Gerry Dulac: OK kids, we're going to start our chat in just a few minutes...
Gerry Dulac: OK, here we go..!!
Stairway to seventh seed: Gerry: counting Bruener and Robinson, the Steelers might have 6 inside linebackers who can play. Can you see one of them being traded for a WR or OT? What caliber of WR could say Holcombe bring?
Gerry Dulac: Well, they couldn't or wouldn't trade Bruener because he's a low-drafted rookie and wouldn't command anything. Holcomb would be a possibility but his past injury might limit his market. I like Holcomb and if he's your backup you're doing OK
Steeler Fan in SC: Gerry , good morning . What’s the feel or vibe you get from this team about the season ? Super optimistic & confident on making the post season ?
Gerry Dulac: My man, I'm never super optimistic about anything, much less the chances of the team. And I'm not sure I'm even confident, though I'm more that than super optimistic.
Read More
Steeler Fan in SC: Also what about the attitudes of all the new free agent veterans that have joined the team ?. Is the appreciation of the Steeler culture of years past when we developed our own players long gone and what truly being a Steeler organization meant?
Gerry Dulac: That's too hard to evaluate, especially this early.
Retire21: Have you seen HG2?
Scottie Scheffler is really ingratiating himself to us with his self deprecating humor.
Gerry Dulac: I have and I'm not exactly going to encourage anyone to go watch it. But, yes, Scottie is very good.
Bill in LA: If you were calling the shots, what QB moves would you have made since Ben retired? Start Mason? Something else?
Gerry Dulac: I would've drafted Kenny Pickett. Oh wait, they did that
Stairway to seventh seed: Gerry: in the mid teens there were a lot of 26 and 84 jerseys in the stands. I think many fans now look back on that era and think it was derailed by the selfish attitude of those players who were more interested in leading their position in salary than winning. A decade from now will we feel any differently about TJ Watt?
Gerry Dulac: It is beyond unfair and completely inappropriate to put Watt in a conversation with those two, especially 84. Just because he has a big contract doesn't qualify him to be selfish and narcissistic. He is anything but
Chris Parker: Hi Gerry - thanks for the chats. Definitely not the most talked about topic, but what does the punting competition look like between Waitman and Johnston thus far?
Gerry Dulac: Johnston will be the punter, but I'm impressed with Waitman. I don't know why or how he didn't get a shot with another team in camp. Maybe he will eventually. He's an NFL-capable punter.
Lou: Hey Gerry. How is Roman Wilson looking at camp? Think he will hold up as WR2?
Gerry Dulac: He will not be WR2 unless something dramatic and completely unexpected happens. I'll say this, even without pads, he has not done anything to stand out after one week at camp. I like the guy, but at some point, even in shorts, you have to stand out. Maybe he will soon
Bill in LA: In a scale of 1 to 10, with 10 being excellent, how would you rate the Steelers ability to evaluate quarterbacks since Ben retired?
Gerry Dulac: Well, the only one they apparently over-rated was the guy they drafted in the first round and traded two years later. They might have under-rated Mason Rudolph. They got more out of Justin Fields than the Bears did. Rodgers? Kind of hard to over-rate a four-time MVP
Mfinn: Good morning, Mr Dulac. My question has to do with compensation for players on the practice squad. My impression is that there must be tiers, but I don’t know. If, for example, a player who has signed a contract that would pay him for being on the 53 and is then moved to the PS, is there a corresponding change in what he is paid?
Gerry Dulac: Yes there is.
Ryan: Wouldn’t it be prudent to find out what you have in Will Howard THIS year, before potentially trading up to draft a quarterback next year? I feel like we will never know the true potential of Howard because Rogers will be starting this year and then next year they’re going to go and draft “their” guy. Maybe you already have the quarterback of the future on the team and can use all those picks to build around him next year 🤔
Gerry Dulac: They are interested in this year, not 2026 or 2027. They are trying to win this year, which is why Aaron Rodgers is here. They will worry about 2026 and 2027 in 2026 and 2027
Jim: So far Rodgers looks like a major upgrade "arm wise" over Wilson, is the arrow pointing up on the season? Defense looking good, RB's solid, improved all the way around from last year?
Gerry Dulac: It's only one week into camp with no pads. I'll wait
Guest: If Broderick Jones was a 6th round draft pick, would he still have a job? Is he just not living up to expectations of a first round pick or is he really as bad as he seems? The three penalties in five snaps game was really hard to watch.
Gerry Dulac: He's not as bad as you seem to think he is.
Jim: Do you think Johnson will surpass Warren early in the season or at all? He looks good so far.
Gerry Dulac: At some point he will. I'm eager to see him pads against guys wanting to tackle. But he will be the starter in 2026 because they will not re-sign Warren.
Jersey Danno: Line from a movie last night that's stuck in my head. "no matter how bad things get, somebody else always has it worse." Which in our case would be Browns fans. Do you get the sense Stefanski has the same level of control over there as MT has in Pgh.?
