Gerry Dulac: OK kids, one more cup of coffee and we'll get started...
Gerry Dulac: OK, let's get started...
Tom: "Always open" is a trendy cool thing to say for WR. Isn't it the responsibility of the offensive coaches to explain to Pickens that he needs to actually be open? How do you get through to him that he is a professional and playing not nearly good enough?
Gerry Dulac: Did you say "how do you get through to him???"
Post Gazelle: Going by Pickens mantra of "always open"....doesn't he drop a lot of easy balls?
Gerry Dulac: But he does catch a lot of crazy ones
Read More
Stairway to seventh seed: Gerry: a lot of the problems defending the run the last two weeks seem to be caused by opponents going to 3 WRs on 1st down or 2nd and short. The Steelers primarily use their nickel defense in that situation and leave themselves exposed to power running. Does it make sense to expose yourself to the run just to keep Moon out there and bring Bishop in? Shouldn't they stick with 3 DL, take Moon (or even the weak against the run Herbig) out and maybe bring in an extra safety instead of Bishop? They could still use their traditional nickel or dime in obvious passing situations.
Gerry Dulac: Very perceptive and very correct Stairway
Stairway to seventh seed: Gerry: it was widely believed that Keanu Benton would be a force this year. I can't say that I have noticed him at all. Is he just another in a long line of high picks that flash as rookies and then regress? Jones seems clearly to be in this camp along with the likes of Burns, Bush, Claypool, Pickett etc. Why does this happen so often now?
Gerry Dulac: Now, I disagree with you here. I have no problem with Benton. I wasn't expecting him to be Chris Jones anyway
IUP Dave: Good morning Mr. Dulac. Wednesdays are great because of your chats. GPs eye tape comment of Open (bleeping) Always might be overlooked more if he would always Catch (bleeping) Football and Secure (bleeping) Football.
Gerry Dulac: It's early, but...Pay the man!
Post Gazelle: I'm not the biggest fan of TomlinBall, but also think that it may be best for this Steelers team. Do you see the Fields, Harris, Pickens triplet in the top half of the league? At best they could get us to .500, but wouldn't it be more likely a few more turnovers and worn down defense would likely lead to an extra loss or two?
Gerry Dulac: If you mean that trio in the top half of the league collectively, you might be being kind. As for the TOs and "word-down defense," that's true of any team.
Bill in LA: Gerry – greetings from the land down under! How do you feel about the sameness of the Steelers offense after 5 games with Aurther Smith compared to last year's offensive production? Maybe it's just Mike Tomlin and the players and not the OC after all?
Gerry Dulac: Well, Bill Down Under, I just checked the offensive production after 5 games last year to five games this year, and hard as it is to believe the offensive numbers are better this year in every category. I didn't know you were a member of the Matt Canada fan club?
Steelers Dan in FL: Hey Gerry! I see ppl blaming TA for the defensive lapses but doesn’t MT have his hands on it? With that said, do you think he heeds Minkah’s plea to “simplify” so this defense can play how they should?!
Gerry Dulac: Yes he does. And maybe he should.
IUP Dave: Mr. Dulac. Good morning. Tomlinson excuse for GP's snap management was done to (paraphrasing here) be more productive. Could that be code for "sometimes we are better off without GP on the field?
Gerry Dulac: I think you can read in to it anything you want, because clearly the reason he is giving is not the true reason
SMF: Hi Gerry: Thanks for the chats. I was watching Lamar Jackson closely last week comparing him to Justin Fields style of play. It appears obvious (at least to me) that Jackson usually drops back 5 yards farther than Fields on passes. He scans the field so much better and gives him more room to move around. Fields often drops back 2-3 yds. like a Statue QB and takes too many sacks. He loses so much opportunity to use his talents. Can that be fixed?
Gerry Dulac: You are right about the deep drops by Jackson. But he does that because he can, which is why he's a two-time league MVP
Tom in TN: Good morning Gerry, the Steelers sit at 3 & 2 and appear to be lucky to have caught Atlanta & Denver early. The defense has been a disappointment & they have a QB they don’t trust, so how far away is Wilson from playing and will it make a difference?
Gerry Dulac: I think it will be soon. And I'm sure it will make a difference because, after all, that's why they went and acquired him in the first place. He's not a nine-time Pro Bowler and Super Bowl winner by accident
Fake tomlin: Tomlin would be an excellent politician, lies all the time and uses non sensical phrases to confuse everyone. The steelers “culture” is do whatever you want as long as you’re talented. Classic top down management flaw. Do you believe a change is necessary? Even if it’s not probable.
