Word of caution to those fretting about the inefficient performance of the first-team offense in Arthur Smith’s debut as coordinator:
Don’t.
All that is necessary is to remember what happened last year.
The Steelers first-team offense, minus nine-time Pro Bowl quarterback Russell Wilson, failed to produce a point in three possessions in Friday night’s 20-12 loss to the Houston Texans at Acrisure Stadium.
Justin Fields, the hit of training camp, completed 5 of 6 passes for 67 yards but had two fumbled exchanges with new center Nate Herbig and was sacked twice. Running backs Najee Harris and Jaylen Warren, the engines of Smith’s physical style of offense, combined for 20 yards on six carries.
It was not exactly what the Steelers had hoped to see in their preseason opener. They will expect better when they play their second preseason game Aug. 17 against the Buffalo Bills. Coach Mike Tomlin said he anticipates Wilson making his debut against the Bills.
Read More
“I think, overall, we ran the ball well and moved the ball,” Fields said. “I think we were just shooting ourselves in the foot from the snaps. We just got to be on the same page.”
Not that it really matters, as they discovered last year.
Kenny Pickett and the first-team offense looked flawless and explosive in three preseason games in 2023, scoring touchdowns on all five possessions. They went up and down the field with ease, looking like Patrick Mahomes and the Kansas City Chiefs.
But once they got to the regular season, that all disappeared. The Steelers ranked 28th in the league in scoring (17.9 points per game) and touchdowns (29) and eventually fired offensive coordinator Matt Canada before the season was over.
Point is: Don’t put too much stock into what happens in the preseason. What happens in August has little bearing on what happens after Labor Day.
“You can kind of get a feel on what Arthur’s thinking, how he goes about the game, how he communicates with you on the sideline,” Fields said. “That was good, just being with him and kind of having a real in-game experience with him. I think the overall process went well.”
Still, there were fundamental lapses against the Texans, and that’s what bothered Tomlin — in particular, a pair of fumble exchanges between Fields and Herbig that disrupted each of their first two possessions.
“It’s a fundamental component of ball; we work it every day,” Tomlin said. “We start our practices with it. So it’s unacceptable.”
The first botched exchange came one play after Fields completed a 15-yard pass to George Pickens on the opening series and lost 4 yards. The second came on the first play of the ensuing series, though the gaffe actually resulted in a 4-yard gain.
“Things like that, they can kill the whole drive,” Fields said.
Herbig, starting his first game at center with the Steelers, accepted the blame.
“I have the full confidence in myself to snap the ball,” Herbig said. “I didn’t have a bad snap all training camp. It happened (tonight). That’s all that matters. Bad football by me.”
That was just part of the bad first impressions.
Wide receiver Quez Watkins, signed in free agency from the Philadelphia Eagles, had trouble with awareness and judgement as a punt returner. Even rookie right tackle Troy Fautanu, their No. 1 pick, was beaten twice for sacks before leaving with a knee injury. The extent of the injury was not determined.
But the offense did find some life with quarterback Kyle Allen, a seven-year NFL veteran who nearly brought them back from a 17-0 deficit. He completed 17 of 23 passes for 193 yards and produced two touchdowns, including a 6-yard pass to H-back Connor Heyward. He also completed a 38-yard pass to receiver Scotty Miller to set up Daijun Edwards’ 1-yard touchdown run.
“He looked like a guy who played some ball,” Tomlin said of Allen. “And that’s what you expect from veteran backups. Those guys get in the game late, and their experience usually carries units.”
Gerry Dulac: gdulac@post-gazette.com and @gerrydulac on X






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.