Welcome to Stars and Skulls, a weekly grading series that focuses on individual performances of Steelers players.
Each week, Christopher Carter gives his grades after watching the All-22 film of the Steelers’ most recent contest. These grades reflect the impact the players made on the game. While all players are considered for grades, players not named are considered to have neutral grades where they either didn’t make a major impact on the result of the game, or their combination of successes and mistakes evened each other out.
The Steelers’ 23-9 rout over the Browns on Sunday was their first win by multiple scores this season. The victory featured several players who performed well and few who made major errors without redeeming moments.
Here are the Week 6 stars and skulls:
⭐⭐⭐ (Elite performance)
QB Aaron Rodgers
Though his numbers won’t look elite, Rodgers’ ability to recognize where the Browns defense was pre-snap played a huge role in his quick release of the football all game and contributed to the game plan to limit Myles Garrett and the pass rush. Add in some crucial throws into tight passing windows — including a touchdown and a key third-down conversion, which both came on the run — and you have a performance that reminds everyone why the Steelers were so patient to wait for Rodgers to sign with the team.
Read More
RB Jaylen Warren
Warren only had 63 yards from scrimmage, but his hard-running style behind the Steelers’ offensive line produced the second-most rushing yards by any player against the Browns defense this season — only behind Jahmyr Gibbs’ 91 yards. But even more impressive than Warren’s running was how he was a complete player for the Steelers as a pass protector. On several plays, he was tasked with picking up rushers and helping primarily against Garrett. On a third-down reception in the second quarter, Warren started the play with a key chip against Garrett and then became the target for Rodgers to hit on an flipped pass to keep a drive alive that resulted in a field goal.
WR DK Metcalf
Caught four of nine targets for 95 yards and a touchdown, with several of his receptions coming with tight coverage. Metcalf continues to show why the Steelers made him their top receiver this offseason with his consistency as a route-runner and big-play producer for Rodgers.
LB Nick Herbig
Herbig has back-to-back three-star performances for the Steelers, as he led the team with six pressures and two sacks Sunday. His skills as a pass rusher make him dangerous wherever he lines up on the defensive front, as evidenced by Pro Football Focus’ charting of his four different alignment spots on defense Sunday. He’s also not nearly the liability against the run he had been last year. He could be the team’s most underrated player.
⭐⭐ (Exceptionally good game — or multiple vital plays)
TEs Darnell Washington, Connor Heyward
For a second consecutive game, Washington had the most snaps of the Steelers’ tight ends. This time he registered a career-best 62 receiving yards on three receptions. But when you add his contributions as a blocker, it’s hard to overlook just how important Washington is to the Steelers’ offense when they want to win in the trenches against good defensive fronts.
Heyward makes this list with some solid run blocking and a remarkable touchdown reception. Rodgers called for Heyward to adjust in the end zone on a scramble drill, and the two read each other like they’d played together for years with how well they executed.
OL Zach Frazier, Mason McCormick, Troy Fautanu
The Steelers’ trio of 2024 NFL draft picks delivered in a big way on the offensive line, as they collectively only allowed two pressures between them. Plus, the majority of the Steelers’ best run plays came from running behind them. The A-gap between Frazier and McCormick, B-gap between McCormick and Fautanu and C-gap off Fautanu’s right hip were gaps where Steelers rushers averaged at least 4 yards per carry. The most successful gap came off Fautanu’s right hip, where the Steelers took a collective seven carries for 36 yards — an average of 5.1 yards per carry — for three first downs and featured two runs of 10 yards or more. If this group continues to take steps forward, it will open up a lot more for the Steelers offense.
DL Derrick Harmon
Four more pressures from Harmon was a good sign of just how good he can be against the pass. He got home twice with two half-sacks and played a big role in plugging the run. He’s been a breath of fresh air for a defensive line that struggled outside of Cam Heyward in the first three games.
LBs Patrick Queen, T.J. Watt
Queen continues to look like the star linebacker the Steelers hoped they were getting when they signed him in free agency in 2024. Nine tackles, a pass broken up and some big hits in space all played an important role in the defense. More importantly, he’s conducting the defense that’s improving each week against the run.
Meanwhile, Watt only got a half-sack this week but tied Herbig with six pressures, broke up two passes and hit Dillon Gabriel four times. Add in solid run defense with five tackles, and you have another good game from the former defensive player of the year.