Gerry Dulac: In an election year, you make a good comparison
SMF: Hi Gerry: Thanks again for the chats. Like it or not after 5 games Arthur Smith’s Offense is performing very similar to the Steeler fans favorite chew toy Matt Canada. Short runs into walls for no gain, check downs, lots of pre-snap penalties, and little to nothing in the middle of the field. Maybe it’s the poor play of the Offensive line and/or the WRs are rarely open, or Tomlin?
Gerry Dulac: What was the last part of your point...??
Guest: Different QBs, OCs, etc. Similar results. Do you think Tomlin would ever consider a change in his own philosophy?
Gerry Dulac: Whaaaaattt??
Bulldog: Hi Gerry. Thanks four your chats. Seems like MT has another receiver he cannot control or is willing to properly discipline. Is this one of his major faults?
Gerry Dulac: What did he say yesterday in his weekly news conference..."sometimes two instances is a pattern."
Steve: GM Gerry. Mike Tomlin is famous for saying "we want volunteers, not hostages." But could it be possible that Mike Tomlin's lack of discipline, and not holding certain players accountable is enabling them to become hostages?
Gerry Dulac: Well, maybe this time he's holding Pickens accountable. Nothing gets a message across like cutting a guy's playing time.
IUP Dave: Mr Dulac. I don't have the ability to see the "all 22" tape. I am curious that in some of the still shots of the game against the Cowboys receivers were open deep down the middle. Did Fields just miss them, or did they come open after the ball had already been delivered?
Gerry Dulac: Probably a little of both. But he also had Connor Heyward and Darnell Washington open down the field and overthrew each
Zamo: Gerry, think it’s fair to say the organization failed this year from top to bottom managing the WR room. What can be done at this point to turn this ship around? Last, based on your observations, does the locker room want fields to keep the job (I certainly do) or is Russ really in play? The players must have a lean. Cheers bud
Gerry Dulac: I don't think the players are anywhere near the point where they want one quarterback over the other right now. But the WR room, to your question, is not in a good spot.
Steve in Canton: Hi Gerry, would it make sense to slide ILB Patrick Queen over to OLB to help replace Highsmith, Herbig and Leal? PQ is athletic, and maybe he gets a 'splash play' or two.
Gerry Dulac: No. He is not that type of player. Tomlin was asked a similar question yesterday if Payton Wilson could be moved to outside and he emphatically said no.
IUP Dave: Mr Dulac. Roman Wilson still has not been active for games and we know it is always hard to get on a moving train. But the moving train that is our offense has to be going really really slow. Is this the week Roman Wilson gets a chance? Especially in light of the snap management now being used for other receivers?
Gerry Dulac: If the train moves any slower it will stop. Roman Wilson will get in there eventually because 1) Why not? and 2) He's a third-round pick who at some point they want to see in a game, even just for a couple plays.
60 Prevent Slot Hook And Go: Hey Gerry, thanks for the chat and all you do to keep us Steeler fans informed. It’s much appreciated. Do you think we’re heading towards yet another 7th seed or barely missing the playoff type season? The good vibes from the Chargers game are pretty much gone. It feels like we’re looking at a very mediocre team once again. Injuries are an issue but the lack of skill players and elite QB play are hindering the offense and our defense doesn’t have any one making impact plays besides TJ. Do you see any path towards a playoff win this year?
Gerry Dulac: I think it's way too early to assess where they are headed or if they can win a playoff game. Case in point: Last year the 49ers started 5-0 and were averaging like 34 points a game. Then they lost three in a row where they scored just 17 points in each of those three losses. And they ended up OK. Even last year, as bad as the Steelers looked at 7-7, Mason Rudolph came in and got them to the postseason at 10-7. And nobody woulda thought that at the time.
John from Toronto: Hi Gerry. Is Mike Tomlin's approach to winning outdated? I took a look at Super Bowl champions from 2016 to 2022. All of them had high ranking offenses, ranging from 1 to 7 on a points per game basis. On the defensive side of the ball, the Patriots had the #1 PPG ranking in 2016, but otherwise the range was 4 to 16 over that time period, with the Rams at 15 in 2021 and the Chiefs at 16 in 2022. Basically, the conclusion is that elite offenses with elite QB play win Super Bowls since 2016, and can overcome average to mediocre defensive play. Tomlin's got it backwards, thinking an elite defense can cover for a below-average offense. Thoughts?
Gerry Dulac: I couldn't agree more. But they have those players capable of playing that way. No more Killer Bs. So this is the way they have to play until they prove they have an offense scaring the other team, which they don't.
Hi Brian -: How long before the national media reconciles with the local media on the underwhelming performance of Tomlin and the Steelers?
