Each week, the Post-Gazette will recap the most interesting Steelers player grades released by Pro Football Focus, the scouting website that evaluates players’ performance on every play of every game. For context, players are graded on a 0-100 scale. Here’s a look at how select players performed in the preseason.
Russell Wilson (70.0) — The Steelers’ likely starter at quarterback got limited reps in his two exhibition games — just 15 drop-backs in matchups with the Buffalo Bills and Detroit Lions. That’s roughly half of what he might see in one regular season games, so it’s difficult to extrapolate much from his numbers. His average depth of target of just 5.8 yards does stand out for those who remember the lack of explosiveness that doomed last year’s offense led by ousted coordinator Matt Canada and quarterback Kenny Pickett. Improvement will require better vision downfield, something we saw from backups Kyle Allen (8.9) and Justin Fields (8.4.) There’s still plenty of time for Wilson to show it, too, but the fact that we haven’t seen it from him heading into Week 1 against the Atlanta Falcons is at least a slight cause for concern.
Kyle Allen (72.6) and Justin Fields (61.5) — For as much talk as we’ve heard about Fields pushing Wilson for the starting job, it was actually the presumed third-stringer who had the best preseason of the bunch. With a similar number of reps, Allen posted four big-time throws — graded by PFF as among the best in the NFL in a given week — to Fields’ zero. His adjusted completion percentage, which factors out drops, was nearly seven percentage points better. Allen was at 76.9% while Fields was at 70.4%. And Allen’s 9.3 yards per attempt average was almost two more than Fields’ 7.4. About the only area where Fields had the edge as a thrower was in turnover-worthy plays. He had none, while Allen had two. Of course, Fields is one of the sport’s best athletes at the position and showed what he could do with his legs compared to Allen several times. Still, it’s noteworthy that Allen was significantly better as a pure passer with Fields’ NFL future hanging in the balance.
Dez Fitzpatrick (89.8) — He started the preseason off of most people’s radars as an option to make the team at receiver, but he certainly belongs there now. His grade was the best on the entire unit in the preseason. His yards per catch average was an explosive 26.0. And perhaps more importantly, he was making those plays happen down the field, with an average depth of target of 17 yards. That beat out not only competitors for a roster spot including Scotty Miller (10.2), Van Jefferson (8.2) and Quez Watkins (6.5.) It was much stronger than that of even presumed No. 1 receiver George Pickens at 9.2. Of course, the sample size was only five targets, so let’s not crown him the next Jerry Rice just yet. What we can say is that he was the guy most consistently getting open downfield across three exhibition games. That has to count for something.
Cory Trice Jr. (81.3) — Sample size was not a problem for this second-year corner who had his rookie season wiped out by injury. Only one corner — Zyon Gilbert — saw more than Trice’s 66 preseason snaps. And yet, opponents utterly failed to throw successfully against him. He was targeted just three times, and while he allowed three receptions, they went for a total of just 5 yards. That’s about as solid a showing as could have been asked, given the circumstances. Continue to keep an eye on him as he navigates his groin injury.
Payton Wilson (46.0) — The rookie linebacker was a camp darling out in Latrobe and earned high marks from many for leading the team in tackles in preseason Week 1 vs. Houston. His total preseason grade, however, ranked fifth from the bottom among Steelers defensive players. Clearly PFF scouts were not impressed with his pair of missed tackles — leading to an elevated missed tackle percentage of 18.2% — and his four receptions totaling 41 yards allowed on five targets in coverage. All this while generating zero pressures. He did register four stops — classified by PFF as plays that result in failure for the opposing offense. But you probably would have wanted to see more given his 70 defensive snaps frequently coming against fringe roster candidates on other teams. None of this is to say that he can’t prove himself to be a valuable part of the defense moving forward. Just that it might be a bumpier ride than some riding his hype train are expecting.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.