Ray Fittipaldo: Happy Valentine's Day and welcome to the chat. Let's get started.
MD: Joey Porter Jr seemed like a pretty good CB for Penn State, although I like Witherspoon and Ringo a good bit better. That said a) taking Pickett given the Pitt connection; b) overdrafting Conner Heyward; c) overpaying Derek Watt; d) retaining Central Catholic's Danny Smith after all of these years of poor performing special teams; e) hiring and retaining the OC that recruited Dino Tomlin; f) all the internal coaching promotions and g) then drafting Porter given PSU, his dad, his roots. At some point don't these "nepotism" moves seem more like how the Steelers were run in their first 40 years (0 playoff wins) than in the second 40 (33 playoff wins)?
Ray Fittipaldo: I think there is something to be said for knowing all of the small details on a player. Mike Tomlin noted this when the Steelers took Pickett last year. They were well-acquainted with him and felt very comfortable making the pick. The same can be said for Connor Heyward. They know the family and felt very comfortable making that pick. You say he was over-drafted, but he played pretty well, especially late in the season. Hey, the Steelers could have drafted Skyy Moore, Dino Tomlin's high school teammate, over George Pickens if they wanted to. But they took Pickens because they felt like he was the better prospect. I'm just saying they don't always pick the guy with ties to Pittsburgh or the Steelers.
Johnny U: Interesting MT chose Canada over Klemm. Another example of his poor judgement with asst coaches. I think if Dan Rooney was still around MT would have some explaining to do? How do you see it? Thank you.
Ray Fittipaldo: I think it's always easier to side with a coordinator because the coach's name is on the line. He made the hire. It's much easier to move on from a position coach if there is a clash in personalities.
Guest: Hey Ray. The Chiefs won in large part due to the offensive line holding off the Eagles defensive line. Creed Humphrey was a big factor. I wanted him in the first round in 2021, but we passed on him twice – for a RB and TE. Those positions are a dime a dozen. What was our future Hall of Fame coach who has never had a losing season and his brain trust thinking??
Read More
Ray Fittipaldo: The Chiefs offensive line did a great job against the Eagles though the field conditions certainly played a factor in the lack of a pass rush. The field was a slip and slide. The NFL should be embarrassed. For a multi-billion dollar league it's astonishing how things like this happen on such a consistent basis. But getting back to Humphrey, the Steelers aren't the only team that passed on him twice. Thirty other teams did too. But this has been and will continue to be a lightning rod of criticism for the Steelers.
Guest: Why are there so many saying Mahomes is possibly the greatest QB of all time? He’s 2-1 in the big game. Terry and Joe are 4-0. How is there even a comparison?
Ray Fittipaldo: Mahomes is a great player. There is no doubt about that. He showed me more in Super Bowl LVII than he did in the first Super Bowl win over the 49ers. He gutted his way through that game after aggravating his ankle injury in the first half. He's great because he has talent, but he also has all of the other qualities great quarterbacks have -- leadership, intangibles, etc. It's too early to say where he ranks. He might play another 15 years. There's plenty of time to let him state his case. And who knows? It might be better in 15 years.
Guest: The Chiefs clock management was perfection at the end of the game. Our coach fails at every opportunity to do that. Why is it so difficult for Mediocre Mike to do what Andy Reid did?
Ray Fittipaldo: McKinnon did a nice job getting to the ground. Not all RBs have that sense of the moment. And yes, it was good coaching, but the defensive holding penalty all but handed the Chiefs the game. Not saying it was a good call or bad call, but they got a first down with less than two minutes to go after the Eagles had used their timeouts. Pretty easy to steer that ship home.
62 Stack Monster: Hi Ray, Would the Steelers take Paris Johnson over Van Ness if available at number 1?
Ray Fittipaldo: That's a good question. Both have some nice upside. Would depend on who has the higher grade, and it's impossible to know at this moment how the Steelers view those two prospects. I like Skoronski and Broderick Jones more than Johnson, but he does have potential if he puts it all together. If it's me I'm leaning more toward Van Ness if I had the choice.
Terrible Towelhead: Steelers offense found success post-Claypool trade with '12' personnel, with 1 RB, 2 TE. Do you think they could target an athletic blocking TE that could really help Kenny stress the seams with Freiermuth?
Ray Fittipaldo: They could. This is a very good draft for tight ends, but I would argue they have many other needs to address before No. 2 tight end.
CG: Hi Ray, I want offensive players with 2 of the first 3 picks. The Steelers need the offensive talent to overcome schemes and play calling? If Addison at #17, could he be Pickett's Jamar Chase?
Ray Fittipaldo: I like Addison, but let's not compare him to Jamarr Chase, who was the No. 5 overall pick in the draft. Addison might be a first-round pick, but he doesn't have Chase-like qualities. And the Steelers have two good receivers on their roster already.
