Each week, the Post-Gazette will recap the most interesting Steelers player grades released by Pro Football Focus, the scouting website that evaluates players’ performances on every play of every game. For context, players are graded on a 0-100 scale.

Alex Highsmith (90.6) — The veteran pass rusher was the defense’s highest-graded player Sunday against Indianapolis for what should be obvious reasons. He had four pressures, two sacks and a forced fumble against Colts quarterback Daniel Jones. Highsmith also added three stops, defined by PFF as tackles that result in a play’s failure for the opposing offense. It was a loud performance in a season that’s otherwise been impacted by injury and lacking in similar splash plays.

When Highsmith is available, though, he also hasn’t been quite as bad as some critics might think, averaging 2.5 pressures, 2.33 stops and 0.66 sacks per game. His 77.3 overall grade is fourth best among Steelers defenders with at least 100 snaps. Only Nick Herbig (90.4), Cam Heyward (90.3) and T.J. Watt (82.1) are better.

It’s fair to want a little more sizzle from his game like we saw Sunday. That can be true at the same time that his baseline production is satisfactory relative to a lot of other guys on this unit.

Advertise with us

Calvin Austin III (56.8) — You can debate how important a No. 2 receiver is in coordinator Arthur Smith’s offense as currently constructed. He’s using a lot of heavy personnel — from tight ends to eligible tackles — that is naturally going to limit the amount of snaps a guy like Austin sees and therefore the volume of counting stats he’s going to accrue. No one should be expecting him to be on anything resembling a 1,000-yard pace.

What’s not debatable is Austin’s production lacks with the opportunities he does get. His 1.41 yards per route run rank 59th among receivers with at least 20 targets in 2025. His 4.4 yards after the catch per reception rank 32nd. His 10.2-yard average depth of target ranks 61st. And he’s forced just two missed tackles all season.

For a guy whose game is built around speed, he’s not doing much to elude anyone. There’s little in his stat profile you can say he does particularly well relative to his peers. He’s just sort of a replacement-level body. Many guys around the league could do the job as he’s doing it, and it’s fair to wonder why any Steelers brass would be satisfied with that ahead of the NFL trade deadline.

This team may not need a Plaxico Burress to pair with Hines Ward or a JuJu Smith-Schuster to line up across from Antonio Brown. But it does need some level of credible threat opposite DK Metcalf to keep defenses honest. And Austin is not that right now.

Brandin Echols (67.0) — The reserve corner got more coverage snaps than he’d had in the previous three games combined and he made the most of them despite being challenged often by Jones. On the nine occasions he was targeted, Echols allowed just six catches for a total of 58 yards. He had four tackles, with no misses, to lower his season missed tackle rate to a very solid 8.7. Just 10 of those yards came after the catch, and he added a stop for good measure. His overall season grade is now up to 64.0, which ranks behind only Jalen Ramsey among corners with extensive 2025 usage. He should probably see the field more moving forward.

Advertise with us

Pass blocking (82.4) — It seems strange to say on a day when Rodgers was sacked three times, but the offense otherwise did a phenomenal job of keeping him clean against the Colts. As a group, the five starters — plus Spencer Anderson, who replaced the injured Isaac Seumalo mid-game — allowed just four total pressures and a couple of hurries in addition to the sacks. This on a solid volume of 40 pass-blocking snaps.

As a result, Seumalo (86.7), Zach Frazier (84.2), Mason McCormick (83.1) and Troy Fautanu (80.5) all checked in with very solid grades. In the case of Frazier and Fautanu, they were the best pass-blocking scores of their careers. Broderick Jones allowed two of the four pressures and was subsequently marked lower. But his 64.7 pass-blocking score was his third at that mark or higher in as many weeks, a signal he’s making quantifiable progress from the mess he found himself in earlier this season. Encouraging signs all around.