Gerry Dulac: OK kids, we're going to start the new year off with the best chat ever so get your questions ready. The ball will drop around 945 am
Gerry Dulac: Ok kids, let's get started...Go!!
Jim in Az.: I advocated that PIckett should have started at the beginning of the year based off of exhibition game performances, all 3 QB's were fairly equal in their performance but if you had to rank them it would have been Mason, Kenny and then Mitch.
Gerry Dulac: Jim, Mason was never going to start, even after how he looked in training camp. Never. That's why they brought in two guys over him during the offseason -- they thought they needed some better. And their plan never included Pickett starting at the beginning of the year. Never. that's why they brought in Trubisky.
Jim in Az.: Hindsight Gerry, would you now admit Pickett should have been the starting QB all year long? If so, I believe the Steelers are in the playoffs rather than just contending for a spot in the final week.
Gerry Dulac: No
Read More
Mike: Go 9-8 and make playoffs, go 9-8 and miss playoffs, or go 8-9??
Gerry Dulac: Just go 9-8
Joel: Happy New Year, Gerry. Somber week across the NFL. Between Tomlin and Heyward, it seems to me the Steelers have the right leadership to handle the emotions leading up to the game on Sunday. Will the Hamlin situation have any impact between the lines this week?
Gerry Dulac: Do not take this the wrong way -- Hamlin's situation has impacted everyone across the NFL, probably most especially the players. And while it has cast a somber mood across the league, most especially in Buffalo and even here where he grew up, once the players and coaches take the field they will be thinking about only one thing -- beating the Browns.
Tom: If the Steelers didn't have the reputation of finding gems wr's in midrounds, would Dionte Johnson be viewed to be as good as he is now?
Gerry Dulac: Good question. But those numbers he posted last year suggested he is good.
Joel: Gerry, Cam Heyward has been so great this season —- just a rock on and off the field. Can we talk Hall of Fame yet? I’m concerned he won’t make it as his career has coincided with a down time for the Steelers overall, at least in comparison to their usual championship “standard.” Is he worthy and will he make it?
Gerry Dulac: I do not hold out a lot of hope that Cam will make the Hall of Fame, which is no reflection on what type of tremendous player -- and team player -- he is. One of the best
Mike: What’s your prediction?:
Gerry Dulac: For....??
obxandy: If Steelers offer Mason Rudolph a market based 3 year contract to be backup to Pickett, what are chances he would accept the deal? I'm thinking he is most likely going to be backup in future and why not do it in Pittsburgh if $$$ are fair. Thank you. Have a great 2023.
Gerry Dulac: I don't think he has any interest in staying here after the way he was demoted/treated.
Stlrdave1: Good morning Gerry. As a transplanted Steeler fan living in Nevada, I've had a good look at how an organization should be run, and one of the many in the NFL who are not. Yes we expect more always from the team. But we have been blessed with a track record for the most part. Thank you for taking my comment
Gerry Dulac: I trust you mean seeing how the Steelers do it as opposed to how the Raiders do it there in Nevada. I'm with ya
Marc from Germany: Hi G! Have we overdone it with our lust for ever bigger, faster fester and stronger players to the point that it is no longer sustainable even for those seamingly superhuman bodies? And if so: is this calamity eever going back in it's Box?
Gerry Dulac: Marc, not exactly sure what specific incident might have spawned your question, but my answer is likely the same -- probably not
Ironcadet: Hey Gerry, if the Steelers don’t make the playoffs, is there a team you’ll be rooting for or an ideal Super Bowl matchup that you want to see?
Gerry Dulac: I won't be rooting for any specific matchup, but I think the three AFC teams -- Buffalo, KC and Bengals -- would be a great matchup for SF's defense.
John in SC: Good morning Gerry. To my untrained eye, it seems that our receivers run poor routes. Seldom is someone wide open. Yet it doesn’t appear to be an issue for the opponents. Is that on the personnel or on the coaches.
Gerry Dulac: Not all the receivers. DJ is a good route runner, despite his drops and suspect footwork along the boundary. He gets open cause he comes out of his breaks better than the others. It's something George Pickens needs to improve, but he's a rookie and I'm sure he will.
