Gerry Dulac: OK kids, we're going to get started in just a few so get those questions ready....

Gerry Dulac: OK, let's get started...Go!!

Ryan: Based on the last game, I think many of us underestimated how important Dionte is to this offense. Whom else on the O might we be underrating?

Gerry Dulac: Nobody like that. DJ's importance is based on his ability to get open and make plays after the catch. They don't have another receiver who can separation like he does. And I think you saw on those middle crossing routes how it creates more room for George Pickens

Advertise with us

Gus: Good morning, Gerry, Thanks for the chats. Do you think that finances have played any role in keeping Matt Canada this year? I mean they would have had to pay the rest of his contract and then pay a new OC to take his place. Essentially paying for two OC's. Any thoughts on that possibility?

Gerry Dulac: Those are more than just thoughts, Gus.

Dan: Hey Gerry, thanks for the chats, I look forward to them every week. Do you think there’s any chance we trade for a quality corner before the deadline? Our starters sure look like liabilities back there

Gerry Dulac: I wouldn't rule it out, only because I've learned not to. I will tell it has been quiet on the trade front as far as the Steelers are concerned. But, as the deadline gets closer (and teams get more desperate), activity and discussion tend to increase dramatically.

Tom Kane: Hey Gerry, is there any reason to believe Omar Khan will be active at the deadline based on his recent history or are the Steelers content with this group? We need a CB lets be honest.

Advertise with us

Gerry Dulac: I wouldn't rule out the possibility Tom.

SMF: Hi Gerry: Thanks for the chats. Was Chris Boswell hurt last year? He is just booming his kickoffs this year—all to the back of the endzone with no run backs. He looks so much stronger this year, never looked better. He really is "Money."

Gerry Dulac: Yes he was, bothered by some injury that apparently is going him from time to time. But he is one of just six kickers in the league who hasn't missed a FG or PAT this year. Of course, now that I just jinxed him....

Jim_Bow_Dean: How many points per game do they need to average over the last 11 for Canada to return? Will they meet that number?

Gerry Dulac: 432

Advertise with us

Jim_Bow_Dean: Why isn’t the NFL smart enough to understand too many penalties makes for unwatchable football? Unless the penalty is obvious, and directly impacts the play, don’t call it.

Gerry Dulac: JBD, I've thought for a while. If a penalty doesn't directly affect the play, pickup the flag. Of course, that would require an interminable discussion as well, so, on second thought, just step it off and let's get on with it. But, because you asked, Mike Tomlin was indirectly saying that neutral zone infraction call against TJ Watt was chicken bleep, and he was right. I think the paint abnormality on the front of his facemask was over the line and they called it. Geeziz.

Ghollywoodg: Gerry. do you have an understanding about how timeouts work?… what’s the difference between just a regular “ time out” and a “30 second time out”?… and what exactly determines that… thought you might be able to shed a little light..thanx

Gerry Dulac: Most timeouts are 30 seconds except for TV advertising timeouts. If a team calls a timeout and the network doesn't want to go to a commercial, or doesn't need to, then the timeout is just 30 seconds.

mrbig: WHat is the rule with toe tapping? His heal came down on the line so his foot was out of bounds I thought-

Advertise with us

Gerry Dulac: The explanation on TV is that he tapped his toe in bounds, regardless what the rest of the foot did, just like when a receiver taps his toe inbounds before the rest of his foot drags out of bounds.

Lou: Hey Gerry. Do you think a CB or WR will be added via trade before the deadline? Also…Corey Trice—-think he and Porter will be starting CBs in 2024?

Gerry Dulac: No wide receiver, at least not one of note. I wouldn't rule out a CB. Not saying it's going to happen, but I have thought since the preseason that was one position that was an injury away from being a little dicey

Jay Daven: Gerry, what adjustments, if any, did the coaches make at the half against LA because they looked like a different team?

Gerry Dulac: Well, look, they are not going to tell us or anyone what adjustments they made and announce their "secrets," if you will. But I think one of them that was apparent was moving TJ Watt around, even lining him in coverage, and you saw how that worked out.

