If Aaron Rodgers and the Steelers are going to turn their passing attack around from an abysmal showing against the Browns in a do-or-die-regular season finale against the Ravens, the four-time NFL MVP will need to be more in-sync with what Arthur Smith has dialed up in key situations.

Rodgers had a tall task on Sunday to get the passing attack going against the Browns’ top-ranked pass defense without the Steelers’ top receiver, DK Metcalf. Add in that the Steelers could only protect Rodgers with a fourth-string left tackle in Dylan Cook and a backup left guard in Andrus Peat against the NFL’s leader in sacks — Myles Garrett — and you have a 42-year old quarterback with a sped-up internal clock while making those tough decisions.

The problem the Steelers ran into Sunday was that Rodgers’ choices in the game’s biggest moments put the weight of the game on lower percentage targets in both schematics and matchups. But those weren’t always the primary designs of the plays called by Smith, and it appeared that sometimes Rodgers’ decisions would clash with the intended design of several plays.

If the Steelers are going to see improvement from Rodgers and a passing unit without Metcalf — and now Darnell Washington due to injury — it’s going to require Rodgers to take advantage of the opportunities Smith draws up that create conflicts for the Ravens defense. If Rodgers can exploit those moments against the Ravens where he didn’t against the Browns, it could be the factor that gets the Steelers their first AFC North title since the 2020-2021 season.

Advertise with us

Here’s a look at where some of the moments presented themselves for Rodgers against the Browns, and where he either took advantage of the moment or missed the opportunity.

Focus on conflicts

The Steelers have benefited from Rodgers’ ability to throw a good ball to a receiver deep outside the numbers when Metcalf has been on the field. It opened up the Steelers’ 27-22 win over the Ravens at M&T Bank Stadium on Dec. 7 with a 52-yard strike to Metcalf on the offense’s first play of the game and came in handy to wipe out a 1st-and-20 against the Lions on a 20-yard back-shoulder strike in the Steelers’ 29-24 win on Dec. 21.

But against the Browns, that never manifested without Metcalf. When targeting outside the numbers 10 yards or farther downfield, Rodgers completed 0 of 6 passes. Even on passes between the line of scrimmage and 10 yards downfield, he only completed 3 of 6 of those passes outside the numbers for a total of 14 yards.

The best success came for the Steelers when they threw down the middle of the field. When Rodgers targeted the middle of the field beyond the line of scrimmage, Rodgers completed 12 of 14 passes for 144 of his 168 passing yards on the day. Most of those yards came when Rodgers utilized passing concepts when Smith’s schematics isolated defenders into difficult decisions about which player they’d cover and gave Rodgers an open option to target if he could decipher what the defender would do during the play.

But sometimes, Rodgers opted to take a shot deep downfield to one of his receivers. One such play came in the second quarter on a second down play when the Steelers used identical route combinations on both sides of the field. To the left of the formation, Marquez Valdes-Scantling ran an out-and-up while Scotty Miller ran a slant route underneath it and Kenneth Gainwell went from chipping Myles Garrett to a delayed release.

Advertise with us

Rodgers took the shot to Valdes-Scantling against cornerback Tyson Campbell. Campbell is a talented cornerback who has an allowed completion rate of 51.1% since joining the Browns — which is 11th best among cornerbacks with over 300 snaps in coverage this season. That’s a mismatch that favors the Browns, as Valdes-Scantling spent most of this season as a free agent or on the Steelers’ practice squad.

But to the right side of the formation, the Steelers ran the same route combination with Adam Thielen and Jaylen Warren. Warren’s slant was uncovered as there were less defenders in coverage on that side of the field, but Rodgers didn’t see the opportunity.

Shots like that aren’t as harmful to the game plan, as a quarterback should take shot plays downfield to force defenses to respect the deep ball even when it’s not the strength of your team. The problem came when that was the decision Rodgers made in crucial moments of the game and where an incomplete pass was more costly.

Rodgers did find spots in the Browns’ defense where the Steelers’ route concepts created openings. Late in the second quarter, Rodgers hit Freiermuth on a 21-yard strike down the middle of the field while the Browns were in zone coverage. The conflict came when Thielen and Freiermuth ran a dig-seam concept where Thielen cut inside and Freiermuth went vertical. It froze rookie linebacker Carson Schwesinger — who was playing injured — just long enough for Freiermuth to break open underneath the Browns’s safeties.

