Welcome to Brian Batko’s Steelers mailbag. You’re more than welcome to email him at bbatko@post-gazette.com, tweet him @BrianBatko or slide into his DMs to inquire about the Steelers, NFL or anything out of bounds.
Joe Z: Hey Bats! I really think Tomlin’s straight up stubbornness is costing the team. He won’t admit mistakes and retaining Canada is crippling this team. It’s painful to watch an offense that can’t make chunk plays and dinks and dunks down field. He won’t play Warren more because he has a man crush on Najee even though he’s hurt or just not very good. Please tell me the Rooneys see this? Canada is crippling team/player development (especially Kenny) and Tomlin is having his worst season in 16 years. What’s worse is he’s standing by letting it happen. Thoughts? He owes it to the team to fire Canada at/before the bye week.
Jim in Florida: Canada is gone after the season. Do the Steelers hire a young wiz kid from outside of the organization or do they continue the maddening practice of staying in-house?
Brian: Let’s go ahead and group these questions together. Don’t mistake Mike Tomlin’s inaction on staff changes for satisfaction. Obviously, he’s not pleased, and he’s going to do what he thinks is best to win games. I doubt I’ll ever question his motivation on that front, given his resume to this point.
As for owing it to the team to fire Matt Canada, it’s just as likely that would lead to dysfunction as it would bring a collective sigh of relief. Sure, perhaps players would rally around it. Or maybe things would get even worse. And if you want to argue they can’t get any worse, I’ll remind you that many were saying that about the 2021 Steelers offensive line. The only offensive assistant on staff with play-calling experience at the college or pro level is quarterbacks coach Mike Sullivan, who hasn’t done it since 2017 with the Giants. Those G-Men were the second-lowest scoring team in the NFL at 15.4 points per game. But hey, don’t they say the backup play-caller is always the most popular guy in town?
I think Jim is more on the right track here, that the Steelers will have little choice but to shake things up on offense this offseason and move on after two years of Canada. If that’s how it plays out, then once again, I don’t see any logical person on staff to receive an internal promotion. And even if there were, that approach hasn’t been working, anyway. Here are a few offensive coordinator candidates who could be in high demand after this year:
Read More
• Joe Brady — He was fired before the end of his second season as the Panthers OC last year, but looking at the dumpster fire that became of Carolina, are we sure it was all his fault? Brady’s now the quarterbacks coach for the Bills, so he’s now worked with both Josh Allen and Joe Burrow, who had his legendary 2019 season at LSU with Brady as the passing game coordinator. Like Mike Tomlin, he’s a former William & Mary wide receiver, but he’s only 33.
• Zac Robinson — The Rams pass game coordinator/QBs coach, Robinson has been on Sean McVay’s offensive staff since 2019. At 36, the 2010 seventh-round draft pick out of Oklahoma State doesn’t have a ton of coaching experience, but someone has to give him his first shot as a coordinator and there are worse trees to shake than McVay’s.
• Tee Martin — If the Steelers want to keep it in the family, the quarterback they drafted in the fifth round in 2000 (one round before Tom Brady) has a decent track record. He doesn't have NFL play-calling experience but was the offensive coordinator for three seasons at USC, the first two of which the Trojans averaged more than 30 points per game. He’s now wide receivers coach for the Ravens after interviewing for the Bills offensive coordinator job last offseason.
• Brian Johnson — Like Martin, he’s been a Power Five college coordinator but only a position coach in the NFL. As the Eagles quarterbacks coach, though, Johnson has been lauded for his work with Jalen Hurts. He’s another up-and-comer at just 35 years old.
• Eric Bieniemy — A pie-in-the-sky idea, given that NFL coordinators almost always leave those posts for head coaching gigs, but it’s no secret that hasn’t panned out yet for Andy Reid’s longtime right-hand man in Kansas City. Bieniemy re-signed with the Chiefs on a one-year deal in February. If he gets passed over for head coaching vacancies again in 2023, could he decide to take a leap to another team just to prove he can call plays and lead an explosive offense away from Reid and Patrick Mahomes?
There are a multitude of other candidates both young and old, with and without NFL coordinator experience. And this is where we’re obligated to mention that Kenny Pickett’s college play caller, Mark Whipple, likely will be out of a job this offseason.
Miles M: Hi Brian, is WR COACH F. Jackson one and done with the Steelers? Our WR have zero mental awareness. I mean #13 getting that illegal shift is absolutely maddening. Why does he keep seeing the field
Brian: That penalty on Pickett’s successful 3rd-and-1 sneak wasn’t Miles Boykin’s fault. Just about every party involved has weighed in, with Tomlin saying Tuesday that right tackle Chuks Okorafor moved at the line of scrimmage. When I asked Okorafor about it Wednesday, he called it “bad luck” that he wasn’t set, or that Pickett didn’t hold off a tick longer on sending Boykin in motion.
Canada spoke on it quite a bit Thursday, too, and chalked it up to a rookie mistake by his rookie quarterback.
“How many times has Kenny Pickett sent a guy in motion on a play in his life? A whole bunch. But that time, we weren’t quite set,” Canada said. And, indeed, Boykin’s motion allowed him to push Pickett forward for the first down, but ...
“It was a good play; we got it,” Canada said. “Boykin wasn’t illegal. Boykin wasn’t going forward. It was just everybody wasn’t set before [Pickett] sent him, which is something that can’t happen, but it did. Like I said, why was that? Fundamentally, we didn’t coach it. Again, whatever’s not good on tape, we as coaches all own. Obviously, we hadn’t done it.”
Canada joked that Pickett would probably “punch me in the face” for taking any blame on that, because he’s a guy that’s “not seeking comfort.”
“It happened. I feel real strong it’ll never happen again,” Canada said. “If Kenny’s here for the next 15 years, I bet that never happens again. That’s a crappy lesson we’ve got to deal with, but it’s life.”
Alan from Indy: Brian, we’re draft picks on O and D line and a new Offensive Coordinator away from contending again? Your thoughts?
Brian: They better be good draft picks. It’s easy to say now that the Steelers need to fortify both lines and things will be looking up next season. But don't forget that defensive starters Terrell Edmunds, Devin Bush, Cam Sutton and Arthur Maulet will be free agents.
And yeah, the quarterback matters, too. Let’s just be honest, the jury is still out on Pickett.
If he struggles for the remainder of this season and the Steelers have a top-five pick, you know there will be questions about what they should do at the most significant position. Assistant general manager Andy Weidl comes from an Eagles organization where they drafted Jalen Hurts in the second round four years after taking Carson Wentz second overall. Wentz was still widely viewed as the face of the franchise at that time, but the Eagles weren't shy about placing an emphasis on being “quarterback developers.” And who really knows what general manager Omar Khan’s philosophy will be?
Make no mistake, no matter who’s calling the plays or blocking up front, it’ll be the guy under center most responsible for making the Steelers contenders again. Same as it ever was.
Think you have better questions? Email bbatko@post-gazette.com or write him on Twitter @BrianBatko.







Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.