The Steelers dropped a 35-25 decision against the Green Bay Packers on Sunday night at Acrisure Stadium. Here are four questions for them and the rest of the NFL to ponder ahead of NFL Week 9, when they’ll welcome the Indianapolis Colts to Pittsburgh.
Is there a Plan B for this defense? We know what the Steelers want to do with this unit — cover well enough on the back end, especially in man coverage, for your pass rushers to wreak havoc on the front end.
Nearly halfway through the season, we haven’t seen that plan succeed with any consistency. And in the last two weeks, the secondary has provided practically no resistance to Joe Flacco and Ja’Marr Chase of the Bengals or Jordan Love and Tucker Kraft of the Packers.
And the unit isn’t young enough to believe things are going to change meaningfully on the personnel side. Jalen Ramsey, Darius Slay Jr., Brandin Echols and Juan Thornhill are all 30 or older. There’s not a ton of upside to be mined in their games at this stage. They are who they are.
Coach Mike Tomlin and defensive coordinator Teryl Austin need to figure out how to compensate for it — quickly — and stop stubbornly trying to make their preferred style happen in spite of the struggles or things could get ugly in the second half of the season. Josh Allen, Lamar Jackson, Jared Goff and the resurgent Daniel Jones are among the guys they still have yet to face on this schedule. Every one of them is likely salivating about getting Steelers defensive backs one on one right now.
Is Baltimore turning the corner? The Steelers’ principal division rival ended its four-game losing streak Sunday with a 30-16 win against Chicago.
Read More
Tyler Huntley did everything his team needed to do in Lamar Jackson’s absence, completing 17 of 22 passes for 186 yards and a touchdown. He finished the day with a more-than-solid passer rating of 116.9. The running game didn’t encounter much resistance either en route to piling up 177 total yards. Derrick Henry led the way with 71 of them and two scores on 21 carries. Huntley himself was dangerous, too, averaging 6.6 yards across his eight totes. On the other side, the defense flustered Bears quarterback Caleb Williams into completing just 65.7% of his passes for an average of 7.5 yards per attempt.
With Jackson getting healthy, it feels like the tide is slowly turning in this AFC North race as the Steelers’ schedule stiffens and the Browns and Bengals are still mired behind with losing records of their own. It’s still a two-game lead in the loss column for Tomlin and his squad. But they have a long way to go to make it hold up.
Did the Bengals waste their chance to get back in it? A week and change ago, the Thursday night win against the Steelers at Paycor Stadium appeared to have Joe Flacco and Co. remaining a factor in the division.
Then came an epic meltdown Sunday against the lowly New York Jets, who entered the day winless in seven attempts in 2025. The Bengals held multiple two-touchdown leads, including one with a little over 10 minutes left. But Justin Fields and Breece Hall could not be denied.
The former led a furious rally, with 244 yards and a touchdown on 21 of 32 passing. The latter piled up 133 yards and two scores against the shoddy Cincinnati front. Impressively, most of that production came in the second half with his team trailing, even as NFL teams typically turn to the pass in such situations. And then Hall finished the Bengals off by throwing a touchdown to rookie Mason Taylor for the go-ahead score.
The Bengals are now 3-5 and still don’t have Joe Burrow’s return anywhere in sight. While Flacco has proven he can generate plenty of offense with Ja’Marr Chase and Tee Higgins — he threw two touchdowns Sunday — he can’t fix a defense that is clearly deficient in almost all areas. Annoyingly for Steelers fans, it still looks like a team they should have beaten.
Are the Steelers running into a buzzsaw against the Colts? Indianapolis moved to 7-1 on the season Sunday with a dominant 38-14 win over the division rival Titans.
Daniel Jones continued his comeback player of the year campaign with three touchdowns and 272 yards on 21 of 29 passing. His passer rating was a superb 136. Jonathan Taylor was even better, with 153 yards and two touchdowns on just 12 carries. That comes out to an obscene average of 12.8 yards per carry.
The defense, meanwhile, sacked rookie quarterback Cam Ward four times and forced him into an interception while keeping the running game comfortably in check.
Maybe Rodgers will fare better with 20 seasons of experience compared to Ward. But as we saw Sunday night, it may not matter if his defense can’t stop a Colts offense that’s as dynamic as anything the Steelers have seen on their schedule so far.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.