The Steelers used a similar dig-seam concept that worked on their final drive of the game for a gain of 29 yards to Freiermuth. This time, Freiermuth was held up in his go route by safety Grant Delpit, who engaged with him beyond the 5-yard zone where defenders are allowed to contact a receiver. But Freiermuth fought through the contact and Rodgers trusted him to be there, and it was the longest gain of the day for the Steelers.

Advertise with us

Those two plays were the longest gains for the passing attack all game for the Steelers. The problem was that those moments came when Rodgers was running a hurry-up offense and not regularly throughout the game when Smith called the plays. There were times when Rodgers completed passes within the constructs of Smith’s designs, like an 8-yard completion to Miller over the middle on a 3rd-and-5.

Miller ran out of a trips-left formation where he cut inside of Freiermuth and right behind a blitzing linebacker. Rodgers quickly saw Miller go to the space the linebacker vacated and completed the pass to keep the drive alive.

Forcing an issue

While that happened occasionally, Rodgers wasn’t able to replicate that success in the biggest moments of the game. Twice on fourth down, Smith dialed up concepts that caused conflicts for the Browns’ defense and opportunities to move the ball downfield.

When the Steelers had 4th-and-1 in the second quarter, Mike Tomlin had the offense get aggressive and go for it to keep the drive alive. Smith dialed up a similar concept to the other completions as Freiermuth motioned just inside of Thielen and ran up the seam to cut off Thielen’s defender as the 35-year-old receiver ran a quick slant over the middle. Like on the 8-yard Miller completion, the Browns blitzed their inside linebacker that opened up space for Thielen’s slant.

But Rodgers locked in on Miller running a go route against Campbell — a mismatch like when Valdes-Scantling faced Campbell earlier. Miller was blanketed, and Rodgers was unable to hit a passing window that didn’t exist.

Advertise with us

The motion of Freiermuth to the inside of Thielen, with Thielen being open almost instantly is the primarily designed concept on that play as it caught the Browns in the proper alignment to create a quick passing concept opening for Rodgers on a 4th-and-1 scenario. Rodgers’ choice to ignore it passed on a high percentage opportunity for an option that was harder to hit and a personnel matchup that didn’t favor the Steelers.

That was also the mistake Rodgers made on the final three plays of the Steelers’ last drive, as he targeted Valdes-Scantling against Denzel Ward — a five-time Pro Bowl cornerback. On fourth down, Smith dialed up a similar dig-seam concept for Freiermuth and Thielen, but with how often the Steelers had called it, the Browns put four defenders to guard the two targets.

While Rodgers locked in on Valdes-Scantling, Kenneth Gainwell’s delayed slant broke open coming from the other side of the field away from the Browns’ four defenders focused on Freiermuth and Thielen. While it wouldn’t have been a given that Gainwell would’ve scored the touchdown, it would’ve been a higher percentage play for a running back who Pro Football Focus has charted to have forced 11 missed tackles on receptions this season.

Missing Metcalf is a major hinderance to an offense without another premier threat among their wide receivers. When that happens, Rodgers has to work within the constructs of the plays to rely on more structural ways to beat defenses. Smith’s designs might not always present open opportunities, Rodgers has to be the decisive quarterback that’s made him a future hall of famer.

Rodgers’ biggest plays passing down the middle of the field came when the team was in a no-huddle offense that was more under his control. But those options were still available when Smith was calling plays for Rodgers to execute out of the huddle and were often passed up for deep shots to receivers who are lower on the Steelers’ depth chart against the Browns’ top cornerbacks.

Advertise with us

Fortunately for the Steelers, the Ravens’ defense ranks 29th in passing yards allowed compared to the Browns’ top-ranked pass defense. But Rodgers still has to find where the higher percentage throws will be for his playmakers to have the best chance to succeed downfield. If he and Smith can’t get on the same page about when to expect those opportunities against the Ravens, it could be the end of the Steelers’ season.

This story was originally published with images that are no longer available.