Gerry Dulac: OK kids, we'll start our chat in about 20-25 min so get ready....

Gerry Dulac: OK, let's get started..

Tony in Augusta: Is there a reason why Russell Wilson never really took time off to rest his calf and strictly rehab it? Was there ever any cause for concern from the staff that the way he was going about his injury recovery (aka continuing to take reps in practice even if they were limited) might have led to the length it has taken to rehab his calf strain? Tomlin has preached he would rather tell players to hold up instead of get going, but this just seemed like a reasonable time to, at some point, tell Wilson to hold up. Thanks!

Gerry Dulac: I don't know what you would call the last 6 weeks, but I'd call that rest and rehab

Advertise with us

Lou: Morning Gerry. Do you have any insight/thoughts on if/who the Steelers could trade for as the WR still needs help?

Gerry Dulac: Lou, I wish I did, but nothing concrete at all. They inquired about Davante Adams, but they knew he wanted to go to the Jets with Aaron Rodgers or the Saints w Derek Carr -- quarterbacks with whom he played before. The reason Adams could control where he wanted to go is because he wouldn't work out a new contract with any other team.

Tony in Augusta: One more question. If the Steelers trade for a WR, let’s say Mike Williams for example, who will have their playing time affected the most? Likely answer is Roman Wilson, right?

Gerry Dulac: Likely answer is they're not going to trade for Mike Williams.

X Yunzer: Gerry - another question - will Russ have the ability to audible out of a bad play into a new play - either run or pass?

Advertise with us

Gerry Dulac: Maybe not right away in a new system, but I would imagine eventually.

X Yunzer: Gerry - thanks as always for your chats - very insightful. Yesterday you wrote that it's time to bring Russ in - and I get your point about the passing - Fields' passing has left much to be desired (though his running is a unique weapon for the Steelers- something they haven't had in years). A couple of questions for you: How is the locker room about Wilson v. Fields? And will they open up the playbook with Wilson as the starter? IMO if they don't and run the same conservative plays they've been calling for Fields, Wilson's inability to run will cost him and the team.

Gerry Dulac: I don't think there's any question what they will call in the passing game and how they attack will be different with Wilson. That's why they are contemplating the switch. And I don't think the locker room really cares much. They just want to win. But I'm sure there are a few who are wondering why they're making the switch now being 4-2. But all you have to do is watch the Ravens -- with 4, 8 and 22 -- and ask yourself: Can the Steelers compete with that? It will help you better understand why the switch -- and why they acquired Wilson in the first place.

Man of Steel: Probably more of a comment than question, but thinking back over the first 6 games, Tomlinson and even more so Arthur Smith have managed the games brilliantly with what players they have had at their disposal, especially at quarterback. They have allowed Fields to display his best attributes while keeping mistakes he was prone to have in Chicago, so I understand why so many people think they should stick with him. Don’t you feel like I do that the offense can be so much better with a former pro-bowler and Super Bowl winner at the helm even if he is only 85% of his former youthful self?

Gerry Dulac: You are 100 percent correct

Advertise with us

Tom: The Steelers offense hasn't had a qb pass for multiple touchdowns or 300yrd passing in more than 2 years. Do you think that the fans have gotten so used to mediocre QB play that they really see Fields as the best option? What if Wilson actually finds open receivers and hits them?

Gerry Dulac: OK, that's two sensible questions/comments in a row! What's happening here?!?!

Tom in TN: Good morning Gerry, sounds like Russell will start this week. From what you saw in camp can the other Wilson add to the WR corps when given a chance?

Gerry Dulac: We never saw him in camp, that's the problem

Bean Hunter: Hi Gerry, and as always, thanks for the chats. Any update on Corry Trice?

Advertise with us

Gerry Dulac: I don't have one at the moment, but I'll check

Tim: Steelers stability rules due to ownership. Cowboys, Browns and Jets are all a mess. Common denominator is ownership. Steelers set the bar on class and stability. Frustration by some sunday outcomes but never do i lose sight of the historic class and success of this organization.

Gerry Dulac: Bingo! Great examples

Yinzer Maguire: Helo Gerry, if there's not a big difference between how Wilson and Fields play, and the Steelers have a similar season like 2022, 2023, then who do you sign for a new contract? Or maybe neither of them gets a new one?