Nate from Fort Wayne: Hey Ray, Was the Eagles Defensive line not as good as we thought or was the Chiefs O-Line and play calling way better than we thought?
Also wanna praise the Chiefs, they traded one of their top 3 players(Tyreek Hill) , get a bunch of draft picks, trade 2 draft picks for Toney who helped them greatly in the Super Bowl and still have 9 picks coming up in the draft and probably one or two comp picks to add on.
Ray Fittipaldo: I'm with you on winning without Hill. I wasn't sure how that would play out. Kelce is their No. 1 receiver even though he's a TE. JuJu was their No. 2. He's an unrestricted free agent, but as you point out they are positioned well to replace him in the draft if they so choose. By the way, JuJu played very well in the second half. He'll land on his feet if the Chiefs don't re-sign him.
Jim B.: In your opinion, what are the odds of a Devin Bush return?
Ray Fittipaldo: 1%
Alan: Hi Ray. Do you see any OTs possibly sliding to #17 that the Steelers might be interested in?
Ray Fittipaldo: It depends on the needs of teams in front of them. I will say this. Skoronski and Jones and Johnson are good prospects, but none of them are slam dunks to go in the top 10. So yes there is a chance one or maybe two of them could fall to 17. The question then becomes how do the Steelers feel about them if they do fall?
Amy: Would it be all that bad if the team went 2 OL and 2 DL in first 3 rounds?
Ray Fittipaldo: No, not at all. I'm not sure that happens because I think they need a corner in there somewhere, but your needs are spot on.
Guest: What would you think of drafting Michael Mayer and playing more 12 personnel in 2023? His blocking should be a big asset to the run game and he and Freiermuth would be tough for teams to cover in passing game.
Ray Fittipaldo: Good prospect, but again you already have a starting tight end. And a good one at that. That would be the old Patriots model with Gronkowski and Gonzalez. I suppose it's possible, but the game has changed since then. You need a variety of receiving targets.
Mark: in the context of the Chiefs 2nd half adjustments, from your experience playing college ball, what are these “adjustments” at a player’s level? I know play calling (both sides of ball) and who is on the field are major adjustments, but what specific adjustments might a given indiv player make when coached in-game on the sidelines or at halftime?
Ray Fittipaldo: It's not so much in the play calls. There are only so many plays in a game plan. It's more in the mentality of the play caller. I thought the Chiefs came out in the second half and established Pacheco, which was a really good move. Even though they were down 10 they didn't want to become one-dimensional. That was so important. Other coaches might have panicked there and came out passing. I mean, they still passed, but if you look at the stats it was a well-balanced offensive effort by the Chiefs.
Joe Momma: Which rookie do you expect to make the biggest leap in year two? Also, do you expect any players to decline in performance next year?
Ray Fittipaldo: I would imagine Pickett and Pickens could make big leaps. If the Steelers are going to get back to the playoffs Pickett has to become m ore dangerous as a passer. He only had seven touchdown passes. Obviously, that doesn't cut it in today's NFL. That's two weeks work for Patrick Mahomes.
Jay: Hello Ray. In the event the top 3 OT and CBs are gone, can you see a surprise pick of MLB or hybrid S at 17?
Ray Fittipaldo: I don't see an ILB there, but Brian Branch would be interesting.
Jim: If one of the top linebackers are there and one of the CB's which do you think is more of a need? I say LB, as long as we resign Sutton.
Ray Fittipaldo: I still think it's CB even if Sutton re-signs.
jeff: Thanks for the chats Ray. Do you think they will ban the push QB sneak play?
Ray Fittipaldo: Great question and it's something I'm sure the competition committee will look at. The Eagles perfected it, but other teams including the Steelers took advantage of the loose interpretation of the rule by officials. Kind makes you shake your head when the Steelers simply refused to run the sneak for so many years with Ben Roethlisberger. They sure could have used it in the 2016 AFC title game when they were near the goal line at the end of the first half and still very much in the game. And they could have used it the next year when they lost to the Jaguars and had a number of fourth-down calls fail, including a toss to Le-Veon Bell on fourth-and-short. Oh well.
NY Lenny: Good afternoon Ray. I’m still puzzled at the reason that Mr. Rooney have to keep Canada. His offense hasn’t worked since he has been there. The reason for not getting Pickett another OC in his second year doesn’t make sense. There are alot of I offensive minded coaches out there that can replace Canada. Sign a new OC and let them grow together for the next three years. If Canada doesn’t work out next year, he will be gone and the Pickett will have to learn all over again. Your thoughts?
Ray Fittipaldo: You make great points, which is why if the offense doesn't improve this year all the blame should shift away from Canada to Tomlin and Art Rooney. They had an opportunity to make a move and decided to stick with Canada.
