The last couple of years, it’s been very easy to pass out honors among the Steelers. T.J. Watt led the NFL in sacks in back-to-back seasons. Chase Claypool was a revelation and Najee Harris a sensation as rookies in 2020 and 2021, respectively.

But 2022 was a wide-open season with plenty of contributors. Not enough to compose a playoff team but enough to go 9-8 and finish 7-2 after the off week. We now leave this preamble to acknowledge that it’s awards season, and as such, here are one man’s opinions as to whom the honors should go at the end-of-the-year banquet for both the Steelers and the NFL at large.

First, our Steelers selections:

Team MVP: Cam Heyward. Minkah Fitzpatrick was the players’ choice and a fine one given that he tied for the league lead with six interceptions, but Heyward was a consistent force week in and week out, in good times and bad. If you take him off this defense, what becomes of it? Sure, you could make that same case for T.J. Watt, but Heyward played in all 17 games for the second year in a row as he nears his mid-30s.

Advertise with us

Offensive Player of the Year: Pat Freiermuth. A late push was made by Najee Harris and his 1,000-yard season, but Freiermuth didn’t start slow. He helped keep the offense afloat more often than not. Freiermuth could’ve had an even bigger Year 2 if not for a couple injuries and an offense that didn’t throw the ball effectively in the red zone, where he does his best work.

Defensive Player of the Year: Minkah Fitzpatrick. If part of Heyward’s MVP nod is due to his leadership and force-of-nature effort, let’s split the difference and call Fitzpatrick the most outstanding player on the defensive side of the ball this season. Just spreading the wealth.

Special Teamer of the Year: Miles Boykin. Too inconsistent for Chris Boswell and Pressley Harvin III. Christian Kuntz did his job as the long snapper, but Boykin was a force as a coverage player, racking up a team-high nine solo tackles on special teams.

Breakout Player of the Year: Alex Highsmith. With 14½ sacks and a league-best five forced fumbles, there’s no other choice here. He probably should’ve made the Pro Bowl. Keep it moving.

Rookie of the Year: George Pickens. The local chapter of the Pro Football Writers of America voted for Kenny Pickett, but Pickens made an impact immediately as a Week 1 starter. He didn’t start producing until that wild Week 3 catch in Cleveland. From there, Pickens looked like the team’s most talented wideout, even if he disappeared from the offense at times.

Advertise with us

Comeback Player of the Year: T.J. Watt. Now, this doesn’t entirely fit the conventional definition for this award, but Watt was lost for an extended period even before the end of Week 1. Plus, there are no other strong candidates. Tyson Alualu’s return from a significant ankle injury in 2021 is admirable, but he wasn’t the same player.

Surprise Player of the Year: Jaylen Warren. Yes, he was a camp darling and generated some buzz for himself in Latrobe. But who would have foreseen him outplaying Najee Harris at times and being the best backup running back the Steelers have had in recent memory? Warren did it as a traditional between-the-tackles rusher, as a pass catcher and as a blocker, which wasn’t necessarily his reputation as an undrafted free agent out of Oklahoma State. Runner-up: Connor Heyward.

Biggest Disappointment: Ahkello Witherspoon. Perhaps you could argue for Mitch Trubisky or Diontae Johnson — or Chase Claypool — but Witherspoon just completely flopped with a chance to be a starting cornerback from Day 1. A nagging hamstring injury didn’t do him any favors, either. He’s under contract for another season, so he might get an opportunity to bounce back. Runner-up: Claypool.

Most Underrated: Terrell Edmunds. Just a steady, durable, reliable starter at strong safety for the third year in a row. He’ll never outplay the expectations of being a first-round pick, but Edmunds made the Steelers look smart for bringing him back on a one-year deal just before the draft last year. Unless he gets a more lucrative offer elsewhere, this feels like a situation in which he’s more valuable to the Steelers than other teams and they’re more comfortable with him now than when they declined his fifth-year option. Runner-up: Fellow safety Damontae Kazee.

Offensive Assistant Coach of the Year: Pat Meyer. It’s somewhat of an obvious pick. He got a lot out of his offensive line in his first season and had time to develop a group that stayed healthy at an uncanny rate. Meyer has more work to do with the likes of Dan Moore Jr. and Kevin Dotson — not to mention a draft pick or two, most likely — but it looks like Tomlin replaced Adrian Klemm with a good hire. Runner-up: QB coach Mike Sullivan for his work with Pickett.

Advertise with us

Defensive Assistant Coach of the Year: Grady Brown. The relatively anonymous secondary coach, Brown had more responsibility with Teryl Austin being promoted to defensive coordinator. He also had a rash of injuries to deal with at various points, from cornerback to safety. The Steelers tied for the league lead with 20 interceptions, and all but two of those came from defensive backs, who benefitted from his drill work and coaching.

Best Win: At Ravens. Sunday night, hostile environment, battle of physicality against a team that pushed the Steelers around just three weeks prior. The defense did its job in the second half and Pickett led another game-winning touchdown drive, capped by the on-the-run dime to Harris. Runner-up: Tampa Bay with a depleted secondary.

Worst Loss: Jets. Letting Zach Wilson (you’ll see his name again later) pick you apart at home for his only fourth-quarter comeback of the season was brutal. Runner-up: The 38-3 loss in Buffalo, most lopsided under Mike Tomlin.

Best Play: Pickett to Harris for the win in Baltimore. According to NFL Next Gen Stats, Pickett was running at a speed of 13.1 mph, his first career touchdown pass “on the run,” per that advanced metric (8-plus mph). Runner-up: Minkah Fitzpatrick’s blocked extra point in the season opener.

Worst Play: Gunner Olszewski’s muffed punt against the Patriots. Runner-up: Josh Allen 98 yards to Gabe Davis on the third snap in Buffalo.

Advertise with us

Best Catch: George Pickens in Cleveland. Runner-up: T.J. Watt’s interception in Cincinnati.

Best New Tomlin-ism: “Man, I’m [expletive] working,” Dec. 4, 2022, in Atlanta.

Now, for our leaguewide honors …

MVP: Chiefs QB Patrick Mahomes

Offensive Player of the Year: Vikings WR Justin Jefferson

Advertise with us

Defensive Player of the Year: Cowboys LB Micah Parsons

Breakout Player of the Year: Eagles QB Jalen Hurts

Rookie of the Year: Jets CB Sauce Gardner

Comeback Player of the Year: 49ers RB Christian McCaffrey

Surprise Player of the Year: Seahawks QB Geno Smith

Advertise with us

Biggest Disappointment: Jets QB Zach Wilson

Most Underrated: Steelers DL Cam Heyward

Offensive Assistant Coach of the Year: Lions OC Ben Johnson

Defensive Assistant Coach of the Year: 49ers DC DeMeco Ryans

Brian Batko: bbatko@post-gazette.com and Twitter @BrianBatko.