You’ve seen Gerry Dulac’s marks for the Steelers’ 2023 draft class. But what do experts from around the country think of the job that general manager Omar Khan and Co. did with this year’s prospects? Here’s a summary with explanations included.
Chad Reuter, NFL.com
Grade: A
Analysis: Another solid first two days for the Steelers, with the trade for Broderick Jones filling the left tackle spot that was a sore spot last season, Joey Porter Jr. picked as a playmaker outside (not just a legacy pick), Keeanu Benton adding strength and athleticism up front and Darnell Washington's massive frame giving him a chance to excel as a blocker and receiving threat. Using the early second-rounder gained in the Chase Claypool trade on Porter was a major win. ... Nick Herbig can play inside or outside for the Steelers, with his aggressive nature overcoming his slight build. Spencer Anderson has good size and decent athleticism and should land on the roster as a swing tackle.
Grade: A+
Read More
Analysis: The Steelers jump up three spots, giving up a fourth-round pick to make sure they land the offensive tackle they wanted. Jones impressed as a pass blocker in 2022, earning a 84.1 PFF pass-blocking grade and allowing just nine total pressures from 470 pass-blocking snaps. ... Pittsburgh takes PFF’s CB4 and 21st-ranked prospect to open up Day 2 of the 2023 NFL draft. Porter wins with his length. The former Nittany Lion’s 34-inch arms make it easy to disrupt his opponent at the catch point and line of scrimmage. Porter’s 40% forced incompletion rate in 2022 led all Power Five cornerbacks.
Grade: B+
Analysis: Pittsburgh head coach Mike Tomlin made just seven picks, but they add protection up front for quarterback Kenny Pickett with the addition of offensive tackle Broderick Jones. And defensively, the addition of Joey Porter Jr., the son of Pittsburgh's legendary pass rusher Joey Porter, should improve the team's secondary. Pittsburgh likes to use tight ends, and Georgia's Darnell Washington is physical playmaker who will be a tough matchup on game days in the red zone. Wisconsin defensive tackle Keeanu Benton has the athletic traits to develop into a productive interior pass rusher.
Pete Prisco, CBS
Grade: B+
Analysis: They traded up to land Broderick Jones in the first round, which will be an immediate help up front, and that was a must. Second-round corner Joey Porter Jr. was a nice pick as well, playing for the same team as his father. They did a solid job all the way around. Second-round tackle Keeanu Benton didn't play up to his traits, but he has the body.
Danny Kelly, Ringer
Grade: A+
Analysis: The Steelers tried a crazy strategy this year: Picking really good players every time they were on the clock. I loved this team’s haul in Omar Khan’s first draft as general manager, starting off with first-round tackle Broderick Jones and continuing through day three. Former Penn State cornerback Joey Porter Jr. was a steal (and a heartwarming story) with the first pick of day two, and I really like the pick of Wisconsin defensive tackle Keeanu Benton later that round. Each of those first three picks could be starters in Week 1. Georgia tight end Darnell Washington reportedly dropped in the draft because of concerns around the health of his knee, but if healthy, he projects as a perfect complement to Pat Freiermuth — and gives Pittsburgh more blocking power in the run game and on screen passes. Wisconsin linebacker Nick Herbig is an undersized but explosive pass rusher and Cory Trice is an excellent depth addition at corner.
Vinnie Iyer, Sporting News
Grade: A+
Analysis: The Steelers crushed the first draft with GM Omar Khan. They filled their two biggest needs, a pass protector for Kenny Pickett and a big cover man to help Patrick Peterson. Jones and Porter were both first-round talents. Washington is a great No. 2 as a blocker and the Wisconsin 1-2 punch of Benton and Herbig will provide Badger T.J. Watt with upfield support.
Mel Kiper Jr., ESPN
Grade: B+
Analysis: With three picks in the top 50, the Steelers entered the draft with a real chance to come away with multiple new rookie starters. They need help on both sides of the ball. And I'm a fan of what they did on the first two days of the draft. They traded a fourth-round pick to move up three spots in Round 1 to grab Broderick Jones (14), who will start at one of the tackle spots. He had an elite 2022 season.
Grade: A
Analysis: Excluding their final pick, the Steelers had six selections. All six of those picks scored a "B" grade or higher. This included their initial choice, Broderick Jones, whom Pittsburgh traded up for in the opening round. The Steelers had no choice but to do so, given that the Jets would have selected him at No. 15. Jones has a low floor, but he also possesses great upside to be a franchise left tackle. He could be essential to Kenny Pickett's development.
Ryan Gosling (not that one), Pro Football Network
Grade: A-
Analysis: It’s difficult to imagine the 2023 NFL draft going much better for the Pittsburgh Steelers. They landed an explosive offensive tackle who can benefit the ground game from the get-go while honing his craft as a pass protector. Pittsburgh bolstered the CB room with two impact players, including legacy pick Joey Porter Jr. Multiple times, the Steelers took advantage of falling talent, most notably with Georgia TE Darnell Washington.
Kristopher Knox, Bleacher Report
Grade: A
Analysis: The only negative here is that Pittsburgh didn't add the explosive slot receiver it lacks — though the trade for Allen Robinson II may help alleviate the issue. The Steelers nailed three of their first four picks and have a markedly better roster than they did last week.
Matt Verderame, Sports Illustraded
Grade: A
Analysis: The Steelers might have had the best draft of any team. Pittsburgh found a left tackle in Jones, who could prove to be the best of his loaded class. In the second round, general manager Omar Khan took Porter Jr., a legacy in the Steel City with a ton of ability. He should start as a rookie opposite Patrick Peterson. Later on, the Steelers took Washington, a hulking tight end at 6-7 who should provide second-year quarterback Kenny Pickett with a large red-zone target. Finally, Herbig was a productive linebacker at Wisconsin. Look for him to be good depth and a solid special teams contributor.
Nate Davis, USA Today
Grade: A
Analysis: Rookie GM Omar Khan looked every bit the seasoned exec in his maiden draft as shot-caller. He vaulted in front of the Jets on Thursday night — in a deal with New England no less — in order to take highly touted Broderick Jones, who should solve Pittsburgh's left tackle issue for years. Khan then ended the tumble of CB Joey Porter Jr., whose dad was a star linebacker in the Steel City, atop Round 2 — with a pick obtained last fall by trading WR Chase Claypool. Day 2 also brought DL Keeanu Benton and TE Darnell Washington, who's a glorified tackle — though one with great hands and speed. And getting OLB Nick Herbig in the fourth? Larceny. Much rides on the development of QB Kenny Pickett, but this team appears much improved.
Ryan Dunleavy, New York Post
Grade: A
Analysis: After getting protection for their young quarterback — always a good idea — the Steelers drafted the son of one their greats to start the second round. Porter is physical, but only had one college interception. The 6-foot-7 Washington’s drop to No. 93 is one of the great mysteries.
Rob Maaddi, Associated Press
Grade: A
Analysis: Moved up for OT Broderick Jones (14). Got first-round talent in CB Joey Porter Jr. and TE Darnell Washington in Day 2.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.