Tom: I'm surprised at the talk about keeping Canada. The offense still barely scores a touchdown a game, right?
Gerry Dulac: That is what is very very apparent!! That's why I always say the Steelers can't be fooled by this late-season run when evaluating where they are as a franchise going forward. They have to view the season, even last season, in its totality
Tim: It is now crystal clear to me that Devin Bush is the biggest bust in my lengthy memory following the Steelers. Not starting in favor of an undrafted free agent in his same draft class and a seventh rounder this year who was a rb not long ago speaks volumes. Burns, Jones, Worley pick 7, Richardson and Stephens did not combine both draft position and draft capital given up as much as Bush. Drafting not always an exact science, but what a big miss!
Gerry Dulac: Pay the man!
MTScott: Should the O-Line be awarded as Steelers MVP this year?
Gerry Dulac: They would get my vote as the MVU (unit)!
Tim Jetty: Hi Gerry, When QB's ( especially a rookie) consistently bring a team back late to win games ALL the "draft stat" negatives go out the window. The guy IS a winner. Pickett has this. You agree?
Gerry Dulac: There is no doubt he has shown that in those fourth-quarter situations of late, though he didn't earlier in those losses to the Jets and Miami. That's all part of his growth. In his three 4th quarter comeback wins, he has completed 17 of 21 passes for 176 yards, 2 TDs, no picks and a 132-plus passer rating. For the other 10 or more quarters in those three games, he has been mostly average, with a 70.1 passer rating. He has responded in the biggest moments lately, which would suggest he is a winner. But, good or bad, I'm not going to evaluate him on one season. It's always a little tougher for QBs the second time around the NFL.
Uncle Floyd: Hi Jerry, enjoy all of your work. I feel the Steelers did a fairly good job slowing down the Ravens running game, but I don’t think the same strategy will work for the Browns. In my opinion, they will need to pay more attention to the Browns passing game and also try to harness the running game.
Gerry Dulac: Don't worry, their strategy/game plan will change. It has each of the past three games how they've handled the run. Give them credit for all the different looks/personnel packages/schemes they have used against Carolina, Raiders and Ravens, three of the better running teams in the league. It has been marvelous coaching!!
WarrenBankston: Can you remember the last time a Steeler receiver caught a ball in stride while running toward the goal line?
Gerry Dulac: Nope. Not when the longest offensive TD this season is only 24 yards. Think about that for a second...
Guest: Now that the OL and DL seem to have maybe kinda/sorta gelled, would or should the Steelers go back to drafting "best available" player, except QB and RB?
Gerry Dulac: Nope. They need to address their lines of scrimmage, especially defense. They need to find some young studs like Pouncey, DeCastro, Heyward, Tuitt. Not 3rd and 4th round picks. First-rounders. They've put it off long enough.
Jim Harrold: Do you think the Steelers should have interest in penn state coaches Manny Diaz and/or Mike Yurcich ?
Gerry Dulac: Uh....no
JW: Don’t have the stats, but did over the middle passes increase substantially in the 4th qtr?
Gerry Dulac: Because of two back-to-back completions on the final drive? Just a small sample size. The answer is no.
MTScott: Thank You for all you do to keep Steelers Nation updated - especially enjoyed your coverage during the recent loss of Franco ????
Gerry Dulac: Thanks man
BPOS: Najee is finally running like he's possessed which is great to see, but yet the undrafted Warren looks like he has the makings of a feature back. While I'm not anointing Warren to the pro bowl, and Najee has more talent, do you think in hindsight using a first round pick on an RB where there is value later was a mistake like most self-proclaimed draft experts proclaim.
Gerry Dulac: I agree whole-heartedly, but I'm not going to say Warren is a feature back. I think you're getting ahead of yourself. But he has been very good. Love the way he runs -- right to the hole at 120 mph
Rock Daddeo: What am I missing? We block and run effectively at Baltimore, play tough defense, no turnovers, look like an offensive juggernaut on the last drive. But only 1 TD? Why did it go down this way?
