Gerry Dulac: OK kids, we're going to start our chat is just a few minutes so get ready...
Gerry Dulac: OK, here we go....Fire away
Tom: Gerry thanks for coverage and these chats.
You have much better insight and understanding of how the Steelers operate than we do so can I ask you to help me understand how Rooney watches & allows the Canada ineptitude to continue? And what’s it say about Tomlin’s unwillingness to do the right thing and send Canada packing months ago? Thank you.
Gerry Dulac: I'm not sure I understand either, to be honest. I was a bit surprised he was brought back this year but I don't expect that be the case for next season. I also don't expect him to be fired before the season is over, like some people want or think will happen. But I wouldn't be surprised if some of his duties were altered to include someone else. Or, here's a novel idea, how about meeting with the other offensive assistants when developing a game plan???
Guest: Gerry: the Steelers have been cavalierly trading away late round picks for fringe players or using them on QBs that can't even get a rep in camp. With that background, does it amaze you that they continue to stick with Pressley Harvin seemingly just to justify that they used a 7th round pick on him?
Read More
Gerry Dulac: Yes it does. I thought that last year. His inconsistency and failure to deliver the monster punts -- the reason they drafted him after all -- do not merit such faith.
Jeff: Thanks for the chats Gerry. I guess I am one of the few that actually likes what I see from Pinkett. He seems to have all the attributes of a good QB, maybe even great. Good arm strength, good pocket presence and he is smart with a great work ethic. Kid will learn so let him learn. And if I didnt have a life I would dig up first year stats for Manning, Aikman and Bradshaw...which were not good.
Gerry Dulac: I don't think anyone should question if Kenny Picket will be a good quarterback (I'll hold off on the 'great' proclamation). He has all the intangibles in addition to having many of the measurables. He is going to make mistakes and cost them games, which he already has. They just have to live with it. The problem is, Mike Tomlin made this change earlier than he wanted and should have, and now he will sacrifice victories (two already) at the sake of development, something that is not typically in his DNA. You have heard him say many times "Winning is our business." And that is not the business he is conducting right now.
JM from the Burgh: Thanks for the chats Gerry. Najee Harris has all the physical tools and a great work ethic but it seems he may be lacking “Vision” in his running style. Warren seems to see holes better and James Connor was not as gifted physically but I feel he was able to anticipate holes and read block extraordinarily well. Granted the line was better then but with Najee’s physical ability shouldn’t he be producing better as a No. 1 pick?
Gerry Dulac: Pay the man!
Ghollywoodg: penalties penalties penalties… pre-snap penalties especially cost us any chance that we had to win that game at the end… doesn’t that show a lack of team discipline?…. and doesn’t that go back directly to coaching?..
Gerry Dulac: To a degree, but I'm not going to lay everything on them. Sometimes the player just has to be smarter, not to give the coaching a pass
Marc from Germany: Hi G! Firstly: If you send KD a deaththreat, please get help. This is not to taunt or insult you. I'm genuinely concerned for you and those around you. Now my question: have we as a fanbase finally and completely lost our minds? I love football way to much, but come on!
Gerry Dulac: Marc, you use the word 'finally' as though this is a recent development. I think it is just the latest example of what has been going on for years and years
Retire21: Looks like a good QB draft unlike this year. Steelers with high pick could package that for several later picks because they won’t need a QB. Makes sense?
Gerry Dulac: Nope. They made their QB pick, though your point about this year's class is well understood
Travis: Your October 25th Steelers chat begins on October 26th? Makes sense.
Gerry Dulac: We're a quick starter
Robert in VA: Hi Gerry. Thanks for the chats. What can possibly be the mindsets of both Mike Tomlin and Matt Canada with regard to the Steelers lack of effectiveness of their offensive strategy and game time play calling? Are they both in denial with a fixed mindset? Is Canada in good graces presently with Tomlin? How are they working through the difficulties with the scheme not working?
Gerry Dulac: This might sound strange, but i haven't had a huge problem with the flow of the play-calling for the most part. However, the bottom line is this offense doesn't produce points, and hasn't since the start of last season. And the only time they did was when No. 7 took control in the fourth quarter and called what he knows will work best. I'm not sure too many other head coaches would have tolerated such lack of productivity. A bigger problem is the players losing trust in the offensive coordinator
Retire21: I am in the one percentile of golf watchers. Watch every Sunday and have been following Rocco’s recent good play in Champions. Looks like hel’ll get into the top 36 finals. I don’t miss the Liv guys. Do you think Liv overestimated the value of signing big names?
Gerry Dulac: I think this thing still has more to play out.