Gerry Dulac: That's what we're going to find out. And that's an answer they seek as well, don't forget that.

Advertise with us

SDWC: Hi Gerry, off-topic but do you think Pittsburgh will ever get a regular PGA Tour stop? And theoretically, what venue would be the most likely/attractive in your opinion?

Gerry Dulac: I do not.

Alan in Bama: Gerry, appreciate your chat and Steeler coverage, always taking a pragmatic view. As much as I enjoy rooting on the black and gold I don’t see the potential in this teams offense to make or go anywhere in the playoffs. Offense reminds me of my 70 year old golf game playing with the young guys. Keep it in play, chip and putt well and don’t come in last in the foursome but never come in first. Your thoughts?

Gerry Dulac: I think Alan that is why they brought in Russell Wilson and why it is time to play him. That was the plan all along and nothing has changed. They spent a whole offseason meeting and determining how to improve their offense. They're not going to let 6 weeks change their mind.

SMF: Hi Gerry: Thanks again for the chats. The Steelers as I recall were interested in Mike Williams for WR2 but he signed with the Jets. He has not had a big year thus far in NY. After the Jets trade for Adams do you think the Steelers are still interested in a trade to get him?

Advertise with us

Gerry Dulac: Based on what I've seen from him so far,I hope not.

Upstate NY Fan: Do you believe that the Steelers are still talking with the Titans for a possible trade for Hopkins? I think he would be the ideal candidate to instill some leadership and maturity in the WR room, while also being a legitimate offensive threat on the field.

Gerry Dulac: They are not. Don't think they ever were

Jeff M: Morning Gerry, Not a question but wanted to point out that I was listening to a national podcast yesterday and they were mocking local Pittsburgh reporters for insisting Wilson is the starter throughout camp and preseason. They were questioning why Tomlin hasn't officially named Fields the #1 QB. This was before the weekly press conference. Just more proof that national media knows nothing.

Gerry Dulac: The national media has no concept of what goes on daily inside the Steelers. None

Advertise with us

Upstate NY Fan: Beanie Bishop had a rough outing against the Cowboys. I didn't hear his name called much this past Sunday - did he redeem himself against the Raiders?

Gerry Dulac: I thought he was better in LV. Nonetheless, the Steelers can't wait until Cam Sutton can return

Dana: NFL practice squad players are paid a small fraction of what what the 53 man roster makes. I could surely live comfortably on that wage but I digress........ how much of a raise do they get when called up on game day and how does it affect the salary cap?

Gerry Dulac: I'm not exactly sure how it changes if they get elevated to the 53 for game day, but they are under a contract for the practice squad. And the practice squad players count approximately$3.7 million against the cap.

Tom: Is it fair to Broderick Jones that people say he isn't playing up to expectations when he had to switch positions? Dan Moore was so bad there they won't even attempt to put him there. Why does Jones get judged for this then?

Advertise with us

Gerry Dulac: Of course not. But who are the people complaining?

Upstate NY: Any word yet on the extent of Zach Frasier's injury? He has been solid; hate to lose him for an extended period.

Gerry Dulac: Tomlin said he's week to week, so you can probably expect that to mean 2-3 games.

Yinzer Maguire: Donte Jackson is playing really well, which helps somewhat ease the discomfort of losing your WR2. But, since Adams and Aiyuk are gone, do you believe this is the WR room the Steelers will keep for the remainder of the season? Is this the first Omar Khan's big mistake?

Gerry Dulac: Never rule out a move, especially if they think they are good enough to position themselves for a playoff run. They'll get a better idea with Wilson at quarterback

Advertise with us

BPOS: All the buzz was around D. Adams but where they also in discussion to acquire Cooper before he went to the Bills? Or was it the Browns didn't want to trade with a division rival.

Gerry Dulac: Right. Browns weren't going to trade him to a division rival

Jay David: Is the best we can say is that we aren't the Jets? Or Carolina? Fields missed open guys downfield that the Russ of old would have hit in stride. And can we get someone like Ramon Foster to help B. Jones with his confidence?

Gerry Dulac: I think the best you can say is they are 4-2 and tied for the division lead.

Guest: Good morning Gerry. Recently we've seen a lot of 2nd year players regress. It happened with Dotson, Claypool, Leal, now it's happening with Jones. Is there something in the way we coach them that has caused this increase? It's not just one position either, so is their an organizational flaw is philosophy?

