Welcome to Brian Batko's Steelers mailbag. You can submit your questions to Brian directly @BrianBatko on X and bbatko@post-gazette.com.

Sean M: Hello Brian. Seems like we are finally seeing progress among some on the roster that may open up options for 2026. It’s a small sample size but is it possible Dylan Cook is the answer at left tackle? If it is determined yes by the end of this season, what options does that open up for next season? Pass on Jones’ option? Spencer Anderson to replace Seumalo? Part 2: Could the Steelers trade Highsmith for a #2 pick and roll with Watt, Herbig, and Sawyer next season?

Brian: Hello, Sean. That’s a good observation by you that in the midst of this two-game winning streak — which feels something like a seven-game winning streak given how low this team was after the loss to the Buffalo Bills (I posited that it was rock bottom under Mike Tomlin, remember?) — the Steelers not only are taking care of business but they’re learning about some next men up.

Dylan Cook might be chief among them, considering we already learned plenty about Kenneth Gainwell earlier this season. But Cook came out of left field, in a sense, to play left tackle. And he’s done quite well, albeit in a small sample size, as you mention. While he showed flashes in camp and the preseason, consistency eluded him, which isn’t entirely unexpected for a guy who converted from quarterback in college and went undrafted.

Advertise with us

Exercising the fifth-year option on Broderick Jones was already dubious and now, unfortunately for him, you add a neck injury into the calculus. But that doesn’t mean Jones would be gone next season. He’d still be in the mix, and now you potentially have competition for him in Cook, if he continues to play well.

Spencer Anderson almost certainly will get a chance at left guard, but he’s been so effective as the sixth lineman that it’s almost tempting to keep him in that role regardless. They need to draft someone there for sure and try to get younger, whether it’s an instant starter or not.

As much as I like Alex Highsmith and as dominant as he’s been lately, that’s going to be a natural subplot to this offseason. It’s really more about how Nick Herbig, and to a lesser extent Jack Sawyer, have developed than it is a knock on Highsmith. I’m not sure you can pay three edge rushers big money on second (and third) contracts, so if it becomes a Highsmith-or-Herbig dilemma, age is always a factor.

And here’s one more to consider: Are James Pierre and/or Asante Samuel Jr. giving the Steelers something to think about at cornerback, or even Kyle Dugger at safety? Those three are still under 30, unlike the new receivers contributing on the other side of the ball. At the very least, it looks like there might be more internal options than we initially anticipated.

PJ S: Has the rate of QB pressures allowed from LT Position increased since the injury bug started to bite? Are we much worse off (QB pressure-wise) than before with all of the recent substitutions?

Advertise with us

Brian: PJ sent this in last week, prior to the Miami Dolphins game, and now we can definitely say Cook held down the fort better than Andrus Peat. Cook is younger, moves better and is probably better-equipped to play tackle at this stage in his career than Peat, who’s been more of a guard in the NFL.

For what it’s worth, Pro Football Focus has not tagged Cook with a pressure allowed, let alone a sack, through his first 41 pass-blocking snaps. Jones has just one game this season with zero pressures, per PFF charting, and it happened to be his last game, against the Chicago Bears.

Jason W: My question is, is this kind of offense sustainable against teams not from Miami? It’s alarming to see the Steelers win by... **gasp!** doing what every Steeler junkie thought the offense would attempt every game, based on the players they have.

Brian: The Dolphins’ defense is youthful and not very well-compensated, I’ll give you that. But they’d been thriving recently and having fun, forcing turnovers and generating pressure. And to be fair, the Steelers also had similar success the week prior against the Ravens, in Baltimore, so you can’t just say it was a Dolphins thing.

But you’re sort of right that these past couple weeks have looked like, well, the comments sections come to life. Deep balls. Middle-of-the-field passing. Pat Freiermuth! Even the usage of Adam Thielen and Marquez Valdes-Scantling over the previous candidates for the No. 2 receiver spot scratched a long-standing itch within Steeler Nation. Maybe Mike Tomlin was so unsettled by the chants for his firing that he opened his suggestion box for the first time in 19 years!

Advertise with us

Andrew in Australia: We're back in "feel good" mode, following the post-Buffalo funk. Are we (and, to some extent, the ball club) losing sight of the fact they're in no shape to go deep into January, and that a home Wild Card win would do nothing to change that (trust me: I hope I'm wrong). Perhaps the Detroit Lions can give us a short, sharp reminder of that.

Brian: Possibly, Andrew. But as you even allude to with your second parenthetical, that’s the whole point of fandom, isn’t it? As Slim Charles said in The Wire, “Once you’re in it, you’re in it. If it’s a lie, we fight on that lie.” Even if it’s unlikely, you root anyway for the fairytale ending.

On one hand, I hear you that a moderately fluky win against the Ravens and a stomping of Tua Tagovailoa does not a contender make. But having Aaron Rodgers, particularly the way he’s played these past two games, gives this team a bit more juice and intrigue than they’ve had since at least Ben Roethlisberger’s final season.

Scott E: Were you, as I was, checking to see whether Rivers had a comparatively better game than KP?

Brian: I wasn’t exactly sitting down to compare Philip Rivers and Kenny Pickett but I was fascinated to see them both play Sunday. Rivers looked 44 years old, from his mobility to his arm strength, and yet he managed to get the ball to where it needed to be more often than not.

Advertise with us

It’s important to note that Rivers has a much better supporting cast and offensive scheme. But, clearly, Pickett was overwhelmed and overmatched by the Philadelphia Eagles in his first start for the Las Vegas Raiders — also his first start in nearly a year. The uncomfortable reality for Pickett is that he’s seeing his career settle into what was basically the worst-case scenario coming out of Pitt. Hanging around as a longtime backup looks to be the ceiling now and it’s getting late early for his chances of bouncing back to starter status.

Rick W: So tell me, please, why you guys are so down on Will Howard. Shouldn't he be given a fair chance to play to hopefully prove his worth as a Pittsburgh Steeler QB? Isn't it possible he could be the next Ben Roethlisberger Steeler QB?

Brian: Rick, I’ll do you one better. Will Howard should start Week 17 in Cleveland … if the Steelers lose in Detroit and if the Ravens win against New England. Because in that scenario, the penultimate game for both teams — Ravens at the Green Bay Packers, Steelers at the Browns — is completely meaningless. The only way it would matter and that tiebreakers would come into play would be a Steelers-Ravens tie in Week 18.

Therefore, I submit Proposition Rick, which henceforth begs the Steelers to give the people what they want, give them a glimpse into the 2026 equation — that’s a callback to our opening query — and start Howard in his adopted home state. Against Shedeur Sanders, no less. Please discuss in the comments.