Fifty years after they drafted four players who ended up with busts in the Pro Football Hall of Fame, the Steelers hope to avoid another type of bust when they make their top pick in the NFL draft.
Short of crowning the Super Bowl champion, no league moment receives as much hype and produces the greatest level of anticipation as what will transpire Thursday night — the selection of each team’s No. 1 pick.
It is a night that culminates three months of boundless conjecture, unrealistic projections and unsubstantiated mock drafts. But, with the right pick, it can immediately change the fortunes of a franchise. Or it can cost someone their job with the wrong pick.
To be sure, the Steelers have had some missteps along the way with their No. 1 picks. Jarvis Jones in 2013, Artie Burns in 2016 and Devin Bush in 2019 might not be classified as draft busts, not like Jamain Stephens, who didn’t even make it to his third season after being their top pick in 1996. Nonetheless, they were failures, players whose performance was never commensurate with their first-round selection. Kenny Pickett, the top pick in 2022 who was traded after just two seasons, would be the most recent failure, though his departure had more to do with his off-field behavior as it did his on-field performance.
Detect a pattern here?
It is pure coincidence, but since Jones was the 17th overall pick in 2013, it appears the failed No. 1 picks occur every third year for the Steelers. Fortunately, perhaps, they are out of that cycle this year.
Read More
The Steelers have the 20th pick in the three-day draft and, rest assured, they have their targets. They have compiled a list of who they think are the best 20 players in the draft and will select from that grouping. Safe to say, the pick is likely to come from one of three different positions — center, right tackle or cornerback.
And the most logical is center, mainly because it is the only position on the team where there isn’t a starter. Despite their insistence they have options currently on their roster — guard Nate Herbig being the one commonly referenced — none are better than Mason Cole. And they released Cole.
That leaves a hole the size of Montana on their offensive line. It is one they need — and want — to fill.
It is entirely feasible the Steelers could draft a right tackle — either Troy Fautanu or Taliese Fuaga — because of their desire (urgency?) to move Broderick Jones to left tackle. But the Steelers do not NEED a tackle, not this year. They already have two starters, lest anyone forget Dan Moore, who has started every game at left tackle since being a fourth-round pick in 2021.
And it would not be far-fetched to think they would take a cornerback to pair with Joey Porter Jr., especially if Iowa’s Cooper DeJean is still available.
But they will not draft a quarterback in the first round, despite what some people wish. And, short of Marvin Harrison Jr. somehow dropping in the draft, they will not take a wide receiver on the first round because they already have a No. 1 receiver — George Pickens. But after trading Diontae Johnson and with a deep pool of receivers available, they will likely draft one before Friday is over.
It would be mere folly to suggest they are hoping to draft the next Maurkice Pouncey, who was their most recent center taken in the first round. Prior to Pouncey, an eight-time Pro Bowl center who was taken 17th overall in 2010, the Steelers had not drafted a center in the first round since they selected Duquesne’s Mike Basrak in 1937.
But they are looking for a player who can anchor the line, be the leader of the group and a frequent Pro Bowl performer for the next decade.
And they think they know just the guy.
Graham Barton spent the majority of his four-year career at Duke playing tackle, though he was a center as a freshman. There appears to be little question he will play center in the NFL. There are those in the Steelers organization who believe Barton (6-foot-5, 313 pounds) is a generational player, a moniker typically bestowed on players considered above everyone else at his position in his era. The Quenton Nelson of centers, if you will.
That is an extreme projection and perhaps a bit of hyperbole. But it nonetheless points to the regard the Steelers have for Barton.
Will he be available at No. 20?
Typically, centers are not high- or even mid-first round selections. Pouncey was the 18th overall pick. Two years ago, Tyler Linderbaum, another one of those “generational” centers, lasted until the 25th pick when he was selected by the Baltimore Ravens.
So let’s break it down.
At least four quarterbacks and possibly even five — Caleb Williams, Jayden Daniels, Drake Maye, J.J. McCarthy and Michael Penix Jr. —- are expected to go in the upper half of the first round. So will three wide receivers — Harrison, Malik Nabers and Rome Odunze. At least two edge rushers (Dallas Turner and either Jared Verse and Laiatu Latu), one tackle (Joe Alt), one tight end (Brock Bowers) and one or two cornerbacks (Quinyon Mitchell, DeJean or Terrion Arnold) should also go in the upper half.
That leaves no more than six spots before the Steelers pick, and we haven’t even mentioned the many tackles out there, including Fuaga, Fautanu, Penn State’s Olu Fashanu and Alabama’s JC Latham; or the likelihood that at least one other cornerback is selected.
Not only are those among the more highly coveted positions in the draft, but there will be a run on tackles and cornerbacks once the draft gets past the quarterbacks.
If the Steelers would take a tackle or cornerback on the first round, they are assuming a large risk of not finding a starting center at all in the second round, not with the 52nd overall pick. By then, there is a good chance Barton and the other two top centers in the draft — Oregon’s Jackson Powers-Johnson and West Virginia’s Zach Frazier — will be gone, as well.
If they don’t take a center in the first round, look for them to trade up in the second round.
But why run the risk when you have a chance with the 20th overall pick to address the one position that screams for a starter, especially if the player you covet is available?
And that player is Graham Barton.
Gerry Dulac: gdulac@post-gazette.com and @gerrydulac on X






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.