Advertise with us

SMF: Hi Gerry: Thanks again for the chats. According to all reports I read Kevin Dotson is playing lights out for the Rams, getting top of the league PFF scores, but at Right Guard. He had another great game against the Steelers last Sunday. I recall one reason he was let go was he was not versatile and only a LG. Was he misplayed at LG by the Steelers or just didn’t fit the Steelers scheme?

Gerry Dulac: His lack of versatility was that he didn't play tackle or center, not the other guard position. Also, I don't pay attention to those PFF grades because they were misguided too often. So, if they're giving Dotson high grades, well, good for him. But, hey, Dotson started 17 games last season, so it's not like he's a bum.

The Dude: From comments you have made previously, I have concluded you don’t think much of PFF grades. Could you explain your position on this and tell fans how we should be judging the performance of the players. Some positions are more difficult to grade than others, but isn’t it obvious that Pat Pete and Wallace are terrible at the corners and PFF has that right?

Gerry Dulac: Well, I just said that so your timing is perfect. But, hey, if the fans want a grading system, which they do, then there is nothing wrong with them reading PFF each week. I have seen too many times when their grading system does not accurately reflect a player's performance or impact in the game. Case in point, TJ Watt's grade against the Raiders. What a joke.

Yates: Hi Gerry- What to make about MT’s response to question about opening scripts during this week’s presser? Lots of BS in that answer. How about score a TD? Did you find that response a tad curious?

Advertise with us

Gerry Dulac: I find a lot of his answers to be curious. And what was that other word you used???

Accountability: The Steelers receivers showed lack of maturity and selfishness once again. This time it was in their unnecessary taunting penalties. Yesterday, I heard Tomlin discuss the reason as the tenor of the officials. Does this deflection and lack of accountability help with these issues? Our history of letting receivers get away with selfish actions has caused issues many times in the past. Will he ever learn how to handle these situations?

Gerry Dulac: Pay the man!

Rocky: Gerry, do you think Austin will be used much more this season? Seems like they are using him less and less as the season progresses. Thanks!!!

Gerry Dulac: I agree and I'm not sure why. I will try to find out why his snap counts and targets have dropped.

Advertise with us

Dylan H: Hello Gerry. Do you see a scenario other than injury in which Broderick Jones gets on the field? Are the Steelers intentionally trying to develop him slowly? Thank you kindly

Gerry Dulac: It is intentional to a degree, and I'll be honest, I thought we'd see more of him as a tackle eligible, especially with a shortage of TEs. And we really haven't.

KN Phoenix: Thank you as always for the chat . Do you see any reinforcements coming at the trade deadline? It seems that addition of a Pass catching tight end because of Friermuth being on IR and a Corner can really help this team . Thank you very much .

Gerry Dulac: Don't hold your breath on a tight end. That's not going to happen. But a top-tier corner would be a good addition.

Fundamentals: What is going on with our tackling? I noticed lots of missed tackles, attempts at shoulder tackles, and most disturbing many tackles with the top of the helmet and eyes looking straight down. Haven't these guys been tackling since they were kids? Our fundamentals have declined each decade and tackling with your head has become common over this past decade. Does our coaching even staff teach fundamentals? If so, a new teaching method is needed.

Advertise with us

Gerry Dulac: I hate to tell you, that's the entire NFL. Just watch. They all do it.

HOF Town Guy: Gerry, how long do we have to watch Levi Wallace get burned? WHY is he still a starter? Time for both JPJ and Jones to start! Leave it to Tomlin/Steelers to have basically two first round draft picks not starting at this point in the season. Also, I think it’s safe to say that Art Rooney II is NO Dan Rooney…..

Gerry Dulac: I think you will have to watch it less and less going forward.

Ghollywoodg: Just wondering…. with Ed B’s retirement…. Who got his vote for the Hall of Fame selections?…

Gerry Dulac: The guy you are chatting with!

Advertise with us

Guest: Johnson and Pickens are selfish or at least seem selfish imho. Unsportsmanlike penalties like that could cost us a win. Ask Vontaze Burfict. What behind the scenes do you think was said/done to these guys to try to get them to see the big picture? I do understand you want fire from your players but they must play under control.

