In preparation for the 2025 NFL draft, the Post-Gazette’s team of experts will go position by position and analyze the best fits for the Steelers. Our entire big board will be available and updated as we get closer to draft day, April 24 in Green Bay, Wis.
Today’s group: quarterbacks.
1. Jaxson Dart (Mississippi, 6-2, 223)
The skinny: Aptly named for his position, Dart is a Salt Lake City-area native who transferred from USC and thrived under Lane Kiffin. Dart threw for 4,279 yards, 29 touchdowns and six interceptions last season — career highs across the board. But he has mobility, too, averaging 500 rushing yards and four touchdowns on the ground the past three years.
Steelers fit: NFL decision-makers will need to separate the player from the scheme, particularly considering the cautionary tale of Matt Corral just a few years ago coming out of the same program. The Steelers were scouting the QB class heavily that season, as well. Dart can move well and has upside, as he won't turn 22 until after the draft, so that’s the case for him to be any team’s consolation prize beyond Cam Ward or Shedeur Sanders.
The latest: Dart drew mixed reviews at the Senior Bowl but may have garnered enough buzz in the right circles to vault himself to the No. 3 quarterback in 2025. Scoring a point with some scouts, Dart even suited up for the Gator Bowl and shredded Duke for 404 yards and four touchdowns on 27-of-35 passing. He didn’t do any athletic testing at the combine but did not shy away from the throwing drills.
NFL comp: Zach Wilson
Read More
2. Will Howard (Ohio State, 6-4, 236)
The skinny: Threw for 4,010 yards and 35 touchdowns to 10 picks by the time he led the Buckeyes to the national championship. Howard has the coveted size and solid athleticism, too, as the eastern Pennsylvania prospect found his way to Kansas State coming out of Downingtown West High School. A decent run as a game manager there paved the way for Howard to transfer to Ohio State for his final season and win big.
Steelers fit: Howard has the kind of gritty toughness that allows a guy to take a slight jab at Penn State during the week, then do enough in the ensuing matchup to help the Buckeyes beat the Nittany Lions (who didn’t offer him a scholarship). That underdog mentality served him well after Ohio State’s loss to Michigan, and he ended the college football season hoisting the trophy. Howard turns 24 in September, so he’s more of a win-now type of quarterback than a developmental one.
The latest: The all-star circuit missed out on Howard because of Ohio State’s championship run well into January. That means he didn’t get to throw alongside some of his competitors in this class. But Howard did so at the combine, with some struggles, and he’s sure to have a million or so scouts at his pro day given the large contingent of prospects coming out of Columbus.
NFL comp: Josh McCown
3. Jalen Milroe (Alabama, 6-2, 217)
The skinny: A roller coaster of a career and of a final season didn't stop Milroe from declaring for the draft. He threw for less than 3,000 yards and only 16 touchdowns to 11 interceptions last year, but his value as a prospect is in his rushing ability. Milroe, who turned 22 in December, ran more each season he started, culminating with an average of 55.8 yards per game and a whopping 20 touchdowns on the ground in 2024.
Steelers fit: Mike Tomlin and Company surely have had their ear to the ground in Tuscaloosa on Milroe for years, considering how often they go there in the pre-draft process. Milroe won’t be the kind of pure passer the Steelers have been searching for post-Ben Roethlisberger, but he certainly has the dual-threat ability Tomlin loves. He’d almost certainly be a developmental option for them, with a veteran quarterback needed to bridge the gap to Milroe.
The latest: The way Milroe threw the ball at the Senior Bowl, many will argue dual-threat is a stretch, and he didn’t do any running or jumping at the combine. He’ll need to ace every other aspect to erase some of the questionable accuracy issues he put on tape for the Crimson Tide. But most impressive might be that he won the William V. Campbell trophy, essentially the “academic Heisman” for star plays who excelled in the classroom, as well.
