Gerry Dulac: OK kids, let's get our chat started
Stairway to seventh seed: Gerry: you reported a few weeks ago that the Steelers remain committed to drafting a QB this spring. Can you elaborate a little bit more on this finding? For instance is your source in a position to already know just how dreadful the 2026 QB class has looked? Do you think that good judgment still has a chance to prevail or are the Steelers destined to repeat the mistake of the 2022 draft?
Gerry Dulac: I think my sources are more aware of anything you think -- and maybe even what I think -- of the college QB landscape. They're not dummies, ya know
Different Perspective: The Steelers have three starting quality tight ends who have had a solid amount of recent success either this year or last year. Instead of choosing which two TEs to play, should Art Smith go all out and play 3 TEs for the majority of the game? Is any NFL team really built to cover 3 relatively athletic tight ends for a game? Linebacker and safeties both have mismatches. Mike D’Antoni is said to have expressed that one regret from his Phx Suns days was that he didn’t go all out and have the team run faster and shoot more 3 pointers. Shouldn’t Art Smith go all out and aggressively embrace this mismatch? It is a highly aggressive approach that does not take away from the organization’s preferred offensive philosophy.
Gerry Dulac: The problem is, the one with the most "quality" is the one they are using and utilizing the least. And, in case you haven't noticed, they use all three TEs at once any number of times. That's what they call "13" formation
Stairway to seventh seed: Gerry: my theory is that Cowher hired Arians, Rooney hired Haley, and Ben hired Fichtner. If true, then Canada and Smith are Tomlin's only two hand picked coordinators. Given the similarities that we have seen between these two like an aversion to throwing over the middle, is it possible that Tomlin took more control of the offense when Canada started just like he took more control of the defense when Butler took over?
Read More
Gerry Dulac: Ben didn't hire Fichtner; he was promoted from QB coach.
Dan W.: Is it a coincidence that the present and past offensive coordinators keep making the same mistakes in game? Not attacking the middle of the field, running plays over 70% of the time on 2nd and long, etc. Seems like offensive minds go to Pittsburgh and forget how to coach.
Gerry Dulac: That should tell you something else, as well.
Gerry Dulac: Seven9:58In your opinion, was Mason Rudolph just off at Chicago or did the offensive scheme not play to his strengths?
Gerry Dulac: Mason's turnovers didn't help. And he missed a couple deep throws for a QB who is a pretty good deep thrower. Otherwise, he wasn't off at all, not the way he kept bringing them back after Bears TDs.
Lee In SC: Hi Gerry,
I posed the same query to your colleagues and wondering what you take on this is.
It’s looking like it will take 10 wins win the North/make the playoffs. This means the Steelers need to win 4 of the next 6 games.
I do not see that happening.
I see 2 nearly certain wins (Cleveland, Miami).
I see 2 almost certain loses (Buffalo, Detroit).
This means they need to sweep the Raven which we almost never do.
I guess my questions are:
1) How many wins do you see the Steelers getting in the remaining 6 games?
2) If they miss the playoffs or again get in and are one and blown out is it finally time to blow things up and do a rebuild? And I do mean blow it up. The O is in the midst of being rebuilt while the D is aging and not up to the standard.
Your thoughts?
Gerry Dulac: I think 9 wins might win the division, but only if the Steelers manage to get at least a split with the Ravens.
Seven: Happy Thanksgiving Gerry. Like you, I have watched football for a long time. I never have seen a defense play nickel on third and goal from the 2. What the heck are they doing?
Gerry Dulac: I don't know this, but I'm sure they were anticipating a Caleb Williams option run around the end.
HeHateMe: Morning Gerry! Bottom line is Tomlin scheme is outdated and his ego won't change it or he doesn't know how to change it. Until he is gone he will do the same thing praying for different results. Your thoughts?
Gerry Dulac: I don't know about outdated, but changing it? Well, when Tom Brady says he always knew what the Steelers were going to do defensively because they never change ....
Jim Bow Dean: Why build your offense around tight ends and then never use the middle of the field? It’s mind boggling.
Gerry Dulac: That's one school of thought. And a good one
Jim Bow Dean: Where is the pitchfork muster point when Tomlin gets another three-year extension this offseason?
Gerry Dulac: OK, and that means....??