Irritable bowel: While I agree in allowing Kenny Pickett to play through his struggles to further his development, I can’t help but wonder why Mason Rudolph wasn’t afforded this same luxury. He was pulled after one bad half in favor of an undrafted free agent. Then they jump at the opportunity to sign another team’s failed QB who has 50 starts on his resume under the premise he hasn’t reached his full potential, all while concluding Rudolph isn’t the answer despite having only 1/5 the starts of Trubisky. To What do you attribute this apparent hypocrisy by Coach Tomlin?
Gerry Dulac: The fact that Kenny Pickett was a No. 1 draft choice and not a third-rounder. But, I am searching for money to pay you
RT from Fl: Would you say the Steelers are in rebuild? If so why not trade Claypool and Rudolph to add draft picks for next year. OL and DL need young talent badly. Thank you.
Gerry Dulac: The problem is, they don't think they are in a rebuild, even though they are because of a rookie quarterback. But don't hold your breath about any trades before Tuesday
Retire21: Other than the Buff blowout Steelers could have won all the other games. That said they could be 0-7. Do you agree with MT that this young team is not far away?
Gerry Dulac: I do not agree. I also don't think 0-7, but definitely 1-6. I also think if Mason Rudolph were the quarterback they would have won Jets game and Miami game.
Stlrdave1: Good morning Gerry. I believe we are at the point of letting Pickett get valuable experience. Yes the point is to win every game, but losses may be more than usual.. And can Mr. Rooney please tell Coach Tomlin to get some NFL experienced assistants. Thank you as always for taking my questions
Gerry Dulac: There is no doubt they are at the point of letting Pickett get valuable experience. But this is the NFL, not a college program, and that stands for Not For Long for a coach's security if he is interested in playing for next year.
RaySherman: Why was Tomlin putting the blame for Miami loss on defense for dropping INTs? Did he expect his offense to take advantage by throwing passes behind the line of scrimmage to a 280 pound backup tight end?
Gerry Dulac: I don't know that it was so much blame he was assigning as it was an observation he was making. But let me say this -- Mike Tomlin says things on Tuesday that are subtle messages to his players and even coaches. So, sometimes when it appears he's issuing blame, he's actually challenging his players. And sometimes when he's not placing blame publicly, he does something different privately. Keep that in mind.
Joe: Odds that Matt Canada gets fired before the end of the season?
Gerry Dulac: Not very good
Cabbage King: Has Tomlin, or Canada, ever explained why the offense mostly ignores the middle of the field?
Gerry Dulac: They are asked all the time. And the answers are always vague. Non-answers, if you will
Cabbage King: Will Canada be OC after the break?
Gerry Dulac: Probably
DormontDoug: Do you worry about Pickett's deep ball and overall arm strength? I do sometimes.
Gerry Dulac: Me too.
Cabbage King: Has Edmunds outplayed a multi-year contract with the Steelers?
Gerry Dulac: I don't know what they are going to do with him after the season, but I'll tell you this -- since the middle of last season he has very good, even better this year. He has been one of their better players.
Steeler in Virginia: I haven't given up the dream yet - after the bye with a healthy defense, this team could run the table and sneak into the playoffs. If management believes this, what is the one area they should try to upgrade before the trade deadline?
Gerry Dulac: I suggest you dial up another dream.
Robert in VA: Are Omar Khan and Andy Weidl presently engaged to any degree with Steelers in-season football team on field & game performance issues? Or are they focused primarily on scouting and other team business activities leaving the former up to HC MT? Should they be involved in how in-season team football playing performance is unfolding?
Gerry Dulac: Of course they are. They watch every practice, attend every game, meet with Mike Tomlin daily.
Robert in VA: Gerry, do you have any opinions you are willing to share about the Art Rooney, Sr racket articles recently published? How did Steelers front office and owners view the articles? Any league interest?
Gerry Dulac: I would venture to say they viewed it they way you might expect
Mark in Etown: Gerry, let's talk time management, yet again. 2nd Qtr. Why in the world did they rush to get a play off before the 2 minute warning? Yes, they scored. Strategically, run the ball ONE time after the warning and you are eating away at least 40 seconds. That ends up giving the Dolphins three valuable points and changes the final drive from "we need 6" to "we need at least 3".
Gerry Dulac: Now there's a perceptive guy!!
Cabbage King: Outside of a few guys on defense, it's hard to not believe the cupboard is mostly bare for this rebuild. Am I falling into the gloom and doom trap?
Gerry Dulac: I don't think the cupboard is mostly bare. In fact, if you look around the league, most teams are never really that far away
tsr: Any sense on what the steelers are leaning towards with Austin? Seems like we'd want to get him reps if the playoffs are out of reach, but I don't know if Tomlin would ever accept that
Gerry Dulac: It will come down to this -- do they want to use up a roster spot so he can develop and maybe get him some playing time late in the season. They really like Austin, but he's missed so much time and never played in a game it is not reasonable to think he will play in a game anytime soon and be able to help the team. Coaches teach and help develop in the preseason, not in the regular season.