Gerry Dulac: In case you haven't noticed, it's been going down that way. That's the seventh game in which they've scored only one TD. But, to your point, they have been moving the ball very well up and down the field the last three or four games, even going back to the first Baltimore game. nd I haven't had any big problems with the play-calling, not at all. They just haven't been able to finish.
Les: Good Morning, please help me understand why the Chiefs vs Raiders game is being played on Saturday? Why would they schedule a game that has direct implecations on the seedings for Sunday. This of course is now a "non matter" because of the Bills not completing their game vs the Benglas, but if the Bills would have lost (and I believe they were on their way to doing just that) and the Chiefs won, the Bills would have been locked in to the 2nd seed. That then would give the Patriots a huge advantage because the Bills would possibly now rest several of their top players. I just don't get it. They could have had the Jaguars and Titans play on Saturday and it would have had no affect on anyone. Can you help me understand why the NFL would schedule this way?
Gerry Dulac: It's Saturday in prime time. They want to put some game of interest there. What did you want them to schedule in that slot -- Houston at Indy??
Lenny from NY: Good morning Gerry. The last drive of the game the Steelers opened it up a bit and threw downfield. Before that drive and it seems all season, they really don’t throw deep. Why do you think that is? Thanks
Gerry Dulac: Cause they had to. But you're right -- they tried only ONE pass over the top all game. and that was a 31-yarder that was overturned because Diontae Johnson couldn't get his other foot inbounds (again).
justin: Any Steelers' loss this season in particular you think should have been the win to make the difference between a guaranteed playoff game and hoping that other teams lose to get to the playoffs?
Gerry Dulac: Pick from 4 -- NE, Jets, Miami and first Baltimore game. But, if you had to pick one, I'd say Miami
CoalportKid: Chances Pickett lobbies for Canada at EOY like Ben used to do for Arians?
Gerry Dulac: He has NO say in the matter. None.
Matt: What do you think is a better scenario for the Steelers, qualify for the playoffs and get some valuable experience for young core or a higher draft pick?
Gerry Dulac: Playoffs. Even at this point, what's the difference if they are 8-9 or 9-8, in terms of where they will draft?? It won't matter but a spot or two
Guest: Gerry, This has been from an ideal season for the Steelers. However, the experience for KP & our younger players has been great. The way things are progressing for both O & D units is a blessing for Steelers for next year. A solid draft & a few key adds & subtractions could put them back in contention as early as next year.
Gerry Dulac: Agreed.
Bill: Who was the knucklehead Steelers player who came off the bench in street clothes to celebrate the winning touchdown in the end zone and draw an unsportsmanlike penalty - AGAIN? Isn’t it on Mike Tomlin for not cracking the whip on this undisciplined behavior after the exact same thing happened in the Raiders game a week before?
Gerry Dulac: That's today's professional athlete.
Bill: If Presley Harvin were cut by the Steelers, would any team pick him up?
Gerry Dulac: Probably
Bill: Who are the Steeler’s receivers next year and do they need another playmaker? Is Calvin Austin a legit slot receiver? Does Anthony Miller come back?
Gerry Dulac: Forget Anthony Miller. Been here two years and done nothing. But, indeed, Calvin Austin is a guy they have some high hopes for. But, no pun intended, don't just slot him as a slot guy. He lined all over the field in college and rarely played in the slot. All that being said, I think you might see a WR drafted around the fifth around, only because they never turn their back on skill players.
Guest: Do you think #44 and #90 will work on JJ to try to get him to play one more year ? JJ at 75% should be better than any DLineman that the Steelers could pick up in the off season.
Gerry Dulac: Nope
Jeff in Ohio: Good day Gerry. Is it fair to say the Steelers plan to use Mark Robinson more? What's his future? I still think they need upgrades to MLB for next season. Clearly Bush isn't the answer and Jack has been serviceable.
Gerry Dulac: More than fair. It might just be one more game to "use him more" this season, but rest assured the plan right now is he will be one of their starting ILBs next season
Dr Cornfedder: If the Steelers beat the Browns on Sunday to go 9-8, what letter grade will you give Mike Tomlin for the season?