Gerry Dulac: You might be waiting a while
Steve in Canton: Do you think the Steelers play Russell Wilson as a way to showcase him (as healthy) before the trade deadline?
Gerry Dulac: That won't be the reason they play him
Steve in Canton: Would you trade George Pickens to the Raiders for Davante Adams and a draft pick?
Gerry Dulac: I think I would consider it if this nonsense continues.
Jerrydewlack: Is trading pickens on the table
Gerry Dulac: Not that I'm aware of. That would really be weakening your chances
Steve in Canton: What would fair compensation be for the Steelers to offer in a Davante Adams' trade?
Gerry Dulac: 3rd round pick
GeneMingo: What is going on with Roman Wilson? He’s apparently healthy. It’s not like they have a plethora of All-Pros at the position. Got to get on the moving train sometime.
Gerry Dulac: It's called "he's a rookie and not sure what he's doing."
Bulldog: MT has gotten a lot of the pieces he was looking for. A mobile qb, ilb to help replace Shazier, new oc, new o linemen, new cb's, etc, yet he still fails to consistently win games. Will this continue through 2027?
Gerry Dulac: Maybe longer if he gets another extension
Steve in Canton: Do you think the Steelers make a move of any kind at or before the Nov. 5 trade deadline?
Gerry Dulac: I wouldn't be surprised. Depends if there's a significant injury to a starter, too
Hi Brian -: Should we all stop complaining about Tomlin's deficiencies and the Steelers' lack of preparation and creativity? With Mr. Rooney's extension to HCMT, we get what we get, and there is no reason to get upset because 9-8 is the new "standard." Is this simply the new reality?
Gerry Dulac: Now there's a good point!
Steve in Canton: What will it take for WR Roman Wilson to finally make a gameday appearance on the field?
Gerry Dulac: Couple more games. But I don't think you should be expecting Antonio Brown. Be happy if he gets as many catches as his uniform number
John from Toronto: Hi Gerry. Building on my previous long question. In 2015, the Broncos led by a past his prime Peyton Manning had the 19th ranked offense on PPG basis, and the #1 ranked defense and won the Super Bowl. And going back to 2008, when the Steelers won the Super Bowl the last time, their offense was ranked 20th and their defense was 1st overall on a PPG basis. So I get it, Tomlin won a defense-first Super Bowl, but that will be 16 years ago come February 2025. Why is he so stubborn? And why does he refuse to evolve his thinking to align with the modern day NFL?
Gerry Dulac: Because his way, for the most part, has been consistently successful.
Steve in Canton: What's the status of ILB Cole Holcomb? And will he play this season for the Steelers?
Gerry Dulac: I highly doubt it. And, right now, there is no reason to play him.
Black N Gold: Gerry, If you owned the Steelers would you force MT to hire a game management coach and actually let that person do their job? It is astonishing that he is in his 18th year and is still remarkably awful at handling challenge, clock, and 4th down decisions.
Gerry Dulac: No.
Bulldog: In a past chat while Ben was still playing, someone complained that Roethlisberger needed to be let go. You told them the day will come where they would regret not having him. You get a Pay The Man for that! What do the Steelers need to do to get back to winning and competing for Super Bowls?
Gerry Dulac: Get Ben back?
Steve in Canton: How much time will you have for the tiki bar and pool-side lounging at the Las Vegas hotel?
Gerry Dulac: Haha...alas, none
Steve in Canton: Will you and Ray F. be hitting the casinos in Las Vegas?
Gerry Dulac: I'm taking Ray's room key away
Robert in VA: Hi Gerry. Thank you for the chats. Following and being a fan of Steelers football has become tough since about a year befoe Roethlisberger retired. The team is stagnated and their approach for success (winning a super bowl) has become rote. Simply put, I am losing interest. Do you know of any effective way to measure fan perception in this regard so I can determine if I am alone with my waning patience and interest?
Gerry Dulac: I hear ya Robert. It is not entertaining football and hasn't been for 3 years now. It is difficult to watch and stay interested. You are not alone. I hear that from a lot of people.
Steve in Canton: Does L.C. Greenwood have a legit chance of making the HOF this round?
Gerry Dulac: As a senior, yes he does. And he should.
Gus: Good morning Mr. Dulac. Appreciate your time. I saw the paragraph below in an article written by one of your compadres at the PPG the other day.
“It starts with the owner, obviously, and it continues with an accountability that has seemingly vanished.
For example, Nutting said in January and reiterated in June that making the playoffs was the Pirates’ goal for 2024. That obviously didn’t happen. So why make only cosmetic changes?
Their frustrating acceptance of mediocrity should cause all of us to ignore those same overtures next season. Compete for the playoffs in 2025? Great.
