draft a WR high.
Jlw3rd: Why did the Steelers let Connor Heyward walk given that they released Jonnu Smith?
Ray Fittipaldo: I'm guessing he didn't fit into Mike McCarthy's offense. He's a pretty unique player. He's first and foremost on any roster for his abilities on special teams. Beyond that, he's an H-back whose biggest contribution last season was as short-yardage QB. We don't even know if McCarthy will do the tush push the way Arthur Smith did.
David D: An NFL Insider reported the Steelers had reached an agreement with Trevor Hoffman then pulled back that claim. It was before the restricted FA tag deadline. Are teams allowed to negotiate with other teams restricted FA before the deadline? & if not could the Steelers be penalized for tampering? I see the Cowboys ultimately didn't tag Hoffman.
Ray Fittipaldo: They call him The Closer! And he has a terrific right arm! I'm kidding of course. I know you mean Brock Hoffman not the fireballing former Padres reliever. Listen, they might sign him in the future, but he's not a big name or a big priority at this point.
Pistol33: Any truth to either of the reports for QB's are linked to Simpson( Florio) or McShay ( Beck)?
Ray Fittipaldo: They're doing their due diligence on this QB class. Beck, by the way, is on a top 30 visit to the Steelers as I type this.
CG: Wow, Denver traded for Waddle.
Ray Fittipaldo: Just saw that. Looks like the Broncos are all in next season. They should be. They got close this past season, and the AFC does not have a dominant team.
JPinPDX: Good morning Ray. Do you expect that we’ll address OG in free agency, the draft, or both?
Ray Fittipaldo: Definitely in the draft and maybe a minor move in free agency like Hoffman.
Tommy from Florida: Hello Ray, can you explain to us how the gain or loss of compensary picks work?
Ray Fittipaldo: No one really knows the exact formula, but basically it's calculated by the number of free agents who depart your team compared to how many free agents you sign. Plus, the size of the contract and playing time matters. So Dan Moore signing that big deal with the Titans turned into a third-round comp pick.
Tdomenick: Why why all the love for the Ravens second best odds for Superbowl don’t get it
Ray Fittipaldo: The AFC is wide open. Who else are going to be the favorites?
Jim H: Ray, any idea how Mike M views the usage of Roman Wilson? I personally think he can be a great slot receiver if he can get his head straight. Will they draft a slot receiver or someone who can play inside & outside?
Ray Fittipaldo: They have not given up on Roman Wilson. I think there were some issues with the previous OC and with Rodgers, but the new staff wants to work with him.
Pentasuglia: With the QB options much stronger ger in next year's class why not load up on best players available, see what you got with Will, and attack the position next year? This would prevent 2asting draft capital on a qb and Will would atleast get good experience towards being a backup and allow for a potential Rudolph trade???
Ray Fittipaldo: That very well could be the plan if Rodgers retires.
TODave: Hi Ray. What approach to you expect the Steelers to take with respect to starting left guard in 2026: 1.Go with who they have, possibly drafting a later rounds “developmental” pick, 2.Look for a starter prior to the draft through FA or trade, or 3.Draft a starter with a early pick? Thanks
Ray Fittipaldo: Or 4. draft a Mason McCormick type in the middle rounds and have him compete with Spencer Anderson.
Ray Fittipaldo: But I wouldn't be surprised if they drafted a guard in the first round who won the job. That's a distinct possibility.
Nick: Hi Ray- is Jamel Dean actually that big an upgrade over James Pierre?
Ray Fittipaldo: Pierre is making $ million a year on his Vikings contract and Dean is making $13 million a year on his. Money isn't everything, but there is a reason for these contracts. But good for Pierre for getting that pay bump. He had been going year to year on vet minimum deals. That's a great contract for him.
Cdub: If they do a deal with Broderick, it'll probably be for less than the fifth year option. What do you think it'll take for him to sign?
Ray Fittipaldo: It's so hard to say given the injury. If he gets a clean bill of health maybe Jones would want to bet on himself and get to free agency next year. Left tackles are always in demand.
Cynthia: Will the draft bring in PGH have any bearing whatsoever on the “splash” they might make one night one?
Ray Fittipaldo: No. This is not a very sexy draft. Beyond Mendoza there might not be another QB taken in the first round. In a perfect world, the Steelers could have announced a QB and had that moment, but that doesn't look like it will happen.
Bud: Hello Ray. Do you think the Steelers would get enough value at pick #21 if they took a guard?
Ray Fittipaldo: If he's the best player available, sure.
J D: Ray, in order to be stout on defense do you think it's best to draft a defensive lineman in the first round and move up to get him if needed?
Ray Fittipaldo: Eh, I don't think this is a great DL draft.
Pittfan: Hi Ray. I often wonder, like in the case of Gainwell, who makes the final decision regarding the next team and contract. Could the Steelers have had him back for another 2 million or was he going somewhere else regardless? I just can't see in any player's case an amount that small not getting a deal done. Especially if the team finds that player valuable.
Ray Fittipaldo: It always come down to money. This was Gainwell's first chance for a big money deal. And he got it. But it also comes down to fit. And I think Rico Dowdle is a better fit for Mike McCarthy than Gainwell. They have a history together in Dallas and there is a comfort level there for McCarthy.
JP: Is there any data on probability of landing all-pro players in earlier rounds vs mid/late rounds? Why can’t they burn all of the picks for 2 or 3 top players if most draft picks dont make the team anyway?
Ray Fittipaldo: I came across a pretty good thread on this subject on reddit. But obviously, most the majority of All-Pros are selected in the first round and then it declines by round. But some interesting stats if you have time to go down that rabbit hole.
Noah Kravitz: Hiya Ray hope you're doing well. Do you buy that Will Howard buzz is just smoke for the Steelers to take Simpson at 21?
Ray Fittipaldo: I don't think the Steelers will take Simpson at 21, and the Howard buzz is real in the sense they like his potential. That doesn't mean he's a future franchise QB. Just that they are intrigued by his size, skill and leadership abilities.
Draft King: Where do you put the odds that the Steelers will pick Ty Simpson at 21?
Ray Fittipaldo: 50-1
Ray Fittipaldo: OK that's all the time I have for today. Let's do it again next Tuesday.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.