Gerry Dulac: Same as the record -- slight above average, C+
Chris M: You praised the last game heroics of Big Ben last year, Will you do the same with Pickett?
Gerry Dulac: Already did pal
Harry Callas: Is Pickett’s late game success a result of the Steelers letting Kenny call the no huddle offense and abandoning the Matt Canada offense?
Gerry Dulac: The Steelers do not let Pickett go no-huddle and call his own plays and abandon Matt Canada's offense. OK.
Bridgette B: Is Frank Reich a realistic OC candidate?
Gerry Dulac: I hope so, but I'm not so sure you are going to see a change there
Guest: Hi Gerry. We hear a lot about Pickett being drafted cause they knew him so well. He was “in the building “. Pitt has a lot of players drafted and sticking with NFL teams. So why not more by the Steelers?
Gerry Dulac: That stuff sounds good, but it has little basis in merit. They drafted Pickett because they liked what they saw on tape and type of guy he is. Has nothing to do with practicing next door.
Chaconutz: Good morning Gerry, and Happy New Year! Do you think the Steelers will make the playoffs? If they do, do you foresee any other scenario than them getting absolutely decimated by the number two seed? At that point, is it even worthwhile to make it to the big dance? (Experience for the rookies, maybe?)
Gerry Dulac: It's always worthwhile to make the postseason. Always. Better than the alternative, despite what you or other fans might think. And, your final point is a major reason, too -- the experience of the postseason for a young team. Big bonus points there
Linebacker Lounge: How much is ILB a draft priority? I believe 93 can start, but unsure of the Jack contract.. Can also see 41 as a third., Thoughts?
Gerry Dulac: It's not a priority, at least not in the first or second round. They need to fix the people in front of the ILBs, not the ILBs. That will make all the ILBs better
Steeler in Virginia: In your opinion, which of the team's defensive backs are back on the team next year? Could be a lot of holes to fill.
Gerry Dulac: Cam Sutton. Levi Wallace. Damontae Kazee. Minkah of course. Maybe Edmunds (should be).
Charlie: It seemed like the Steelers used more zone blocking concepts against Baltimore, which has one of the best run defenses in the league. It resulted in, to my eyes, Harris’s best game as a Steeler. Warren ran well too. Did you notice a change in the run game schematics? And do you think they’ll continue to use it this week since it was so successful in Baltimore?
Gerry Dulac: It hasn't change from what they've been doing most of the season. They are not a big zone-blocking team, so I wouldn't say that was it.
Tony from London: Hi Gerry, one of the most pleasant surprises has been the play of the OL, I am especially impressed by the play of Kevin Dotson, do you still think we need to replace him?
Gerry Dulac: He is more than serviceable, minus the penalties
Pete: Has Tomlin addressed the team about Damar Hamlin?
Gerry Dulac: I'm sure it has been discussed.
Horse: Pickett was complimentary of Matt Canada after the Ravens game, is that more evidence that Canada will return next year?
Gerry Dulac: I am told Pickett likes Matt Canada
david--: The refs almost decided the last Steelers game with that B.S. call on Cam. Did you notice how few penalties were called in the Raiders game? Apparently when its extremely cold it's more important to have a short/fluid game with minor infractions ignored. (I actually didn't mind that!)
Gerry Dulac: Neither do I.
Groovy Greg: Will 93 Robinson see action against the run-heavy Browns? Chubb chopped them up earlier in the year.
Gerry Dulac: I think you will
Butkus: Gerry, does playing inside backer really require more studying than nuclear fusion reactions? You tell Robinson to hunt the ball, and leave it at that? It's not like our ILB guys can cover even when they try, so might as well focus on the run, no?
Gerry Dulac: That's a Kendrell Bell game plan. Only works for a short while before teams exploit that. Sounds good but it's not that simple.
Gerry Dulac: Ok kids, I'm outta time. Thanx for the questions. Let's do it next week






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.