Brian Batko: Hey everyone, I'm posted up at the Boston airport waiting to fly back to Pittsburgh. The Steelers flew back last night with a huge W. Let's chat about it.
Bud: Brian, the offensive line features four young players who are not getting noticeable better. When does a new line coach come in?
Brian Batko: It's only been three games but I do think this is a make-or-break season for Pat Meyer in that role. Shoot, I thought he might be in trouble after the way last season played out for Broderick Jones. But the Steelers favored continuity for that young group and so far they haven't exactly hit the ground running.
Vincent LaGuardia Gambini: I have several friends that are fans of other NFL teams, and they are baffled as to why Steelers fans are so miserable. Each of them has told me Steelers have the only fanbase they've seen that complains after a win like they lost by 28. I agree with them, I've been saying this for years. The Steelers have some issues, but can we just enjoy a win? Aren't sports suppose to be fun Brian?
Brian Batko: Yes they are supposed to be fun. And I would even venture to say yesterday was a fun, entertaining game. But it was stressful for Steeler fans. I imagine many of them are feeling like it's deja vu, winning ugly, doing so with a formula that's repeatable but not exactly sustainable, which in turn leads to banging their heads against the same damn ceiling they've been under since 2017. That's not too fun.
Drleppy: Looks like getting a top wr2 would help a ton
Read More
Brian Batko: Sure, having more good players never hurts. But what gives people confidence that this offense can even sustain two heavily targeted wideouts, two heavily targeted tight ends, Darnell Washington post-ups in the end zone, and then the two running backs who are good pass-catchers? And that's on top of a desire to get this ground game going, too.
Tom: Hi Brian, a better peformance but have to get that run game going. 3rd and 4th down defense was bad but players were in position on few of those. How do we get offense going? pass pro was a little better but run game has to get going. Not loving Arthur Smith's gameplan or playcalling?
Brian Batko: No, Tom, stay on message. They need another wide receiver to be their No. 2 option! Come on now. In all seriousness, Arthur Smith discussed going into this game how it's a push/pull between trying to run the ball for the sake of how their team is built and what they want to accomplish, but also trying to attack where the Patriots aren't as sound. And the Patriots certainly aren't as sound in the secondary with Christian Gonzalez still out.
Victor C.: Good morning Brian. I understand why Kaleb Johnson didn’t play yesterday, but do you think he will get on the field next week? I’m concerned about his confidence level.
Brian Batko: Good morning. I look at Kaleb Johnson and I still see a 6-1, 220-pound back who had touchdown runs of 65 yards or more all three seasons at Iowa. He can help. But yes, the confidence probably isn't in a great place right now. It's a long season.
Bob: We were extremely lucky yesterday to win. Why are opposing receivers so wide open and our receivers are always covered so tightly?
Brian Batko: The spacing in Arthur Smith's passing concepts does seem to be a negative thus far. They've had some opportunities these first few games to run a scramble drill with Aaron Rodgers, get open and produce a chunk play but it just hasn't been executed. Steelers fans know what it should look like from years of watching Ben Roethlisberger with Antonio Brown and others. As for the defense, Patrick Queen, Cole Holcomb and Payton Wilson all had missteps in coverage.
Pittfan: Hi Brian. When is Tomlin going to be called out on the poor defensive communications that have plagued this team for years? I can't believe the players are dumb. It has to be coaching and that lands directly on him. If he is asked, he'll give his typical Tomlinism without anyone challenging him. By the way, I no longer listen to his press conferences because I'm tired of hearing him talk.
Brian Batko: I think we've written about the communication breakdowns plenty, both over the years and already this season. You and the other readers can do with those articles what you will. And you clearly have decided it's a coaching issue. Fair enough. I don't necessarily disagree. It's difficult to play defense against NFL offenses, but when there's a common denominator for weeks or even years at a time as different players cycle through, you have to zero in on that.
Titan in Charlotte: Hi Brian, why do you think Benton is still playing the nose. It looks fairly obvious this is not his position of strength.
Brian Batko: Hey Titan. I would say the Steelers are trying to give deference to patience with Keeanu Benton there. But eventually, the trend will be too much to overlook if he doesn't improve and they can go in a different direction. With Derrick Harmon healthy and looking good yesterday in his debut, the Steelers have more options at their disposal to figure out the right D-line mix.
Butcher: I get that they love gainwell. But they ran well with Warren first series then disappeared. You were watching with Ray I believe... Is this scheme, play choice, or lack of performance of the o-line or a little bit of all three? I just don't understand why we run so inconsistently. Seems like different issues every week
Brian Batko: Hold on let me ask Ray
Gracie Lou: Good morning Brian from North Carolina! If my memory serves me correctly you said you were a fan of college basketball? I can send you a Duke or Tarheels jersey! I text this comment because the Steelers are 2 and 1 which puts them over 500 and we our officially a winning football team in the NFL. So it will be a very upbeat and positive chat with no complaints from the gang of regulars. Might be a slow day question wise for you. The Duke vs The Tarheels basket ball game in Charlotte is pretty wild! Think Baltimore vs Pittsburgh week!