Gerry Dulac: No he does not. He has a meddlesome owner who learned nothing in his time as a Steelers investor
Jim: Do we need to start worrying about Jones yet? Not hearing great things out of camp about him. Is it just media hype or is he struggling?
Gerry Dulac: They're not even in pads or hitting yet. What's to evaluate??
Left tackle: Good morning, Gerry. Hope the weather cooperates today for pad popping. Suppose Broderick Jones is average at best, what, if any moves are the Steelers ready to make in order to protect AR?
Gerry Dulac: They are not prepared to make any. Jones is their guy...unless he's a complete disaster
Jersey Danno: Morning Gerry. I looked at the hall of honor roster this morning and it appears the only prominent member of the four-rings club from the 70's that's missing is JT Thomas. Do you envision him on a short list anytime soon?
Gerry Dulac: Not sure.
Jersey Danno: Lots of candidates for Camp Darling '25. Sawyer, Johnson, Howard, Castro. Any emerging dark horses early on?
Gerry Dulac: Gotta wait a little more
itsallmoot: Do you recall a season with so many unknowns/new variables on one side of the ball? 2 of three top RB's are new; New QB; 3 of top 5 WR's are new (4 if you include Jonnu here). Only stability is TE & dare i say it - Oline. Even Oline has two positions in new spots. Going to be fun to watch how AS tries to get everything to gel.
Gerry Dulac: I cannot
artie bridge: Gerry, I haven't read/heard a word about DeMarvin Leal in coverage of camp. How does he fit into plans and what is his likely role?
Gerry Dulac: Yeah, it's been quiet, but we'll get a better sense of him and their plans when we start to see some hitting
Ben: Hey Gerry, what do you see as the big difference between Minkah and Ramsey? When the Steelers acquired Minkah, I remember them talking in similar ways about him playing in the slot, at either safety, etc. Then they seemed content to have him play center field. Does Ramsey have a unique skill set or a more flexible mindset? Thanks
Gerry Dulac: Ramsey does have a unique skill set because he can play CB and safety. They did move Minkah around a lot two years ago, less last year. Ramsey will be a great addition.
Jim: Do you think we will wit until the waiver wire to grab another WR, or is Omar looking to trade now?
Gerry Dulac: Not sure, but I don't think you should be anticipating a trade or anything like that. Haven't they made enough moves??
Jim: Looks like our linebacking (ILB and OLB) are about as solid as we've had in years, are you as optimistic as I am?
Gerry Dulac: That is correct. As good and deep as they've had
Radatatat: Do you feel more confident in this team than you did after the draft? I think they are legit Super Bowl contenders! Rodgers MVP, Watt DPOY, Tomlin COTY
Gerry Dulac: I thought more of their chances once they signed Ramsey
Bill in LA: The Steelers have two undrafted receivers on their roster, Roc Taylor and Montana Lemonious-Craig. Both have good size. Why exactly do they have do they have ZERO chance of making the team?
Gerry Dulac: I wouldn't say ZERO, maybe slim and none. Gonna be tough
Jim: What do you make about all the communication issue talk? Do you think Minkah was the issue? Seems like that's what some of what I read is referring to.
Gerry Dulac: You know what I think when I hear them talk about miscommunication? It's another way of saying some guys don't know what they're doing.
Seth Daddy: To the national pundits, the Steelers are weak at receiver. But they never know anything. Do you agree that with Metcalf, Jonnu, Pat and Austin that they are above average, and maybe top 3 or 4 in the league?
Gerry Dulac: Definitely above average, but not as high as you suggest
Ryan from the sticks: Is Big Ben a top 10 qb of all time? Some people were saying Favre should be ranked higher than him, but there's no way. I'd put Ben around 6 or 7, at worst.
Gerry Dulac: He's a top 10, but not everyone thinks so. I'm sure just about everybody would rank Favre above him
Captain Midnight 50: I'm so excited to see this Defense this year! do you think we solved our Ravens' and Bengals problems?
Gerry Dulac: That's what they've addressed in the offseason and that's what we're going to find out.
Jersey Danno: I hate to beat a dead horse, but a true WR2 would be a real nice addition. Are you hearing any juicy scuttlebutt?
Gerry Dulac: None yet but I'm listening
Sunner in Orlando from Lebo: Good morning Gerry! Thanks for the chats! Very worried about B Jones at left tackle. Whether it be his health or his ability to keep AR upright, is this the key to the offense moving forward?
Gerry Dulac: It's not the key, but it's left tackle and it is the most important position on the team
Bud: Gerry, how big of a concern is OL depth with Jones already injured, especially if it is one of those nagging injuries that may limit him all season. We saw an elbow bother him all last season.
Gerry Dulac: There isn't a team in the league that has good OL depth. Most teams have a hard time fielding a starting OL. The Steelers actually had the best OL depth in the league last year.
Mark: Have any of the receivers, including DK Metcalf, stood out over the first few practices?
Gerry Dulac: Yeah, DK Metcalf
TVC15: Hi Gerry, Is there a Steeler receiver in the Wes Welker slot receiver mold? A tough, surehanded, quick guy. It seemed like Brady could pick up 8 yards at will --- at least against he Steelers --- just hitting Welker on quick slants. Since the Steelers finally have a quarterback who is not terrified to throw over the middle they should take advantage of it. Could Roman Wilson fill this role?