NFL comp: Malik Willis
4. Quinn Ewers (Texas, 6-2, 214)
The skinny: A prized recruit out of high school who went viral for his quick release and high-velocity throws, Ewers opted to transfer to Texas instead of waiting his turn behind C.J. Stroud at Ohio State. Ewers was a three-year starter with impressive numbers, highlighted by this past season when he completed 65.8% of his passes for 3,472 yards, 31 touchdowns and 12 picks. He also had to hold off wunderkind Arch Manning as his backup for two years.
Steelers fit: Ewers doesn't turn 22 until March 15 but guided the Longhorns to the CFP semifinals, making him a reasonable balance between instant impact and potential. Steve Sarkisian’s Texas offense is known for having plenty of pro concepts, so he’s not strictly an RPO merchant. He won’t do much to keep defenses honest with his legs but the Steelers had a formal meeting with him at the combine, including Mike Tomlin asking about his major, GPA and personality (according to Ewers himself).
The latest: The outside world’s last image of Ewers was getting strip-sacked for a touchdown by Ohio State’s Jack Sawyer on the second-biggest stage in college football. He had committed to participate in the Senior Bowl but withdrew, citing an injury, though he did work out at the combine. Ewers reportedly dealt with oblique and ankle injuries last season, so he’ll need teams to be comfortable with his medical report on top of his performance.
NFL comp: Jimmy Clausen
5. Tyler Shough (Louisville, 6-5, 219)
The skinny: Seven years in college football, three schools and only one full season as a starer, Shough (rhymes with chuck) is a fascinating study for this particular draft class. He’s got great size, four-star pedigree as a recruit and finished strong with a victory lap campaign at Louisville for 3,195 yards, 23 touchdowns and six interceptions. Shough will be 26 in late September, a little more than six months after Justin Fields turns the same age.
Steelers fit: We know they like big quarterbacks in Pittsburgh, and Shough checks that box. He scrambled more when he saw action at Oregon and Texas Tech but mostly stayed in the pocket this past season. Because of his age and experience, he might be the most realistic rookie who could step in immediately to start in 2025 — and the Steelers had him in for a pre-draft visit March 6.
The latest: Shough helped himself more than anyone else at his position at the Senior Bowl, and now draft gurus are going back to find some eye-popping throws of his throughout the season. It remains to be seen how high he climbs up boards or if scouts view him in too harsh a light because of how old he is. There’s a good chance he’s a finished product already, but he was one of just three quarterbacks to run the 40 at the combine and posted a nice time of 4.63 seconds to show his straight-line speed.
NFL comp: Joe Milton
6. Riley Leonard (Notre Dame, 6-4, 216)
The skinny: Leonard has had some draft traction since his breakout sophomore campaign at Duke, where he got injured as a junior. He transferred to South Bend to finish it out and had the Irish on the brink of a national championship. As a senior, Leonard completed 66.7% of his passes for 2,861 yards, 21 touchdowns and 8 interceptions while adding 906 yards and 17 more scores on the ground.
Steelers fit: A strapping, mobile quarterback coming off a trip to the College Football Playoff title game screams Pittsburgh in a lot of ways. Leonard wouldn't be a bad lottery ticket as a backup with potential to be more, but with concerns about his throwing ability, it’s unlikely to see him as an option in the first few rounds. He’s fairly similar to Howard, just not as consistent as a pocket passer, and could even moonlight as a short-yardage or red-zone threat.
The latest: Leonard seems to understand how much he can improve his stock in the pre-draft process and the steps he needs to take to do so. He participated in the Senior Bowl, practices and game, despite the quick turnaround for him. Teams won't be able to question his competitive desire, as he also put himself up against the other passers at the combine — though it will be interesting to see if he runs a 40 or jumps at his pro day.
NFL comp: Tim Tebow
7. Kyle McCord (Syracuse, 6-3, 218)
The skinny: A five-star recruit from powerhouse St. Joseph’s Prep near Philadelphia, McCord waited his turn and was supposed to be the next great one at Ohio State but didn't quite live up to huge expectations in his lone season as the starter succeeding C.J. Stroud. So he transferred to Syracuse for his fourth year and put together the most prolific campaign in FBS, completing 66% of his passes for 4,779 yards, 34 touchdowns and 12 interceptions. But he also was sacked 27 times and had six fumbles.
