Welcome to Brian Batko’s Steelers mailbag. You can submit your questions to Brian directly @BrianBatko on X and bbatko@post-gazette.com.
Bill in SF: Hello Brian. Did it look to you like the Steelers were not ready to play at the start of the game? The first play deep pass may have been a surprise, but did they really not know that the Colts were going to run Taylor and Richardson at them? And the offense came out literally "stumbling, bumbling, fumbling"
Brian: From the top rope in San Francisco! But man, they really did stumble on the first play. Nice one, Bill. I’m not going to go into any super in-depth explanation about the Steelers and their defensive game plan — Chris Carter already did that in his weekly film study — or lack thereof. Let’s just boil it down to the Shane Steichen Effect.
Now, I’m not trying to make the Colts head coach/offensive play-caller sound like the second coming of Andy Reid, but here’s some food for thought on Steichen. The last five times the Steelers have faced an offensive coaching staff with Steichen on it, they’re 4-1 while allowing an average of 28.4 points per game. Here are those games:
• 2024 vs. Colts (HC/play-caller, QB Anthony Richardson/Joe Flacco) — 27-24 loss, 358 yards allowed, 6 yards per play, 225 passing, 133 rushing
• 2023 vs. Colts (HC/play-caller, QB Gardner Minshew) — 30-13 loss, 372 yards allowed, 6 yards per play, 202 passing, 170 rushing
Read More
• 2022 vs. Eagles (OC/play-caller, QB Jalen Hurts) — 35-13 loss, 401 yards allowed, 8 yards per play, 290 passing, 111 rushing
• 2019 vs. Chargers (QB coach, QB Philip Rivers) — 24-17 win, 348 yards allowed, 6 yards per play, 316 passing, 32 rushing
• 2018 vs. Chargers (QB coach, QB Philip Rivers) — 33-30 loss, 371 yards allowed, 6 yards per play, 286 passing, 85 rushing
Steichen has had more and more of a say in his team’s scheme at every stop, and you can see that it’s uncanny how well offenses he’s had a hand in have fared against the Steelers. That’s why I singled out the matchup of Steichen versus Mike Tomlin in last week’s scouting report. I’d say the Steelers lost that one.
Steve B: Why is it people are praising Fields, but when we are in a two minute drill or a situation where the clock is running down, it looks like no one is in charge on the field. He is looking around for help instead of taking charge. It happened in the Colts game twice and the second time may have cost us the game. It is not the first time this year. There was that “hurry up” fourth down play in the last game when a timeout should have been called when they were not ready. I’ve read that they go through the two minute drill at training camp all of the time. You can’t tell it. Maybe Wilson is not as good, we do not know. But in those situations you can bet he would take charge and know what to do. Fields did not jump on a moving train. There is no excuse for the lack of leadership in crucial situations
Brian: That’s an odd criticism to me, Steve. I’m just not sure what you’re seeing and I don’t agree. Do you just think it looks that way because he was running a no-huddle offense? A quarterback in a hurry-up tempo can, I suppose, look ... hurried.
But other than the botched snap — which was a major gaffe, of course — he actually looked quite calm and composed to me down the stretch of that game. Even after the fumble, he comes back, steps up in the pocket and gives George Pickens a chance on a 50-50 ball, which I’ll always call a good decision even if it wasn’t the best throw. Then there’s the completion to Najee Harris, who failed to get out of bounds. If you want to say Russell Wilson would’ve found an open receiver on that final play, the 4th-and-10, then OK. I can’t prove you wrong.
Jerry P: I wondering which coach is most responsible for the complex process of snapping the ball? Is the Offensive line coach the one who created the process that has a Guard randomly tap the Center as a signal to snap while the Center and the QB are focused on other matters??
Brian: It’s not random and it’s a fairly standard way to operate a silent count in football when dealing with loud road stadiums. Ramon Foster used to do it all the time for Maurkice Pouncey and Ben Roethlisberger. The operation generally works well, but as we saw Sunday, a breakdown at any phase of it can be catastrophic.
Ed H: Even with their early season success, might there be a divided Steelers locker room on whether it should be Justin Fields or Russell Wilson at QB? What might you be sensing?
Brian: There almost always are differing opinions in locker rooms, Ed. It’s a collective of 53 guys, more if you include practice squad, even more if you include coaches, and they’re never going to think with one brain.
In this case, my sense is that there’s plenty of support for Fields. Obviously, it’s tough to know for sure without being in there all the time and without being inside guys’ heads, but I think Wilson earned plenty of confidence and respect throughout the offseason and training camp. That only goes so far, though. Fields has done his part to help get victories. That matters more.
Jeff T: I have looked all day and haven’t seen anyone address the sequence when the Steelers went for it on their 40 yard line in the first half and didn’t get it. I was hoping I didn’t imagine it but it sure looked clear in the replay that on third down the ball should have been marked well over the yard line for a first down and was spotted well short. Tomlin didn’t challenge the play and the steelers ultimately gave up the ball on the next play putting them in a deep hole and keeping the D on the field too much. If you also saw this or heard anything it would be great to find out if I’m just ultra biased or this was another terrible job by the officials and by Tomlin’s use/non-use of challenge flags over the years. (not to mention the challenge he did use and then lost even though if he won it wouldn’t really have benefited the Steelers much).
Brian: Ah, Jeff, I wouldn't call you ultra biased here. It didn’t look like a great spot to me on that Harris run, but I don’t necessarily blame Tomlin for not challenging it. Those are hard reviews to win when you’re talking about an inch here or an inch there. I’m also generally a proponent of going for it on 4th-and-1 because if you can’t get an inch on offense — shotgun run, quarterback sneak, tush push, whatever you choose — you deserve your misery.
But I’m with you that Tomlin challenging that Josh Downs catch to move the chains a few plays later was strange even in the moment. If you’ll recall, Tomlin declined last year to disclose who his replay assistant is in the coaches’ booth, saying only: “Rest assured there's somebody that's on that job each and every week, home and away, all season — regular season, preseason, postseason.” Hopefully, that person wasn’t in the restroom at an inopportune time Sunday.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.