Welcome to Brian Batko's Steelers mailbag. You can submit your questions to Brian directly @BrianBatko on X and bbatko@post-gazette.com.

Mark from Cali: Can you give us some insight, based on what you see, what the issue is from coaching staff concerning Mason? He is calm in the pocket, he goes through his progressions, can make the deep throws and the players seem to rally around him. In the Buffalo playoff game in 2023, I believe we were missing several linebackers, and he still put up pretty good numbers. Thank you.

Rick W: Brian, I believe Rudolph still has untapped potential. He was never properly developed by Mike Tomlin, who yanked him at the first signs of struggling. All quarterbacks go through rough stretches when coming into this league. Rather than allowing him to play through them, Tomlin panicked and yanked him for Duck Hodges in a futile effort to remain competitive and keep his winning season streak afloat. The guy just needs an opportunity to play his game without fear of being yanked upon his first interception. I don’t want to hear about last year in Tennessee either. That team around him was trash. Your thoughts?

Brian: Congratulations to Mason Rudolph, who now has to have set the record for most litigated and relitigated career in Steelers history. We’re in the midst of it again, against all odds, and at this point I guess this is instance No. 4 or 5 of “Is Rudolph the answer?” discourse. There was his initial draft selection, his 2019 season from Dante’s Inferno, the first offseason post-Ben Roethlisberger, the 2023 playoff push, and then really all ensuing fallout.

Advertise with us

Let’s not act as if the Steelers are Rudolph haters. If that were the case, they would've gone back to Kenny Pickett once he was healthy two years ago. And they brought Rudolph into the fold again this season even after his struggles with the Titans (perhaps they agree with Rick that no one can be judged on playing in that situation).

Ultimately, though, the Steelers likely see the same limitations other teams do (hence no one ever trading for Rudolph or signing him before or for more than his original team). His mediocre mobility, lack of elite arm talent and — to this point — inconsistent play overall won’t have many envisioning him as a franchise quarterback. But credit to Rudolph, he’s not going away quietly as he continues trying to prove that he’s better than he showed out of the gate and can be reliably effective in the right offense.

Arthur L: Based on what I've read from you and other PG writers, their plan has been to save as much draft capital as possible to move up in Round 1 next year and select a QB. Do you think they should stick to this plan or adjust given data coming in on this crop of QBs. The 2027 draft may not have as many potential Round 1 QBs but their ceiling seems much higher than this group is showing. I know it's all a crap shoot but with the age of their defense, would plan 1A be where they use the majority of their draft capital this season to continue to build the DL and secondary, get a good to great WR prospect and build depth on the O-line be the better option given how this QB class has performed to date?

Brian: These days, I’m thinking the only logical execution of this plan is to somehow move heaven and earth for Indiana’s Fernando Mendoza or hope Dante Moore from Oregon enters this draft, too, as a redshirt sophomore. The idea of there being five or six first round-caliber quarterbacks, a la 2018 or 2024, appears to be out the window.

But I still can’t imagine the Steelers making a meat-and-potatoes pick — defensive line, offensive line — in a year there will be so much pomp and circumstance for the draft in Pittsburgh. I know, I know, it sounds ridiculous. And, intellectually, it wouldn’t be good process to let that impact your roster-building. It’s just that the amount of draft resources they’re accruing, they have to do something with it. You aren’t going to have 10 or 11 draft picks make the team in a given year.

Advertise with us

Tim from Charlotte: I enjoyed your column on the mid-season awards and we are halfway done. Give us your All Madden Team from the halfway point from ALL teams, but only current roster players allowed. You can go on the defensive side of the ball or offensive side whatever makes better reading and a challenge for you. Build a team no one will score on, or a team scoring 40 points a game all season.

Brian: The way he’s playing, give me 11 Myles Garretts and I don’t think anyone’s scoring on me. Maybe put Jalen Ramsey and Kyle Hamilton back there at safety.

On offense, I’ll take Josh Allen as my quarterback, Jonathan Taylor at running back, Brock Bowers at tight end, and then George Pickens, George Pickens and George Pickens as my three receivers.

Mike M: It almost seems like a waste to have a play maker like Ramsey play free safety. I say that because he seems lined up pretty far away from the line of scrimmage. Do we have anybody else who could play there and have Ramsey play some strong safety or get back into the slot?

Brian: Maybe they should sign Juan Thornhill off the Jaguars practice squad. Veteran presence, longtime free safety, two Super Bowl rings. Wait a second …

Advertise with us

In all seriousness, we did this for years with Minkah Fitzpatrick, going back and forth between whether he should be in the deep post or moving around to get near the ball. I can’t complain about Ramsey’s usage and the way he’s playing. It’s working for them.

Mark in Buffalo: Pierre has been a fringe player for years but playing above the line this season. Do you think it’s a matter that he’s progressively improved to being a solid player? Still a fringe player but who has been in the right places at the right times on the field this season? Or injuries and play of others make him look better than he is?

Brian: The skeptic in me is doubtful that an undrafted free agent who ran a 4.59 40 at the combine hasn’t gotten faster at age 29. It’s entirely possible he’s just had a nice couple of games based on the matchups or the scheme.

But you can’t deny the plays he made against the Chargers and Bengals, and when I think back to training camp, I feel like he played fairly well. Let’s let Pierre Peninsula have a day in the sun.

John from Kentucky: At 6-4 what do you think our final record will be?

Brian: John, it’s painful to even make weekly predictions on this team and you want me to project out to January? 10-7.