Welcome to Stars and Skulls, a weekly grading series that focuses on individual performances of Steelers players.

Each week, Christopher Carter gives his grades after watching the All-22 film of the Steelers’ most recent contest. These grades reflect the impact the players made on the game. While all players are considered for grades, players not named are considered to have neutral grades where they either didn’t make a major impact on the result of the game, or their combination of successes and mistakes evened each other out.

The Steelers’ 27-20 win over the Colts saw a return of the defense playing the way it’s designed to disrupt opponents. But who were the biggest contributors to the big day? And which players on offense helped the most?

Here are the Week 9 stars and skulls:

Advertise with us

⭐⭐⭐ (Elite performance)

LBs Alex Highsmith, Payton Wilson

Both linebackers took part in the team’s six forced turnovers Sunday, as Highsmith sacked Daniel Jones twice, forced a fumble that the Steelers would recover, and broke up a pass while dropping into coverage. He was everywhere for the Steelers, including leading the way to stop the run whenever the Colts tried Jonathan Taylor out wide to his side.

But Wilson was also everywhere for the Steelers’ defense, as he led the team with 13 combined tackles, nine solo tackles, an interception and a tipped pass that was intercepted. The All-22 tape showed how he flew all over the field to stop the run and limit the Colts’ yards after the catch.

⭐⭐ (Exceptionally good game — or multiple vital plays)

QB Aaron Rodgers

On a day where the Steelers’ top running back averaged 1.9 yards per carry, Rodgers had to find a way to move the ball through the air against the sixth-best scoring offense in the NFL. He did that with 25 completions on 35 passes for 203 yards and had several drops, including a dropped touchdown pass from Darnell Washington.

Advertise with us

OL Troy Fautanu

Fautanu has become a force for the Steelers’ offensive line and its best player. He didn’t allow a single pressure on 40 pass-blocking reps and had several plays where he flattened defenders who came his way.

DL Keeanu Benton, Derrick Harmon and Cam Heyward

The Steelers’ defensive front manhandled what has arguably been the best offensive line in football in the Colts. Taylor was shut down largely because the defensive line kept the Steelers’ linebackers clean. Heyward went toe-to-toe with Quenton Nelson and won plenty of times. Harmon was a force against the run, and Benton showed improvement against the run while also adding a sack.

LBs Patrick Queen, T.J. Watt

Advertise with us

Although Queen didn’t register a bunch of stats, the film showed he was a crucial component to the Steelers’ defense limiting Daniel Jones’ quick passing attack. He not only covered players underneath well, but communicated at a high level to keep the defense on point. Meanwhile, Watt was a destructive force against the run, and his sack, forced fumble and recovered fumble that all happened on the same play flipped the entire game around for the Steelers.

CB Jalen Ramsey

Although Ramsey played a lot of safety in this game, he was also a menace for the Steelers when in underneath coverage. He brought a swagger to the secondary the unit had been missing in their two most recent losses, and that deserves recognition.

S Kyle Dugger

When you only get two practices with a team and then play 77 snaps as a starter with only 22 receiving yards allowed on three receptions from four targets, you had a big day. Add in his two run stuffs, and you have an inspiring fill-in performance.

Advertise with us

⭐ (Solid performance — or made a big play without a costly play)

RBs Jaylen Warren, Kenneth Gainwell

Although he averaged just 1.9 yards per carry, Warren did what he could with a Colts defense that was fully committed to stuffing the run. That includes his first two rushing touchdowns of the season, both of which came in short-distance, goal-line situations. Gainwell finished with negative rushing yards, but his four receptions for 35 yards were big in some key moments.

WR Calvin Austin III

Led the team with five receptions on six targets for 56 yards. Two of those catches resulted in first downs — one of which was a third-down conversion. And another of his grabs set up a 4th-and-1 situation the Steelers would convert on an eventual touchdown drive. He stepped up when the offense needed him.