Brian Batko: I grew up a Duke fan, actually, because I loved Grant Hill for some reason. He was All-NBA first team in 1997 when I was six and probably starting to get into basketball, so that makes sense. Um...anyway...yeah, the natives aren't at all restless. It's all sunshine and rainbows here. I would love to go to a Duke-UNC game.
Takoma Tom: If the Pens can fire Mike Sullivan after 2 Stanley cup wins, how can coach T. Still have a job after almost 10 years of not having a playoff win?
Brian Batko: Well, the Steelers emphasize stability. We know this. Mike Tomlin still gets them in the dance more often than not. They just haven't made anything shake once they get there in eight years.
Patrick: The offense is lackluster. It needs something. I don’t know if it is a second wide receiver or a more stable offensive line. What are your thoughts? Hopefully, 88 and 8 are now on the same page for scrambling rules like 19 is now.
Brian Batko: Flea-flicker
SteelerByBirth: Hello Mr. Batko - Thank you for your work. A win is a win so we will all take it and be happy about it. It wasn’t exactly a win that builds a fans confidence for the rest of the season, was it?
Brian Batko: Not in my view. As I mentioned earlier, I think there's a fine line between repeatable and sustainable. We've seen them win games like this a lot in recent years. But we've also seen them fall short in the postseason against better competition a lot in recent years.
DennisSC: First, thanks for the chats. Do you see yesterday's win more as a step forward or just another paving stone on the road to mediocrity?
Brian Batko: Neither, I guess? But I feel like it was more of the latter. Getting all those sacks and turnovers is a step forward. The sacks are probably more likely to come in droves. The takeaways...I'm sorry, but some of those were of what I would call fluky. Take nothing away from Cam Heyward, because his motor was running hot again two weeks in a row after a disappointing opener, but it looked like he got a fingertip on both of the turnovers he forced. And even Cole Holcomb's forced fumble, while massive to start that game, was kind of a routine tackle on a guy who has major fumbling issues.
Jacksplat: tomlin seems to love the term splash plays. The concern i have with his focus on splash plays = takeaways by the defense is that they hide poor fundamental play. They trick you into a false sense of accomplishment.
Brian Batko: Yeah I can remember having those conversations with players last year or the year before maybe. Basically, what happens if the ball starts not bouncing your way or the randomness of football just causes the turnover well to run dry, can you beat a really good team straight-up? As we saw in the playoffs, the answer in those seasons was very much a resounding no. If you're the Steelers, I suppose you can argue that's why they brought in Aaron Rodgers. They're playing the same style of ball but now, they hope, with an ace up their sleeve in the biggest games.
Silent Bob: Hi Brian do you think an issue with the Steelers draft challenges are they are selecting gold athletes but not assessing their smarts? The NFL is very complicated. Are guys like Wilson, Williams and Jones perhaps not picking up the offense very well?
Brian Batko: Not really. There's always a football IQ aspect, a character aspect, an intangibles aspect when it comes to work ethic, resiliency, that sort of thing. That's the inexact science of drafting. But, at least on paper, I feel like they've actually improved in that regard from the final years of Kevin Colbert to the initial years of Omar Khan. Fewer red flags in the more recent draft picks. I know that's not necessarily the same as what you're asking as far as cerebral players, but I hardly think the Steelers are drafting more space cadets than the average NFL team.
Jim Bow Dean: Did the run defense improve in this game? I know they gave up over 100 yards again but most of that was from Maye and it didn’t look like the DL was getting push around like they did in the first two games.
Brian Batko: Yeah I'd say it was their best job against the run so far. Breece Hall and Kenneth Walker looked like Barry Sanders, so they really had nowhere to go but up. To be fair, credit the coaches for making personnel changes on defense that seemed to pay off immediately. Cole Holcomb and Jabrill Peppers were the main ones.
TVC15: Happy 1st Day of Fall Brian, Who is the better defensive coordinator? 1) The supposedly Hall of Fame worthy Mike Tomlin / Teryl Austin duo or the maniacal looking Steve Belichick?
Brian Batko: Same to you, TVC. Well, considering young Stephen Belichick is now the DC for a UNC team that has allowed 48 and 34 points in its two games against power four competition this season, I'll go with the Steelers guys.
ABNormalville: I don't think Calvin Austin as the number 2 receiver is the problem. The OL doesn't look like it's getting much done in the running game (which hurts the passing game) and the pass protection is shaky. Thoughts on who needs to step up on the OL?
Brian Batko: Everyone. And I say that not to be flippant, but there aren't any solutions waiting in the wings. Spencer Anderson is a good jack of all trades to have in your room. Calvin Anderson is a vet. But if the starting five can't get it done, I don't particularly have a ton of confidence that upgrades are in the offing.
JPinPDX: Good morning Bats. How much credit do we give the Steelers D? As opposed to how much derision do we heap on the Patriots ball carriers?