Gerry Dulac: Agreed. That usually is not DJ's style and I was surprised when he did that. I was not, however, surprised when Pickens did that. And I'm continually surprised when coaches leave those players in the game after committing such stupid penalties instead of yanking them from the game and making them sit a while -- and, gee, who knows, maybe teach them a lesson not to do it again???? BTW, I just watched Burfict's idiocy (and PacMan's) again last night in some Twitter post about the 2016 playoff game.

KN Phoenix: Hello . Thank you as always for the chat . I saw a significant improvement in kenny Pickett last week against Rams . Perhaps improvement in OL play and DJ return has helped. Did you see significant improvement in Picket play ? I have always believed that with better protection , he can be a top 10 QB in the league. Thank you very much .

Gerry Dulac: I'm not going to assign number ranks to where Pickett stands in the league. But I think his improvement in most noticeable in the second half of games. However, if you watch him in the first half of games, you wouldn't think he was improving at all. In fact, you might think the opposite.

Justin: Hi Gerty - While I agree that Matt Canada's offense is not suited for the NFL, the issues are bigger. When KP calms his feet and stays in the pocket, delivers the ball to his playmakers and let's them make plays the outcomes change. Hence the 4th quarter success. He handles himself differently in the second half. What are your thoughts and can this be coached?

Advertise with us

Gerry Dulac: He is definitely a different (and better) QB in the second half of games -- dramatically. He has demonstrated that continually. Why? Who the heck knows. But I do think it has to do with getting more comfortable with and understanding what the opposing defense is doing. I think it takes young quarterbacks a little longer to process because, hey, they're young QBs.

marty: What would "Emperor Chas. & Cowher do about the taunting penalties from last Sunday?

Gerry Dulac: Get em out of the game!!

Tim: I just don’t get it, Gerry. Listening to the halftime show Sun, Phil Simms says Miles Garrett is the best defensive player in football. He always seems to come up small against the Steelers while TJ puts on a clinic. Just look at the comparables. Garrett isn’t even the best defensive player in his own division!

Gerry Dulac: Bingo!!

Advertise with us

Richard: What kind of trades could the Steelers make before trade deadline. If any.

Gerry Dulac: You'd have to consider a veteran player who has some measure of marketability, a player such as Markus Golden or Levi Wallace. Even Mason Rudolph if some team has injuries and is desperate for a QB. That's where you can make a trade and get some value. Teams always overpay and over-evaluate QBs.

Yates: Gerry- At this point what division of labor for the slot corner should the Steelers deploy to put in best position for defending (1) run heavy teams and (2) pass heavy teams?

Gerry Dulac: Patrick Peterson.

Out of Time: Tomlin stated yesterday that he didn't have the chance to talk to his players during the game to tell them not to taunt. 1. Why doesn't his players already know that? 2. What does Tomlin do that prevented him from having 5 seconds to talk to someone?? Typically he just looks like he is standing there calm watching the game. He doesn't have a play card. He doesn't have conversations with players on the bench. If he can't reign in players in game, what is his role?

Advertise with us

Gerry Dulac: I don't recall him saying he didn't have time to talk to his players about the penalties. My only recollection is him saying he didn't have time to get an answer from the officials about why DJ's penalty wasn't as dead-call penalty instead of off-setting.

Franco: Hello Gerry, thanks for the chats, who is Kenny Pickett, the quarterback in the 4th quarter or the one through the first 3 quarters. Is it the play calling or QB.

Gerry Dulac: It's the QB

TxSteeler: Two weeks ago in your quarter by quarter analysts you used the word “great” to describe Trubiski’s play last year. How can a QB who threw more INT than TD, including multiple crucial ones in the red zone in a one score loss to your biggest rival, be described as playing “great”?

Gerry Dulac: I never used the word great

Advertise with us

Jay Daven: Gerry, how is Cam Heyward progressing from his surgery and is this type of surgery routine in the NFL? He will make this defense even better!

Gerry Dulac: I don't know if it's routine or not. He looks like he is coming along nicely when he walks

Andrew from Johnstown: Good morning Gerry! How active do you see the Steelers being at the trade deadline? Maybe bring back Edmunds after that trade? Thanks!

Gerry Dulac: That's not a position where they need help.