Ed in Carrick: This has clearly become a league where offense is of paramount importance. The Steelers are loaded at skill positions and the Offensive Line got better as the year progressed. Why can’t they hit the 20 ppg mark? That is a low bar and yet they couldn’t even hit that.
Ray Fittipaldo: For one, the head coach has to get comfortable enough with his young offensive talent and let them play a little more. It's a fine line though because turnovers would put the defense in some bad positions they might not be able to overcome. Secondly, the coordinator has to do a much better job in the red zone next season. For whatever reason, Freiermuth disappeared from the red zone attack last season after flourishing there with Roethlisberger as the QB.
Yates: Hi Ray - will the push from behind QB beak get outlawed? Would that also lead to outlawing linemen pushing running backs as well?
Ray Fittipaldo: The only thing that seems to be illegal now is pulling players forward. Everything else, including pushing from behind is legal. At least it's been interpreted that way by the officials. Honestly, I think it adds some layers of strategy to the game. I'm not totally against the idea of teams being able to utilize the play. It just puts more emphasis on winning first and second down.
Jim: I think we need to get an Olineman with one of our first 4 picks, should we grab one at 17 if a good one is there?
Ray Fittipaldo: If they have a high grade on one, then sure. But they also need DL and CBs. Get the best player available at one of those three positions.
Alan in Hoover, Alabama: Sheldon White, Weidl, bringing in David Morehouse. The Minkah and Bush trades. Stretching the way that they structure contracts for guys like TJ. Signing the O-Lineman and Jack and others this off-season. Adding Flores, etc. Seems to me that outside of having coaches complete their contracts, the organization has been evolving.
Ray Fittipaldo: I would say you are right and you'll continue to see some evolving as Khan gets his tenure started. It's only natural when you have new people in charge at important positions.
Carl in Carrick: Hey Ray. Do you anticipate any rule changes for next season? I would love to see a team penalized when the defense runs into the end zone following a turnover. Your thoughts please.
Ray Fittipaldo: Ha ha. I don't see that being a rule change but would certainly welcome that fad coming to an end. I think the Steelers started that fad.
Paul from Beaver Falls: What’s Trubisky’s trade value?
Ray Fittipaldo: Late rounder, if that.
Al Derogatis: They used the QB sneak often in ‘22 and nearly all were successful. Does this solve the mystery of why they did not use it prior to ‘22? Which is the 6-5 250 lb QB didn’t want to do it?
Ray Fittipaldo: But as you point out he did it in 2021. I don't want to go back and assess who did or didn't want to do it. I know the Steelers wanted to protect him and not expose him to hits. The game has changed. Teams seem less concerned about putting their QBs in harm's way in almost any situation.
obxandy: If Steelers traded up in draft, using #1 @ 17 and #2 @ 49 how far up could they go -- to 10th pick? Thanks.
Ray Fittipaldo: You can look at the trade value chart. There are different ones that are out there, but here is one of them: https://overthecap.com/draft-trade-value-chart. They're all in the same ball park.
Chuck from Michigan: Ray, loved the Big Ten selections (Dawand Jones (OT), Lukas Van Ness (DL), Olu Oluwatimi (C)) in your mock draft. Which Big Ten players are on your radar for ILB, CB, NT that the Steelers can build with? Thank you very much!
Ray Fittipaldo: Joey Porter, Jr. of course. Keanu Benton is a DL from Wisconsin. He'd be a mid-rounder. Jack Campbell is a mid-round ILB prospect.
Ray Fittipaldo: Campbell played at Iowa.
Chapstick Wes: is it’s given that the Steelers draft an offensive lineman in the first two rounds?
Ray Fittipaldo: Not a given, but I'd be surprised if they didn't take one with their top three picks.
Mike P.: I've seen a handful of mock drafts (I know, I know) with the Steelers taking a OLB at 17. How good would an OLB need to be for the team to pass up filling any of the bigger holes and taking one? Also, I saw one mock with the team taking a RB in the 3rd - what?!?!!
Ray Fittipaldo: Really good and it would signal they didn't think they could re-sign Highsmith.
Booie: If Canada’s offense gets off to a slow start next year, do you think the Steelers break their mode and actually can him during the season?
Ray Fittipaldo: They didn't do that last year. To me, if they did that they'd be admitting a big mistake. So we'll see, but they'd have to be pretty bad for that to happen.
STEEL72: All roads go through KC. If our draft goes perfectly-- in whatever shape that takes-- are the Steelers with current coaching/management philosophies anywhere near competitive... or are we looking at the next Brady/Patriots on our back?