Epiballo: Big Ben had a phenomenal rookie year. Could it be that that set up unrealistic expectations for Pickett, at least in the back of the mind of some? The criticisms after so short a time in his first season is puzzling to me.
Gerry Dulac: Anybody who thinks Kenny Pickett is going to be Ben Roethlisberger is being unrealistic. That's no knock against Pickett or has anything to do with how good he can be. You can't project that on any rookie quarterback. Anyone who thought that is getting waaaaaay ahead of themselves with delirium
Epiballo: Historically, the Steelers lose games they should win and win games they should lose - so will that trend continue in Philadelphia this weekend?
Gerry Dulac: We'll see. But you're right
Epiballo: The O-Line played pretty well and the defense really well (except for dropped interceptions); with the return of TJ Watt and a less daunting schedule after the Eagles game, do you see the Steelers in the hunt for a wildcard?
Gerry Dulac: Not now.
Cabbage King: Are offensive players keeping their frustrations among the team or are there rumblings when the mics are off?
Gerry Dulac: I'm never sure if that noise I hear is the train going by the facility???
Bill: Did the Steelers over react to Ben's retirement by signing Trubisky and then drafting Laldokun in the 7th round, when Mason Rudolph was a more than adequate bridge QB?
Gerry Dulac: I didn't have a problem with the Trubisky signing. It was the right thing to do. Drafting a second QB with only seven picks was ridiculous and a waste. It did not go over very well internally, trust me
Bill: Does Gunner have any guaranteed money? He looks like a useless signing, like Ryan Switzer # 2, and should be cut.
Gerry Dulac: Yes, but only in a signing bonus. It wouldn't cost them much if he were released.
Guest: Are the Claypool trade rumors likely coming from his agents?
Gerry Dulac: Not at all.
Guest: Is there a timeline for Kazee's return?
Gerry Dulac: It should be soon.
doyle37: Why was Tomlin not asked about Gunnar replacing Claypool during crunch time ?
Gerry Dulac: There is no reason to ask that question
Woody: Great work sir. With the first overall pick of the 2023 NFL Draft, the Steelers select...Joey Porter Jr. Am I too far off thinking Tomlin would want to get his best buddies kid? If so, how can anyone take him seriously again.
Gerry Dulac: I don't know if it would have anything to do with being Joey Porter's son or the fact that Joey Jr is very very good, possibly the best corner in the draft.
Charlie from sugartown: GOOD morning Gerry. Not a Steelers question but always wondered why if you are top tier prospect, say Trevor Lawrence. Why would you enter the draft and get picked by a bad team vs just being a free agent right out of the box and get to a team you choose and a contract that isn't set by the league?
Gerry Dulac: Because you cant be a free agent to enter the league. There is only one way -- through the draft
21-58-66: Hi Gerry....thanks for the chats. Concerned that Austin might become the next Golston....hope you see it differently?
Gerry Dulac: I wouldn't go that far. Let's hope not
RyanW: I get wanting to be patient and not make change "for the sake of change" but what possible damage could you do by at least giving play call duties to someone else? I mean Sullivans offesene on 2012 with Tampa was the 13th ranked with Josh Freeman at QB.
Gerry Dulac: Couldn't hurt at all at this point
Guest: Do we know when Leal will return?
Gerry Dulac: He has to stay on a minimum of 4 weeks, so count it out from the Buffalo game
Guest: Is there any scenario where the team hands over playcalling duties to Sullivan while retaining Canada?
Gerry Dulac: I would never say never.
Sweaty Ken: I know the team has more pressing issues than this, but Harvin has been horrendous this year so far after he was horrid last year. Does the team have any intentions on making a change there? Thank you!
Gerry Dulac: It's the same as last year -- he has not been very good
Guest: Safe to say the offense has lost confidence in Canada?
Gerry Dulac: Not a stretch at all
Donny F: Gerry, among Steelers power-brokers, who had the most say in the Steelers drafting Kenny Pickett: Rooney, Colbert, or Tomlin?
Gerry Dulac: Colbert and Tomlin
Tom in Punta Gorda: Hi Gerry, how much cap room will the Steelers have for free agents next spring? Also, trade Johnson to Green Bay for a 2& 4.
Gerry Dulac: I haven't looked that far ahead
J: We all know Matt Canada has been horrible since becoming OC. With this season basically being lost already, is there a reason why they won’t fire him now and bring in a new OC to let Kenny develop and becoming comfortable with him so that next season they will already know the playbook? Thanks!
Gerry Dulac: The Steelers historically don't fire coaches during the season, so I don't see that happening.
Gerry Dulac: OK kids, have to go to the locker room, so that's all the time we have. Good stuff today






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.