OL Zach Frazier, Broderick Jones, Mason McCormick, Isaac Seumalo

Advertise with us

Although the Steelers’ offensive line didn’t get much push in the run game, the linemen did a good job to give Rodgers time in the pocket to see the field. He was only pressured four times on the day and was sacked three times, one of which he took to keep the clock running late in the game and avoid a turnover. As a unit, they still have plenty to improve. But they’ve also come a long way.

TEs Darnell Washington, Pat Freiermuth

Washington dropped a touchdown but followed it up with four big receptions that kept drives alive for the Steelers as he tallied up 43 receiving yards. Meanwhile, Freiermuth scored another touchdown — his third in the past three games.

LBs Nick Herbig, Jack Sawyer

Herbig and Sawyer each got two pressures on the day and helped to hold the edge against the run and force the Colts back inside the tackles. Sawyer also capitalized on Wilson’s tipped pass to catch his first career interception.

Advertise with us

CBs Brandin Echols, Joey Porter Jr.

Echols and Porter were the most-targeted defensive backs Sunday, but both made plays and didn’t allow the Colts to thrive. Echols had a breakup on third down and recovered a muffed punt on special teams, but he did get beat for a touchdown.

Porter may have been called for two more defensive pass interference penalties, but he was a tough beat for the Colts receivers, as he only allowed five receptions on his 10 targets for just 63 yards, including three passes broken up and an interception that helped seal the game in the fourth quarter. Jones’ passer rating when targeting Porter was 30.4. Eliminate the penalties, and it might’ve been a three-star day for Porter.

K Chris Boswell

Two more made field goals and three extra points. Boswell allowed his first kick to reach the end zone this season, but the Colts chose to return it. Also, Boswell put a ball out of bounds on a kickoff following a personal foul penalty from the Colts that the Steelers took advantage of to make them start at the 25.

Advertise with us

P Corliss Waitman

Waitman’s become a consistent punting force for the Steelers, as he averaged 50.4 yards on five punts with his longest being 67 yards, twice landing punts inside the 20.

Notable neutrals

There are players who aren’t given a star or a skull because they either didn’t impact the game in a significantly good or bad way — or they did, but in a way that balanced out the good with the bad. Here, I’ll note players who classified for the latter category.

LB Malik Harrison

Played 26 snaps and wasn’t much a liability for the defense. Had two tackles, but also missed a tackle on a fourth down against Taylor that would’ve spoiled a red zone possession. Still, he was helpful in other spots.

Advertise with us

OL Spencer Anderson

Anderson helped in pass protection but lost too often in the run game to be an asset this week as the extra lineman. He did fill in well as the replacement guard for Seumalo.

💀 (Mildly poor performance — or made a key mistake without redemption)

WR DK Metcalf

Second straight week for Metcalf getting a skull grade, this time because of a drop and only 6 receiving yards on two catches. After catching a touchdown in four straight games, Metcalf only has one touchdown in his last three contests. He’ll get back to producing eventually, but this was a disappointing game.

TE Jonnu Smith

Advertise with us

Dropped the opening pass of the game that would’ve been a 30-yard gain or more. A great call by Arthur Smith wasted. Smith did bounce back with three catches for 25 yards, but the drop ruined the opening possession.

CB Darius Slay

Not a terrible game from Slay, but he got beat in some situations he could’ve played the ball better when the rest of the defense did a good job taking away Jones’ options. He allowed three catches for 61 yards. He does get tough-guy points for coming back from what appeared to be a painful hand injury and other maladies he appeared to suffer during the game.

💀💀 (Bad overall game, or multiple critical mistakes in costly moments)

None.

💀💀💀 (Terrible performance, major hindrance to team/game plan)

WR Roman Wilson

It’s rare a player gets a three-skull grade for just one bad moment, but it could’ve been a costly mistake when Wilson fumbled a pop pass after he leapt into the air and exposed the ball to be knocked out in the fourth quarter. It looked like he had the first down on the play and didn’t need to do that. He’ll take it as a lesson for a young player, much like Kaleb Johnson did when he allowed the Seahawks to recover a kickoff that bounced over his head for a touchdown during the home opener.