Soggy: Good Morning & Happy Thanksgiving Eve Gerry.. It looks like another 9-8 season for the Steelers. I think this will drop them out of the elite QB race. The WR class seems to be deep & one could fall into the Steelers lap @ pick 20. What are your thoughts on an elite WR in round one & say John Mateer in round two. Mateer looked pretty good prior to his injury Thanks Gerry
Gerry Dulac: Actually, 9-8 gets them closer than 10-7 or 11-6
DJ: Gerry, have the Steelers totally mismanaged the post Ben era? If you look at the Patriots post TB, they did not go all in to stay 1 game above 500, moved on from their long term successful coach, found what looks like a QB for the future, and now they are the #1 AFC seed. It looks like their near term future is much brighter as we sift through being in the perpetual muddled middle.
Gerry Dulac: It took them a couple years to get there, like 5. Meantime, the Steelers were in the postseason four of those five years. Which would've you preferred at the time???
Stairway to seventh seed: Gerry: for 50 years I've been hearing after a loss that the Steelers should have run the ball more because it is "Steeler football". This reached the extreme this week when some analysts pointed to the decision to go for a 2nd and 1 deep shot on the first drive as a major reason for a loss. Ever since Bill Walsh got going in San Francisco, I would estimate that at least 95% of the championship caliber offenses that we have seen have had dangerous passing attacks. Even a casual observer of NFL Films highlights would realize that "Steeler Football" only won one of the Steelers' Super Bowls in the 70's. When will everybody involved in the Steeler Nation from the fans, to the media, to ownership, and coaches get over this archaic fixation on the running game?
Gerry Dulac: I have no problem attacking down the field like they did. If they would've completed, everyone would have applauded their aggressiveness, especially on the road against a good team. I didn't have a problem at all with the call. I had a problem with Metcalf not trying to break up the pass so the defender couldn't intercept.
artie bridge: Hi Gerry. Obviously with just six games remaining, each is important. That said, how critical do you rank this Sunday's with Buffalo?
Gerry Dulac: Very. If they beat Buffalo and Baltimore, then the Chicago loss isn't that bad after al. But that's a huge IF
Rahn: Team management may not have grown tired of Mike Tomlin and his performance, but what percentage of the fan base do you think has?
Gerry Dulac: How high am I allowed to go?
Uncle Larry: Does anyone ever, ever give Art Rooney the what for he deserves for being CEO of this mediocre condition of a once great and proud organization?
Gerry Dulac: I think a large percentage of the people on this chat.
MediocreMike: I won’t even make this about Tomlin. It’s pretty clear what he is and isn’t. He’s not a great coach and his playoff wins and SB were with Cowher’s left over players, coaches, and culture. That’s indisputable. The biggest problem goes higher. It’s Art 2. My question is do we think Art is truly incompetent or is this just a money making venture to him and as long as the dollars roll in the results don’t actually matter. Because there is no way a competent human being can watch over what has become of the Steelers under Tomlin and think it’s acceptable. What gives?
Gerry Dulac: I beg to differ. He is a good coach, his record proves that. But this isn't about whether he's a good coach or not. He is. This is about watching the same old thing happen year and year and not doing anything about it. How long are you going to tolerate it?
Rahn: You've maintained that the Steelers will use their ammo to move up in the draft to pick a QB, despite the topsy-turvy fortunes of many of the preseason prospect rankings. Could that mean moving up in the second round instead or do you think they have a few guys in mind to move up and select in the first?
Gerry Dulac: I don't know who they have in mind right now. All I can tell you is that's their plan. That doesn't mean circumstances might force them to change.
Justin: Hey Gerry, any idea if the Steelers were interested in Brandin Cooks before he went to Buffalo?
Gerry Dulac: Nope
IUPDave: Good morning Gerry and Happy Thanksgiving. 160 million dollar investment into the defense, still no WR 2. Is it time to rethink our philosophy and put more resources in the offense and try and out score teams, instead of holding opposing defenses to 17 points. It is clearly not working this year.
Gerry Dulac: No it isn't Dave. Not when the defense is allowing the most points per game since 1988
Rahn: You do a great job of circling the coaching philosophies that drive fans crazy like not throwing in the middle of the field, an overpaid, underachieving defense that also looks really slow, et. al. And these have been the same quandaries year-over-year. When does "a fresh start" become a viable option for ownership and with many minority partners, have you sensed any drumbeat from them to make a change?
Gerry Dulac: There are no drumbeats or puffs of smoke right now, but check my earlier answer to Mediocre Mike about a "fresh start."
