INDIANAPOLIS — Steelers insider Ray Fittipaldo grades each aspect of the Steelers’ 27-24 loss against the Colts.

Quarterback

Justin Fields had by far his best statistical game as a member of the Steelers — 312 passing yards and 55 rushing yards with two rushing touchdowns — but he made a couple of critical mistakes that cost the Steelers, too. He took a 22-yard sack and fumbled when the Steelers were in field goal range, and he took the blame for the botched snap on the final series that pretty much put a nail in the Steelers’ coffin. Fields also has to play better earlier in games. The Steelers have been downright awful in first quarters. They have scored 10 points total in the first period through the first four games. The Colts had 14 in the first quarter alone on Sunday. The slow starts have been a point of emphasis, but it continues week after week. Fields showed leadership by leading the team back in the second half, but cleaner football all around is needed going forward.

Grade: B

Running backs

It’s going to be overlooked, but Cordarrelle Patterson’s ankle injury played a big role in the Steelers losing this game. Najee Harris was ineffective with 19 yards on 13 carries — not that he had a lot of room to run — while Patterson had 43 yards on his six carries before he was injured. Give Harris credit for contributing in the passing game, though, with Jaylen Warren not playing. Harris had three catches for 54 yards, including a 32-yarder in the fourth quarter that set up a touchdown. Fields led the team with 54 rushing yards. It’s nice to have that in your starting quarterback, but the Steelers have to become much more efficient in their basic running-game concepts. It’s not nearly good enough right now.

Advertise with us

Grade: B-

Receivers

George Pickens had seven catches for 113 yards, but he had a critical fumble in the first half that thwarted a scoring drive. Pickens caught the ball at the 5-yard line, broke a tackle and then fumbled when the Steelers trailed 17-0. But it’s hard to fault Pickens when he was just trying to make a play. The issue with this offense is the obvious lack of another receiver that can make any impact on the game. Pickens was targeted 11 times. The other three receivers who dressed — Van Jefferson, Calvin Austin III and Scotty Miller — combined for three catches for 38 yards. Even more telling was the trio was targeted only four times. Either they can’t get open or the offensive coordinator has no confidence in them to make plays. Maybe Fields should start throwing the ball tight end Darnell Washington more. All he does is makes plays when he’s targeted.

Grade: C-

Offensive line

The injuries up front are beginning to be problematic. The Steelers have been playing without starting left guard Isaac Seumalo, and on Sunday, they had to play most of the game without right guard James Daniels. That left rookie Mason McCormick and second-year offensive lineman Spencer Anderson, who have four NFL starts between them, to play the entire game. Fields ended up getting sacked four times. Add in a false start penalty by McCormick and a personal foul penalty for a late hit by Anderson, and it was a very forgettable day for the line.

Grade: D

Advertise with us

Defensive line

Jonathan Taylor got injured in the second half, and the Colts still rushed for 133 yards and averaged 4.2 yards per carry. The defensive front was far too soft against the run in the first half when the Colts had 85 of those yards. The pass rush wasn’t effective, either. Cam Heyward had one of the team’s two sacks, but he failed to wrap up Joe Flacco on another that allowed the veteran quarterback to throw the ball away in the fourth quarter. It ended up being a critical play because Flacco converted on 3rd-and-10 on the next play. Larry Ogunjobi was active with six tackles and a half-sack, but he needed much more help from his teammates.

Grade: D

Linebackers

All-Pro outside linebacker T.J. Watt was almost held off the stat sheet. His final line: two assisted tackles. No solos and not even a pressure when the Colts dropped back to pass 30 times. Nick Herbig, who was making his first NFL start in place of the injured Alex Highsmith, was equally ineffective. He had one solo tackle and no pressures. DeMarvin Leal did nothing when he came on to spell Watt and Herbig. We keep hearing about Leal’s improvement, but when is it going to show up in a game? He’s like Velcro on offensive tackles. He just sticks to them. It might be time to get another true outside linebacker on the roster to help while Highsmith is out. The inside linebackers were active with Patrick Queen and Payton Wilson combining for 13 tackles, but Queen said afterward he did a poor job of communicating the defensive calls, which led to many of the Colts’ big plays.

Grade: F

Secondary

Joey Porter Jr. and the rest of the secondary couldn’t cover Michael Pittman Jr., who finished with six catches for 113 yards. Porter also dropped an interception in the end zone that could have wiped out an early Colts touchdown. The corners didn’t fare much better with Josh Downs either. He had eight catches for 82 yards. DeShon Elliott and Minkah Fitzpatrick led the team with 12 and nine tackles, respectively. That’s the only thing that saved the secondary from a failing grade.

Advertise with us

Grade: D

Special teams

Punter Corliss Waitman did well in his first two games with the Steelers after replacing Cameron Johnston, but his performance on Sunday was bad. He had three punts for a 34.4-yard average. Austin’s 30-yard punt return might have been bigger if Fields didn’t fumble a few plays later. Chris Boswell made another 50-yarder, but that’s old hat for him.

Grade: B-

Coaching

This game was lost in the first half when a series of strange decisions by Mike Tomlin helped get the Steelers into a 17-0 hole. He eschewed a 59-yard field goal attempt in a dome — one week after Boswell attempted a 62-yarder on grass at Acrisure — for a punt when it was 7-0. The Colts then marched 86 yards for a 14-0 lead after shredding the defense for a second consecutive drive to open the game. Then, on the next drive, facing 4th-and-inches from their own 39, offensive coordinator Arthur Smith had Fields line up in shotgun and attempt a quarterback draw that was stopped for no gain. Whether it’s Smith or Tomlin, these ultraconservative game plans to start games are getting old. The defenses know exactly what’s coming, and Smith had no answers, at least in the first halves of these games. Speaking of adjustments, the Steelers didn’t make many once Flacco came in for Anthony Richardson. Flacco is among the least mobile quarterbacks in the league, and the Steelers didn’t blitz enough to pressure him. Tomlin said that was a calculated decision, as he did not want to thin his coverage. That’s all well and good, but at least try to hurry him on occasion to throw off his timing or make him think. Tomlin made sure he got an F for this game when he left a timeout on the board when the Steelers faced 4th-and-11 with 37 seconds remaining on the clock.

Grade: F