Welcome to Brian Batko’s Steelers mailbag. You can submit your questions to Brian directly @BrianBatko on X and bbatko@post-gazette.com.

George T: Hi Brian, I have been seeing where a lot of folks do not want the Steelers to re-sign TJ and some want them to trade him. They say he is getting too old and not good anymore. If they think he should be getting about 20 sacks each year that is not understanding football. I know last year he only got credit for 11.5 sacks but he also had 4 or 5 taken away because of defensive holding calls. Without them he would have been around 15 sacks which I believe is above average for the league and good. Also if the new DL draft picks can push the pocket he could get many more. Also he was rated near the top of the league against the run.

Brian: The Steelers have wisely rid themselves of one potential contract negotiation headache with George Pickens. But another tricky one is still on the docket.

It’s now been one day less than a month since T.J. Watt’s cryptic peace-out post on Instagram. Watt currently is the seventh-highest-paid edge rusher in the NFL by average annual salary and fifth in total contract value, according to OverTheCap.com. The guys in his stratosphere are Myles Garrett, Maxx Crosby, Nick Bosa, Josh Hines-Allen, Danielle Hunter and Brian Burns. Only Garrett (14) and Hunter (12) had more sacks last season than Watt.

Advertise with us

Trey Hendrickson, the NFL’s reigning sack leader, and Micah Parsons (12 last season) want to be paid in the same realm as those seven, but their teams are hemming and hawing about getting those new deals done. While Watt is not infallible as a player, most NFL onlookers who are not as close to the Steelers’ eight-year drought of not winning a playoff game as frustrated Steelers fans likely would agree he’s still very much in that conversation with those well-compensated pass rushers.

I can understand not wanting to pay for past performance, but as George points out, it’s not as if Watt fell to single digits in the sack category for just the second time since his rookie season in 2017. Yes, he was held without one for five of the final six games (including the playoff loss) and yes, everyone on this defense is on notice to be better defending the run.

But Watt still led the NFL with six forced fumbles, still sits atop the opposing offense’s game plan each week and still plays more than 80% of the snaps. And he did indeed have a third-down sack of Joe Burrow in Week 18 wiped out by a holding call against Cory Trice Jr.

This isn’t to say a Watt negotiation will be easy — it never is when you’re in the $40 million a year range — but it feels like we’re still a down year or two away from serious discussions about him being a former superstar now in decline. Alex Highsmith is solid, Nick Herbig has been impactful — sometimes game-changingly so — and I suppose we’ll see what Jack Sawyer brings to the group, but I wouldn’t be in any hurry to see this defense without Watt.

Nate K: Greg Popovich, possibly the greatest NBA coach of all time, just announced his retirement. With his departure, Mike Tomlin becomes the longest-tenured head coach in the Big Four of professional sports. Popovich hadn’t won a playoff series since 2017. Had he not retired, would Spurs fans, who generally seem to have tremendous love and respect for Pop, theoretically have been justified in calling for his firing — using the same logic many Steelers fans apply to Tomlin’s recent postseason record? If not, what accounts for the difference?

Advertise with us

Brian: First of all, please give Gregg Popovich his second G. The greatest Gregg of all time, perhaps, other than maybe Gregg Allman. But I digress...

While Popovich’s transition from head coach to solely the president of basketball operations in San Antonio does make for an interesting Mike Tomlin factoid, I’m not sure we should be comparing the two. Popovich coached the Spurs for 28 years, led them to five NBA championships and is the winningest coach in the history of that league. It’s more akin to how Patriots fans may have felt about Bill Belichick when he split with the Patriots.

But sure, six consecutive seasons without making the playoffs — after being there 22 years in a row — is reason enough for frustration for supporters of any team. One key difference is that the Spurs have openly been in rebuilding mode, prioritizing player development throughout their youthful roster, while the Steelers are loath to go that route in a league with much more parity and a lot more layers to it than flipping a basketball roster.

Mike from Iowa: List of players who played CASH (hybrid safety/LB) at Iowa since they added the position to the defense in 2018:

Amani Hooker (Titans)

Advertise with us

Dane Belton (Giants)

Cooper DeJean (Eagles)

Sebastian Castro (Emergence during 2022 season allowed Hawkeyes to move DeJean to CB)

If you’re looking for a UDFA to watch this year, check out Castro.

Brian: Agreed on Sebastian Castro, the hard-hitting Iowa defensive back who could save the Steelers a roster spot (or two) if he can excel as a slot corner, strong safety and special-teamer.

Advertise with us

Just to add further context to Mike’s Iowa expertise, Hooker was a fourth-round pick who’s entering his seventh season in Tennessee, playing everywhere from the slot to strong safety to free safety. Belton was a fourth-rounder who’s been a part-time starter playing either safety role. DeJean, of course, was a second-rounder who stepped right in and starred as the primary nickel for the Super Bowl champs.

Clearly, the Steelers like something about the Hawkeyes lately. Castro doesn’t have the size and speed combination of those guys, plus he’ll be 25 in October, which surely hurt his draft stock and led to him being a rookie free agent. But he could be a camp standout.

Bob L: Not exactly a Steeler question, but who do you see as being the odd-man-out in the Cleveland QB room? Some local interest would be Kenny Pickett.

Brian: Eh, it’s enough of a Steelers question for me. They’re gonna play those guys at least twice — probably only twice — and there’s intrigue in how Cleveland’s quarterback derby plays out. We know the obvious connection to Kenny Pickett. But the Steelers could’ve signed Joe Flacco and sat out the Aaron Rodgers sad trombone sweepstakes. They also could’ve drafted Shedeur Sanders three times.

I actually think Sanders will be the odd man out. Not necessarily because he’s the worst of the four — he actually might be the best — but he has the least invested in him as a fifth-round pick other than Flacco. Flacco, though, has experience the others don’t, which makes him the most logical to keep even if it’s in a backup capacity.

Advertise with us

Chuck from Houston: Will Howard is already looking like a keeper with his off-field first impressions around town and with the coaching staff. Seems like we got this one right eh??

Brian: I don’t know what chances he’s had to make impressions so far, but he does seem very likable, yes. Will Howard’s personality seems to strike that balance of having an edge to him when it matters but not taking himself too seriously at the same time. I can see him fitting in well as a backup, and I can see players believing in him if he becomes the starter at some point.

That combined with his physical profile left me surprised he didn’t go higher, but I suppose there weren’t a ton of quarterback-needy teams once the draft got into the middle rounds, and I never in a million years would’ve guessed Dillon Gabriel ahead of Howard. If nothing else, the Steelers should have themselves a solid presence in that room for a long time, whether he’s No. 1, 2 or 3.