Troy: Hi Gerry! I believe Chuck would have summed up the current Steelers organization with, "Our problems are great, and they are many."
Happy Thanksgiving!
Gerry Dulac: Hahaha. Bingo
Steve from NC: Hey Gerry, Ive noticed over the last few years, any time the Steelers defense plays a team with an Oline described as one of 'patchwork', 'inexperienced', 'struggling', 'on its 3rd string left tackle', or 'plugging in warm bodies off the street', they shut down the Steelers Pro Bowl pass rush and even gash the front 7 with the run game. Why can we never seem to take advantage of teams like that? And why does our Oline of mostly high round draft choice pedigree take so long to function as even an average Oline, while these other teams seem to plug in average joes and successfully figure it out on the fly against the Steelers
Gerry Dulac: I think when you hear that stuff, it's usually an overzealous, whimsical and hopeful analysis of what they would like the Steelers to do, not what will they do.
Sadkelso: Gerry, Im 42, always been a Steelers fan.. and as far back as I can remember, I've never felt the overwhelming doubt as I feel this year about our Steelers, do the coaches even try and adjust at halftime? I dont even want to watch the rest of the season, any upside you can give the fans ?
Gerry Dulac: I wish I could, but the next two games will tell if you need to watch the rest of the season, hard as that may be to do
Pittfan: Hi Gerry. Happy Thanksgiving. You’ve explained to us firing Tomlin won’t happen because of his contract. If the season ends without another playoff appearance let alone a win, do you think ARII will insist on coaching changes and force Mike to give his coordinators more autonomy?
Gerry Dulac: It's not because of contract. That matters with assistant coaches/coordinators. It's not about contract with Tomlin. Not when he keeps getting extensions. It's going to be like Bill Cowher -- he will leave basically when he wants.
Rahn: Outside of the Super Bowl '70s teams, which squad had the best secondary? I would vote for 1989 with Rod Woodson, Dwayne Woodruff, Carnell Lake and Thomas Everett with D.J. (then David) Johnson working in.
Gerry Dulac: That's a good place to start.
IUPDave: Good Morning Gerry. I have been to a few training camp practices over the past year and have noticed the Steelers offense completing passes over the middle of the field with success. Yet we refuse to use that part of the field during actual games. Why the allergic reaction to using the middle of the field in the passing game? Especially this past week, the injuries to the Bears linebackers screamed test them in the passing game, yet we didn't throw any over the middle? Again another game where we intentionally let 88 just be a casual participant in the offense.
Gerry Dulac: I think if you look, Aaron Rodgers does test the middle of the field, especially with TDs. And the lack of use of 88 baffles me continually
Tim: Anything to take away from PQ comments amongst others in terms of schemes and preparedness of defense? Seems to me to be a repeating theme these past few seasons. As HCMT says, that is why mt is well compensated. What am I missing Gerry? Happy turkey day
Gerry Dulac: You're not missing anything my friend.
IUPDave: Good morning Gerry. Pickens as many receiving yards than all Steelers WR combined. Embarrassing.
Gerry Dulac: And telling
John: Mind boggling that devin hester got in before ward. Ward is the best run blocking WR ever. He was also durable and a hell of a receiver.
Gerry Dulac: And what if Vinatieri gets in before him??
Lou: Happy Thanksgiving Gerry! Is Roman Wilson not getting enough chances? Does he look like he’s open often and just not getting a ball?
Gerry Dulac: He is and he's open. And, as you have seen, he goes after the ball.
russellhalloffame34: I think Omar Kahn has done a good job drafting rebuilding the lines. But do you trust Tomlin's and his offensive staff input when they draft a quarterback with his track record?
Gerry Dulac: Well the one and biggest misfire was Pickett.
Dan Reynolds: Playing Jonnu Smith and not Freirmuth is foolish. Smith will never score a TD for us. He just doesn’t seem to know what to do once he catches a pass. On the other hand, Freirmuth has proven to be a great target especially in the end zone. Come on, MT and Smith - use your heads for once.
Gerry Dulac: Hear hear!!
Guest: You didn’t finish answering Soggy’s question.
Gerry Dulac: Which was...??
Soggy: Thanks for the insightful answer! Hope you get trichinosis from eating undercooked Turkey!! Other than that, hope you have a great Thanksgiving
Gerry Dulac: What was you insightful question that deserved what you derisively call an insightful answer???