Gerry Dulac: He could but I have not seen any Wes Welker reincarnates yet
Rich in TN: Good Morning Gerry... Thanks for all you do! I know it's still early.. but has your views/assessment of Will Howard changed at all? Looking forward to seeing his preseason game play....Wish Ed the best when you see him.. Cheers
Gerry Dulac: My view hasn't had a reason to change. And my view is I think he was a great pickup on the sixth round. And this isn't my view, but reality -- the Steelers didn't draft him with the idea he would be their franchise QB
Dr. Sardonicus: Do you have any favorites from the late round UDFA folks who have made good?
Gerry Dulac: Too early to tell Dr.
Guest: Who do you anticipate will see more targets - Jonnu Smith or Darnell Washington?
Gerry Dulac: If it's Darnell Washington, then it was pointless acquiring Smith
John from Toronto: Hi Gerry. What's the plan if Broderick Jones can't go at LT due to injury? Would they flip Fautanu to the left side and move one of the back ups to RT?
Gerry Dulac: He's fine. He's supposed to be back on the practice field today
John from Toronto: Hi Gerry. For the DL, do you see all three of these guys making the 53 man roster: Leal, Loudermilk and Lee? I'm intrigued by Lee.
Gerry Dulac: I am curious to watch Lee, as well, and so are the Steelers.
John from Toronto: Hi Gerry. Are we looking at a 4,000 yard season for Aaron Rodgers? It seems within reach with this roster and the way he spreads the ball around. And if he's just a little more efficient this could be the best QB play the Steelers have had in nearly a decade.
Gerry Dulac: John, I wouldn't go that far. It's not as though he still has Metcalf and Pickens as his WRs
Billy Conn: Good morning Mr. Dulac: Since the 'standard is the standard' 500 football and win one playoff game; if that happens this year are we stuck with Tomlin for perpurtidity?
Gerry Dulac: You got him, baby....regardless
The Truth: Hey Gerry! If Broderick Jones ends up being a bust at LT, and it does not look great so far, is there a chance that Fautanu gets a look at LT considering he played there (and very well might I add) in college? Could he actually be the left tackle of the future?
Gerry Dulac: Anything is possible. It's possible they could flip-flop the two
KMan: Are the reports of Frazier's snaps overblown, or are they something to be concerned about? Is it breaking in a new QB/C mesh or a case of the yips? He strikes me as the type of player who can/will confidently correct what he needs to.
Gerry Dulac: Overblown. It's not as though he's firing pitchouts back there
The Truth: In your mind, did the Steelers really get that much better this offseason? It feels to me, like they got marginally better in all areas but not significantly enough to win a playoff game. It feels like another 10-7, no postseason wins, type of year. DO you agree?
Gerry Dulac: To a degree, yes, but a lot depends on Rodgers, of course. But, once they acquired Ramsey, I though that move made them better than last year
The Truth: I thought Elandon Roberts, in his role, did very well. Do you think letting him walk was a mistake? Who replaces him as the run stopper?
Gerry Dulac: Don't know if it was a mistake, but why release him and sign Malik Harrison? That doesn't make sense to me at all
Mrbig: Has anyone figured out why they collapsed last season, specifically R Wilson.... he had his best game & stats against cincy, then fell apart? Anything to do with Wilson calling audibles?
Gerry Dulac: It was more than that. Before their late-season collapse, they were 7-1 and averaging 28.8 points in an eight-game stretch. What happened? The reasons are many, but some of it had to do with a disconnect between Wilson and Arthur Smith about the way the offense should operate
The other Bill in LA: I would have not signed Russell Wilson and see if Pickett could have beat out Fields. The year before, I would also have not signed Mitch and would have let Rudolph start while Pickett backed him up.
Gerry Dulac: You're forgetting that if there was still a Pickett, there wouldn't be a Fields. He was only acquired after they traded Pickett.
Mrbig: Am i crazy or didn't holcombe play great veggie his injury?
Gerry Dulac: You're not crazy
Gibby: Hey Gerry! Hope your day goes well today!! Do you know when your going on the Rich Eisen Show next? Absolutely love to see you two interact its such a joy to watch
Gerry Dulac: Thanx. I don't know the next time but I enjoy being on w Rich
The Truth: I understand having faith in your guys, but how on earth do we not have an established WR2 on the roster? Same situation as last year. If Metcalf goes down, are we really going to have to rely on 5-7 Calvin Austin, old Robert Woods and unproven Roman Wilson? And spare me the "tight ends will function as the WR2" nonsense. Heard that song and dance last year!
Gerry Dulac: Pay the man!
Joe: Is Broderick Jones reaching bust category already? The guy is either a low-IQ player or lazy, maybe both. Just an awful pick so far considering they moved up in the first round to take him
Gerry Dulac: Give him a chance
Gerry Dulac: OK kids, we're out of time. Thanx for the questions. Do it again next week






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.