Advertise with us

Gerry Dulac: I think you are making broad assessments

Chris F.: Hi Gerry. Does it amuse you as much as me to read the certainty with which counterfactuals are offered here and elsewhere? As an example: “Wilson can’t run and will get killed behind this line.” This of course ignores the potential for his reading the field more accurately, hitting the hot receiver with frequency to stall the blitz and similar aspects of a mature passing game. Point being that we won’t know until we run the experiment.

Gerry Dulac: Wow, another good one...hear hear!!

Guest: While Fields did more than I expected, watching his lack of accuracy and vision warrants this move. The fumbles don't help his case either. Stubborn Mike has wanted an athletic QB for years and has chased Fields, Haskins, Dixon, etc..

Gerry Dulac: That's right. The bar was set really low with Fields. What he has done is play above those low expectations.

Advertise with us

IUP Dave: Good Morning Gerry. Is there a better chance we trade for a WR 2 or hope that Russell Wilson unlocks a WR 2 with a better QB passing attack?

Gerry Dulac: I think that's what they think they are going to find out

IUP Dave: Good Morning Gerry. A great day to read your chat. Why all the QB angst I want to see what Wilson can do. This is a future HOF QB and with the second half of the season, I want know which QB gives us the best chance to win in the playoffs rather than try to win enough games to just get in with Fields and lose in the first round. We need to be able to beat the better teams to succeed.

Gerry Dulac: IUP, I'm giving you two questions in a row because this makes waaaaay too much sense

Dr.Sardonicus: Hi, any chance of seeing Trice or Ryan Watt come back from injury this season. We need more players for the defensive secondary.

Advertise with us

Gerry Dulac: Trice should be back soon I believe. Not so with Watt

Befuddled: Gerry, did MT promise RW the starting job during his all day interview that culminated with his signing? This would explain why he was named the starter ahead of week one despite rarely practicing or playing all summer. It would also clarify why he has remained at the top of the depth chart despite being inactive for 5 of the 6 games. It is my belief this happened with Mitch in 2022. His signing was followed by a faux "competition" that guaranteed he would "win" the opening day gig. This would also explain why Mason and Pickett high tailed it out of town virtually the day Russ was signed. They knew there was never going to be a true competition.

Gerry Dulac: Don't be befuddled. They brought Wilson in for a reason -- to be the starter. And nothing was going to change their mind.

SteelGotIt: Gerry, It's no secret the Steelers passing game is W-E-A-K, obviously with Russ most likely being QB1 this week that seems like a move that will boost it... However I must say you cant put feathers on a pig and call it a flamingo so do they use this game as a review of the need for WR or do they have other plans?

Gerry Dulac: Yeah, their other plan is to win the game and boost their passing game.

Advertise with us

Vincent LaGaurdia Gambini: Let's have some fun,thrillseeker! Is the 2025 opening game starting QB on the roster right now?

Gerry Dulac: Let's not

IUP Dave: Good morning Gerry. You get to see more practice that we do so can we be encouraged that Roman Wilson can provide a spark as a receiver or is he just another guy?

Gerry Dulac: AS for right now, he's just another guy. Doesn't mean he can't be a quality receiver for them at some point

SMF: Hi Gerry: Thanks for the chats. What is there about Tomlin’s control over the Offense that minimizes plays over the middle of the field-first downs and careers are made on short slants by every winning Offense. The opposite thing on Defense; constantly allowing over the middle short and intermediate wide open opponent receivers and backs. Both sides of the ball appear straight jacketed. Why?

Advertise with us

Gerry Dulac: That's a very good observation that I can't answer

BPOS: What to make of Broderick Jones? They obviously will continue to hope he works through his issues but you'd expect better, much better, from a 14th round pick who they had to trade up to get. He looks overwhelmed out there.

Gerry Dulac: He does not look like the dominating tackle he wants to be, but I'm not going to fret like other people

IUP Dave: Gerry. How much freedom with Russel Wilson have to change plays at the LOS? Having the ability to change out of plays may mask the difference in mobility of the two QBs.

