Welcome to Brian Batko’s Steelers mailbag. You can submit your questions for occasional offseason mailbags to Brian directly @BrianBatko on X and bbatko@post-gazette.com.
Carl in California: Bats, any more insight on whether Diontae Johnson will be traded? If the Steelers get a #2 or #3 pick, seems like a good deal.
Brian: Hey, Carl. So good to see you. I can only assume you’re asking this because of something I floated on last Friday’s North Shore Drive podcast that got picked up and run with by the various NFL news aggregators. That was my wondering aloud whether Diontae Johnson could be on the move this offseason, and at this time of year, websites are so hungry to keep the football rumor mill churning that such a thought becomes viral social media fodder.
Obviously, I wasn’t reporting anything. I was simply looking at the situation in totality and why it could be a logical move from all sides for someone entering the last year of his deal. First of all, with Johnson, we know there was friction at times last season. There was the incident in the locker room in Cleveland with Minkah Fitzpatrick. There was the lack of effort on the fumble in Cincinnati, which would’ve been a bigger story had they not pulled that one out. There was Mike Tomlin dancing around Johnson’s touchdown dance while getting pummeled at home by the 2-10 Cardinals before eventually admitting he had an opinion on it that he did not want to share publicly. And there was just bad body language that naturally coincided with the offensive struggles but still noticeable nonetheless.
You don’t need me to point out that Johnson is a helpful piece for any offense, given his ability to get open, make yards after the catch and produce the occasional highlight-worthy snag. That’s why the Steelers gave him a new three-year contract worth $39.5 million with $27 million guaranteed in 2021 on the day my daughter was born. If he’d have gifted me even a tenth of that, I would’ve happily named her Dionne, Tae, Aytine, really anything in his honor. But I digress.
Johnson now has a cap hit of nearly $16 million in 2024, coming off his two worst seasons statistically since his rookie year. But he was injured for part of 2023. He was being coached and schemed for by a soon-to-be-fired offensive coordinator. The quarterback play he received? Well, we’ve written enough about that. Perhaps a team that needs one more offensive asset to get over the hump would be interested, which would pave the way for George Pickens as the unquestioned No. 1 receiver and go-to guy in Pittsburgh. Again, I’m just speculating but not without reason and evidence based on what we’ve already observed. It’s no different than when we try to project cap casualties or free-agent targets.
Read More
Kathy G: What do you think of the Steelers players who are saying who they want at QB? Thanks.
Brian: Who’s saying what here? We can go back to Diontae Johnson for a moment and his comments in the locker room after the Bills game. Johnson was asked if Mason Rudolph’s performance down the stretch surprised him at all. I’m going to type Johnson’s words verbatim for reasons that will be clear later.
“I’ve been knowing how Mason plays since my rookie year, so it’s nothing I wasn’t expecting for him not to do, so I kind of had high hopes of him doing what he’s doing when he came in and became the starter. Like I said, hopefully, he get the job next year, do what he gotta do, but other than that, he did a great job to me, in my opinion.”
Just realized I have video of the now much-discussed Diontae Johnson answer on Mason Rudolph postgame in Buffalo. I didn’t even think much of it at the time because to me it seemed more like a matter-of-fact statement about *if* Rudolph is QB1 next year. pic.twitter.com/tVr9adB5cw
— Brian Batko (@BrianBatko) January 19, 2024
Johnson is soft-spoken in these settings, and we all know quotes can be taken out of context or look differently in print than how they sound. That last sentence is the one that has driven so much Steelers offseason quarterback hysteria, though it mostly went unnoticed postgame. You’ll lose your mind if you try to parse every word an athlete says — did he mean to say if he gets the job next year? — but as someone who was there and listening to it live, I didn’t think much of it other than a standard positive response about a teammate. Only Johnson knows if he meant it to be more of a tacit or outward admission.
Other than that, I’ve found every Steelers player since Rudolph’s first start to be buttoned up when questioned about the quarterback controversy, either declining to answer or speaking in generalities. Oh, George Pickens did put a “goat” emoji five times on Rudolph’s latest Instagram post. But I don’t really want to go there. Maybe he’s saying he wants Tom Brady at quarterback in 2024.
Steve in Iowa: The Steelers, in the past, have drafted some of their best inside linebackers from converted college 4-3 outside linebackers (Chad Brown, Lawrence Timmons, Ryan Shazier). James Farrior was also an outside linebacker with the Jets before he came to the Steelers. Why have the Steelers moved away from this successful trend, and do they plan on going back to it because drafting a college inside linebacker has not panned out in recent years?