Steelers fit: McCord is as good a pure passer as there is in this draft, but his lack of mobility hinders his NFL ceiling. That could make him a decent option as a Steelers backup if he’s around on Day 3. He might just have to put his head down while walking through the parking lot if he passes anyone from the Pitt team that harassed him into five interceptions and four sacks last season.
The latest: His arm talent stood out above the other quarterbacks at the Shrine Bowl after he was a surprising omission from the Senior Bowl roster. McCord got the chance to show his impressive arm at the combine but, like most quarterbacks, opted not to do any of the timing drills. The team that drafts him will have to overlook his athletic limitations.
NFL comp: Chad Henne
8. Kurtis Rourke (Indiana, 6-4, 220)
The skinny: A Canadian who followed in the footsteps of his older brother Nathan to start at quarterback at Ohio, where he spent his first five years in college, Rourke found the right place for himself in his bonus sixth season. Indiana took the college football world by storm in large part thanks to Rourke’s 3,042 yards and 29 touchdowns to just 5 interceptions on 69.4% passing. But he’ll be 25 in October.
Steelers fit: Rourke has the ideal size to go with a ton of college experience between the MAC and Big Ten, but not much potential to help the run game. If they’re searching for someone who could be a long-term backup, Rourke might fit the bill. And he should come in with no culture shock given the Yinzer-centric staff he was coached by with the Hoosiers.
The latest: No all-star game and no on-field work at the combine for Rourke, who played the entire 2024 season with a torn ACL and had surgery in January, according to his agent. Rourke also missed time late in the year with a thumb injury, though he also pushed through that to lead the Hoosiers in their playoff game. Teams surely will appreciate the toughness but could question the overall injury risk with Rourke.
NFL comp: Matt Hasselbeck
9. Seth Henigan (Memphis, 6-3, 215)
The skinny: The starter all four of his years, Henigan rewrote the quarterback records at Memphis. He threw for at least 3,000 yards and 20 touchdowns all four seasons while never tossing double-digit interceptions. Henigan turns 22 in March.
Steelers fit: Henigan is another experienced college quarterback in the backup mold. He’d have at least one strong connection, as he actually was the starting quarterback for Calvin Austin III’s final season when Henigan was a freshman. If they don’t jump at a quarterback in the earlier rounds, Henigan could be there later in the draft.
The latest: Regardless of how he fared in the Senior Bowl practices, Henigan didn’t hurt his cause in the game. He threw for 132 yards on 12-of-14 passing, including the winning touchdown to Jack Bech as time expired. Henigan put himself through the whole battery at the combine other than the bench press, running a 4.76-second 40.
NFL comp: Kenny Pickett
10. Taylor Elgersma (Wilfrid Laurier, 6-4, 216)
The skinny: Perhaps the most fascinating quarterback prospect in the draft, given that he’s never played a down of college football in the U.S. Elgersma actually played 12-man Canadian football at his school, where he was league MVP for an undefeated team after throwing for 2,643 yards, 20 touchdowns and 9 interceptions with a 74.5 completion percentage in eight games. He’ll turn 23 in late March and also played hockey growing up in London, Ontario.
Steelers fit: Hey, if you’re stuck in quarterback purgatory and want a chance to shake things up, why not try something really out there? Elgersma could be a total bust, but he’s tall with a live arm and we’ve seen the Steelers throw away seventh-round picks for less. If there were ever a year to explore the market inefficiency of untapped talented throwers before they hit the CFL, this might be it.
The latest: Enough evaluators out there saw a legitimate NFL prospect in Elgersma that he was invited to the Senior Bowl, which is just about unprecedented for someone in his position. He completed 4 of 7 attempts in the game for 57 yards after what had to be a whirlwind week of practices. No combine invitation for Elgersma, though, so he’s flying under the radar like a Canadian goose.
NFL comp: Desmond Ridder






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.