Each week, the Post-Gazette will recap the most interesting Steelers player grades released by Pro Football Focus, the scouting website that evaluates players’ performances on every play of every game. For context, players are graded on a 0-100 scale.
Mason Rudolph (59.8)
The reviews have been glowing after Rudolph relieved the injured Aaron Rodgers in the second half on Sunday against the Bengals. But let’s not get carried away.
His average depth of target for the day was just 2.9 yards. That was the lowest mark in the league for Week 11 by 2.1 yards. Rudolph also had zero big-time throws, rated by PFF as among the best in the NFL in a given week.
He was not a downfield threat in any way, shape or form. His success was predicated on being accurate at short distances and his receivers making significant plays after the catch.
To be fair, we did see him excel in this area as the Steelers’ starter down the stretch in 2023. His average depth of target that year was a solid 7.5 yards, better than his predecessors in the role. So it’s possible he’ll be better with a week of game planning around him should he start against Chicago. It’s just also true that some of the lavish praise he’s getting for Sunday is a little premature in terms of his prospects as the long-term starter should Rodgers need to miss significant time.
Joey Porter Jr. (74.0)
The third-year corner has taken a lot of flak for his handsiness and rightfully so. Pass-interference penalties to which he’s proven himself prone don’t help the cause. Statistically speaking, though, he’s generating a fair amount of value when he’s keeping himself out of trouble.
Read More
Sunday against Cincinnati was his second straight game of not allowing a reception. Opponents are 0 for 5 when targeting him in that span, reflecting an ability to both cover his assignments and make plays when the ball comes his way.
For the season, he’s allowed catches on just 17 of his 35 targets, so opponents are succeeding against him just 48.6% of the time. He’s also allowed 40 or more yards when targeted just once in his seven games this season. That’s solid production.
So it’s possible his many critics may be focusing a little too much on the interference calls against him. He’s far from a lost cause as much as he needs to clean up the finer points of his game.
Jaylen Warren (91.2)
The Steelers better hope his injury Sunday doesn’t linger for too long because the numbers he’s generating are downright impressive when they can get him the ball.
Warren ranks 10th in yards per carry after contact (3.24) among NFL backs with at least 100 attempts this season. And he’s in a tie for seventh in missed tackles forced with 32. These are all signals he’d be able to make more big plays if his blockers can keep him cleaner for longer. He ranks just 21st in runs of 10-plus yards with 12.
He’s also been very dangerous as a receiver. He ranks third among running backs in that cohort with 1.78 yards per route run. And he’s fifth in receiving grade at 84.5. Kenneth Gainwell’s presence on passing downs has somewhat limited his opportunity in this area. And that’s not likely to change after Gainwell’s big day against the Bengals. Still, if the goal is to get Warren the ball in space more, he’s an option Arthur Smith may want to consider when he’s in the game.
Cam Heyward (90.4)
Here’s a stat that shows just how solid the defensive captain remains in his 15th season: Through 10 games, he still has yet to miss a tackle. PFF has him as a perfect 24 for 24 in that category, with 13 assists. That’s an incredible feat considering many of his teammates find themselves with double-digit missed tackle percentages.
Beyond that, he’s been a menace against the run, with 20 stops — which PFF defines as plays that result in failure for the opposing offense — and an 83.3 grade. And although he was fairly quiet on the pass-rush front Sunday against the Bengals, with zero pressures, he has 28 for the season, which translates to nearly three per game.
His contract dispute drew a lot of attention to his play during training camp. And to his credit, he’s lived up to his side of the bargain, even at this late stage of his career when many defensive linemen begin to falter.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.