Welcome to Brian Batko's Steelers mailbag. You can submit your questions to Brian directly @BrianBatko on X and bbatko@post-gazette.com

Ty H: Morning BB, thought it was good to see Peppers getting some playing time and he looked like he was in the right position and made some plays for only being here a few weeks. Not sure how he got cut from the Patriots. Do you see him starting more games, even when Elliott comes back?

Brian: That’s a great question. So great, in fact, that I asked Jabrill Peppers that in the aftermath of the game.

“I mean, we’re gonna see,” Peppers said. “I gotta watch the tape. But I definitely think the way I play, my passion for the game, any team can use that. Just gotta keep getting better, honing the minute details, keep jelling with the guys.”

Advertise with us

Peppers is a pretty candid interviewee, as I’ve quickly found out, especially considering Mike Tomlin busted out a “minutiae” at Tuesday’s press conference.

Anyway, I’m not sure how much of a niche Peppers will carve out. If there were ever a week to use him a lot, it was that revenge game against his ex who broke up with him abruptly after three years.

But it does seem like Juan Thornhill already has fallen out of favor to some degree. I don’t know if it was the miscommunication against the Seahawks on the Tory Horton touchdown that had Teryl Austin cussing up a storm days later or a multitude of factors.

There may not be a ton of separation between Chuck Clark and Peppers, but when DeShon Elliott returns — which feels like it could be this week — the Steelers have options. And credit Peppers for even making himself an option this rapidly.

Remember when Desmond King jumped on a moving train even earlier in the process and still couldn’t find a seat at any point? That struck me as a cautionary tale for the Peppers acquisition, but he’s already done more than King, who has an amazing Steelers stat line of one career defensive snap played and one touchdown scored when he was on the field. Wonder if that stands alone in franchise history.

Advertise with us

Josh H: In your opinion, did the Steelers win the game or did the Patriots lose it?

Brian: That game was kind of like giving someone a bunch of really amazing ingredients — A-1 meats, imported cheeses, exotic spices — and asking them to make you dinner while you go out for the day.

You get home, and instead of an elaborate four-course meal, it’s just a plate of chicken nuggets, grapes and carrots. Sure, you’ll be fed and won’t go to bed hungry, but what happened with all the premium supplies (in this case, the five turnovers)?

Well, they accidentally knocked over the spice rack, spilled food on the floor and burned the wagyu beef. But hey, dinner is served anyway because they found a way, and maybe the next meal will be better.

Sean M: Hi Brian. We keep hearing how the Arthur Smith tight-end-heavy offense can dictate games by confusing defenses and limiting personnel groupings. However, the Steelers have targeted their TEs on just 25 of 86 attempts (30%) for the season so far. In fact, there are 9 teams with more TE targets than the Steelers through week 3. The Patriots utilized the TE short passing game to perfection against the Steelers. I know opponents dictate offensive game plans, but is the Steelers TE-driven offense little more than propaganda? Short, rhythm passes to TEs would seem to be fertile ground for a team with an aging QB and a leaky offensive line.

Advertise with us

Brian: Hi Sean. I don’t know that I ever professed the belief they could “dictate games” because of Arthur Smith’s scheme. Inherently, running the ball should be easier out of 12 personnel with two tight ends, but there are many other factors that go into that, as well.

The Steelers are tied for 28th in plays run on offense and are tied for 25th in pass attempts, so they aren’t able to target anyone very often right now. I still think those tight end days are going to be there eventually. Aaron Rodgers will be trusted to target the middle of the field, and that top two of Jonnu Smith and Pat Freiermuth is too good to not make an impact at some point.

Alan H: Why don’t the Steelers go back to the 4-3 defense. Look what the 4-3 Philly defense did to KC! When the Steelers had the 4-3, very few teams could run on us. It’s time we start discussing bringing it back, dontya think?

Brian: The structure of defensive fronts in today’s NFL isn’t really a black-and-white issue, Alan. When the Steelers are in their nickel defense, which is essentially every team’s base defense because of modern passing offenses, they’ve got two defensive linemen and two outside linebackers.

That’s not much different than two defensive tackles and two defensive ends in a four-man front. Now, the Steelers do tend to look for a certain body type in their outside linebackers because of what they’re asked to do — standing up to rush the passer, occasionally dropping into coverage — so you could argue that aspect of the 4-3 or 3-4 discussion. And with the way this defense has played through three games, I won’t argue any new ideas, big or small.

Advertise with us

Tom in Dallas: When they added the 17th game, it was an interconference game. When they go to 18 games, what would that format be? Another interconference game?

Brian: First of all, I commend you on the proper usage of interconference versus intraconference. I haven’t read or heard anything about how they would approach an 18th game, but just playing another NFC team (if you’re an AFC team such as the Steelers) might be the simplest solution.

Otherwise, you’d get into some pretty funky and confusing rotations. It could also help with parity to add another opponent who finished in the same place in its division the year prior, as the NFL did with that cross-conference 17th game. I get there are generally more and better rivalries within conferences, but to me, the sport is already so much more about specific players, individual matchups and history than it used to be that it might not matter if the Steelers end up playing, say, the Seahawks nearly as much as the Patriots.