What happens if you don’t? Yeah, probably nothing.”
Without too much difficulty could you insert Rooney for Nutting and Steelers for Pirates and be telling close to the same story for the last five or six years? Certainly, as far as the head coach is concerned, No?
Gerry Dulac: There is nothing that would ever have me compare Art Rooney II to Bob Nutting when it comes to team ownership. The Pirates have been the antithesis of the Steelers for as long as you care to mention.
Steve in Canton: What's the biggest thing you're going to watch for today at Steelers' practice?
Gerry Dulac: My watch.
Linebacker Lounge: Is there a focus of not getting the RB’s TD carries as it would help their stock in free agency?
Gerry Dulac: They're not worried about a player's free-agency chances
Steve in Canton: If Kenny ends up starting at QB any for Philly this season, will you watch?
Gerry Dulac: Nope.
Linebacker Lounge: Edmonds not looking like player prior to leaving. Am I wrong?
Gerry Dulac: Well, he's not. He was a starter then, he's not now.
Linebacker Lounge: What is the reason for l k of splash plays from 39.. Player or coaching? It’s actually kind of surprising from the start he had..
Gerry Dulac: It's hard to quantify why Minkah hasn't been able to come up with takeaways. But it's not from a lack of effort. The guy is all over the field.
Scott from NC: Thanks for your chats. It looked to me that the Cowboys had spread the field and had a lot of open receivers whereas the Steelers struggled to find open receivers. Comments as to what went wrong?
Gerry Dulac: The Steelers have always left the middle of the field open with the way they play defense
mrbig: Does Justin Fields resemble a typical backup qb? He had some success, but eventually exposed... and those fumbles during snaps, ugh.
Gerry Dulac: Yes. And that's why he is
Tim: When Wilson goes under center, will the safe play calling by Smith via Tomlin reduce? The offense is,well, stagnant and offensive.
Gerry Dulac: It should. After all, Wilson has been in the league 13 years
Tex: Last year after GP was publicly called out on social media after a poor game he bounced back and did his “silencing the noise” celebration after a long TD. Do you expect a bounce back game from him?
Gerry Dulac: Are you suggesting motivation from him?
Hillbilly: Hi Gerry. Thanks for the chat. Hypothetically how about Pickens and a third for Adams?
Gerry Dulac: That's a good hypothetical, but that's all it is
Linebacker Lounge: Is PQ playing up to the contract or way to early?
Gerry Dulac: Patrick Queen is fine
Guest: Good morning Gerry. Most knew Pickens was a problem when we drafted him. Those guys rarely behave better when they get paid. We've seen this with 5-6 WR recently. My question is why is Tomlin covering for him? Doesn't that just enable this behavior? Hasn't he learned from the past? I couldn't imagine The Emporer enabling players like that.
Gerry Dulac: And what do you think is going to happen if and when the Steelers give him a new contract? Look out...
Jim Bow Dean: Have you ever heard a more BS answer than what Tomlin said about reduced snaps for Pickens? That was politician level nonsense. If he benched him and doesn’t want to say so to protect the player just don’t answer the question. Why lie?
RAM: Well, here we are again Gerry. Another undisciplined receiver that has no consequence for his unprofessional actions. Obviously scouting reports on him revealed all these issues. Why does the Steelers organization continue to think coach T can change players like this when it has been proven he can’t/won’t take the necessary actions to do so?
Gerry Dulac: Oops, this answer is for Jim Bow...... Bingo!
Gerry Dulac: OK, and this is for Ram....Those red flags aren't just for a replay challenge!!
Colonel: If and when Russell Wilson plays this year, will the offensive game plan be any different than it is now or should we just expect more of the same?
Gerry Dulac: Think Mason Rudolph/Kenny Pickett
Timbo: Good morning Gerry, If you were to guess, what would it take for the Steelers to move on from Mike Tomlin? Obviously, he's not a great game manager or Xs and Os coach. Great motivator, yes, but that doesn't win (meaningful) games in the NFL. If they were to have back to back losing seasons, does he still finish out his contract?
Gerry Dulac: That will be up to him
Keisha Grey: Morning, Gerry. Do you think Davante Adams would be more likely to want to be traded to the Steelers with Fields as the starter or with Wilson as the Starter?
Gerry Dulac: I don't think he wants to be traded to the Steelers, at least, not as much as the Jets and/or Saints apparently.
Karlee Grey: Are there any Wr’s on the Steelers radar not named Adams or Hopkins before the trade deadline?
Gerry Dulac: Could be
Gerry Dulac: OK kids, we're outta time. Let's do it again next week. Thanx for the questions.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.