Welcome to Brian Batko's Steelers mailbag. You can submit your questions to Brian directly @BrianBatko on X and bbatko@post-gazette.com.

Evan E: Why is no Pittsburgh sportswriter doing any research on Rodgers’ past relationship with McCarthy? I have some very good friends in Green Bay who are diehard Packer fans and each one of them have told me repeatedly that Rodgers was one of the biggest advocates of getting rid of McCarthy. And now all of a sudden it's supposed to have been a very amiable split back then and Rodgers and McCarthy are now best friends?

Brian: I don’t think anyone’s suggesting they’re best friends, but Mike McCarthy himself said at his introductory news conference that he’d spoken with Aaron Rodgers upon getting the Steelers job. And he has reiterated that in other sit-down interviews since.

For his part, Rodgers has spoken fondly of McCarthy since their Green Bay breakup. When he ticks off the list of great coaches he’s had over the years, he includes McCarthy, so no hard feelings there. It’s not just vague platitudes, though. Here was Rodgers late last season, Dec. 31 to be exact, answering a question about embracing the mundane aspects of the job:

Advertise with us

“I've always relished those. That's the teaching from Tom Clements, going way back to my early years, and Mike McCarthy trying to find the little advantages Monday to Saturday — cues and patterns that you might recognize on game day.”

That’s a fairly specific item of praise in favor of McCarthy’s preparation, at a time when no one had the slightest idea he’d be the Steelers’ head coach within a month. Then there was the 2022 game when Rodgers — still with the Packers — beat McCarthy’s Dallas Cowboys at Lambeau Field.

In his postgame comments on the field, Rodgers made it clear he still has a lot of respect for McCarthy. He also said he got to the game early so that they could spend some time together:

“I have so much love for him. You can't write the story of my career without Mike McCarthy. I have so much gratitude for the role he played in my life. I’m so thankful to have his friendship.”

Is that enough research? In all seriousness, that doesn’t necessarily mean Rodgers wants to work with him again in a professional capacity. Only Rodgers knows that in his heart of hearts. But I’m just telling you why that narrative of a nasty divorce — which may very well have been true at the time — hasn’t been the prevailing one since McCarthy’s hiring.

Advertise with us

Doug in Philly: Is fair to say that Andrew Berry might have single handedly altered the entire AFC North this past season with the Flacco trade? At least, altered the fate of all 4 head coaches? The Flacco trade likely saved Zac Taylor in Cincinnati by overachieving while Burrow was out. In Cleveland, the trade accelerated two rookie QBs into the lineup, almost certainly resulting in the demise of Kevin Stefanski. Neither of those conclusions are a huge leap. For Tomlin and Harbaugh, an argument could be made that the Steelers’ Thursday night loss to a Flacco-led Bengals team directly contributed to the competitive final game in Pittsburgh. Flacco’s impact was undeniable in that game and Tomlin called Andrew Berry out at the time.

If the Steelers had won that Thursday night game, that would have nearly locked up the AFC North, given where the Ravens, Browns and Bengals were at that point. As for Tomlin, we’ll never know. Maybe ‘Fire Tomlin’ chats aren’t as loud against the Bills. Was Tomlin right when he suggested Andrew Berry is smarter than everyone else? Sure seems that way now.

Brian: Hello, Doug. Even if we accept all your alternate realities here, which I’m not sure I’m inclined to do, I fail to see how this makes Andrew Berry a sage general manager.

If anything, Cleveland might be worse off than before. Todd Monken strikes me as a perfectly fine offensive coordinator but a major reach as a head coach. I’d go so far as to call it an uninspiring hire as they move on from Stefanski.

In my view, what impacted the division — and perhaps the Steelers — more than anything was probably Joe Burrow’s injury so early in the season. Cincinnati ended up going 5-3 when he started, so if he stays healthy, perhaps they keep it rolling from their 2-0 start and win the AFC North. And maybe then the Steelers miss the playoffs and the whole hiring process is different in the wake of Mike Tomlin stepping down.

Advertise with us

See, we can all play the what-if game. But if my aunt had … never mind. The bottom line is I think you’re giving the Browns general manager too much credit.

Matt from LA: All in all, unless you like defense, a rather boring Super Bowl?

Brian: I don’t dislike defense, but I found the game rather boring regardless. Was there a multitude of fantastic individual plays on that side of the ball? It was more so a run-of-the-mill mismatch fest all around, which is a testament to both units — especially Seattle — but not all that exciting to watch.

If you like kicking and punting, it was a blast, I imagine. Also, the commercials were rather weak, weren’t they? The only ones I remotely enjoyed were Bruce Arians and his tight ends, the “Good Will Hunting” parody and Pokemon (which I only care about because my kindergartener is still sort-of in his Pokemon phase).

Mike in Virginia: The Steelers beat the Patriots (although with multiple weird turnovers) and maybe could have beaten the Seahawks if not for a rookie's fumbled kickoff. Reason to take solace in this season's results or random facts that don't really matter?

Advertise with us

Brian: Give me the latter, Mike. Not to take anything away from those performances in a vacuum, but to me, that’s just a glaring sign that those two teams ascended as the season progressed while the Steelers were mostly stagnant.

Now, as far as the reason for that, I feel like you can naturally draw a line to coaching in those instances. Not that Mike Tomlin did a terrible job or anything — they won the division and made the playoffs — but clearly it wasn’t the same caliber as Mike Macdonald or Mike Vrabel. It might speak to the youth of those two Super Bowl teams, too. The Steelers entered the season as the second-oldest team in the NFL while the Seahawks were fifth and Patriots 11th, according to Philly Voice. Those two were far from finished products when the Steelers played them early in the season.

Jeff B: What are your thoughts on the staff Mike McCarthy has built so far? Superior or equal to his predecessor?

Brian: With the caveat that evaluating or rating assistant coaches is an exceedingly inexact science, I’d give the slight edge to McCarthy already — and his staff isn’t complete yet. Maybe I’m a prisoner of the moment or caught up in recency bias or whatever, but I really like what they’ve done with the big boys.

James Campen and Jahri Evans seem like a perfect pairing to coach the offensive line. Domata Peko should be really good for the individual development on the defensive line. And I’ve heard nothing but good things about Brian Angelichio and Patrick Graham from non-Steelers people in the league I trust to shoot me straight.

Advertise with us

George T: Brian, in this year’s draft I am hoping in the first two days of the draft we get 2 WR, CB, S, DL, and OL. I am also in favor of moving to get them.

Brian: George, every beat writer will tell you we’re in favor of moving up in the draft. Trade all those seventh-round picks. In fact, trade out of Day 3 completely if you can pull it off, Omar Khan.

Then I’ll have an extra free Saturday in April. Everybody wins.