Welcome to Brian Batko’s Steelers mailbag. You’re more than welcome to email him at bbatko@post-gazette.com, tweet him @BrianBatko or slide into his DMs to inquire about the Steelers, NFL or anything out of bounds.
Jud W: Hope things are going well. Do you think the Steelers are bringing back Mason in the case of another hostage situation by Trubisky (quietly behind the scenes) or perhaps in a public spat down the road?
Brian: Well, Jud, in the lag time between your email and this mailbag, Mitch Trubisky signed up for two additional years in Pittsburgh. But it’s still a fascinating scenario to take stock of, given the way 2023 played out for both of them.
Starting with Trubisky, it’s not hard to see why the Steelers want him around in this role. It’s difficult to thread that needle of a backup who’s both willing to be the sidekick but young and talented enough to succeed if he’s pressed into duty. For all we know, Trubisky is content at this point in his career to serve as Pickett’s backup. Even last year, when the script was flipped and it was Trubisky trying to hold off Pickett for the starting job, I got the sense that those two hit it off and get along well.
And, who knows, perhaps deep down Trubisky also believes the gap between Pickett and himself isn’t that large. Obviously, in an ideal world for the Steelers, Pickett will blow away the competition at every turn. But if you check your bias at the door and recognize that Pickett only has 12 starts under his belt at this level, being the man behind him — even a first-round pick — isn’t quite like sitting behind Patrick Mahomes, Joe Burrow or Josh Allen.
As for Rudolph, you can probably take a lot of the same logic that applies to Trubisky and trickle it down to his situation. Sure, he’d love to be vying for a starter’s job as he enters his age-28 season, but that wasn’t realistic. And if he has to be a third-stringer, he might as well do it somewhere he knows the offense and would have a decent chance to play well, certainly in the preseason if not in the regular season. I’m guessing it’s that simple for Rudolph, rather than a pipe dream that he’ll eclipse Trubisky in camp this year to be the No. 2 guy.
Read More
Now, for the Steelers and Omar Khan, they’ve arguably got the deepest quarterback depth chart in the NFL. From an experience standpoint, no other team has three quarterbacks who have started double-digit games in the NFL, as far as I can tell. From a talent standpoint, you’ve got a No. 2 overall pick backing up the 20th overall pick from a year ago, and a third-rounder behind them.
When it comes to sizing up the roster and evaluating positions of strength, Khan will view the quarterbacks in that way. He at least has the luxury and flexibility to take calls on Trubisky or Rudolph if another general manager is up against it at the most important position. Much like last year, the presence of both gives the Steelers peace of mind beyond Pickett, and it seems as if Trubisky and Rudolph get the same kind of stability for themselves, for better or worse.
Scott in Columbus: Of all the factors for a good 2023 season, the biggest has to be how much growth we see from Pickett, at the end of the day with the promising roster and schedule the QB will either be the limiting factor or what gets us into a playoff run… that said I feel like they kept the handcuffs on him last year, maybe wisely so, but have you heard anything that would let us believe our OC will actually let him play to his abilities this year?
Brian: We’ll find out more about that next in OTAs, Scott. Without knowing entirely who will and won’t attend the voluntary sessions in Pittsburgh, there should be enough offensive players undergoing the installation process with Matt Canada to pick their brains about the overall approach.
As for Pickett, I agree with you. He is the X-factor. Sometimes it’s overly simplistic to say that about a quarterback, but I thought Dan Orlovsky summed it up well on Twitter recently. He put the returning 2022 starters into three tiers for 2023: “QBs you win because of,” “QBs you’ll win a lot with” and “Big season of answering ?s ahead” — with Pickett in that last tier.
Now, Orlovsky wasn't one of the bigger Pickett backers entering his draft, even saying the Steelers should’ve taken a chance with Malik Willis instead. But Orlovsky was high on some of Pickett’s film during his rookie season, so take that all into account.
To me, a lot of Steelers fans already view Pickett in that “QBs you’ll win a lot with” category. Maybe that’s more wishful thinking than objective analysis. But I’m generally in the same bucket as Orlovsky on that front (though I may quibble with Tua Tagovailoa and especially Mac Jones being in the tier above Pickett).
Javier M: Hello Bats. Is it safe to say the jury is still out on Pickett and this year will be interesting to see what the Steelers really have in him? Just a hypothetical question,but if they dont make the playoffs and Pickett has bad year would they consider looking at QBs in next year draft?
Brian: Another one on Pickett, though with a twist. Yeah, Javier, I could shoot you down like Mike Tomlin and tell you I don’t do hypotheticals. But I’m not an NFL head coach, I’m a sports writer, so of course I do hypotheticals, especially in this mailbag
Naturally, while making or missing the playoffs is a binary outcome, “a bad year” is subjective for Pickett’s sophomore campaign. Let’s just say, for the sake of discussion, the Steelers go 9-8, miss the postseason and Pickett throws for 2,900 yards with 19 touchdowns and 12 picks. That might not be bad, but it’d be mediocre. And he’d likely have to be considerably worse than that for the Steelers to consider bringing in young competition for Pickett.
The bottom line is if Pickett struggles this season, it will be nearly impossible to separate that from the Canada factor. If the Steelers make any major move on offense in response to a disappointing year, it would have to be bringing in a new coordinator and play-caller to work with the player they invested a first-round pick in and have spoken so highly of since then.
Bill in SC: Do you see the Steelers waiting until the second half of the season before they try to lock up Alex Highsmith? He goes UFA in 2024. He will most likely demand a high salary so cap space may be an issue.
Brian: No, Bill, that’s not how the Steelers do business. If they’re going to sign Highsmith to an extension they’ll have to do so before the season opener. That has long been their personal philosophy and de-facto deadline.
What’s more curious is how Highsmith will approach this offseason as he enters the final year of his deal. Does he attend OTAs? If so, does he limit his own participation the way T.J. Watt, Minkah Fitzpatrick and Diontae Johnson did when they were eying a new deal? Would Highsmith also hold himself out of training camp if they don’t have an agreement by then?
There’s no doubt Highsmith is a worker and a team player. He’s one of the most beloved players in that locker room. But Watt and Fitzpatrick were All-Pro guys when they went through that process, so they set a precedent in that sense. Basically, do all the right things to show you’re invested in the team and working hard, but don’t sacrifice your leverage in any way.
The prediction here is that Highsmith does get a new contract and it’s more a matter of when, not if. And the Steelers showed a willingness to cut the check earlier to Fitzpatrick last June, rather than taking it into training camp, so it wouldn't be surprising to see a similar move for Highsmith.
Think you have better questions? Email bbatko@post-gazette.com or write him on Twitter @BrianBatko.







Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.