Anthony: Your mere expression of an off the cuff opinion about Jon Gruden as an OC candidate was totally misrepresented and blown out of proportion. I am certain that you, as a legitimate legacy journalist, get quite frustrated with the click bait rumor monger pretenders that cannot even post an "article" with correct grammar. Does the Steelers organization empower these individuals by giving them access in press conferences? Or are they merely scavenging the work of you and your colleagues? How does it work these days...how do these guys gain enough notoriety to have a platform?

Advertise with us

Gerry Dulac: I'm not only going to pay this guy, I'm going to take him to dinner.

Ryan: Gerry when does Minkah get his first interception of The Year

Gerry Dulac: I'll ask him. But I think he gets two this week. As Bubby Brister once said, "Write it down."

Doug from Moon: How does a live ball PI offset a dead ball penalty on that last series.

Gerry Dulac: I'm still not sure. But the problem is, they didn't call it a dead-ball foul, they called it a continuous penalty, which is wrong according to NFL Rule Article 14, Section 1B

Dylan H: Morning Gerry

Do you see a path (barring injury) in which Broderick Jones sees the field?

Gerry Dulac: Sure. Just not now

Junior High: 17 Steelers sacks, plus 3 turnovers = 4-2? How else can you explain it

Gerry Dulac: And there you go!!

Jeff Lebowski: Is the offense we saw in the 4th quarter of the Rams game a sign of things to come or a flash in the pan?

Gerry Dulac: That's what we're going to find out. Let's see if they can do something resembling that in the first half. Which they haven't.

RAM: Hey Gerry! Can you tell me why Tomlin is so resistant to starting our number one draft pick? Jones looked real good when he started. Why is MT so stuck on Dan Moore? I know he had a good outing last week but c’mon man!

Gerry Dulac: I think because they think, right now, Dan More is a better option than Broderick Jones. I could understand if they had some swinging gate at left tackle, but Dan Moore is not that.

Sal: Hello Gerry! Happy Wednesday.

So, if the Offense shows progress week by week as they have shown the last two games . Do you think there is a chance of making playoffs and winning one playoff game?

Gerry Dulac: I'm not going to predict any playoff victories, not after what I've watched the last 3 times there were in the postseason. But I have thought since the beginning of the season they can be a playoff team.

Richard: I know it’s early in there careers. But we’re Harris and Picket the wrong players to take in the first round in 21 and 22. Could they have picked better options in round one (offensive line especially). Then picked up a RB and QB later in draft.

Gerry Dulac: I had absolutely no problem with Harris in 2021. That was the perfect choice for them. They needed a big-time RB and he was probably the best available. I thought they needed a big-time DL in 2022, and I thought that again this year. And if they fail to do it again in 2024, they deserve everything they get when they can't stop the run.

Guest: The Steelers have the worst roster in the division. Colbert's last 5 years were horrific. Why do you think he gets credit from the local media for doing a good job of drafting? He failed miserably the last few years.

Gerry Dulac: I'll ask him

mats: Could Dan Moore be traded? If so, what would be his draft value?

Gerry Dulac: No.

Mike: Do you believe Tomlin blamed the refs for the taunting penalties Sunday? Don’t the players know what is taunting and what isn’t?

Gerry Dulac: I don't think he was blaming the officials at all for those calls.

whats up: Do any of the reporters ask Tomlin why his defense rates so low in so many categories or are they afraid to ask? Tomlin's defense is terrible.

Gerry Dulac: I'll tell him. And I'll ask my colleagues

Eduardo: Hi Gerry, as always thanks for the chats, who would you consider the weak link of our oline?

Gerry Dulac: When they're playing well, none of them. When they're playing poorly, all of em.

Gerry Dulac: Andrew from Johnstown10:46Good morning Gerry! Did you see the Steelers looking into trying to trade for Terrell Edmunds after his recent deal? Thanks!

Gerry Dulac: No. Why?

Sal: I have seen there are a lot of tryouts of DB's for the last 5 week.Is that an indication of Team is looking for more DB help during the season. Do you see any impact on those Practice Squad DB recently hired

Gerry Dulac: No, it's an indication how they are always on the lookout for practice squad guys whom they feel could develop going forward. It is not done for any immediate help

RAM: Presley Harvin is quietly becoming the punter we hoped for when we drafted him? Your thoughts?

