Each week, Christopher Carter gives his grades after watching the All-22 film of the Steelers’ most recent contest. These grades reflect the impact the players made on the game. While all players are considered for grades, players not named are considered to have neutral grades, where they either didn’t make a major impact on the result of the game or their combination of successes and mistakes evened each other out.

The Steelers’ 28-15 win over the Dolphins was a beatdown where Miami was fortunate to get some late garbage-time points to make it look closer than it was. As such, there are plenty of high marks to distribute and not too many demerits.

Here are this week’s stars and skulls:

⭐⭐⭐ (Elite performance)

QB Aaron Rodgers

Advertise with us

He’s now won three of his last four games and each has featured a passer rating over 100. He finished Monday with his second-best rating of the season at 125.9. Rodgers’ command of the offense seems to be taking over, as he looked efficient with the football on a 85.2% completion rate, two touchdowns and his fourth straight game without an interception. He’s become a catalyst to open up the offense. His touchdown pass to DK Metcalf split two defenders with a laser that was reminiscent of some of the touchdowns he threw against the Steelers way back in Super Bowl XLV.

RB Kenneth Gainwell

He had just 13 carries, but he took them for 80 yards for an average of 6.2 yards per rush. He also caught all seven of his targets for 46 yards and continues to look like a dangerous man with the ball in his hands.  Pro Football Focus had him forcing six missed tackles.

WR DK Metcalf

Though his 55 receiving yards aren’t a big number, his plays were huge — especially the stiff arm he laid on Minkah Fitzpatrick on his 28-yard touchdown, where Metcalf broke loose and rumbled into the end zone. He continues to show that if he gets the ball and isn’t brought down, the home run is available.

Advertise with us

OL Dylan Cook

Cook played 30 passing plays and didn’t allow a single pressure. As the team’s fourth-string left tackle, that’s a great day. The team didn’t run behind him much, but they didn’t need to.

⭐⭐ (Exceptionally good game — or multiple vital plays)

OL Troy Fautanu, Zach Frazier

Out of the rest of the offensive line, Fautanu and Frazier were the best. They both delivered key blocks on zone runs for Gainwell to take his time and accelerate when and where he needed to against the Dolphins. Both allowed a single pressure, and Frazier’s pressure led to a sack. But their contributions to get the run game back on track were huge.

DL Cam Heyward

Advertise with us

Four pressures, a sack and three run stuffs were the weekly reminder that Heyward’s still got it. He’s the lineman offenses want to avoid in the run game — and often can’t because he fights through the blocks.

LBs Malik Harrison, Alex Highsmith

Harrison might’ve had his best game for the Steelers this year. He registered five tackles, two of which were run stuffs. He’s becoming the thumper linebacker this team needed. Highsmith didn’t get a sack, but he led the team with six pressures and was a key element in stuffing the outside run.

CBs Joey Porter Jr., Asante Samuel Jr.

Porter was lights out again in coverage with just one reception allowed on three targets, and he broke up a third-down pass. He continues to be a cornerback teams want to avoid. Samuel got his first start and his first interception with the team. He played his zone well on the play and baited Tua Tagovailoa into a bad decision. He did get beat for a touchdown in garbage time, but the interception is too big to overlook.

Advertise with us

⭐ (Solid performance — or made a big play without a costly play)

OL Isaac Seumalo

He was playing well before he got injured. Steelers could use him back, as he’s been playing at a high level.

WRs Ben Skowronek, Marquez Valdes-Scantling

Valdes-Scantling’s touchdown gets him his first star of the season, while Skowronek gets on the board again for his special teams play. Skowronek had a good tackle and saved a punt from a touchback to pin the Dolphins deep.

TEs Pat Freiermuth, Connor Heyward, Jonnu Smith, Darnell Washington

Advertise with us

All the tight ends make it this week — which is a first. Smith had a touchdown run and trucked over a defender on a pop pass. He was also tagged for a holding call, even if it looked soft. Freiermuth caught three passes for 45 yards, Washington caught three for 25 yards, and Heyward was the team’s wrecking ball on their four uses of the tush push.

DL Esezi Otomewo

He’s been called out for bad play before, but he gets a star with his sack this week.

LBs Patrick Queen, Payton Wilson

Queen had two tackles for loss to go along with his 10 tackles that led the team. He continues to be the glue of the defense when it plays well. Wilson registered a sack and looked helpful in coverage, but it is notable he only played 21 snaps.

Advertise with us

S Jalen Ramsey

He added a sack for the defense and wasn’t targeted a single time. The Dolphins had a clear plan to avoid him, and that helped the rest of the Steelers make plays.

Notable neutrals

These are players who aren’t given a star or a skull because they either didn’t impact the game in a significantly good or bad way — or they did but in a way that balanced out the good with the bad. Here, I’ll note players who classified for the latter category:

WRs Calvin Austin III, Adam Thielen

Austin threw a nice block to ensure Metcalf would score on his touchdown, and Thielen caught one pass for 7 yards. They’re contributing, just in small doses.

Advertise with us

DL Keeanu Benton, Yahya Black

Mixed bag for these guys against the run. They had some good moments but also some plays where they were blown off the ball. But in a game without Derrick Harmon and T.J. Watt, these two at least held their own.

💀 (Mildly poor performance — or made a key mistake without redemption)

RB Jaylen Warren

A rare skull for Warren. He had just 33 rushing yards on 12 carries for just 2.8 yards per carry. Add in a play he got bulldozed in pass protection that led to Rodgers being sacked, and he gets placed here.

OL Mason McCormick

Advertise with us

He gave up two pressures, including a sack, and got tossed out of the way too often. He was the least effective lineman, but it wasn’t a terrible day.

CB Brandin Echols

Not terrible, but he allowed all three of his targets to be caught for a total of 45 yards. He’s had much better games this year and will most likely bounce back.

S Kyle Dugger

He got beat for a touchdown and didn’t have any big plays to show for it like Samuel. Allowed 4 of 5 targets to be caught in total, but only for 37 yards.

Advertise with us

K Chris Boswell

He’s only here because of the miscue on the kickoff where he kicked it short of the landing zone. He only had four extra points to kick all game.

💀💀 (Bad overall game — or multiple critical mistakes in costly moments)

None.

💀💀💀 (Terrible performance, major hindrance to team/game plan)

None.