Each week, the Post-Gazette will recap the most interesting Steelers player grades released by Pro Football Focus, the scouting website that evaluates players’ performance on every play of every game. For context, players are graded on a 0-100 scale.
Tackling (41.0) – Sometimes football is complicated, and sometimes it’s not. The Steelers were horrific in getting ball-carriers on the ground Sunday against Green Bay, as they were the previous week against Cincinnati. As a team, they missed 11 tackles and have now missed 27 across the past two games. The most frequent offender has been middle linebacker Patrick Queen, who’s missed seven tackles against the Bengals and Packers. Cornerback Darius Slay Jr. has added five, and safety Chuck Clark has been responsible for three. It’s sloppy and helped the two opponents pile up a combined 408 yards after the catch. Those are hard numbers to overcome, even with the best schematics in place. As much as fans would probably like to blame the coaching staff, the reality is that the players simply aren’t making the plays they’re positioned to right now. And coach Mike Tomlin and DC Teryl Austin shouldn’t have to be teaching professionals how to tackle in Week 8 of a season.
Broderick Jones (72.2) and Troy Fautanu (80.0) – These two had their best game as a tackle duo to date against the Packers. There were certainly blemishes — five pressures and a sack of QB Aaron Rodgers allowed between them. But those numbers came across 45 pass-blocking snaps, as the offense was forced into a throw-heavy game by its big deficit in the latter portions of the game. Mason McCormick (five pressures allowed) was the bigger issue in terms of giving up pressure, so it’s fair to say these two continue to make major strides since their early struggles. Fautanu was also dominant in run blocking with a grade of 86.7. He was a big reason RBs Jaylen Warren and Kenneth Gainwell were able to have productive nights. So it will be interesting to see what his upside can be over the rest of his quasi rookie season.
T.J. Watt (78.6) – He’s been a focal point of a lot of fan rage following his protracted contract dispute with the team in the offseason and his perceived lack of production through seven games. So let’s try to put his numbers in context. Watt has 24 total pressures this season, which puts him in a tie for 24th among EDGE defenders in the NFL. His five sacks put him in a tie for 16th. And his 15 stops, defined by PFF as tackles that result in failure for the opposing offense, put him in a tie for 12th. That’s all good, but not great from a guy who is now one of the highest-paid players in league history. Realistically, the data is presenting a mixed verdict on his culpability in the overall unit’s struggles. No, he’s not living up to his contract. But he’s also far from the problem within a group of many of them. And any defensive game plan built around him disrupting at a superhuman level ad infinitum is probably not a great one.
DK Metcalf (76.0 season grade) – The vitals are strong here statistically. His 10 yards after the catch per reception rank first in the NFL among receivers with at least 30 targets. His 270 yards after the catch rank third behind only Ja’Marr Chase (363) and Khalil Shakir (295.) His 17.1 yards per reception rank fourth. And yet, his overall grade ranks 18th in that cohort because the Steelers aren’t accessing those elite ball skills nearly often enough. His 2.14 yards per route run rank 14th. And his 45 total targets rank 31st. For context, league leaders like Chase (97), Chris Olave (80), Keenan Allen (69), and Jaxon Smith-Njigba (67) are dwarfing him in terms of attention. Were Metcalf touching the ball more, he’d be right there with them in terms of the evaluation. He’s not, because this passing game still likes to look at tight ends. Or even tackles eligible, after Spencer Anderson was targeted in the passing game. As long as that’s the case, OC Arthur Smith probably isn’t getting as much out of Metcalf as the numbers suggest he could.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.