Gerry Dulac: Agree 100 percent

Ryan: Will we have a better idea what we have in Kenny next year with a new OC?

Gerry Dulac: I think you should have a good idea now.

Yo Yo: Pickett doesn't have the look of a potential exceptional QB in his second year. Looks intimidated most times.The 4th quarter luck will run out eventually. Trubiskys best year as an NFL QB was about the same as Bens 18th year. (comp%, Yards and TDs). It's time to play Rudolph. Nothing to lose and all to gain.

Gerry Dulac: I'm not sure about that "all to gain" stuff

ryan: Why are so many in the national media putting Garrett ahead of Watt? Watt leads in every statistical category and the steelers record with him vs without him proves his impact on the team.

Gerry Dulac: I agree. Stupid

Yo Yo: Mason still has the best rushing yard average as a Steeler compared to Pickett and Trubisky.

Gerry Dulac: I'll tell Mason his uncle is chatting with me.

Steelbro: Ok so ... 3 of the Steelers' 4 wins "shouldn't" have been wins. But lo and behold, they are wins. At what point is that a reflection of coaching and not dumb luck? (Winning games straight up is another question for another time.)

Gerry Dulac: They don't ask you how, just how many.

Mike—EE: Gerry, our offense was unwatchable during the first half.

Gerry Dulac: That's no different than the first half of any other game this season.

Gerry Dulac: SOMD10:51Lightning round? One word answers only?

Gerry Dulac: Yes. Here we go....

pistachio pete: do you believe harvin doing much better this year at pinning the opposite team within their ten and also hitting booming kicks is because he is healthier or because he has overcome whatever mental roadblock he had or just being more accustomed to the NFL speed and style of play?

Gerry Dulac: Both

IUP DAVE: Good morning Mr. Dulac. I love the Wednesday chats. Can you explain to me while we try to be cute with simple plays and we just don’t follow tried and true methods to complete the push tush. Why do we use our small tight end, have him come in motion to try and push our QB forward. Can’t we just line up our Washington and Jones behind Kenny and impose our will for this play. Stop being cute, just get the job done with the athletes best designed to complete the task. The Eagles have shown the way, let’s copy the play exactly as it should be done.

Gerry Dulac: Will?

Mike—EE: Gerry, the lack of tight end production is killing this offense in my opinion. With the injury to Pat, why don’t we promote someone from the practice squad?

Gerry Dulac: Empty.

steeler in nc: Where has Mark Robinson been, havn't noticed him on the field? Wasn't he an up and coming player?

Gerry Dulac: Coming

Ryan: Lots of negative comments by fans but are we not 15 and 4 since last year's bye week?

Gerry Dulac: 11-4

AL: We are ranked 28th in rushing defense? What is the issue in your opinion? Are our DT's just getting pushed around? Or our ILB's not getting off blocks? Minkah is making too many tackles in the box yet again.

Gerry Dulac: Sub-package

Gerry Dulac: Sunny South Carolins10:53Favorite course to play in South Carolina??

Gerry Dulac: Ocean

Robert in Yorktown Virginia: It's a long season. Weekend and week out even the elite teams suffer let downs. An ugly win is nonetheless still a w in the standings. Maybe the Steelers continue to slowly evolve and mature and get better. We punished will continue to just pick apart how it all unfolds week to week. What a fantastic past time!

Gerry Dulac: Confused

29342ss: Record of 9-8, first round blowout loss of 30+, Tomlin praise, rinse and repeat. Life as we know it?

Gerry Dulac: Yep

Guest: You see pitchers and QB's start their major league careers on fire, then opposing teams figure out their tendencies and they wash out. Why can Dionte still get open? Why haven't defenses figured out what he does and account for it? What does he do differently than other receivers?

Gerry Dulac: Get open.

Gerry Dulac: Oh wait, that's two words.

Gerry Dulac: Ok kids, that's all the time we have today. Gotta run. See y'all next week

Gerry Dulac: gdulac@post-gazette.com and Twitter @gerrydulac