Gerry Dulac: I'm sure he is very adept at it.

wiscoken: Hi Gerry, love the chats! I think the Steeler QB situation is actually working out quite well. After 6 games they have a great read in what they have in Fields (and a record of 4-2, still in contention). Now they get a chance to see what a healthy Wilson has left in the tank... with two home games, followed by an off week they should know which gives them the best option in closing out season and hopefully winning in playoffs. Now they will have a great read on both as we enter the critical stretch, in addition to making a more informed decision looking ahead (do they keep either, neither or one for next season).

Gerry Dulac: Such reasonable -- and welcomed -- logic.

Elliott Metro: Gerry, the decision to make Wilson the starter will definitely open up the passing game because of his experience to not only recognize the opposing defense, but more importantly, looking for other receivers that are also open, as opposed to the primary one that Fields has been doing. so fed up for zero touchdowns in the first half of games this year. We were lucky to score toward the end of the half last Sunday.

Gerry Dulac: Yes it will. And don't you think they don't know that?? There's a reason for all this.

More WR Complaints: Gerry, why does this team continue to fail to get a WR? Do they plan to actually get one? If they do, why do they even want Mike Williams? The dude scheduled a visit with us and then didn’t even bother to show up. Not only would he be a Jet castoff, he has spurned us already.

Gerry Dulac: He didn't bother to show up because the dumb Jets foolishly offer him a one-year deal for $15 million before he could even meet for the Steelers. That's why they Jets are the Jets.

Mark in Etown: With Christopher Carter's article breaking down how Fields is not 'seeing' open receivers, repeatedly... does that not say more about him locking on to or deciding who is his first option pre-snap? It seems that is the case and the failures to check down or read the defense is really hobbling this offense. A great article that clearly lays out what has been one of the knocks on Fields over time. It seems a more "flexible" QB could be getting a lot more out of this offense. It seems to me that if Christopher broke down all six games this way, The play calling would likely look a lot better.

Gerry Dulac: You'd have to ask him

CG: Hi Gerry, any news on a playoff win, while the Jets and Bills improve their WR rooms? Who is the next WR available? Kirk from Jacksonville?

Gerry Dulac: The Steelers had no control over getting either of the two WRs to whom you are referring

Guest: Sorry....typed enter too fast . Do you think he has learned that this isn't the type of QB that wins championships? Or is he too stubborn to admit the errors he's made?

Gerry Dulac: I didn't see the first part of this question but I'm going to guess you are referring to Justin Fields. Mobile QBs are fine if they can make plays consistently in the passing game. If they can't, then they're just runners. Name one who has won a championship??

Jay: Good morning Gerry. The overall philosophy of defense and ball control is flawed. Winning franchises have great QB play or effective offensive schemes. Do you think maybe Tomlin wants to push this narrative to prove he can win without Ben?

Gerry Dulac: He's not trying to push any narratives. All he is doing is trying to find the best way to get back to being a Super Bowl contender. And that starts with the QB

jay new: Thanks for the chats. What is your all-time Steelers O-Line? I go Kolb and Tunch at OT, Faneca and Decastro at G and Dermontti at Center.

Gerry Dulac: Ok, but kinda hard to leave off Webster

Ghollywoodg: Any update or opinion about when Cory Tice

Gerry Dulac: Soon

Ghollywoodg: So..Dose MT make the change to Russ?….or dose he wait til Fields plays him self out of the position or gets nicked?….

Gerry Dulac: I think you are getting your answer...

Guest: Over the past 18 drafts, we've found a star in the first round only 4 times. Watt, Cam, DeCastro, and Pouncey. That's it. We've had different GMs, different scouts, and different position coaches. The only constant in those 18 years is Mediocre Mike. If he shares equal responsibility with the GM, and I would argue he has more power, why is he so bad at drafting? And why is he still given such power after failing so often?

Gerry Dulac: What...you didn't like Jarvis Jones, Artie Burns, Ziggy Hood or Devin Bush?? But you forgot at least one in your other list ... Ryan Shazier.

itsallmoot: If/when Russell Wilson starts, how much impact can he have on helping with protections? I know it's primarily the center's job but seems like his experience, could help identify where pressure is coming.

Gerry Dulac: That's right

Ken: What do you think of the new Kickoff rule and can you ask MT why they just kick it thru the endzone and not try to pin other teams behind the default 30 yard line?

Gerry Dulac: It's a joke. You see any added excitement? I don't

Rich Erenberg: Did Fautanu need surgery for his injury?