Avoid Lloyd: The Steeler defense gets out coached, out schemed by good offensive minded coaches. The Bears game is a perfect example of that in the second half. How is it possible on a goal line situation on a 3rd and 2 only having 2 down lineman and they just walk right in untouched for a score. Do you think at some point veteran players will start coming out anonymously calling out the coaches more directly?
Gerry Dulac: I think some already have, but you have to pay attention to how they tip-toe around the topic
Happy Gilmore: Gerry, Mike Tomlin's arrogance seems to have grown despite going on 9 years without post season success. Does it feel like a defense mechanism to you?
Gerry Dulac: It might be, but I don't try to psycho-analyze
Josh - Boston: Highsmith is gone this offseason right? Or do you see them keeping him around?
Gerry Dulac: They should, but, after paying Watt, going to be difficult.
Josh - Boston: Gerry I get that they won’t fire Tomlin but if they miss the playoffs or lose 1st round again, will ownership step in to force Mike to give up some of the reigns around coordinator control of the scheme and philosophy? Something gotta give right?
Gerry Dulac: Josh, something will definitely have to give. How long can they tolerate watching the same ol' thing??
Michael: Is Tomlin unwilling or unable to adjust his overall philosophy to building a team / staff and allow them to play to their strengths?
Gerry Dulac: I think 19 years -- OK, the last 14 -- has provided the answer.
DaquidoBazzini: You mentioned “how high” you might go on fan dis-satisfaction with Mike Tomlin. What percent would you guess that plays into Art Rooney’s private thoughts about the subject?
Gerry Dulac: Not as high as the fans, obviously
Ryan: Gerry what do you think about the play of Kenneth Gainwell he had a few good runs against the Bears Happy Thanksgiving
Gerry Dulac: Kenny Gainwell has been outstanding.
Michael: Gerry, if you were the owner, how would you personally address Tomlin after the season about his future?
Gerry Dulac: Well, Michael, I'm not and I'm not about to think for him. He doesn't tell me how I should answer the chat questions.
Michael: Do you envision another offseason of personnel changes based on their one year deals or will some of them be extended (Ramsey, Duggan, Echols, etc…)?
Gerry Dulac: Some will, but, to me, I'd clean out more than some of those offseason acquisitions
DaquidoBazzini: Any idea why Kenneth Gainwell’s 55 yard fake tush push wasn’t a TD?
Gerry Dulac: 'Cause he was down short of the goal
Josh - Boston: Are media members allowed to request owners for interviews in season or is it only offseason where Art will make himself available?
Gerry Dulac: They can. Doesn't mean they will get him. AR2 prefers to let his head coach answer all questions during the season. He does not want to be Jerry Jones, and thank goodness for that
Harry: Ready to admit that both you and the front office were wrong about the Pickens trade?
Gerry Dulac: I'm not wrong about it at all. If anything, I was right. I said all along he wouldn't get a second contract from this team and even could be gone before the 2025 season. And he is. But I never said he's not a talent. He is. But he's something else too and that's why the team wanted him out. Give it time in Dallas.
Epiballo: Gerry - got here late so I won’t ask a question you might already have answered. Wishing you a Happy Thanksgiving!
Gerry Dulac: Now that's my kind of guy. Thanx
Patomic Paul: Hey Gerry, I've never seen so much heat placed on Tomlin as this week. He is being assigned new names such as Mediocre Mike. Is Tomlin incapable of change and will he ride his use of stale offensive and defensive schemes into the sunset or shake the whole thing up?
Gerry Dulac: I think we know that answer.
CJ: you are still calling us kids , you will never learn
Gerry Dulac: Awwww. I'll keep trying.
Josh - Boston: Gerry any idea if Andy Weidl will choose to stick around for next year? I believe 2026 will be his 3rd draft with the Steelers and thought the draft picks have been better with him assisting in the process
Gerry Dulac: Andy does a good job. He's a very good personnel guy
Shane in Colrain: The Bills just signed Brandin Cooks! Does anyone know if the Steelers tried to get him? Maybe he didn't want to come here either.
Gerry Dulac: If you were Cooks, where would you sign?
Shane in Colrain: What are the chances that the Ravens and Steelers both end up 8-9 giving the Ravens a home playoff game? It could happen!
Gerry Dulac: It could but I doubt it
Gerry Dulac: OK kids (oops, I'm offending some people), we're out of time. Happy Thanksgiving everyone!!






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.