Brian Batko: Why is it a good morning? Because we're one day closer to death. Mike McDaniel said that. And the Dolphins are 0-3. Anyway...
Sam: Hey Brian, Aaron Rodgers is a bit of a temperamental guy in his last rodeo. How long is his fuse if the passing game either can't scheme anything other than dumps to Warren and fades to the endzone, or simply doesn't have the personnel such that they can spring open in the designed route tree?
Brian Batko: That's a good question. Something I'm monitoring, for sure. Pat Freiermuth and Calvin Austin both were telling me last week that the trip out to Malibu not only broke the ice, but started laying the foundation for those relationships with Aaron Rodgers that it's not jarring to have those tough conversations in the heat of the moment. We'll see if they can get it going more downfield. The chuck-it-deep shot to DK Metcalf didn't produce any yardage in the box score but that PI was huge.
brian: good morning Brian, smoke and mirrors. Steelers should've lost that game. I get it, a W is a W. But man. 200 yards total? giving up 400. My question is how many passes parallel to the line of scrimmage can we throw? Are guys not open? It seems Rodgers is frustrated as well.
Brian Batko: From the press box I didn't feel like there were a ton of open guys he was missing but I'll have to watch it back on the All-22 at some point. Rodgers has seen his intended air yards per attempt and completion decline pretty steadily and this season it's even lower than last year with the Jets. Something to keep an eye on, obviously.
frustrated: Hi Brian, with the Pats tying score you could clearly see Wilson and Queen look at each other confused as to whose responsibility this was. I know this was the third game but these problems carry back to last year? Still? communication issues??
Brian Batko: Yeah, that was bad. Effing bad, to quote Teryl Austin from Thursday. So if you're scoring at home, last week the Steelers gave up a touchdown because of lack of communication/assignment understanding in the secondary. This week it was the linebackers. Maybe they've got them both out of their system now and the coverage will be airtight going forward.
Scranton: What do you think is the main reason things just aren't (and haven't been) clicking for the Steelers? Yes, they won. But, with 5 takeaways, it should have been a blowout. Can't count on that every week.
Brian Batko: I don't know, Scranton. Not to make excuses, but they are missing key pieces on defense right now, particularly at safety and corner. But this is even more alarming when you consider the three teams they've faced so far are all in the midst of transition, be it with their QB, front office, coaching staff or a combination of two or three. The Steelers are dealing with a lot of new faces too, of course. But when they're veterans of this caliber, there's a different expectation for how soon they can fit in.
Mediocre Mikey: The Steelers would have likely lost this game if they would have had 4 turnovers instead of 5. Is that correct?
Brian Batko: Yeah, probably
Kevin: Hi Brian, is Pat Meyer regarded as a good coach, bad coach, or a meh coach ? Seumalo, Frazier, and McCormick seem to have regressed under Meyer.
Brian Batko: Hey Kevin. Did you just include a Google search in a chat question? Never seen that one before. Impressive. Let me know what the internet says.
J D: Brian, why do the Steelers play a soft zone and allow those 8-12 yd catches all the time? Are they playing too conservative on defense? On offense too because they don’t air it out early to set up the run? Thanks for your comments.
Brian Batko: We all surmised the Steelers were going to be playing more aggressive, man-to-man coverage this season with the additions of Jalen Ramsey and Darius Slay. Then again, Joey Porter Jr. was a key piece of that and he's out right now. Then again again, Brandin Echols is that kind of corner and he was in there for 84% of the snaps yesterday.
Dave Moody: This team feels like the car you bought for the looks, because it was "cool," even though the warranty was way past expired, and you're ignoring the check engine lights, because you don't want to feel stupid about what you purchased. This car is going to put us upside down on payments. Thoughts?
Brian Batko: Maybe, but either way, you didn't dip too much into your funds for a new car next year.
Lou: Happy Victory Monday Brian! AR leads the league in TDs thrown. Is that a sign that once this team figures out what works on O, that the expectations can only go up?
Brian Batko: He's tied with Caleb Williams. To be honest, I think there are much better ways to evaluate QB play than touchdown passes. That's pretty archaic and circumstantial.
Quoteth thy Tomlinism: Hi Brian. I'm thinking we start a GoFundMe for Heyward's non-all-pro contract he had to settle for this year, if he continues making the game changing plays like he did yesterday.... anyways, the secondary to me seemed to get absolutely shredded by Maye. I usually find Ray's grading agreeable, but I thought he was generous there w/ the B-. Do you think the secondary was at fault, or the d-line didn't get enough regular pressure, or both? The defense just didn't look great minus the splash plays, as many as there were.
Brian Batko: Cam should've included batted passes in the incentives. He'd be able to buy the Steelers when he retires. Anyways, this is where I tell you that you can ask Ray himself at 10 am Wednesday! Because I'm signing off. Everyone enjoy the rest of your Monday, safe travels if you're heading across the pond, and we'll talk soon.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.