Brian: Hi, Steve. Not that I pretend to be any sort of X’s and O’s guru, but I think what’s lost in your question is that in modern football, it’s become less about inside or middle or outside linebacker in most schemes, hence the term “off-ball linebacker” for describing the types of players who traditionally play at the second level, standing up behind down linemen.
Devin Bush was actually considered more of a weak-side linebacker prospect at Michigan, and if there was one consistent question about his NFL transition, it was his size as a traditional inside linebacker and getting off blocks in that role. Buddy Johnson and Mark Robinson were relatively new to inside linebacker. Nick Herbig had many draft analysts pegging him as too small for the edge and a candidate to bump inside, but I didn’t see that, and clearly, the Steelers don't either.
In this year’s class, one linebacker who fits more of the mold you highlight is Payton Wilson of NC State. He’s somewhat similar to Iowa’s Jack Campbell, whom the Steelers liked last year, in terms of size and production. Wilson (6-foot-4, 234 pounds) was technically an outside linebacker in a 3-3-5 defense for the Wolfpack, but he filled up the stat sheet with 138 tackles, six sacks and three interceptions. Plus, he has that kind of alpha mentality that was often associated with Campbell. Just for fun, Wilson’s older brother is Bryse Wilson, a former Pirates pitcher who started 21 games for them between 2021 and 2022.
Mike B: Brian, I watched the North Shore podcast with Ray and Chris Carter where they discussed draft misses. I think the biggest miss is when they took Claypool instead of Jalen Hurts. Hurts could have had a year with Ben (whether Ben accepted it or not). Hurts has the tools Coach Tomlin has praised; mobility, etc. Am I missing something?
Brian: Thanks for watching, Mike. Hindsight is always 20/20 when it comes to draft decisions, so I won’t sit here and act like I was pounding the table for Jalen Hurts in that one. In fact, I was pro-Chase Claypool, which made me right initially, then kind of very wrong.
Anyway, if you want to stay in that lane of could’ve-been-franchise-altering QB swings, the biggest miss has to be Terrell Edmunds four picks before Lamar Jackson in 2018. What’s interesting about the Hurts hypothetical is that Mike Tomlin’s respect for him is on record. Tomlin himself said Minkah Fitzpatrick put a bug in his ear about Hurts, specifically his intangibles (sound familiar?) that year. Hurts admitted he thought the Steelers might take him.
“Whether Ben accepted it or not” is probably a rather significant caveat there. We lived Roethlisberger’s reaction to the Rudolph choice. The narrative at that time was all about his recovery and comeback from the elbow injury. It would’ve been a bit of a powder keg, especially if Hurts had been waiting in the wings the following offseason when Roethlisberger was going back and forth with the Steelers. Speaking of which, for all the grief Kevin Colbert takes for draft misses late in his career, he was probably right about wanting Roethlisberger to retire after 2021, which could have set the stage for the Steelers to trade up and draft Justin ...
Sunner in Orlando: Regarding the rumors about Wilson and Fields, neither makes sense for the Steelers as Wilson will not come to be a backup to Kenny and Fields is not that much better than Kenny or Mason to justify what they will need to give up in draft capital. Do you agree? But the problem will be if Mason signs elsewhere, what do the Steelers do?
Brian: We are now fulfilling our hourly Russell Wilson/Justin Fields quota for Steelers content. The only new thought I have on this is I don't understand why some are so confused by the Wilson suggestion, be it from Chad Ochocinco or elsewhere.
Would it make for an awkward circumstance for Kenny Pickett? Absolutely. Should that matter? I don’t know. But is it an out-of-the-blue connection with no substance? Hold on a second ...
Wilson has done a lot of moving and shaking off the field in his 12 seasons in the NFL, and one person with whom he has a longstanding relationship is Thomas Tull, a Steelers minority owner. We may have never learned the name Acrisure here in Pittsburgh if it weren’t for Tull, who also has a stake in that company and is a founding partner of their Evolution Advisors venture. The other founding partners are Russell Wilson, his wife, Ciara, and NBA star Russell Westbrook. Does that mean the Steelers and their personnel decision makers want to do football business with Wilson? Not necessarily, but it is a tie to the organization.
Mon City Smitty: How cool would it be in 2026 the Steelers host the draft, get the No. 1 pick because Pickett just obliterated their team, and on that stage take Arch Manning #1 overall?
Brian: That would be litty, Mon City Smitty. Or maybe on draft night the Steelers will be celebrated as the reigning Super Bowl champions thanks to Kenny Pickett helping them defeat Justin Fields and the Atlanta Falcons following an AFC run through the Will Levis-led Titans, Justin Herbert’s Chargers and Joe Burrow’s AFC North-winning Bengals. (Patrick Mahomes retired after three-peating in 2025.)
Brian Batko: bbatko@post-gazette.com and Twitter @BrianBatko.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.