The Steelers dropped a 24-20 heartbreaker of a loss against the New York Jets on Sunday at Acrisure Stadium. Here are some questions to ponder for them and the rest of the NFL as we look ahead to Week 5, when the Steelers face the high-powered Bills in Buffalo.
Have the Steelers crossed the proverbial rubicon with Kenny Pickett? Coach Mike Tomlin insisted to reporters after the game that he wouldn’t commit to the rookie from Pitt as his starter after benching Mitch Trubisky at halftime against the Jets. Then again, Tomlin insisted to reporters after the loss to Cleveland last week that he wouldn’t go to Pickett at all, even if Trubisky struggled against the Jets. Yet here we sit. It sure feels like there’s no way to look back. Trubisky has been ineffective. And while it’s up for debate how much of that ineffectiveness has been his fault, it’s undeniable that Pickett provided a spark and brought confidence to a unit that had lacked it when he entered. His day was not without mistakes — his late tipped interception that set up the Jets’ winning touchdown drive is at the top of that list. But his throw to Pat Freiermuth to set up his second touchdown run in the fourth quarter was emblematic of something we haven’t seen from Trubisky. Swagger. The willingness to stand in the pocket, take a hit, deliver the ball and get up talking junk to the defenders. Deep down, Mike Tomlin has to know he can’t take that ingredient out of the mix now without initiating a controversy that would dog this offense for the rest of the season.
Is it high time the receivers face more scrutiny? The box score says Steelers quarterbacks threw four interceptions on Sunday. What it doesn’t tell you is that three of the passes hit their intended receivers in the hands and were catchable. The first misplay was an inexcusable drop from Diontae Johnson on a throw from Trubisky. The second was a contested but makable play for Chase Claypool on Pickett’s first professional pass. And the third was Pickett’s poor decision to throw desperately to Freiermuth as the Steelers were nursing a three-point lead in the fourth quarter. Pickett shouldn’t have thrown the pass, and it wasn’t an easy play for Freiermuth to make, as the throw was a bit high. Guess what, though? Sometimes receiving corps that are as highly touted as this one need to make those kinds of plays to win. Otherwise, they’re ordinary. With Trubisky seemingly out of the picture, there’s nowhere to hide now. No one on the field to take the criticism from a fan base that’s rabidly behind Pickett. These guys need to stop screwing up like this, or there is going to be legitimate discourse questioning if they’re as good as many of have touted them to be.
Which was the blip for the offensive line? Through the first three weeks, this unit was competent and looking better with each game, at least as far as the pass rush is concerned. On Sunday, it allowed Trubisky to be sacked three times and allowed more pressure to get to Pickett than is conducive to success. That was particularly true on the misfire to Freiermuth, when the rookie felt rushed and made a mistake the team could ill afford. Now that Pickett is seemingly in charge and Trubisky’s veteran savvy is out of the lineup, we’re going to find out who these guys are. Is it the fans’ and media’s feckless caricature from the preseason? Or a half-decent unit that can keep a rookie quarterback reasonably safe and help prevent him from losing confidence.
Can this defense put a complete effort together without T.J. Watt? Looking at the stats, it wasn’t a terrible day for this unit the way it was in Cleveland in Week 3. They held a decent Jets rushing attack to 3.4 yards per carry and were particularly good against ostensible starter Michael Carter, who averaged just 1.7 yards on nine carries. They got after Wilson fairly well, too. He was sacked once, hit six times and scrambled aimlessly before throwing the ball away another half dozen times at least. As late as the middle of the fourth quarter, CBS color commentator Adam Archuleta wondered aloud why the Jets were running the football when it hadn’t worked all day. That’s when you know a unit is doing a good job. Pretty much from that utterance forward, though, almost nothing went right. Breece Hall seemed to pick up five yards every time he got the ball in the backfield. And Wilson found his receivers with ease any time he wasn’t flushed from the pocket. Simply put, this group fell short at the wrong time, even if the game as a whole included some encouraging progress. If the Steelers are going to have any chance of climbing out of this 1-3 hole, they’re going to have to prove they can finish the job with the tough stretch of games that’s looming.
Does anyone want to win the AFC North? For the second time in four weeks, every team in the division that played on Sunday lost. Baltimore failed to score in the second half to blow a big lead against Josh Allen and the Bills to fall by a 23-20 margin. And Cleveland’s defense allowed 13 fourth-quarter points to fall short by the same score against a feckless Atlanta team that could not stop the Browns rushing attack, which averaged 5.1 yards per carry and piled up an impressive 177 yards total. Only Cincinnati salvaged the week by taking down a Miami team that lost Tua Tagovailoa to a scary head injury and was a shell of itself with Teddy Bridgewater behind center. The results leave every team in the division at .500 or worse, meaning the Steelers are still just a game back with 13 games to go. It’s not as big of a hole as it could have been, but if the Steelers want to stay in this mix, the time to get right is now.
Read More
Adam Bittner: abittner@post-gazette.com and Twitter @fugimaster24.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.