Ray Fittipaldo: The Steelers can't worry about KC. They first have to figure how to be better than Cincy and Baltimore and win the AFC North again before they worry about the Chiefs.
Ryan S.: Thanks for the chats, Ray! Curious as to how you see the Lamar Jackson situation playing out? As a Steelers fan, I want to see them sign him to the Watson contract. He's not elite, and I hope to see KP8 passing him by the end of next year as the better QB.
Ray Fittipaldo: I see it as good news either way for the Steelers. Either the Ravens are starting over with a new QB or they're building a roster with a QB who eats up a lot of the cap. On a side note, the Chiefs have a bargain with Mahomes. That's a Brady-Patriots type situation with the hometown discount he's playing on.
Ed in Carrick: ILB would seem to be a bigger need than CB but lots of mocks are predicting CB at 17. The draft seems deeper at CB so why not go with ILB? Is it because that position is just so hard to predict?
Ray Fittipaldo: I think that's part of it. Look what happened when they traded up for Devin Bush. There are no guarantees especially with that position. It takes a special ;player to be able to play the run and run and cover tight ends, receivers and running backs.
Sunner in Orlando from Lebo: Does Spillane sign a new contract with the Steelers or is he gone with Bush?
Ray Fittipaldo: I think it makes sense to bring him back if the price is right.
Steel tree: Ray - lots of folks like to point out Cowher only had Big Ben for three years while Tomlin had him for all but last season, to validate Cowher doing a better overall coaching job during his career. The flip side of that argument though is Tomlin had to deal with the salary cap ramifications of having a future HOF QB to deal with while trying to construe roster while in salary cap hell. (Sorry about the run on sentences). My point is both coaches dealt well with the situations they respectively found themselves in with or without a franchise QB.
Ray Fittipaldo: I agree with you on all points. Hey, the Steelers hired two good coaches. Let's leave it at that.
Weegie Thompson: I think there are some intriguing tight ends in the first 3 rounds. Could the Steekers take one ?
Ray Fittipaldo: Sure but I don't see it happening early.
Tim B.: Do you see another team signing Bush or will he be forced to retire?
Ray Fittipaldo: I'm sure some team will sign him, but he won't get a lot of money.
D-Ru: How many QB’s are game day active next season? 2 or 3?
Ray Fittipaldo: Teams decide that. There is no rule against dressing three, but most coaches opt for two because they value special teams over the fluke of both QBs going down in the same game.
D-Ru: If the top Center is there at 17 or 32 would you draft him?
Ray Fittipaldo: If he's the highest graded player on the board then sure. The nice thing is Mason Cole can play guard.
Naples Snowbird: Do you see any way K Greene is on the 2023 roster, even the PS? If know he was a third round pick but it didn’t work out so I’d cut bait now. There must be bigger and better UDFAs available than to save a slot for his failure.
Ray Fittipaldo: Green would have to show great improvement to be on the 2023 roster. He regressed in his second season. He's the one guy who didn't seem to adapt to the changes Pat Meyer made with technique.
AZBill: Do you and the other PG chat hosts ever discuss posts you get but couldn't get to? For example...I got this one post, really liked it but didn't have time to answer it.
Ray Fittipaldo: Yes, all the time. We also poke fun at some questions we don't answer!
D-Ru: Is Roethisberger still on the payroll and count against the salary cap?
Ray Fittipaldo: No.
Guest: Under Matt Canada, the Steeler's offense averaged 20.2 ppg in '21 and 18.1 ppg last season. Realistically, where do you see that average needing to be to justify keeping MC around beyond next season?
Ray Fittipaldo: 23 or 24 ppg. They need to be pushing up into the top tier offenses next season. The pieces are in place especially if they upgrade the offensive line.
Joe: At CB, what do you do with Jackson and Witherspoon? Anything left to salvage if the FA corner market gets expensive?
Ray Fittipaldo: I'm not very hopeful on either front, but they might keep one just so they have some offseason depth.
BD: Thoughts on Dobbs returning if Mitch doesn't want to back up?
Ray Fittipaldo: He'd be fine as a No. 3 QB.
Mean joe: equal rating at #17 - offensive tackle, guard or defensive end. Which would You select?
Ray Fittipaldo: Hmmm. Tackle I guess, but it's close.
Joe Mayo: Suppose we happen to lose both Trubiski & Rudolph for next season. Now what?
Ray Fittipaldo: Then they'd bring in two new QBs to back up Pickett. Jacoby Brissett would be a hot name if that happened.
D-Ru: After watching the Super Bowl do you think the Steelers can win it ALL next season? I think yes… this offseason is make or break. And I believe in this organization. See ya in Las Vegas!
Ray Fittipaldo: Save a seat for me at the Bellagio!
Ray Fittipaldo: Ok that's all the time I have this week. Let's do it again next week.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.