CBs Joey Porter Jr., Jalen Ramsey
Both players returned from injuries with big performances for the secondary. Porter looked like a shutdown cornerback on the day, as he allowed three receptions on six targets for just 26 yards and broke up two passes. He also got in the head of Browns receiver Jerry Jeudy and drew a personal foul penalty and looked like the cornerback the Steelers need for their future against top receivers.
Ramsey was targeted five times and allowed four receptions for 35 yards, but his biggest contributions came in the pass rush, as he attacked at the right times off slot cornerback blitzes to bring down Gabriel twice. If he’s still not 100% and playing this well, that’s a good sign that he could have a big year ahead of him.
⭐ (Solid performance — or made a big play without a costly play)
RB Kenneth Gainwell
Not as dominant as he was against the Vikings, but it’s a second consecutive week he’s recorded six receptions on six targets. Only got 14 yards with that and 22 rushing yards on six carries, but he’s doing a lot of the little things right to help Rodgers and the offense.
OL Broderick Jones, Isaac Seumalo, Spencer Anderson
Jones still needs to be more consistent in his pass protection, but he did just enough to limit Garrett to just a pressure and two assisted tackles. While it’s clear the team’s game plan revolved around helping Jones, he still needed to win on some key 1-on-1s with Garett and did, including on Rodgers’ 25-yard touchdown pass to Metcalf.
Seumalo played a solid role in the Steelers’ run game and only allowed a single pressure, while Anderson spent another week providing solid assistance as the team’s swing tackle.
DL Cam Heyward, Keeanu Benton
Another solid showing from Heyward with two pressures and significant contributions against the run. He, Benton and Harmon all were important performers in maintaining their gaps to limit Quinshon Judkins and the Browns’ ground attack.
LBs Jack Sawyer, Payton Wilson, Alex Highsmith, Cole Holcomb
While he didn’t register a tackle, Sawyer contributed with three pressures on the day. Pass-rushing was not supposed to be a strength, as he was primarily seen as a run defender coming out of college, but he’s helped there in his early games with the Steelers.
Wilson had another game where his speed played an important factor for the defense, as he made five tackles with one tackle for loss and only allowed 4 receiving yards on the two times he was targeted.
Highsmith returned from injury to contribute with three tackles, a half-sack and two pressures. Having the trio of Herbig, Watt and Highsmith could pay dividends for the Steelers this season.
Holcomb continues to be an asset on early run downs and delivered a big hit in space.
CB James Pierre
Though he’s only been called in as a reserve, Pierre has now been targeted three times in his last two games, and he’s broken up all three passes. He’s providing important depth production at cornerback.
K Chris Boswell
Tough to penalize Boswell for the missed field goal considering the field conditions. He was otherwise perfect.
Notable neutrals
There are players who aren’t given a star or a skull because they either didn’t impact the game in a significantly good or bad way — or they did, but in a way that balanced out the good with the bad. Here, I’ll note players who classified for the latter category.
TE Pat Freiermuth
Freiermuth caught his only target of the game for 11 yards and wasn’t involved much otherwise. He didn’t have any particularly bad plays, either. But the deficit between him and Washington as blockers has led to the third-year tight end out of Georgia getting more snaps than Freiermuth in recent weeks.
DL Yahya Black
Another week where Black doesn’t register a tackle or a pressure, but he wasn’t a liability in the run defense, as he maintained his gap and kept linebackers clean.
S DeShon Elliott
Was a big hitter on defense but got penalized for a crown-to-crown helmet hit on one of those big hits. Still, wasn’t a bad game by any measure.
💀 (Mildly poor performance — or made a key mistake without redemption)
CB Brandin Echols
Not a terrible game for Echols by any stretch, but he allowed three catches and never got a breakup on the day. Could be sharper.
S Jabrill Peppers
Not going to count the blindside block penalty against Peppers, as I thought that was an incorrect call, but his illegal use of hands that wiped out a potential 3rd-and-long wasn’t great, and he didn’t have many plays made outside of one tackle.
P Corliss Waitman
Did have one good punt of 50 yards, but shanked another for just 34 yards and gave the Browns good field position with that mistake. Nothing terrible.
💀💀 (Bad overall game, or multiple critical mistakes in costly moments)
None.
💀💀💀 (Terrible performance, major hindrance to team/game plan)
None.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.