Welcome to Brian Batko’s Steelers mailbag. You can submit your questions to Brian directly @BrianBatko on X and bbatko@post-gazette.com.
Gregg from Shaler: What is a reasonable expectation on date for Rodgers to decide one way or another? To be fair to the team, the other players, etc.
Brian: Probably about three weeks ago at the very least, Gregg. Even Derek Carr’s retirement choice came May 10 for the Saints. Easton Stick was the most recent free agent off the board and he signed April 21 with Atlanta. But the last free agent domino to fall who has any shot at all to be a starting quarterback this year was Joe Flacco to Cleveland way back on April 11.
Of course, the major difference is those guys likely were waiting around for a team to make them a good offer. As we know, in this case, it’s the Steelers waiting around for one man to accept or decline their offer while every other team’s projected starting quarterback is participating in this phase of the offseason.
You could make a case it’s already unfair to the team and other players. I understand that in the NFL, there always will be side stories, distractions and difficult dynamics to answer for, but this is slowly becoming a unique situation for the 2025 Steelers. And even once, or if, Rodgers signs, that’s only the beginning of another cycle that could’ve been old news by now.
The strangest part of this entire saga — and it’s on the brink of being upgraded to odyssey — might be that it has Art Rooney II singing Jackson Browne at every turn. “Just a little bit longer ... ”
Read More
It’ll all be worth it if he’s a lot closer to 2021 MVP Aaron Rodgers as opposed to 2024 post-Achilles tear, below-league-average quarterback Aaron Rodgers. But that’s a significant if. I can’t help noticing Mike Tomlin had a news conference last year on the first day of OTAs and did not address the media Tuesday, the first day of this year’s. Almost makes you think even the head coach leading this pursuit is tired of talking about it.
Alan in Bama: Good morning Brian, with all the draft buzz and the ever present Aaron Rodgers QB fiasco, how do you feel the O line will perform this year. Other than Frazier, it doesn’t seem like the top picks have performed great, injuries a reason no doubt. Seems like the O line didn’t do great with run blocking or protection last year. Your thoughts?
Brian: That’s one of the most pressing questions for this team this season, and you’re right that it’s more or less flying under the radar. But it’s probably appropriate to put it on the back burner until padded practices begin in training camp or even preseason action, when those developing young players are facing guys in different jerseys.
To some extent, Broderick Jones and Troy Fautanu should be afforded the luxury of going through some growing pains, either as a collective bookend duo or individually. But both were first-round picks. As much as their first go ’round together could be viewed as a springboard for 2026, when the Steelers could be plugging in a first-round quarterback, there needs to be some progress made. For Jones, the Steelers will have to make a decision on his fifth-year option after this season, so time is ticking.
Ask me again in August how they’ll fare. We’ll have a better idea then. Although one of the people I’d be seeking out for an evaluation of a promising offensive lineman won’t be able to give me one. Craig Wolfley would’ve turned 67 last week, and as another chapter in Steelers history begins with OTAs, it’s certainly missing someone special.
Stan in CT: With no diva WR for the first time in like ten plus years, how are we going to get through the season?
Brian: It’s kind of nice to have a relatively boring group there, yes. But sometimes drama comes with talent, talent comes with drama. Some of the best Steelers teams in franchise lore were far from boring.
And while I’m not sure I’d call DK Metcalf a diva, he has been prone to the occasional sideline outburst, taunting call or unsportsmanlike conduct penalty. The Steelers are getting him at a point in his career when he’s not a homegrown guy, but to your point, it’d be nice to see them avoid any further headaches with a No. 1 receiver — especially if the quarterback is causing any of those.
Robert L: Was the Steeler 'bumble bee' uniform of 1933 inspired by the Three Stooges football short? They wore a very similar jersey and it was hilarious! Was Art a Stooges fan?
Brian: Art Rooney may or may not have been a “Three Stooges” watcher, but back in that 1934 campaign, the Steelers were not the Steelers, and “The Chief” did originally name his football team the Pittsburgh Pirates in part to piggyback off of the successful baseball team at the time. That’s quite ironic given today’s circumstances.
Also, when the Steelers paid tribute to those jerseys with the alternates unveiled in 2012, they weren’t exactly met with widespread acclaim from players. James Harrison said they should’ve stayed in 1934. We’ll see if this year’s throwbacks get more love from current Steelers.
Arturo A: I hope you are ready to enjoy a nice off season. Thinking about the greatest catches ever, you can always think about OBJ vs Cowboys, Lynn Swann acrobatics, the Helmet catch, etc. but I think that one of the greatest catches ever ever belongs to Martavis Bryant! As you surely remember it included a full flip in the air and catching the football between his knees…. Amazing athletic ability! Don’t you agree it’s a forgotten play? Thanks
Brian: Perhaps because of the way Martavis Bryant’s Steelers tenure ended, it could be viewed as an underappreciated play. But when I go back and watch it, I’m not sure I’d have it on the shortlist of best catches. Bryant kind of put himself in that tough spot by not corralling the pass right away.
That takes away a little bit from how athletic it was to do the somersault while securing the ball. So I’d say it’s plenty memorable, if not quite as impressive as Antonio Brown’s helmet catch against the Titans, George Pickens in Cleveland or even Diontae Johnson’s one-handed snag a few years ago in Cincinnati. Bryant does get bonus points for scoring on his, that’s for sure.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.