Gerry Dulac: Yes

mrbig: Why does some media say Fields was "benched"? He was the backup and now that the designated starter is healthy, Fields is the backup again... I don't see it as a demotion-

Gerry Dulac: Because some media people don't understand how it works

Ty Hink: Gerry, another swing and a miss on Adams. Do we go for three with Mike Williams or someone like Hopkins if it's a conditional 3? Also any word on Ben skowronek coming back? I miss a receiver who blocks hard for his boys behind him

Gerry Dulac: Adams was never coming here, And Hopkins isn't on their radar. And, after what I've seen of Williams, keep him in NY. He's making $15 million for one year. You think he'll agree to take less money from another team?

RAM: Gerry, if Russ gets the start, does well and solidifies the QB1, do you think Arthur Smith works in some plays to utilize Fields talents?

Gerry Dulac: There is no solidifying No. 1. That's done. But, to your question, he should.

The Dude: Wouldn’t Amari Cooper have been well worth it to the Steelers what the Bills had to give up for him?

Gerry Dulac: The Browns weren't going to trade him to a division rival

Linebacker Lounge: Najee Harris is a pros pro, reliable and has not had a great experienced line or proven play caller until maybe now. Why are the fans so against him? Not picking up his option is a mistake. Please advise

Gerry Dulac: Doesn't mean they still can't sign him to a new contract

The Dude: Why has the Steeler offense been so ineffective when using play action?

Gerry Dulac: I think the answer is being provided with the QB switch

Tom: Gerry, I hope you/your family are doing well. From your vantage point why hasn’t Muth been a bigger part of the offense. So many teams go to their TE on crucial downs. All but the Steelers for the most part. Thanks.

Gerry Dulac: I agree. He should be getting twice as many targets as he does.

Jim: Finally, a Queen sighting this week, was it just a matter of getting acclimated to the defense?

Gerry Dulac: Of course.

Linebacker Lounge: Best FA signing in off season? Elliott?

Gerry Dulac: He's a good one. But I think you should know the other two

Jim: With both Fields and Wilson needing a contract next year weren't we eventually going to have to see what Wilson has? We have seen what Fields has, not its Russ's turn.

Gerry Dulac: That is correct. That's not the reason for the move, but it helps

Jim: What would you give up for Williams? 6th rounder, 7th? Not sure why we would give the jets any more than that, if anything at all. They don't need him and are paying him a ton.

Gerry Dulac: But, if the Steelers traded for him, they would have to pay him the remainder of the $15 million he is owed. Maybe that would make a little more sense closer to the trade deadline.

KN Phoenix: Hello . What percentage chance would you say Russel Wilson has to start this weekend ? I do not know what is wrong with ESPN talking heads giving an impression that it is travesty that Fields might not play . Fields has 5 touchdown in 6 games , with one interception, tied for 25th in league , and a QBR of 54 .

Gerry Dulac: I'd say a pretty good one. Those people have no clue

Jim: Any word on how many weeks Frazier will be out? I know he's out this week for sure. Is it a high ankle sprain?

Gerry Dulac: Probably 2-3 games I believe

Ross new in the Burgh: Hi Jerry, will RW be able to hold up with a banged up Oline? Or will he be under constant pressure and have more than one in??

Gerry Dulac: We'll find out. Or, should I say, he'll find out

Steeler fan in Maryland: if Russell Wilson doesn't perform going forward will Tomlin revert back to Fields?

Gerry Dulac: That's a big if.

KN Phoenix: KN Phoenix . Do you think Steelers will be interested in trading for Jets Mike Williams ? When is the trade deadline ? Thank you as always for the chat .

Gerry Dulac: Nov. 5 at 4 pm is trade deadline. It was pushed back a week this year because of a proposal by -- that's right -- the Steelers

Matt: Gerry, I’ve seen you joined the local pgh sports media narrative for the need to start Wilson. Can you explain in detail why you would do this? Fields hasn’t turned the ball over that much. Has a winning record. Playing decent football and getting better.

Gerry Dulac: I never said they need to start Wilson. What I have always said is they acquired Wilson for a reason and the time is now to execute the plan they had in mind. Kenny Pickett had a winning record, too, by the way. And, just for the record, Fields' NFL record is 14-30 as a starter.

Gerry Dulac: Ok kids, went OT today because of all the QB questions. Do it again next week.